Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v MZYHS

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v MZYHS [2011] FCA 53

Citation: Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v MZYHS [2011] FCA 53
Appeal from: MZYHS v Minister for Immigration and Anor [2010] FMCA 417
Parties: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP v MZYHS and REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File number: VID 558 of 2010
Judge: KENNY J
Date of judgment: 31 January 2011
Catchwords: MIGRATION – appeal from decision of Federal Magistrate upholding an application for review of decision of Refugee Review Tribunal – whether Refugee Review Tribunal failed to take into account a relevant consideration – whether decision affected by jurisdictional error – whether psychologist’s report is corroborative evidence of claim to be a refugee – whether failure to consider report as corroborative amounts to jurisdictional error – whether Refugee Review Tribunal misunderstood the purpose of psychologist’s report – making findings on credibility is the function of the decision-maker – it is a matter for the Tribunal to determine the weight to be given to a psychologist’s report – no jurisdictional error – appeal allowed
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth)
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth)
Cases cited: Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf (2001) 206 CLR 323
Craig v South Australia (1995) 184 CLR 163
Abebe v Commonwealth (1999) 197 CLR 510
Htun v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2001) 194 ALR 244
Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2003) 75 ALD 630
NABE v Minister of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (No 2) (2004) 144 FCR 1
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZNPG (2010) 115 ALD 303
Paul v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2001) 113 FCR 396
NADR v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 167
Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; ex parte Durairajasingham (2000) 58 ALD 609
Enfield City v Development Assessment Commission (2000) 199 CLR 135
SZKHD v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2008] FCA 112
Illankovan v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2005] FCA 220
Cong Tam Dang v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (2000) 61 ALD 29
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZNSP (2010) 184 FCR 485
Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; ex parte Applicant S20/2002 (2003) 198 ALR 59
Subramaniam v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2002] FCAFC 255
Thirukkumar v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairrs [2002] FCAFC 268
VGAP v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCA 1607
Rezaei v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2001] FCA 1294
SZJSS v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2009) 113 ALD 270
Swift v SAS Trustee Corporation [2010] NSWCA 182
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZJSS [2010] HCA 48
Date of hearing: 25 November 2010
Date of last submissions: 6 December 2010
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 44
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr R Knowles
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v MZYHS and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 53
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves a challenge to the decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (the Tribunal) to deny a protection visa to the first respondent, a citizen of Bahrain, who had applied for the visa on the basis of a fear of persecution due to his political activities and religious beliefs. The Federal Magistrate had previously quashed the Tribunal’s decision and ordered a re-determination. The Minister for Immigration and Citizenship sought to appeal that decision, arguing that the Tribunal had failed to properly consider a psychologist’s report that corroborated the first respondent’s claims of torture and persecution.

The central legal issue was whether the Tribunal’s failure to appropriately consider the psychologist’s report as corroborative evidence constituted a jurisdictional error. The court had to determine whether such a failure amounted to a disregard of a relevant consideration that the Tribunal was bound to take into account. The Minister argued that the Tribunal misunderstood the purpose of the psychologist’s report, which was intended to support the first respondent’s claims rather than merely assess his fitness to give evidence. The first respondent, on the other hand, contended that the Federal Magistrate’s decision should be upheld because the Tribunal’s handling of the report demonstrated a jurisdictional error.

The court held that while the Tribunal did consider the psychologist’s report, it did not adequately address the report’s purpose as corroborative evidence of the first respondent’s claims. The court found that the Tribunal had misunderstood the significance of the report, which was intended to support the first respondent’s account rather than just assess his fitness to testify. This misunderstanding led the Tribunal to improperly evaluate the report. The court concluded that this failure to consider the report as intended did amount to a jurisdictional error, as the Tribunal was bound to take into account evidence that corroborated the first respondent’s claims. Therefore, the Federal Magistrate’s decision to quash the Tribunal’s decision was correct.

The appeal was allowed, the orders of the Federal Magistrates Court were set aside, and the application for judicial review was dismissed. The first respondent was ordered to pay the Minister’s costs of the proceeding in the Federal Magistrates Court as well as the costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The orders made by the Federal Magistrates Court on 23 June 2010 be set aside and, in lieu thereof, order:

(a) the application for judicial review be dismissed;

(b) the first respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the proceeding in the Federal Magistrates Court.

