Telstra Corporation Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Telstra Corporation Ltd v ACCC
[2008] FCA 1758

TRADE AND COMMERCE – Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), Part XIC, telecommunications industry and access regime – dispute between Telstra and Optus regarding access to Unconditioned Local Loop Service (ULLS) in multi-dwelling units (MDUs) – resolution of access dispute by Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) – final determination made by ACCC establishing regime for ordering and provisioning of ULLS – whether final determination lawfully made


ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – judicial review – grounds of review – appeal under Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) (ADJR) Act 1977 (Cth), s 5 – whether final determination unlawfully made on grounds that, in making final determination, ACCC: (1) did not take into account Telstra’s direct costs of providing access to the ULLS (s 152CR(1)(d)); or (2) did not properly have regard to industry code as model terms and conditions (152AQB(9)) or otherwise (s 152CR(2)); or (3) failed to specify with reasonable precision or certainty terms and conditions relating access (s 152CP(2)); or (4) was so unreasonable that no reasonable person could have so exercised the power (Wednesbury unreasonableness);  or (5) exceeded its jurisdiction by incorrectly assuming a matter upon which the exercise of its jurisdiction depended (s 152CP(1))

TRADE AND COMMERCE – Trade Practices Act, Part XIC, Div 8 – extent to which ACCC’s earlier determination adopted industry code standards regarding ordering and provisioning of ULLS – mandatory terms of s 152AQB(1)(b) and (3) which stated respectively that ACCC “must make a written determination setting out model terms and conditions relating to access to each core service” and that ACCC “must take all reasonable steps to ensure that” such a determination is made within six months after commencement of section – whether ACCC had discretion to declare some but not all model terms and conditions relating to core service

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – clear words used by Parliament requiring ACCC to make written determination to set out model terms and conditions relating to ULLS and to take all reasonable steps to do so within six months – explanatory memorandum qualifying clear words in Bill

Held:  Final determination by ACCC invalid

(1)Words of Minister must not be substituted for text of law, particularly where text of law imposes responsibilities and liabilities on persons, including corporations, who contravene it – the earlier determination of model terms and conditions can and should be construed as a valid exercise of power under s 152AQB(2) by treating ambiguous language in it as intended to comply with the unambiguous terms of the Act

(2)When s 152CR(1)(d) required ACCC, in making final determination, to “take…into account” Telstra’s direct costs in providing access to ULLS, ACCC was required to take that matter into account, together with other matters referred to in that section, and give weight to them as fundamental elements in making its decision – ACCC required to give matter “fundamental weight” in sense that it was to treat consideration of factors (as opposed to factors themselves) as central element…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Telstra Corporation Ltd v Australian Competition and Consume... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 1758
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Telstra Corporation Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, the dispute centered on the interpretation and validity of a determination made by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) regarding the telecommunications industry. The matter was brought before the court by Telstra, who sought to challenge the final determination made by the ACCC. The legal issues the court was required to decide included the admissibility of certain evidence presented by Telstra and the interpretation of specific technical terms within the final determination. The court found that some of the evidence presented by Telstra was admissible as it related to the meaning of technical terms used in the final determination and the industry codes.

The court's reasoning focused on the interpretation of the final determination and the industry codes, including the ULLS (unconditioned local loop service). The court found that the final determination could be read consistently with the Act and that certain parts of it could be severed without affecting the overall validity of the determination. However, the court concluded that the final determination was invalid as it contained an incorrect approach to the significance of a soft dial tone. The court also noted that the explanations provided by Telstra's witness, Mr McAinsh, were in the nature of submissions rather than evidence.

The court quashed the final determination made by the ACCC on 30 November 2007 and remitted the matter back to the ACCC for hearing and determination according to law. Additionally, the court ordered that the ACCC pay Telstra's costs. This decision highlights the importance of correctly interpreting technical terms and industry codes in administrative decisions and the role of evidence in understanding the natural and ordinary meaning of those terms.

Orders

Orders of the court

2. The final determination made by the first respondent on 30 November 2007 be quashed with effect from 30 November 2007.

