ABF17 v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

ABF17 v Commonwealth of Australia [2024] FCA 694

File number(s): VID 233 of 2024
Judgment of: HORAN J
Date of judgment: 28 June 2024
Catchwords:

MIGRATION – application for order in the nature of habeas corpus – statutory duty to remove Iranian national from Australia – where applicant does not agree to his removal to Iran but willing to cooperate with removal to any other country – where Iranian authorities have a policy of not issuing travel documents to involuntary returnees – where administrative processes necessary for issue of travel documents require cooperation of the applicant – whether steps are practically available to be taken which can realistically be predicted to result in the applicant’s removal to Iran in the reasonably foreseeable future – whether the applicant has capacity to cooperate with administrative processes directed to his removal to Iran – whether real prospect of the applicant’s removal becoming practicable in reasonably foreseeable future – Held: that applicant’s detention is validly authorised by ss 189 and 196 of Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – application dismissed

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW – temporal limitation on detention under ss 189 and 196 of Migration Act 1958 (Cth) identified in NZYQ v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] HCA 37; 97 ALJR 1005 and ASF17 v Commonwealth of Australia [2004] HCA 19 – where Iranian national does not agree to his removal to Iran – where policy of Iranian authorities not to issue travel documents to involuntary returnees – where applicant has capacity to cooperate with administrative processes directed to his removal to Iran – where steps are practically available to be taken which can realistically be predicted to result in applicant’s removal to Iran in the reasonably foreseeable future – Held: that applicant’s detention is for purposes of his removal from Australia and does not exceed the limitation identified in NZYQ

Legislation:

Constitution s 51(xix), Ch III

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 13, 14, 5, 48B, 189, 195A, 196, 197C, 198

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 23

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth)

Cases cited:

ABF17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (No 2) [2020] FCCA 3329

AKW22 v Commonwealth (2023) 297 FCR 650

ASF17v Commonwealth of Australia [2024] FCA 7

AZC20 v Minister for Home Affairs [2021] FCA 1234

AZC20 v Secretary, Department of Home Affairs (No 2) [2023] FCA 1497

Blatch v Archer [1774] 1 Cowp 63 [98 ER 969]

Chu Kheng Lim v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1992) 176 CLR 1

Commonwealth v AJL20 (2021) 273 CLR 43

CRS20 v Secretary, Department of Home Affairs [2024] FCA 619

McHugh v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (2020) 283 FCR 602

NZYQ v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] HCA 37; 97 ALJR 1005 ASF17 v Commonwealth of Australia [2004] HCA 19

Plaintiff M47/2018 v Minister for Home Affairs (2019) 265 CLR 285

Plaintiff M96A/2016 v The Commonwealth

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ABF17 v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 694
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of ABF17 v Commonwealth of Australia involved an Iranian national who had been detained in Australia since his release from criminal custody in September 2021. The applicant, born in 1989 in Ahwaz, Iran, had previously sought protection in Australia, claiming to fear persecution due to his ethnicity as an Ahwazi Arab and his past experiences in Iran. After his protection visa application was refused, the applicant was taken into immigration detention. He has since been continuously detained, with his primary concern being his unwillingness to return to Iran. The applicant sought an order in the nature of habeas corpus, arguing that his detention was unlawful because there was no real prospect of his removal to Iran in the reasonably foreseeable future.

The legal issues before the court were whether the applicant's detention was authorised by sections 189 and 196 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) and whether his detention exceeded the temporal limitation identified by the High Court in NZYQ v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] HCA 37; 97 ALJR 1005 and ASF17 v Commonwealth of Australia [2004] HCA 19. The court had to determine if the applicant had the capacity to cooperate with the administrative processes necessary for his removal to Iran, and if there were steps available that could realistically result in his removal in the foreseeable future. The court also needed to consider the implications of the High Court's decision in ASF17, which involved a similar situation where an Iranian national refused to cooperate with his removal to Iran.

