FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Official Trustee in Bankruptcy v Kent [2023] FCA 1211
File number: NSD 272 of 2022 Judgment of: RARES ACJ Date of judgment: 11 October 2023 Catchwords: BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY – meaning of ‘property’, ‘property of the bankrupt’ and ‘property divisible amongst the creditors of the bankrupt’ in ss 5(1) and 116 of Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) – where s 912A(1)(g)(i) and (2) and Pt 7.10A of Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) required financial services licensees to be members of dispute resolution scheme to deal with complaints by retail clients of licensees – where s 1051(4)(e) of Corporations Act required determination under scheme to be binding on licensees if complainant accepted it – where Australian Financial Complaints Authority Ltd (AFCA) operated scheme – where s 116(2)(g)(i) of Bankruptcy Act excepted from property of bankrupt divisible amongst creditors any right of bankrupt to recover compensation for personal wrong and any compensation awarded in respect of such wrong - where, after discharge, bankrupt made complaint to AFCA under scheme about pre-bankruptcy loans by licensee – where subject matter of complaint could comprehend contravention of civil penalty provision or offence under s 133(1) and (6) of National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (Cth) (NCCP Act) of entry into credit contract with consumer that was unsuitable for him or her (irresponsible lending) – where s 178(1) and (2) gave right only to a consumer who had suffered loss or damage if licensee contravened or offended against NCCP Act to apply to court for an order to compensate him or her for loss or damage from contravention of offence – where licensee acknowledged irresponsible lending in answering complaint – where licensee and trustee in bankruptcy, without consent of bankrupt, entered into deed to resolve complaint on final basis for financial loss sum to be paid to trustee for distribution to unsecured creditors and balance to bankrupt – whether right to make complaint under AFCA scheme property at all or property of bankrupt that vested in trustee under s 58(1) of Bankruptcy Act – where only bankrupt and not trustee could make complaint to AFCA under scheme – whether right to apply for order under ss 178(2) and 179(3) of NCCP Act property at all or property of bankrupt that vested in trustee under s 58(1) of Bankruptcy Act – whether right to make complaint under scheme or apply for order under ss 178(2) and 179(3) of NCCP Act right to recover compensation for personal wrong within exception to s 116(2)(g)(i) of Bankruptcy Act – where trustee not entitled to claim or receive any compensation or settle complaint under scheme Legislation: Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) ss 5(1), 18, 55(4), 58(1), (6), 60(4), (5), 109, 116(1), (2)(g), 134(1)(e), (j), Sch 2 s 90-15
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) Pt 7.10A, ss 761A, 912A(1)(g)(i), (2), 1051
National Consumer Credit Protection (Transitional and Consequential Provisions) Act 2009 (Cth) Sch 1 item 19
National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (Cth) ss 5(1), 133,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Official Trustee in Bankruptcy v Kent and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] FCA 1211
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that Mr Kent's right to apply for compensation under the NCCP Act was not capable of assignment to, or vesting in, the trustee in bankruptcy. This conclusion was based on the fact that only Mr Kent, as the person who suffered the loss or damage from the alleged contravention or offence against the NCCP Act, could apply for such relief. The court further reasoned that if these rights were considered property, they would fall within the exception of a right to recover compensation for a personal wrong, which is not property of the bankrupt that vests in the trustee. Consequently, the trustee was not entitled to claim or receive any compensation or settle the complaint under the AFCA scheme.
The court rejected arguments regarding the limitation period for any cause of action held by Mr Kent, noting that the AFCA scheme does not require a complaint to assert a cause of action at the time of the complaint. The court also dismissed the argument that the subject matter of the complaint was statute-barred. The court concluded that the trustee could neither compromise the complaint using its powers under the Bankruptcy Act nor bring a claim for an order under the NCCP Act.
The final orders required the parties to file and serve draft agreed orders to give effect to the reasons for judgment by 18 October 2023. If the parties could not agree, they were to file a marked-up version of the various orders proposed and written submissions limited to two pages in support of their contentions.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. On or before 18 October 2023:
(a) the parties file and serve draft agreed orders to give effect to the reasons for judgment published today; or
(b) in default of agreement, a marked up version of the various orders proposed and written submissions limited to 2 pages in support of its or his contentions.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
AFCA noted that it had not undertaken any preliminary assessment or made any determination of the issue as to whether the trustee had any entitlement to receive the financial loss component. It also observed that it was not a party to the deed which had been produced without its involvement. AFCA observed that it had followed the process outlined in the fact sheet in communicating the draft of the deed to each of Mr Kent and the trustee that the bank provided it and thereafter acted only as a “go between” the parties to the complaint and the trustee.CONSIDERATION I reject the trustee’s and bank’s argument. It confused the subject matter of a complaint by a bankrupt (or former bankrupt) to AFCA under the scheme and the resolution that, under the rules and the tripartite contract, AFCA can impose on the financial firm, if the complainant accepts that resolution, on the one hand, with the rights to the bankrupt’s existing and after acquired property that vested in his or her trustee in bankruptcy by force of s 58(1) of the Bankruptcy Act, on the other. (I will refer simply below to “a bankrupt” for both statuses (present and former bankrupt) unless it is necessary to distinguish between them). The fact that the trustee may be able to sue the bank for a breach of a contractual term between it and the bankrupt, for example, in cl 25.1 of the 2003 code, does not mean that the bankrupt did not retain, first, a right to complain to AFCA about loss arising from the conduct of the bank that arose from a contract or obligation under Australian law or, secondly, a separate, personal or non-proprietary right of action against the bank for compensation in respect of similar conduct that did not vest in the trustee. AFCA can only resolve a complaint by a bankrupt about the latter two categories of right or complaint, not the former. As I will elaborate below, that is because the trustee, as a corporation sole under s 18 of the Bankruptcy Act, is not capable of being an eligible person or a complainant, as defined in rule E.1.1, and so cannot be a party to the complaint in respect of conduct that occurred before the bankruptcy. Importantly, rule A.15.3 demonstrates that, if AFCA resolves a complaint in a determination that the complainant accepts, the financial firm can ask the complainant for a release limited to the subject matter of the determination that will become effective on the date that the financial firm fulfils all its obligations under the determination. Thus, any determination by AFCA of Mr Kent’s complaint that he accepted, and bound the bank, could not release the bank from any liability in respect of Mr Kent’s rights that had vested in the trustee under s 58(1) of the Bankruptcy Act because those rights were not within either Mr Kent’s capacity to complain about or the bank’s contractual agreement to submit to AFCA’s dispute resolution scheme in respect of complaints within AFCA’s jurisdiction under the rules. It follows that the deed could not “resolve” the complaint because there was no legal or equitable interest that the trustee had, or could have had, in any determination of it that AFCA might have made in accordance with the tripartite contract it had with Mr Kent and the bank.The nature of the AFCA scheme