MZZHL v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MZZHL v Commonwealth of Australia [2021] FCA 600  

File number: NSD 1128 of 2020
Judgment of: FLICK J
Date of judgment: 7 June 2021
Catchwords:

MIGRATION – authority to detain a person reasonably suspected of being an unlawful non-citizen

MIGRATION – request for removal – request withdrawn

MIGRATION – continued detention of unlawful non-citizen – no attempts being made to secure his removal from Australia – abandonment of any purpose whilst in detention – power to order release from detention in the absence of visa

MIGRATION – compensatory damages for unlawful detention

Legislation:

Judiciary Act1903 (Cth) s 78B

Migration Act1958 (Cth) ss 4, 5, 46A, 189, 195A, 196, 198

Cases cited:

AJL20v Commonwealth of Australia [2020] FCA 1305

Al-Kateb v Godwin [2004] HCA 37, (2004) 219 CLR 562

AOU21 v Minister for Home Affairs [2021] FCAFC 60

Arthur as litigation representative for CYG20 v Commonwealth of Australia [2021] FCA 259

ASP15 v Commonwealth [2016] FCAFC 145, (2016) 248 FCR 372

Attorney-General of the Commonwealth v Commonwealth of Australia [2020] HCATrans 224

Commonwealth of Australia v AJL20 [2021] HCATrans 68

Commonwealth of Australia v Fernando [2012] FCAFC 18, (2012) 200 FCR 1

Fernando v Commonwealth [2014] FCAFC 181, (2014) 231 FCR 251

Goldie v Commonwealth (No 2) [2004] FCA 156, (2004) 81 ALD 422

Guo v Commonwealth [2017] FCA 1355, (2017) 258 FCR 31

Lau v Calwell (1949) 80 CLR 533

Lewis v Australian Capital Territory [2020] HCA 26, (2020) 94 ALJR 740

Lim v The Minister for Immigration and Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1992) 176 CLR 1

Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v Al Masri [2003] FCAFC 70, (2003) 126 FCR 54

MZZHL v Minister for Immigration [2014] FCCA 1036

Newman v Minister for Health and Aged Care [2021] FCA 517

Plaintiff M47/2012 v Director-General of Security [2012] HCA 46, (2012) 251 CLR 1

Plaintiff M47/2018 v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] HCA 17, (2019) 265 CLR 285

Plaintiff M68/2015 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] HCA 1, (2016) 257 CLR 42

Plaintiff M76/2013 v Minister for Immigration, Multicultural Affairs and Citizenship [2013] HCA 53, (2013) 251 CLR 322

Plaintiff M96A/2016 v Commonwealth [2017] HCA 16, (2017) 261 CLR 582

Plaintiff S4/2014 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] HCA 34, (2014) 253 CLR 219

Potter v Minahan (1908) 7 CLR 277

Ruddock v Taylor [2003] NSWCA 262, (2003) 58 NSWLR 269

Ruddock v Taylor [2005] HCA 48, (2005) 222 CLR 612

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 128
Date of hearing: 4 – 7 May 2021
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr J King with Mr W K Soon
Solicitor for the Applicant: Human Rights for All
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr G Kennett SC…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MZZHL v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 600
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of MZZHL v Commonwealth of Australia involved the Applicant, an unlawful non-citizen, who sought damages for his unlawful detention by the Commonwealth. The dispute centred on the legality of the continued detention of the Applicant by the Commonwealth after March 2019, when it had abandoned any efforts to remove him from Australia. The Federal Court was tasked with determining whether the Commonwealth's actions were lawful and whether the Applicant was entitled to damages.

The key legal issues addressed by the court were the interpretation of sections 189 and 196 of the Migration Act, and the applicability of the decision in AJL20. The court had to decide whether the term "detain" in these sections should be construed as "lawfully detain", and whether the decision in AJL20, which was under appeal, should be followed. Additionally, the court needed to assess the appropriate amount of damages to which the Applicant was entitled.

The court found that the Commonwealth's continued detention of the Applicant after March 2019 was unlawful, as there was no lawful authority for it to detain him without making any attempts to remove him from Australia. The court emphasised that in the absence of clear statutory language, it should not interpret sections 189 or 196 in a way that would render the continued detention lawful. The court concluded that if the then Minister had properly considered the Applicant's situation, he would likely have granted him a visa and released him from detention. Consequently, the Applicant's claim for unlawful detention succeeded, and he was awarded $350,000 in general damages.

