Plaintiff M79/2012 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
HAYNE, CRENNAN, BELL AND GAGELER JJ

PLAINTIFF M79/2012  PLAINTIFF

AND

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND
CITIZENSHIP  DEFENDANT

Plaintiff M79/2012 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

[2013] HCA 24

29 May 2013

M79/2012

ORDER

The questions asked by the parties in the Amended Special Case dated 30 October 2012 and referred for consideration by the Full Court be answered as follows:

Question 1

Was the plaintiff validly granted the temporary safe haven visa?

Answer

Yes.

Question 2

Is the plaintiff's application for a protection visa a valid application?

Answer

No.

Question 3

Who should pay the costs of this Special Case?

Answer

The plaintiff.

Representation

M R Pearce SC and L G De Ferrari for the plaintiff (instructed by Baker & McKenzie)

J T Gleeson SC, Acting Solicitor-General of the Commonwealth with S P Donaghue SC and K L Walker for the defendant (instructed by Sparke Helmore)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

FRENCH CJ, CRENNAN AND BELL JJ.

Introduction

  1. The mandatory detention in Australia of asylum seekers without visas who have tried to enter Australia from the sea is a matter of intense public interest and debate.  Most if not all of such arrivals seek protection visas under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ("the Act") on the basis that they are refugees under the Refugees Convention[1] to whom Australia, as a party to that Convention, owes protection obligations.  

    [1]Convention relating to the Status of Refugees (1951) as amended by the Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees (1967).

  2. The Act provides that such asylum seekers who have arrived in designated "excised offshore places" cannot make a valid application for a protection visa unless the Minister exercises a statutory dispensing power.  An administrative assessment and independent review process has been created to determine their claims for refugee status so that the Minister can then decide whether or not to consider exercising that dispensing power. 

  3. In order to enable a number of such persons to be released from detention pending completion of the assessment and review processes, the Minister, exercising a special power applicable to persons in detention under the Act, decided it was in the public interest to grant each of them two visas: a seven-day temporary safe haven visa and a bridging visa of a duration between three and twelve months. The duration of the bridging visa varied according to different categories of asylum seeker. The purpose of granting the seven-day temporary safe haven visas was to enliven a statutory bar, which would survive the expiry of those visas, preventing the asylum seekers from making a valid application for a protection visa unless the Minister exercised another dispensing power. The purpose of granting the bridging visas was to enable the asylum seekers to remain in the community, to work and to access services pending completion of the assessment and independent review of their claims for protection.

  4. The plaintiff was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Plaintiff M79/2012 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenshi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] HCA 24
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, an unlawful non-citizen and an "offshore entry person" from Sri Lanka, sought judicial review of the Minister's decision to grant him a temporary safe haven visa. The dispute concerned the validity of this visa grant and, consequently, the validity of the plaintiff's subsequent application for a protection visa. The matter was brought before the Full Court of the High Court of Australia by way of a special case.

The court was required to determine whether the Minister had the power to grant the temporary safe haven visa under section 195A(2) of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth), particularly when the Minister had not considered whether the plaintiff actually required temporary safe haven. A further issue was whether the decision to grant the visa was made for an improper purpose, and whether the plaintiff's application for a protection visa was valid, given the operation of sections 91J and 91K of the Act which impose bars on making such applications.

The court reasoned that the Minister's power under section 195A(2) to grant a visa in the public interest was not constrained by the specific purposes for which a particular class of visa was created. The court found that the Minister's decision to grant the temporary safe haven visa was a valid exercise of the power conferred by section 195A(2), as the purposes for which it was granted were not shown to be beyond the scope and purpose of the Act or the power itself, and therefore were not improper purposes. Consequently, the court held that the plaintiff's subsequent application for a protection visa was not valid due to the operation of sections 91J and 91K of the Act.

The court answered the questions posed in the special case as follows: the plaintiff was validly granted the temporary safe haven visa; the plaintiff's application for a protection visa was not valid; and the plaintiff was ordered to pay the costs of the special case.

Orders

Orders of the court

The questions asked by the parties in the Amended Special Case dated 30 October 2012 and referred for consideration by the Full Court be answered as follows:

Question 1

Was the plaintiff validly granted the temporary safe haven visa?

Answer

Yes.

Question 2

Is the plaintiff's application for a protection visa a valid application?

Answer

No.

Question 3

Who should pay the costs of this Special Case?

