Sands v State of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

SANDS v STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

[2015] SASCFC 36

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Blue, The Honourable Justice Stanley and The Honourable Justice Nicholson)

31 March 2015

DEFAMATION - STATEMENTS AMOUNTING TO DEFAMATION - PARTICULAR STATEMENTS - IMPUTATION - CRIMINAL

DEFAMATION - STATEMENTS AMOUNTING TO DEFAMATION - REFERENCE TO PLAINTIFF - INNUENDO

DEFAMATION - ACTIONS FOR DEFAMATION - PLEADING

DEFAMATION - JUSTIFICATION - GENERALLY - WHETHER PLEA ESTABLISHED

DEFAMATION - PRIVILEGE - ABSOLUTE PRIVILEGE - OTHER CASES

DEFAMATION - PRIVILEGE - QUALIFIED PRIVILEGE - STATEMENTS MADE IN RESPECT OF A DUTY OR INTEREST - PARTICULAR STATEMENTS - PUBLICATION FOR THE PUBLIC GOOD

DEFAMATION - PRIVILEGE - QUALIFIED PRIVILEGE - REBUTTAL OF PRIVILEGE BY MALICE - GENERALLY

STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - ENFORCEMENT OF STATUTORY RIGHTS AND REMEDIES - BREACH OF STATUTORY DUTY - GENERALLY

Appeal against dismissal by a Judge of the Supreme Court of an action for defamation and breach of statutory duty.

On 4 July 1997, South Australian Police commenced an investigation into the murder on that afternoon of Corinna Marr at her Collinswood unit.  The plaintiff, Mr Sands, who was then employed as a photographer by Messenger Press, was a friend of Ms Marr.  Mr Sands provided a statement to SA Police on 30 August 1997 and was formally interviewed by police on 8 October 2002.

On 2 March 2004, an application by SA Police for an order under the Criminal Law (Forensic Procedures) Act 1998 (SA) to compel Mr Sands to supply his fingerprints was heard and determined by a Magistrate. The order was made by the Magistrate and Mr Sands complied. The hearing was attended by representatives of the media and was widely reported in South Australia that evening and the following day.

On 3 March 2004, Detective Superintendent Symons conducted a press conference. Before its commencement, he handed to the media representatives a media release, which was also published on the SA Police website.

In September 2005, Mr Sands instituted the action against the State of South Australia for, inter alia, defamation and breach of statutory duty arising from the Criminal Law (Forensic Procedures) Act 1998 (SA).

At trial, it was not disputed by the State that imputations were conveyed by the media release and at the press conference that there were reasonable grounds to suspect Mr Sands of having murdered Corinna Marr and that he had so conducted himself as to warrant that suspicion.  The State denied that three further pleaded imputations were conveyed, namely that there were strong grounds to suspect that Mr Sands had murdered Corinna Marr; that as there were such strong grounds, he was the prime suspect setting him apart from any other suspect; and that the police had information placing him at the scene of the murder which he knew about and refused to challenge.

Before trial, Mr Sands filed an interlocutory application seeking to strike out the State’s pleas of justification and qualified privilege on the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sands v State of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] SASCFC 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal by the plaintiff, Derick John Sands, against a judgment of the Supreme Court of South Australia that dismissed his defamation and breach of statutory duty claims against the State of South Australia. The claims arose from the conduct of the South Australian Police Force during a murder investigation into the death of Corinna Marr. The appeal specifically addressed the dismissal of the defamation action, as other causes of action were not pursued on appeal.

The legal issues before the Full Court included whether certain pleaded imputations were conveyed by a media release and press conference, whether those imputations were defamatory, and whether the defence of justification was established. The court was also required to consider whether the State was precluded from relying on the defences of justification or qualified privilege due to its claim for public interest immunity, and whether the trial judge erred in rejecting the defences of qualified and statutory privilege.

