Commonwealth of Australia v MZZHL

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Commonwealth of Australia v MZZHL [2021] FCAFC 191

Appeal from:  MZZHL v Commonwealth of Australia [2021] FCA 600
File number: NSD 645 of 2021
Judgment of: GRIFFITHS, PERRY AND BROMWICH JJ
Date of judgment: 2 November 2021
Catchwords: MIGRATION – appeal from decision of primary judge which held detention of unlawful non-citizen was without statutory authority and awarded $350,000 in damages – where shortly before the hearing below the Commonwealth conceded non-compliance with s 198 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) for one period of the appellant’s immigration detention – where primary judge held “detain” in ss 5, 189 and 196 means “lawfully detain” – whether appeal had to succeed given the recent decision in Commonwealth of Australia v AJL20[2021] HCA 21; 95 ALJR 567 – consideration of Plaintiff S4/2014 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] HCA 34; 253 CLR 219 and related cases in light of AJL20 – combined operation of ss 189(1) and 196(1) of the Migration Act imposes duty to detain unlawful non-citizen until one of the events in s 196(1) occurs – duty to detain not conditional upon compliance with s 198(6) – hedging duties enforceable by mandamus – respondent’s detention lawful – held: appeal allowed
Legislation: Migration Act1958 (Cth) ss 4, 5, 189, 195A, 196, 198
Cases cited:

AJL20 v Commonwealth of Australia [2020] FCA 1305; 279 FCR 549

Al-Kateb v Godwin [2004] HCA 37; 219 CLR 562

Chu Kheng Lim v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs [1992] HCA 64; 176 CLR 1

Commonwealth of Australia v AJL20 [2021] HCA 21; 95 ALJR 567

Fernando v Commonwealth of Australia [2014] FCAFC 181; 231 FCR 251

Guo v Commonwealth of Australia [2017] FCA 1355; 258 FCR 31

Lewis v Australian Capital Territory [2020] HCA 26; 94 ALJR 740

MZZHL v Commonwealth of Australia [2021] FCA 600

Plaintiff M61/2010E v Commonwealth of Australia [2010] HCA 41; 243 CLR 319

Plaintiff M76/2013 v Minister for Immigration, Multicultural Affairs and Citizenship [2013] HCA 53; 251 CLR 322

Plaintiff M79/2012 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] HCA 24; 252 CLR 336

Plaintiff M96A/2016 v Commonwealth of Australia [2017] HCA 16; 261 CLR 582

Plaintiff S4/2014 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] HCA 34; 253 CLR 219

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 50
Date of hearing: 25 October 2021
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr G Kennett SC with Mr C Tran and Ms N Wootton
Solicitor for the Appellant: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr J King with Mr W K Soon
Solicitor for the Respondent: Human Rights for All

ORDERS

NSD 645 of 2021
BETWEEN:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Appellant

AND:

MZZHL

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

GRIFFITHS, PERRY AND BROMWICH JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

2 NOVEMBER 2021

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be allowed.

2.The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commonwealth of Australia v MZZHL and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCAFC 191
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Commonwealth of Australia v MZZHL, the respondent, an unlawful non-citizen, brought proceedings in the Federal Court against the Commonwealth, alleging unlawful detention and seeking damages and a writ of habeas corpus. The respondent had been detained under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) from August 2018 until 4 May 2021. The primary judge found that the respondent had been unlawfully detained from March 2019 until his release in May 2021 and awarded him damages in the sum of $350,000. The Commonwealth appealed the primary judge's decision.

The key legal issue before the court was whether the primary judge was correct in finding that the respondent had been unlawfully detained from March 2019 until his release in May 2021. This issue turned on the interpretation and application of sections 189(1), 196(1) and 198 of the Migration Act. The court was required to consider whether the duty to detain an unlawful non-citizen imposed by sections 189(1) and 196(1) was conditional upon compliance with section 198. The court also had to consider the High Court's recent decision in Commonwealth of Australia v AJL20, which held that the duty to detain is not conditional upon compliance with section 198.

The court held that the primary judge's decision had to be overturned. The court found that the duty to detain an unlawful non-citizen imposed by sections 189(1) and 196(1) of the Migration Act is not conditional upon compliance with section 198. The court noted that the decision in AJL20 confirmed that the duty to detain is not dependent on the Commonwealth taking reasonable steps to remove an unlawful non-citizen. The court held that the respondent's detention from March 2019 until his release in May 2021 was lawful. The court found that the respondent had not been unlawfully detained and that the primary judge's finding to the contrary was incorrect.

Accordingly, the appeal was allowed. The orders dated 7 June 2021 were set aside and in lieu thereof it was ordered that the originating application be dismissed, that the applicant pay the respondent’s costs, save for the costs of the hearing, as agreed or taxed, that the respondent refund to the Commonwealth $350,000, being the amount of damages he received, and that the respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal, as agreed or taxed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The orders dated 7 June 2021 be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered that:

(a) the originating application be dismissed; and

(b) the applicant is to pay the respondent’s costs, save for the costs of the hearing, as agreed or taxed.

3. Within 14 days hereof, the respondent is to refund to the Commonwealth $350,000, being the amount of damages he received pursuant to the Court’s orders dated 7 June 2021.