Answer

The plaintiff.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff commenced a proceeding in the original jurisdiction of this Court seeking, among other relief, certiorari to quash the Minister's decision made on 12 April 2012 to grant the plaintiff a temporary safe haven visa. The parties agreed in stating questions of law for the opinion of the Full Court in the form of a special case. Those questions asked about the validity of the grant of a temporary safe haven visa and the validity of an application the plaintiff had made for a protection visa. The special case set out agreed facts and documents on which the questions were to be determined.Relevant facts and circumstances On about 7 February 2010, the plaintiff entered Australian territory by entering the Territory of Christmas Island. The Territory of Christmas Island was what the Act called[48] an "excised offshore place". The plaintiff is a citizen of Sri Lanka and he did not have a visa to enter or remain in Australia. He was, therefore, "an unlawful non‑citizen"[49] and he was detained under s 189(3) of the Act. [48]s 5(1), par (a) of the definition of "excised offshore place".[49]s 14(1). Because the plaintiff entered Australia at an excised offshore place and became an unlawful non‑citizen because of that entry, he was[50] an "offshore entry person". For so long as the plaintiff remained in Australia as an unlawful non‑citizen, he could not make a valid application for a visa[51] unless the Minister personally decided to exercise the non‑compellable power given by s 46A(2) to allow the plaintiff to apply for a visa. [50]s 5(1), definition of "offshore entry person".[51]s 46A(1). The plaintiff claimed to be a person to whom Australia owed protection obligations under the Refugees Convention[52]. While the plaintiff was in detention, a departmental officer considered that claim for the purpose of advising the Minister of a matter to which the Minister may wish to have regard in deciding whether to exercise the power under s 46A(2) to permit the plaintiff to apply for a visa. The officer determined that the plaintiff was not a refugee. [52]Convention relating to the Status of Refugees (1951) as amended by the Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees (1967). The plaintiff asked that the officer's decision be reviewed. An independent reviewer appointed by the Minister also concluded that the plaintiff was not a refugee and recommended to the Minister that the plaintiff not be recognised as a person to whom Australia had protection obligations under the Refugees Convention. The plaintiff applied to the Federal Magistrates Court for a declaration that the recommendation of the independent reviewer had not been made according to law. That application has been heard but has not been determined. In November 2011, after the plaintiff had made his application for judicial review of the independent reviewer's decision, the Minister announced that some offshore entry persons (or "irregular maritime arrivals") held in detention would be "considered for community placement on bridging visas while their asylum claims are assessed". On 5 April 2012, the Minister agreed with the Department's recommendation that he consider exercising the power under s 195A(2) of the Act with regard to the plaintiff and 288 other "irregular maritime arrivals". The Department proposed that each should be granted both a temporary safe haven visa (valid for seven days) and a bridging visa "with no work limitations". The Department told the Minister that the grant of temporary safe haven visas to these persons would "bar them from lodging further onshore visa applications".

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, CRENNAN AND BELL JJ HAYNE J GAGELER J
It was open to the Minister, in this case, to grant a temporary safe haven visa by reference to its legal characteristics and consequences unconstrained by the purpose for which it was created under the Act. The purposes for which the Minister might grant such a class of visa were those purposes which would serve the public interest as the Minister judged it. In this case those purposes were not shown to be beyond the scope and purpose of the Act, nor the power conferred by s 195A. They were not improper purposes. The grant of the temporary safe haven visa to the plaintiff was a valid application of the power conferred by s 195A(2). It also follows, by operation of ss 91J and 91K of the Act, that the plaintiff's application for a protection visa made on 18 September 2012 was not a valid application.Conclusion For the preceding reasons, the questions stated for the opinion of the Court on the special case should be answered as follows:•Question 1: Was the plaintiff validly granted the temporary safe haven visa?Answer: yes.•Question 2: Is the plaintiff's application for a protection visa a valid application?Answer: no.• Question 3: Who should pay the costs of this special case?Answer: the plaintiff. The object of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ("the Act") "is to regulate, in the national interest, the coming into, and presence in, Australia of non‑citizens"[42]. To advance that object, the Act "provides for visas permitting non‑citizens to enter or remain in Australia"[43] and records[44] that "the Parliament intends that [the] Act be the only source of the right of non‑citizens to so enter or remain" (emphasis added). [42]s 4(1).[43]s 4(2).[44]s 4(2). Section 31(1) provided that "[t]here are to be prescribed classes of visas". Some of those classes were provided[45] for by the Act in ss 32‑38B and some were prescribed[46] by regulations made under the Act. This proceeding concerns a "temporary safe haven visa", which is a class of visa provided for by s 37A of the Act. The Minister, relying on the power given by s 195A(2), purported to grant the plaintiff a temporary safe haven visa. Section 195A(2) provided that:"If the Minister thinks that it is in the public interest to do so, the Minister may grant a person to whom this section applies a visa of a particular class (whether or not the person has applied for the visa)."In exercising that power, the Minister was not bound by specified provisions of the Act, or by regulations made under the Act, but was bound by all other provisions of the Act[47].[45]s 31(2).[46]ss 31(1) and 504(1).[47]s 195A(3). The central question in this proceeding is whether s 195A(2) empowered the Minister, if "the Minister thinks that it is in the public interest to do so", to grant a visa of a class provided for by the Act, regardless of whether any statutory requirements for that visa were met. In particular, did s 195A(2) give the Minister power to grant the plaintiff a s 37A temporary safe haven visa when the Minister neither considered whether, nor decided that, the plaintiff needed temporary safe haven in Australia? These reasons will show that the Minister did not have this power. The present proceeding

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, CRENNAN AND BELL JJ, HAYNE J, GAGELER J