The Full Court found that the trial judge had correctly determined that imputations (a), (d), and (e) were not conveyed by the media release and press conference. It also upheld the trial judge's finding that imputations (b) and (c) were justified, meaning the statements, while defamatory, were true. The court rejected the plaintiff's argument that the State was precluded from relying on the defences of justification or qualified privilege, finding no error in the trial judge's rejection of these defences. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal by the plaintiff Derick John Sands from a judgment of a Judge of this Court dismissing the appellant’s action for defamation and breach of statutory duty.[1] The action was brought in respect of the conduct of the defendant and respondent the State of South Australia, in particular the South Australian Police Force (SA Police), in the course of a murder investigation. [1] Causes of action for breach of duty of care, duty of confidence and duty of privacy were also dismissed. As there is no appeal against the dismissal of those causes of action, they can be ignored.Background On Friday 4 July 1997 Corinna Marr was murdered. She was shot while in her Collinswood unit. She had left her place of employment at Weeks & Macklin’s Firle office some time between 2.00 and 2.30 pm. At 4.02 pm, her husband Robert Marr telephoned 000 to report that he had just discovered her body. The pathology evidence gave an estimated time of death between 2.30 pm and 3.30 pm although it was conceded it possibly could have been as late as some time after 3.40 pm. No person has been charged with the crime. No murder weapon was ever found. The crime remains unsolved. At the time of the murder, Mr Sands was 27 years old. He had known Ms Marr since May 1995. He met her through his employment as a photographer with Messenger Press. They became friends. Whether the friendship developed into a sexual relationship was an issue at the trial. When Mr Sands met Ms Marr, she was engaged to Robert Marr. She married Robert Marr in January 1996. Messenger Press publishes several weekly suburban newspapers for distribution in metropolitan Adelaide. Mr Sands commenced employment with Messenger Press in 1988. In July 1997 he was employed mainly at its Port Adelaide office but he also performed work from time to time at its Salisbury office. He had available a work-supplied motor vehicle. He also undertook freelance photography work. Ms Marr was employed as a receptionist at the office of the real estate agent Weeks & Macklin at Firle. She also undertook part-time modelling. Weeks & Macklin advertised through Messenger Press. Ms Marr first met Mr Sands when he visited the Weeks & Macklin office to carry out a photographic assignment. Mr Sands visited the Firle office on a number of occasions to see Ms Marr. These visits were not work-related. They also met on a number of occasions outside the Weeks & Macklin office and on at least one occasion at Mr Sands’ residence. Mr Sands and Ms Marr went on photographic shoots together to various locations outside Adelaide. On the morning of 4 July 1997, Ms Marr attended work at the Firle office of Weeks & Macklin. By arrangement with her manager, Colin Todd, she left work early between 2.00 and 2.30 pm to attend a modelling assignment at the Woodville Hotel. She had arranged with Mr Todd that he would collect her from her home and accompany her to the Woodville Hotel. The modelling assignment required her to wear an outfit that she collected earlier that day. It was arranged that she would change into that outfit at home and Mr Todd would collect her sometime between 3.30 and 3.45 pm. As it transpired, Mr Todd was running late. He telephoned Ms Marr’s unit at about 4 pm. He spoke to Mr Marr who told him that she was dead.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The State denied any breach of the Forensic Procedures Act. In the alternative, it contended that any such breach did not give rise to a private right of action. The evidence Mr Sands gave evidence. He also called as witnesses his former solicitor Peter Quinn, The Advertiser journalist Nigel Hunt and Courts Administration Authority business analyst Marc Marshall. The State called witnesses including Mr Sands’ Messenger Press work colleagues Andrew Faulkner, Ian Parrish, George Zvigos, Nicholas Wrankmore and Tom Milosevic; Mr Sands’ former partners Janelle Denley and Kelly Nelson; Mr Sands’ mother Michel Woodward; Mr Marr’s work colleague Dennis Visvardis; Detectives Michael Symons, John Keane, Anthony Crameri and Marie Staffin-Gardner; and various other lay and police witnesses. Mr Sands gave evidence in rebuttal on the issue of justification. He also called witnesses including his Messenger press work colleagues Angela Hudoba and Margaret Betts; Ms Marr’s employer Colin Todd; Ms Marr’s friends Nadine Halls and Paula Petrunic; and the Marrs’ former neighbour Judy Morris. The parties tendered various documents and DVDs.The Judge’s reasons for judgment The Judge found that the State was not responsible for the alleged leak. There is no appeal against that finding. The Judge made an adverse credibility finding in relation to the evidence of Mr Sands. Her Honour found that Ms Morris was an unreliable witness. Her Honour generally accepted the evidence of Mr Todd but expressed reservations about some of his evidence given at the trial. The Judge found that pleaded imputation (b) was conveyed by the Media Release and the Press Conference as conceded by the State.