The court held that the applicant's detention was validly authorised by sections 189(1) and 196 of the Migration Act. The court found that there was a real prospect of the applicant's removal to Iran becoming practicable in the reasonably foreseeable future, as it was within the applicant's power and capacity to cooperate with the steps necessary to facilitate his removal. The court rejected the applicant's reliance on AZC20 v Secretary, Department of Home Affairs (No 2) [2023] FCA 1497 as establishing an exception to the principle upheld by the High Court in ASF17. The court concluded that the applicant's detention did not exceed the temporal limitation identified in NZYQ, as the applicant had the capacity to cooperate with the administrative processes directed to his removal to Iran, and steps were available that could realistically result in his removal in the foreseeable future. Consequently, the application for habeas corpus was dismissed.

The final orders of the court were that the applicant's application for an order in the nature of a writ of habeas corpus be dismissed, and that the parties file written submissions concerning the question of costs and any orders that should be made in relation to the balance of the claims and relief sought in the originating application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant’s application for an order in the nature of a writ of habeas corpus is dismissed.

2. By 4.00 pm on 12 July 2024, each of the parties is to file brief written submissions of no more than 5 pages addressing: (i) the question of costs; and (ii) what, if any, orders should be made in relation to the balance of the claims made and relief sought in the originating application dated 22 March 2023.