The court ordered that the Respondent pay the Applicant $350,000 within 28 days and also pay the Applicant's costs, either as agreed or assessed. This decision underscored the importance of adhering to the provisions of the Migration Act and ensuring that the rights of unlawful non-citizens are protected.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Respondent is to pay the Applicant within 28 days damages assessed in the sum of $350,000.

2. The Respondent is to pay the costs of the Applicant, either as agreed or assessed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Unlike the two earlier periods of detention, it has been concluded for the period of detention between March 2019 and the granting of the May 2021 visas that:·the Respondent was not only taking no steps to secure or attempt to secure the removal of the Applicant from Australia, be it voluntary or involuntary removal, but had abandoned any attempt to undertake any such steps.Given that finding of fact, it has been further concluded that:·the detention subsequent to March 2019 up until the May 2021 visas was “unlawful”; and ·there was no lawful authority vested in the Commonwealth to continue to detain the Applicant, and he should have been released from detention soon after March 2019 or (at the very latest) by mid-2019. This last conclusion requires consideration to be given to:·the authority conferred by (in particular) ss 189 and 196; and ·the decision in AJL20. Separately considered are questions as to the quantification of the damages to which the Applicant is entitled.The facts – the steps being pursued between March 2019 and May 2021 Prior to the making of a decision in January 2021 by the Minister for Immigration not to consider intervening pursuant to s 195A of the Migration Act, the evidence as to the steps taken by the Respondent to address the continued detention of the Applicant subsequent to March 2019 is scant. Some evidence specifically directed to the fate of the Applicant prior to January 2021 is that provided by Ms Kiyak. In her affidavit she maintains that on 8 October 2020 she emailed a Mr Chad Brimfield temporarily re-allocating to him the Applicant’s case. That e-mail requested that Mr Brimfield contact the Applicant “for a removal discussion” and that his case “Remains invol – no involuntary removals to IRAQ”. Ms Kiyak was re-allocated the Applicant’s case upon her return from secondment on 30 December 2020. The next event was the sending of an email from Ms Kiyak to Ms Masri, a Border Force Supervisor in Removal Operations, informing Ms Masri (inter alia) that the Applicant had previously withdrawn a request for removal from Australia on 13 March 2019 and that the Applicant had “no ongoing matters before the department”. The email recommended that the Applicant’s case “be managed in the ‘protracted caseload’”. Ms Masri responded on the same day agreeing with the recommendation. Mr Brimfield did not file any affidavit and it is to be assumed that he did nothing in respect to the Applicant during the period from 8 October 2020 through to 30 December 2020. Mr Hector Gonzalez also gave evidence as to his involvement with the Applicant after March 2019. Mr Gonzalez was the Detention Status Resolution Officer assigned to the Applicant between August 2020 and November 2020. His evidence was that he was satisfied that the Applicant was an unlawful non-citizen. Mr Gonzalez maintained that he spoke to the Applicant on 7 September 2020 and spoke “to the applicant’s legal representative on a few occasions during this period”. The subject-matter of the discussion on 7 September 2020 and the discussions with the “legal representatives” were not set forth. Based upon his understanding of the purposes of s 189(1) of the Migration Act, Mr Gonzalez “caused the applicant to continue to be detained at the [Villawood Immigration Detention Centre] in that [he] did not take any steps to effect his release…” Mr Gonzalez completed a case review in respect to the Applicant on 15 September 2020.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In summary, there was no reason to question the general assessment of damages in the sum of $350,000. That figure stands as the assessment of the damages to which the Applicant is entitled. CONCLUSIONS It has been concluded that the continued detention of the Applicant soon after March 2019 or (in any event) by mid-2019 had become unlawful, and that he should have then been released from detention either because:·the term “detain” as employed in ss 189 and 196 should be construed as “lawfully detain”; and/or·the decision in AJL20 is not “plainly wrong” and should be followed and applied by a single Judge of this Court.In the absence of clear and unambiguous statutory language, no construction of ss 189 or 196 should be readily embraced which would render lawful the continued detention of an unlawful non-citizen, in circumstances where the Commonwealth has both abandoned the pursuit of any attempt to remove the Applicant from Australia (be that removal on either a voluntary or involuntary basis) and failed to give any consideration to whether he could be released – even in circumstances where facts which had come to light in June 2016 and again repeated in March 2019 warranted reconsideration of a claim for protection. Separate from any conclusion as to whether or not the Applicant should have been released from detention soon after March 2019 or (in any event) by mid-2019, it has further been concluded that:·had the then Minister properly considered the plight of the Applicant at that point of time, he would in all likelihood not have countenanced the continued unlawful detention of the Applicant and would in all likelihood have granted him a visa; ·the Applicant’s claim for unlawful detention should be determined upon the basis that he would have thereby secured his release from detention at about that time; and ·the Applicant’s claim for unlawful detention should thus succeed and he should be awarded $350,000 by way of general damages. Costs should follow the event. THE ORDERS OF THE COURT ARE:1.The Respondent is to pay the Applicant within 28 days damages assessed in the sum of $350,000. 2.The Respondent is to pay the costs of the Applicant, either as agreed or assessed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