[16] The Judge found that pleaded imputation (c) with respect to the imputation in (b) was conveyed by the Press Conference as conceded by the State.[17] The Judge found that, while not named, Mr Sands was identifiable by persons with extrinsic knowledge and this had been sufficiently pleaded. The Judge found that pleaded imputations (a), (d) and (e) were not conveyed. [16] The Judge found that the imputation was also conveyed by the Advertiser articles of 28 February and 3 March 2004. As there is no appeal against the dismissal of the claim involving these articles, which was consequential on the plaintiff establishing the alleged leak, we do not refer further to them. [17] The Judge found that the imputation was also conveyed by the Advertiser articles of 28 February and 3 March 2004. As there is no appeal in relation to these articles, we do not refer further to them. The Judge acted on the State’s concession that the imputations conveyed by the Media Release and Press Conference, but not more, were likewise conveyed by the evening news programs of 3 March 2004 and The Advertiser article of 4 March 2004 by way of republication. The Judge found that the Channel 7 promotions and ABC reports in May 2004 did not amount to republications. The Judge acted on the State’s concession that pleaded imputations (a) to (d) were defamatory. The Judge did not decide whether pleaded imputation (e) was defamatory given her Honour’s conclusion that it was not conveyed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The parties tendered various documents and DVDs.The Judge’s reasons for judgment The Judge found that the State was not responsible for the alleged leak. There is no appeal against that finding. The Judge made an adverse credibility finding in relation to the evidence of Mr Sands. Her Honour found that Ms Morris was an unreliable witness. Her Honour generally accepted the evidence of Mr Todd but expressed reservations about some of his evidence given at the trial. The Judge found that pleaded imputation (b) was conveyed by the Media Release and the Press Conference as conceded by the State.[16] The Judge found that pleaded imputation (c) with respect to the imputation in (b) was conveyed by the Press Conference as conceded by the State.[17] The Judge found that, while not named, Mr Sands was identifiable by persons with extrinsic knowledge and this had been sufficiently pleaded. The Judge found that pleaded imputations (a), (d) and (e) were not conveyed. [16] The Judge found that the imputation was also conveyed by the Advertiser articles of 28 February and 3 March 2004. As there is no appeal against the dismissal of the claim involving these articles, which was consequential on the plaintiff establishing the alleged leak, we do not refer further to them. [17] The Judge found that the imputation was also conveyed by the Advertiser articles of 28 February and 3 March 2004. As there is no appeal in relation to these articles, we do not refer further to them. The Judge acted on the State’s concession that the imputations conveyed by the Media Release and Press Conference, but not more, were likewise conveyed by the evening news programs of 3 March 2004 and The Advertiser article of 4 March 2004 by way of republication. The Judge found that the Channel 7 promotions and ABC reports in May 2004 did not amount to republications. The Judge acted on the State’s concession that pleaded imputations (a) to (d) were defamatory. The Judge did not decide whether pleaded imputation (e) was defamatory given her Honour’s conclusion that it was not conveyed. The Judge found that pleaded imputations (b) and (c) were justified. The Judge rejected the defences of qualified and statutory privilege. The Judge rejected Mr Sands’ claims for breach of statutory duty, breach of duty of care, breach of confidence and breach of privacy. Given the Judge’s conclusion on liability, there was no need to assess damages. However, her Honour indicated that, if there had been an entitlement to damages, any award would have been small as the losses suffered by Mr Sands were substantially attributable to other causes. The appeal Mr Sands contends that the Judge erred in failing to find that pleaded imputations (a), (d) and (e) were conveyed by the Media Release and the Press Conference and contends that the imputation in (e) was defamatory. Mr Sands contends that the Judge failed to address his submission that the State was precluded from relying on the defences of justification or qualified privilege by reason of its claim for public interest immunity. He submits that the Judge should have struck out those defences.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established