3. The first respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons stated, I would allow the appeal.BACKGROUND The Tribunal found that the first respondent was a citizen of Bahrain, who entered Australia on 9 May 2007. The first respondent lodged an application with the appellant’s Department for a protection visa on 20 June 2007, claiming that he would be persecuted for reasons of his political opinion and religion if he returned to Bahrain. The first respondent claimed to be a Shiite Muslim, with a history of political activism in Bahrain and consequential punishment, including detention, by the authorities in that country. In a statutory declaration accompanying his protection visa application, the first respondent made a number of claims, including that: (1) he was detained “for about 14 months, from June 1996 to August 1997” following his participation in a peaceful demonstration for the release of detainees; (2) during this detention, he was tortured and “subjected to humiliation and inhumane treatment” and, as a result, continued to suffer psychologically and physically after his release; (3) after his release, he was “under constant surveillance by authorities” and was terrorised by authorities coming to his house at night; (4) he had difficulty in obtaining employment on account of his political detention and on account of being a Shiite Muslim; (5) he was arrested and detained in 2002 for his participation in a demonstration; (6) as a result of this political detention, he was “effectively banned from accessing employment through the employment ministry so it became even harder to look for work”; (7) since 2002, he had been actively involved in protesting against his situation and that of others in Bahrain; (8) he obtained a visa to visit Australia in 2006 because he was “worried that [his] situation might become dangerous”; (9) he was involved in a demonstration against detention and torture in April 2007, as a consequence of which he was arrested and beaten; (10) friends subsequently took him to hospital and his father advised him that he was wanted by the authorities; (11) an uncle arranged for him to leave Bahrain; and (12) he continues to suffer from “nightmares and flashbacks” and fears for his family and that, if returned to Bahrain, he would be arrested, harmed or killed. In addition to Convention-based claims that the first respondent faced a real chance of persecution on political and religious grounds, in a letter from the Refugee & Immigration Legal Centre Inc dated 29 April 2009, a further claim was made on the first respondent’s behalf that he faced persecution on the basis of “his membership of the [social] group ‘survivors of torture in Bahrain’”. On 17 September 2007, a delegate of the Minister refused to grant the first respondent a protection visa. The Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision on 22 April 2008. On 12 August 2008, a Federal Magistrate ordered that writs of certiorari, prohibition and mandamus issue to the Tribunal, amongst other things, quashing its decision and requiring it to re-determine the first respondent’s review application according to law.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the course of setting out its findings with respect to the first respondent’s claims, the Tribunal stated:The Tribunal has considered the various reports from psychologists about the applicant’s mental health. While the Tribunal respects the opinions of the psychologists and has taken them into account, their assessment has not extended to pronouncements that the applicant has ever been unfit to give evidence to the Tribunal. The format of these reports follows the usual pattern of recording the applicant’s version of events and this version of events is subject to scrutiny by the Tribunal. That is, the Tribunal considered that, in so far as the psychologists’ reports (including the Stewart report) recorded the first respondent’s version of events (including that he was a torture victim), they were subject to the Tribunal’s independent examination and assessment. THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATE’S DECISION In his judicial review application in the Federal Magistrates Court, the first respondent asserted various bases for imputing jurisdictional error to the Tribunal. The Federal Magistrate accepted only one of them – concerning the Stewart report. Under the heading of “particulars”, the first respondent had asserted that the Tribunal: … misunderstood the basis and the purpose for which the Psychologist’s Report was produced – which was as evidence of the manner in which the Applicant presented (as someone who had experienced torture) – and dealt with the evidence and claims therein so misunderstood by taking the report into account only on the question of the Applicant’s capacity or fitness to give evidence to the Tribunal.It failed to take account of a relevant consideration or relevant material being the Psychologist’s Report which tended to corroborate the Applicant’s account of past persecution and/or failed to take it into account in any meaningful sense.It failed to give genuine or real consideration to the report and its contents.In circumstances where the “well was not poisoned beyond redemption” it failed to pay due regard to corroborative evidence provided by the Psychologist’s Report of incarceration and torture experienced by the Applicant in the past. It made a finding of lack of credibility without more based on “incongruence” between certain matters leading to rejection of incarceration in 1996 and 2002 before it began to consider the Report. The Federal Magistrate rejected the first respondent’s other grounds of challenge and, in so far as they were not the subject of the appeal, they may be put to one side. The Federal Magistrate accepted the first respondent’s submission that the Tribunal had not considered, as it was bound to do, that the Stewart report was evidence “which tended to corroborate the [first respondent’s] account of past persecution”. His Honour agreed with the first respondent that “the Tribunal appears to have misunderstood what the evidence was designed to achieve”: see MZYHS v Minister for Immigration [2010] FMCA 417 at [20]. His Honour said (at [25]-[28]):In my view, the finding that the account given by Ms Stewart of the facts followed the recitation given to her by the applicant, while true, does not deal with the basis upon which the evidence was put forward. The Tribunal being seized of the fact (or at least as it should have been) that the applicant [first respondent] was saying that his mental state now gives probative force to his assertions of the historical events he asserted is simply not dealt with by the Tribunal in its decision.Given that the evidence of Ms Stewart was uncontradicted expert evidence, this was a matter that the Tribunal, being seized of, should have dealt with.In my view, the failure to address this relevant consideration and relevant evidence falls squarely within the ambit of jurisdictional error.In other words, the Federal Magistrate held that the Tribunal had misunderstood the significance of the Stewart report and, in so doing, had failed to take into account a consideration that it was bound to take into account. Hence, his Honour made a finding of jurisdictional error.THE PARTIES’ SUBMISSIONS