3. The matter be remitted to the first respondent for hearing and determination according to law.

4. The second respondent pay the applicant’s costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Notwithstanding the way in which the Commission expressed itself, first, in its determination under s 152AQB, and secondly, in submissions it made (and Optus adopted) before me, I am of opinion that the October 2003 determination can and should be read consistently with the Act. I find that the then existing industry codes relating to the ordering and provisioning of the ULLS were determined by the Commission to be model terms and conditions (except to the extent that there were any different or inconsistent “contentious” terms expressly specified) in the October 2003 determination.4. AFFIDAVIT EVIDENCE During the hearing Telstra relied on two affidavits by Craig McAinsh which he prepared for the purposes of the proceedings. Mr McAinsh was Telstra’s business processes and systems manager in its wholesale customer transfer group. Some of the material in those affidavits was not objected to, while other portions were relied on as evidence of facts to support Telstra’s arguments going to the validity of the final determination. Optus objected that several other passages in the affidavits were inadmissible because they were in the nature of submissions. Optus argued that, by including detailed submissions in Mr McAinsh’s affidavits, Telstra was seeing to adduce further evidence in addition to what was before the Commission and, in some cases, to vary its position in respect of certain matters. Optus argued that, in light of the evidence before the Commission, no further explanation of the various technical matters was admissible in these proceedings. However, it also relied on an affidavit of Haris Khaliqi, one of its business program managers, in relation to certain matters dealt with by Mr McAinsh. In my opinion, some of the contentious material was admissible to prove the meaning of technical terms used in the final determination, Code 569 and Guideline 587 (discussed below at Ch 7) in the context of the telecommunications industry: Collector of Customs v Agfa Gevaert Ltd (1996) 186 CLR 389 at 398-399 per Brennan CJ, Dawson, Toohey, Gaudron and McHugh JJ. Evidence as to the meaning of technical terms used in an administrative decision is admissible so that the Court is placed in the context of understanding the natural and ordinary meaning of those words as they would be understood by persons familiar with their use: see also Australian Retailers Association v Reserve Bank of Australia (2005) 148 FCR 446 at 566 [458]. Such evidence is capable of establishing that the decision-maker erred in its understanding of the technical matters with which its decision dealt. In Australian Retailers Association 148 FCR at 566 [458], Weinberg J held that such evidence is admissible where an administrative decision is challenged on the ground that the decision-maker lacked jurisdiction to make it because that was dependent on an actual state of facts that did not exist, or the decision-maker based the decision on a finding of a particular fact that did not exist. He said:“If additional evidence is available, in cases reliant upon such grounds, there is no reason in principle why such evidence should not also be admissible where the ground is couched in terms of unreasonableness.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

I am of opinion that par 10(e) could be severed because the rest of the final determination would not operate differently without it: Bank of New South Wales v The Commonwealth (1948) 76 CLR 1 at 371 per Dixon J; Victoria v The Commonwealth (Industrial Relations Act Case) (1996) 187 CLR 416 at 502 per Brennan CJ, Toohey, Gaudron, McHugh and Gummow JJ. The relevance of par 10(e) is that it confirms the incorrect approach which the Commission took as to the significance of a soft dial tone in par 10(a). Severance of par 10(e) would not make the final determination any more meaningful or give it validity.15. CONCLUSION For these reasons, I am of opinion that the final determination was invalid and should be quashed (see s 16(1)(a) of the ADJR Act).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On the other hand, I have treated Mr McAinsh’s explanations, in his affidavit evidence in these proceedings, of the way in which par 10 of the final determination operated, as being in the nature of submissions and not as evidence before me.5. THE COMMISSION’S DECLARATION OF THE ULLS The Commission’s declaration of the ULLS under s 152AL(3) of the Act, which was in effect from 1 August 2006, was as follows:“The unconditioned local loop service is the use of use of unconditioned communications wire between the boundary of a telecommunications network at an end-user’s premises and a point on a telecommunications network that is a potential point of interconnection located at or associated with a customer access module and located on the end-user side of the customer access module.DefinitionsWhere words or phrases used in this declaration are defined in the Trade Practices Act 1974 or the Telecommunications Act 1997, they have the meaning given in the relevant Act.In this Appendix:boundary of a telecommunications network is the point ascertained in accordance with section 22 of the Telecommunications Act 1977;communications wire is a copper based wire forming part of a public switched telephone network;customer access module is a device that provides ring tone, ring current and battery feed to customers’ equipment. Examples are Remote Subscriber Stages, Remote Subscriber Units, Integrated Remote Integrated Multiplexers, Non-integrated Remote Integrated Multiplexers and the customer line module of a Local Access Switch;public switched telephone network is a telephone network accessible by the public providing switching and transmission facilities utilising analogue and digital technologies.” 6. CODE 5696.1 Objectives and definitions Code 569 stated that its objectives were to establish operational principles which would enable an access seeker to be supplied with an ULLS to provide carriage and/or content services to its customers and to set out principles for the implementation and operation of the ULLS in accordance with the Act and the Commission’s declaration of local telecommunications services. The Code defined a communications wire as “a copper or aluminium based wire, forming part of a [PSTN]”. This incorporated part of the definition of the ULLS in the declaration made by the Commission under s 152AL(3). For the avoidance of doubt, Code 569 noted that a communications wire generally meant a copper or aluminium cable pair. (Nothing turns here on the Code referring to aluminium wire in addition to the copper wire used in the Commission’s declaration of the ULLS.) The communications wire, however, had to be unconditioned if it were to meet the definition of the ULLS in the s 152AC(3) declaration. The following definitions in the Code are relevant:“In Use ULLS means a ULLS that is currently being used by a Party [i.e. industry participant] to supply services to a Customer.ULLS Identifier means a unique number allocated by the [access provider] to an individual ULLS.ULLS Request means a specific request from the [access seeker which will gain the customer] to the [access provider] for a Vacant or In Use ULLS or ULLS Transfer Request.ULLS Request Identification Number is a request from the [gaining access seeker] to the [losing access seeker] to determine what Service Number [defined as the Customer’s fixed network billing service number identifiable by full national number – i.e. the telephone number of the Customer] or Service Numbers are associated with an In Use ULLS.ULLS Transfer Request is a request from the [gaining access seeker] to the [access provider] to process a ULLS Transfer [defined as the successful transfer of a ULLS between the losing access seeker and gaining access seeker].Vacant ULLS means a ULLS that is not an In Use ULLS.”