3. By 4.00 pm on 19 July 2024, the parties are to file any written submissions in reply of no more than 2 pages.

4. Subject to further order, the questions addressed in the submissions filed in accordance with orders 2 and 3 will be determined on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons set out below, on the evidence before the Court, I consider that there is a real prospect of the applicant’s removal to Iran becoming practicable in the reasonably foreseeable future, and that his detention is therefore validly authorised by ss 189(1) and 196 of the Migration Act. This is because it is within the power or capacity of the applicant to cooperate with the steps that are practically available to be taken in the administrative processes necessary to facilitate his removal to Iran, which can realistically be predicted to result in the applicant’s removal to Iran in the reasonably foreseeable future.BACKGROUND The applicant is an Iranian national who was born on 17 January 1989 in Ahwaz, Khozestan, a province in southwest Iran. He is of Ahwazi Arab ethnicity and is a Sunni Muslim. After leaving Iran, the applicant arrived on Christmas Island on 30 October 2012 as an unauthorised maritime arrival. On 23 November 2015, the then Minister for Immigration and Border Protection decided under s 46A of the Migration Act to allow the applicant to apply for a temporary protection visa. On 25 February 2016, the applicant made an application for a Temporary Protection (Class XD) (Subclass 785) visa, following which he was granted a bridging visa on 8 March 2016. It is unnecessary in the present context to recount in detail the nature of the applicant’s claims in support of his protection visa application. The applicant claimed to fear persecution from the authorities in Iran because he is an Ahwazi Arab, because he had previously come under suspicion in Iran, and because he was a returned asylum seeker who had fled Iran illegally and had spent time in a Western country. Among other things, the applicant claimed that he had been arrested and imprisoned by Iranian authorities for a period of between 14 and 16 months under suspicion of having stolen certain documents, and that he had been beaten and tortured while in detention. He claimed that his arrest and detention were for reasons of his ethnicity as an Ahwazi Arab and, more generally, that Ahwazi Arabs face discrimination in Iran with respect to employment, housing and civil rights. On 17 August 2016, the applicant was notified that his application for a protection visa had been refused by a delegate of the Minister. The delegate found that the applicant was not a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations. While the delegate accepted that the applicant had been mistakenly imprisoned in 2011 and released approximately a year later, the delegate did not accept that the applicant was of continued adverse interest to the Iranian authorities, nor that the applicant’s family had been contacted by the Iranian authorities since his departure from Iran. The delegate accepted that the applicant is an Ahwazi Arab, but did not accept that he had suffered serious discrimination amounting to persecution for reasons of his ethnicity. The delegate also found that the applicant did not face a real chance of persecution or serious harm as a result of his tattoos, his Western appearance or lifestyle, or his use of online social networking services such as Facebook.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In relation to his reasons for not wanting to return to Iran, the applicant stated that he is genuinely fearful of returning to Iran. He referred to his statutory declaration in support of his protection visa application, including his claims that he has previously been persecuted in Iran and his belief that he remains of interest to Iranian authorities and will be harmed or killed if he returns to Iran. The applicant also gave evidence that he has maintained an active social media profile, including on TikTok and Instagram, since around May 2022, and that he has posted videos about his experiences in detention. In some of those videos, the applicant has expressed his faith and culture, and has been critical of the Iranian authorities due to his past experiences and the manner in which they treat Ahwazi Arabs.Evidence of Dr Kwok Dr Kwok is a clinical and forensic psychologist in private practice. For the purposes of preparing her report, she interviewed the applicant by video-link for approximately one hour and ten minutes on 8 April 2024. Dr Kwok subsequently attempted to contact the applicant by telephone on 10 April 2024 for the purpose of clarifying what she regarded as inconsistencies between what he had reported at interview and the supporting materials with which she had been provided to assist in the preparation of the report (which comprised copies of the applicant’s affidavits and other documents filed in these proceedings), but the applicant did not answer his phone. Dr Kwok described the applicant as “emotionally volatile” during the interview, and noted that he was a “poor historian and said he could not remember details of many of his life experiences”. She opined that the applicant suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) with comorbid depression and anxiety, stemming primarily from “pre-migration” factors including his alleged exposure to torture and sexual assault when wrongfully detained in Iran and other reported difficulties in Iran due to his Arab ethnicity. Dr Kwok stated that the applicant’s psychological distress has persisted in Australia, and that his symptoms include “intrusive memories of trauma events, distressing dreams and nightmares, sleep disturbance, suicidal thoughts, and negative alterations in cognitions and mood”. She observed fluctuations in the applicant’s mood during the interview, and noted that difficulties in emotion regulation are often associated with depression and anxiety. Dr Kwok considered that the applicant’s difficulties with PTSD, depression and anxiety are exacerbated in detention, where he is at a higher risk of self-harm and suicide. Dr Kwok was specifically asked about the impact that the applicant’s mental health condition has on his ability to make decisions with respect to his ongoing immigration detention. Dr Kwok answered this question as follows:[The applicant] can make general decisions with respect to his ongoing immigration detention. That is, he can express his views around his fears of returning to Iran, difficulties in detention, desires to remain in Australia and desire to return to the Australian community. However, due to emotion dysregulation and alteration in cognition (e.g. fixated in his views, inability to reason from other perspectives, limited rational thinking, etc), he has limited ability to engage in complex thinking that are needed for problem solving and planning. Thus, whilst he can express his general views, he will have difficulty processing, understanding and expressing complex information and providing details.