An appeal from the decision in AJL20 was heard by the High Court of Australia on 13 April 2021. Judgment was then reserved.THE MIGRATION ACT The provisions of the Migration Act of immediate relevance to the present proceeding should be set forth and briefly addressed. They are as follows. Initially, it should be noted that the overall “object” of the Act is set forth in s 4 as follows:Object of Act (1)The object of this Act is to regulate, in the national interest, the coming into, and presence in, Australia of non-citizens. (2)To advance its object, this Act provides for visas permitting non-citizens to enter or remain in Australia and the Parliament intends that this Act be the only source of the right of non-citizens to so enter or remain. (3) To advance its object, this Act provides for non-citizens and citizens to be required to provide personal identifiers for the purposes of this Act or the regulations. (4) To advance its object, this Act provides for the removal or deportation from Australia of non-citizens whose presence in Australia is not permitted by this Act. (5) To advance its object, this Act provides for the taking of unauthorised maritime arrivals from Australia to a regional processing country. Of particular importance to any conclusion that an unlawful non-citizen can be released from detention without also having a visa are the terms of s 4(2). Section 5 defines the term “detain” as meaning:(a) take into immigration detention; or (b) keep, or cause to be kept, in immigration detention; and includes taking such action and using such force as are reasonably necessary to do so. The power sought to be exercised to “detain” the Applicant in August 2018 and thereafter was that conferred by s 189(1), which provides as follows:If an officer knows or reasonably suspects that a person in the migration zone (other than an excised offshore place) is an unlawful non-citizen, the officer must detain the person. The mandatory nature of the terms of this section – “the officer must detain” – cannot be underestimated. In Plaintiff M47/2012 v Director-General of Security [2012] HCA 46, (2012) 251 CLR 1 at 78 (“Plaintiff M47/2012”), Hayne J thus observed:[177] The Act spells out the consequences that follow from being a lawful non-citizen or an unlawful non-citizen. Generally, an officer is bound … to detain a person whom the officer knows or reasonably suspects to be an unlawful non-citizen. Subject to the possibility of the Minister making a “residence determination” under s 197AB, s 196(1) requires that an unlawful non-citizen detained under s 189 of the Act “be kept in immigration detention until he or she is” removed from Australia, deported or granted a visa. An officer is bound (s 198(2)) to remove “as soon as reasonably practicable” an unlawful non-citizen who has been detained, has not subsequently been immigration cleared, and has no valid application for a visa that has not yet been finally determined.[178] The Act provides no middle ground between being a lawful non-citizen (entitled to remain in Australia in accordance with any applicable visa requirements) and being an unlawful non-citizen, who may, usually must, be detained and who (assuming there is no pending consideration of a valid visa application) must be removed from Australia as soon as reasonably practicable. These consequences – remaining in Australia on the one hand and detention followed by removal from Australia on the other – follow once the central question has been answered: is the person a lawful non-citizen or an unlawful non-citizen? That question depends upon whether the Minister grants or refuses to grant a visa or, if a visa has previously been granted, whether that visa has since been cancelled.(footnote omitted)