4. The respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal, as agreed or taxed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The primary judge held that MZZHL had been detained without statutory authority from mid-2019 until 4 May 2021. Damages were awarded in the sum of $350,000 on the basis that, absent his unlawful detention, the respondent would otherwise have been at liberty in the Australian community. The primary judge’s reasons for judgment summarised The primary judge addressed the issue of whether MZZHL had been lawfully detained with reference to the following three separate periods:(a)August 2018 to October 2018;(b)October 2018 to March 2019; and(c)March 2019 to May 2021. As noted above, the Commonwealth’s concession that there had been non-compliance with s 198 applied only to the period after March 2019 and involved an acknowledgment by the Commonwealth that “steps should have been taken to inquire of Iraq whether or not it would be prepared to receive involuntary removals”. With respect to the first period, the primary judge concluded that the respondent was lawfully detained during that period because active steps were taken then to secure his removal from Australia, as required by s 198 (at [38]). With respect to the second period, the primary judge stated at [39] that the respondent’s continued detention after October 2018 was changed because the respondent had made a request in writing on 26 October 2018, pursuant to s 198(1), to be removed from Australia. This triggered a statutory obligation under s 198(1) to remove the respondent as requested “as soon as reasonably practicable”. The primary judge noted that the respondent’s written request was withdrawn on 13 March 2019. For reasons provided by the primary judge at [41] to [44], his Honour concluded that the respondent’s detention during the second period was lawful, largely on the basis of findings that reasonable steps were taken during that period to remove the respondent from Australia. The focus of the appeal was on the primary judge’s finding that the respondent was unlawfully detained during the third period. His Honour identified the central question relating to this period as whether the Commonwealth had taken reasonable steps during this period to remove the respondent from Australia. His Honour’s conclusion on this question is reflected at [47] of his reasons for judgment:Unlike the two earlier periods of detention, it has been concluded for the period of detention between March 2019 and the granting of the May 2021 visas that:•the Respondent was not only taking no steps to secure or attempt to secure the removal of the Applicant from Australia, be it voluntary or involuntary removal, but had abandoned any attempt to undertake any such steps.Given that finding of fact, it has been further concluded that:•the detention subsequent to March 2019 up until the May 2021 visas was “unlawful”; and•there was no lawful authority vested in the Commonwealth to continue to detain the Applicant, and he should have been released from detention soon after March 2019 or (at the very latest) by mid-2019.This last conclusion requires consideration to be given to:•the authority conferred by (in particular) ss 189 and 196; and•the decision in AJL20.Separately considered are questions as to the quantification of the damages to which the Applicant is entitled.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It will be necessary to describe the relevant background matters at greater length, however, for these introductory purposes the following salient matters are noted. The respondent (who has the pseudonym MZZHL) arrived in Australia in May 2012 as an unauthorised maritime arrival. He was detained under s 189(3) of the Migration Act1958 (Cth). In May 2013, he was granted a bridging visa. After that visa expired in June 2014, the respondent lived for a period in the community without a visa (i.e. as an unlawful non-citizen). On 10 August 2018, he was taken into immigration detention again under s 189 of the Migration Act. MZZHL commenced proceedings in the Court in October 2020. He sought damages and an order in the nature of a writ of habeas corpus, claiming that he had been unlawfully detained. A few days before the trial below, the Commonwealth conceded that, from 13 March 2019, its officers had not complied with the duty to remove the respondent from Australia as soon as reasonably practicable as required by s 198 of the Migration Act. On the first day of the trial (4 May 2021), the respondent was granted a bridging visa under s 195A of the Migration Act and released from detention. That visa was due to expire on 4 November 2021 but the Court was informed that on 28 October 2021 MZZHL was granted a three-month s 195A bridging visa. The primary judge held that MZZHL had been detained without statutory authority from mid-2019 until 4 May 2021. Damages were awarded in the sum of $350,000 on the basis that, absent his unlawful detention, the respondent would otherwise have been at liberty in the Australian community. The primary judge’s reasons for judgment summarised The primary judge addressed the issue of whether MZZHL had been lawfully detained with reference to the following three separate periods:(a)August 2018 to October 2018;(b)October 2018 to March 2019; and(c)March 2019 to May 2021. As noted above, the Commonwealth’s concession that there had been non-compliance with s 198 applied only to the period after March 2019 and involved an acknowledgment by the Commonwealth that “steps should have been taken to inquire of Iraq whether or not it would be prepared to receive involuntary removals”. With respect to the first period, the primary judge concluded that the respondent was lawfully detained during that period because active steps were taken then to secure his removal from Australia, as required by s 198 (at [38]). With respect to the second period, the primary judge stated at [39] that the respondent’s continued detention after October 2018 was changed because the respondent had made a request in writing on 26 October 2018, pursuant to s 198(1), to be removed from Australia. This triggered a statutory obligation under s 198(1) to remove the respondent as requested “as soon as reasonably practicable”. The primary judge noted that the respondent’s written request was withdrawn on 13 March 2019. For reasons provided by the primary judge at [41] to [44], his Honour concluded that the respondent’s detention during the second period was lawful, largely on the basis of findings that reasonable steps were taken during that period to remove the respondent from Australia.