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 5 January 2017, the applicant applied to the then Federal Circuit Court for judicial review of the IAA’s decision. The applicant was unrepresented in his proceedings before the Federal Circuit Court. On 11 December 2020, the Federal Circuit Court dismissed the application for judicial review: ABF17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (No 2) [2020] FCCA 3329 (FCC Decision). On or about 16 September 2021, the applicant was taken into immigration detention by officers of Australian Border Force (ABF), immediately after his release from criminal custody at the Goulburn Correctional Centre. The applicant has been continuously detained in immigration detention since this time, and is currently detained at the Villawood Immigration Detention Centre. On 24 December 2022, the applicant was married to an Australian citizen. On 18 September 2023, the applicant filed in this Court an application for an extension of time to appeal from the FCC Decision (proceeding No NSD 1074 of 2023). The application had been listed for hearing before Raper J on 9 May 2024. However, at the hearing before me on 26 April 2024, senior counsel for the applicant informed the Court that the applicant had recently given instructions to discontinue that proceeding, and orders were made by consent on 29 April 2024 that the application be discontinued with each party bearing their own costs. There are no longer any proceedings on foot by which the applicant seeks to challenge the refusal to grant him permission to remain in Australia. While he has been in detention, the applicant has made several oral requests to Commonwealth officers that he be removed from Australia to a country than Iran. The applicant cannot recall the dates on which those oral requests were made, but deposes that he asked “at least 3 to 4 times” and was told on each occasion that the Commonwealth cannot remove him “because there is nowhere else to send me to outside of Australia”. On 12 November 2023, following the High Court’s decision in NZYQ, the applicant’s solicitor sent an email request to the Department of Home Affairs (the Department) demanding the applicant’s immediate release from detention, asserting that he had been unlawfully detained on the basis that the Department had not been able to remove him or resettle him to a third country despite him having no substantive visa application or appeal proceedings on foot between 11 December 2020 (when the Federal Circuit Court dismissed his judicial review application) and 27 September 2023 (when he filed his application for an extension of time to appeal from the FCC Decision). The applicant’s solicitor indicated that, unless the applicant was immediately released from immigration detention, he would commence proceedings seeking an urgent writ of habeas corpus. The applicant’s solicitor sent a further email to the Department on 30 November 2023, asking why the applicant still remained in detention and seeking advice as to “the legal basis for his ongoing detention”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 26 March 2024, I made orders directing that the habeas corpus application be heard and determined separately and in advance of the balance of the applicant’s claims for relief. That application raises the question whether the applicant’s current and continuing detention is authorised by ss 189 and 196 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). It is common ground between the parties that there is a present duty to remove the applicant from Australia as soon as reasonably practicable under s 198 of the Migration Act. The applicant has been refused a protection visa and has exhausted all avenues of merits review and, at least as at 26 April 2024, judicial review. He has also made a written request to be removed from Australia, albeit stating that he will not agree to return to Iran. The Commonwealth has not been able to remove the applicant to Iran, on the asserted basis that the Iranian government will not issue travel documents for “involuntary” return of its nationals. The Commonwealth’s position is that the applicant can be removed to Iran if he voluntarily complies with certain steps necessary to obtain travel documents, and in such circumstances is not taking any steps to remove the applicant to any other country. As the High Court recently decided in NZYQ v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] HCA 37; 97 ALJR 1005, the provisions of the Migration Act that authorise the detention of unlawful non-citizens do not validly apply to a non-citizen who has failed to obtain permission to remain in Australia, and in respect of whom there is an enforceable duty to remove him or her from Australia, if and for so long as there is no real prospect of his or her removal from Australia becoming practicable in the reasonably foreseeable future: NZYQ at [55]. The constitutional limitation expressed in NZYQ was subsequently considered by the High Court in ASF17 v Commonwealth of Australia [2004] HCA 19 in relation to an Iranian national in immigration detention who was refusing to cooperate with the administrative processes necessary to facilitate his removal from Australia to Iran, but had expressed his preparedness to be removed to any country other than Iran. The High Court unanimously affirmed the decision of Colvin J (ASF17v Commonwealth of Australia [2024] FCA 7 (ASF17 (FCA)) to dismiss an application for habeas corpus and associated declaratory relief. The hearing of the habeas corpus application in the present case took place shortly after the High Court had reserved judgment in ASF17. The High Court subsequently delivered judgment on 10 May 2024. On 14 May 2024, following correspondence between my chambers and each of the parties’ solicitors, I made orders for the parties to file written submissions concerning the implications of the High Court’s decision in ASF17 for the present application. In the light of the written submissions filed, the principal issue that is now joined between the parties concerns the question whether the applicant has the power or capacity to cooperate with the steps required to effect his removal to Iran, based on the evidence, including expert medical evidence, adduced by the applicant. In this regard, the applicant places reliance on the decision of Kennett J in AZC20 v Secretary, Department of Home Affairs (No 2) [2023] FCA 1497 as establishing an “exception” to the principle upheld by the High Court in ASF17. Accordingly, it is necessary to examine the scope of any so-called exception relating to the power and capacity of a detainee to cooperate with his or her removal from Australia, and its application to the evidence presented in the present case.