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The first respondent sought to maintain the judgment of the Federal Magistrate on the basis that his Honour’s reasons were correct, and on a further basis mentioned below. CONSIDERATION The basic principles as to when jurisdictional error will arise for failure to consider a relevant consideration are well-accepted. Jurisdictional error may be shown where a statutory decision-maker disregards a relevant consideration, in the sense discussed in Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24 (‘Peko-Wallsend’): see Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf (2001) 206 CLR 323 (‘Yusuf’) at 351 [82], citing Craig v South Australia (1995) 184 CLR 163 at 179. That is, the ground of failure to take into account a relevant consideration is only made out if the decision-maker failed to take into account a consideration that the decision-maker was bound to take into account in making the decision: Peko-Wallsend at 39-41. Governing legislation may expressly state all these considerations, although often it does not. In this latter case, relevant considerations in this limited sense are to be determined by reference to the subject-matter, scope and purpose of the governing legislation, which, in the current context, includes the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) and the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth): see, e.g., Yusuf at 347-8 [73] (McHugh, Gummow and Hayne JJ), citing Abebe v Commonwealth (1999) 197 CLR 510 at 579 [195]. Their Honours went on to say in Yusuf (at 348 [74]):What is important … is that the grounds of judicial review that fasten upon the use made of relevant and irrelevant considerations are concerned essentially with whether the decision-maker has properly applied the law. They are not grounds that are centrally concerned with the process of making the particular findings of fact upon which the decision-maker acts. Referring to Htun v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2001) 194 ALR 244 (‘Htun’) at 259 [42], the Minister accepted that, having regard to the statutory framework governing applications for protection visas, an applicant’s claim to be a refugee and the integers of that claim are considerations that a decision-maker is bound to take into account. See also Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2003) 75 ALD 630 (‘WAEE’) at 641 [46]; and NABE v Minister of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (No 2) (2004) 144 FCR 1 (‘NABE’) at 20 [63]. The Minister drew a distinction between a failure to consider an integer of a claim to be a refugee (or a contention that, if accepted, might establish a well-founded fear of persecution) and a failure to take into account evidence that, if accepted, might have led to a different finding of fact. As the Minister submitted, and I accept, a failure to refer to, or adequately to consider, evidence, whether or not it might be thought probative, does not give rise to jurisdictional error, even though it may have led to an erroneous finding of fact. The authorities for this proposition are numerous: see, for example, Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZNPG (2010) 115 ALD 303 at 308-9 at [21]-[28] (North and Lander JJ, with whom Katzmann J agreed (see at [35])); Htun at 259 [42] (Allsop J, with whom Spender J agreed); WAEE at 641 [46]; and Paul v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2001) 113 FCR 396 at 423 [79] (Allsop J, with whom Heerey J agreed). Related propositions are that the weight to be given evidence is a matter for the decision-maker and that a wrong finding of fact does not of itself give rise to jurisdictional error. Furthermore, making findings on credibility is the function of the decision-maker; and they are not ordinarily open to challenge in a court on a judicial review application: NADR v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 167 at [9]; Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; ex parte Durairajasingham (2000) 58 ALD 609 at 624-5 [64]-[67] (McHugh J); Abebe v Commonwealth (1999) 197 CLR 510 at 560 [137] (Gummow and Hayne JJ); and Enfield City v Development Assessment Commission (2000) 199 CLR 135 at 153-4 [44] (Gleeson CJ, Gummow, Kirby and Hayne JJ).