Guo and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

Guo and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2017] AATA 778 (10 May 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2014/6365; 2015/1261

Re:Qi Guang Guo (No 4)

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Justice D Kerr, President
Prof R Deutsch, Deputy President

Date:10 May 2017

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal affirms the decision to refuse the Applicant a Class 815 (PRC) (Permanent) entry visa.

................[sgd]..............................

Justice D Kerr, President

CATCHWORDS

MIGRATION – review of re-notified decision originally made 17 September 1996 – application for Class 815 (PRC) (Permanent) entry visa – other visa history and unlawful detention not relevant to review – transition provisions – s 501 Migration Act 1958 as in force immediately before 1 June 1999 – Directions pursuant to s 499 Migration Act 1958 not relevant to review – special cross-examination arrangements to protect confidentiality of witness’ evidence of informants and police methodologies – character – criminal conduct – criminal associations – standard of proof required – balance of probabilities – evaluation of circumstantial evidence – discretion – decision to refuse application affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975

Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (NSW)

General Direction - Visa Refusal s 501 - No 5

Migration Act 1958

Migration Legislation Amendment (Strengthening of Provisions Relating to Character and Conduct) Act 1998

Migration Reform (Transitional Provisions) Regulations 1994

Migration (1993) Regulations (Amendment) (No 11/1994)

Ministerial Direction 65 (23 December 2014)

CASES

Alexandra Private Geriatric Hospital Pty Ltd v Blewett (1984) 2 FCR 368; 56 ALR 265

Camakau and Secretary, Department of Immigration [1999] AATA 789 (22 October 1999)

Commissioner of Police, New South Wales v Guo [2016] FCAFC 62 (20 April 2016)

Edwards v the Queen (1993) 178 CLR 193; 117 ALR 600; 68 A Crim R

Gruszkowski and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 402 (23 May 2000)

Guo and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2016] AATA 125 (24 February 2016)

Guo and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2016] AATA 897 (26 September 2016) (Guo No 2)

Guo and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2016] AATA 901 (27 September 2016) (Guo No 3)

Guo and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] AATA 729 (9 July 2004)

Lam v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (2002) 117 FCR 325; 66 ALD 569

LSDG and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2016] AATA 55 (4 February 2016)

Lu v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs (2004) 141 FCR 346

Madafferi and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 450 (7 June 2000)

Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles (2001) 52 NSWLR 705; 25 NSWCCR 218

Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24; 66 ALR 299; 60 ALJR 560

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Stretton (2016) 237 FCR 1; 329 ALR 491

Minister for Immigration & Citizenship v Haneef (2007) 160 CLR 414; 163 FCR…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Guo and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migr... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 778
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for judicial review of a decision by the Migration Review Tribunal to affirm the refusal of Mr Guo's application for a Class 815 (Permanent) entry visa. The applicant, Mr Guo, had resided in Australia for approximately 27 ½ years, with his wife and two adult sons being Australian citizens. His original application for a permanent visa was refused on 17 September 1996. The court was required to consider the applicable provisions of section 501 of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth) as they stood immediately before 1 June 1999, due to transitional provisions.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the power to refuse Mr Guo's visa application was enlivened under the applicable section 501 provisions, and if so, whether the refusal of the application was the correct and preferable exercise of the residual discretion. The applicant contended that his criminal record was minor, that allegations of involvement in organised crime were unsubstantiated hearsay, and that the adverse consequences of removal to China, including potential police surveillance, should be considered in the exercise of discretion. The respondent argued that the seriousness of Mr Guo's conduct favoured refusal.

The court rejected the applicant's submission that his criminal conduct could be categorised as minor, finding that the Tribunal's findings entitled it to exercise the discretion to refuse the visa. The court acknowledged that section 501, as in force at the relevant time, required balancing the protection of the Australian community against the personal consequences for Mr Guo and his family. However, it found that the prospect of Mr Guo coming under police surveillance if returned to China was not a factor that should be accorded weight in exercising the discretion in his favour. The court affirmed the Tribunal's decision to refuse the visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant (again summarised and paraphrased) refutes those allegations. He submits that the proposition that he is or was a member of the “Big Circle Gang” crime syndicate and/or has been involved in serious organised crime is false and is entirely based on unreliable hearsay. He rejects all of the most serious of the allegations against him. He submits, to the extent that he has a criminal record, the convictions are for relatively minor matters. They do not justify the Tribunal concluding that he is not of good character. To the extent that those propositions are not accepted he submits the Tribunal should take into account the adverse consequences he will face if he is forced to leave Australia and return to China. His wife and children would be devastated. For those reasons the discretion to refuse the visa should not be exercised.The Applicant’s background The Applicant’s background is set out in his statement of 23 January 2015. He was born in Guangzhou City, the People’s Republic of China on 27 April 1957. He had married Ms Wei Shi on 11 February 1988, six months before travelling to Australia. They have two sons. Since arriving in Sydney Australia on 5 August 1988 on a six month student visa Mr Guo has resided continuously in Australia. That amounts to a continuous period of residency in Australia of some 27 ½ years. It is not in dispute that his wife and two adult sons are Australian citizens. They all reside in Australia. On 28 November 1991 he was granted a temporary entry permit as a citizen of the People’s Republic of China resident in Australia in the aftermath of the Tiananmen Square protests. On 30 June 1994 he applied for a Class 815 PRC (Permanent) entry permit. His application (the decision under review) was refused on 17 September 1996. In common with many others in his position, he was permitted to remain in Australia beyond the period normally applied to persons holding student visas as a result of Australia’s compassionate response to the suppression of the Tiananmen Square protests by the Chinese authorities. Special visa arrangements were put in place to allow Chinese nationals who held fears about returning to the PRC to claim protection.The visa application and decision On 30 June 1994, Mr Guo applied for a Class 815 (PRC) (Permanent) entry permit. That class of entry permit had been introduced by the Migration (1993) Regulations (Amendment) (No 11/1994) (1993 Regulations). The 1993 Regulations commenced operation on 1 March 1994. Under the 1993 Regulations an application for the Class 815 entry permit was taken also to be an application for a Class 437 entry permit. Mr Guo subsequently was granted a Class 437 entry permit on 1 July 1994. The 1993 Regulations provided that where the holder of a Class 437 entry permit was also an applicant for a Class 815 entry permit, the Class 437 entry permit would remain in force until the holder of that permit was notified in accordance with the those Regulations of the decision made in relation to the holder’s application for the Class 815 permanent entry permit.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Cross-examination of the other witnesses for the Respondent, where that evidence was within the terms of those directions was also permitted, over objection, on a similar basis.Crime Commission evidence There was a third significant matter requiring an interlocutory decision. The materials disclosed to Mr Guo in support of the Respondent’s case that the Applicant should be found to be not of good character included a statement dated 27 April 2015 made by Mr Timothy O’Connor, the Director of Criminal Investigations, Crime Commission. Counsel for the Applicant objected to its admission. It was submitted that information in Mr O’Connor’s statement included a copy of an earlier document dated 3 November 1997 that he had sent to the Department. The contention was that the sending of the document involved a serious breach of Mr O’Connor’s duty as an officer of the Crime Commission because, at that point in time, he had not been delegated to disclose that information. It would involve a serious breach of NSW law were he now permitted to give that evidence to the Tribunal. We held in Guo No 3 that it was unnecessary to decide what might have been the position in 1997 because Mr O’Connor had since been conferred with unimpeachable authority to disclose that information. We rejected the Applicant’s objection. In our view, the above is sufficient to give a thumbnail sketch of the interlocutory rulings. The Tribunal’s published reasons address the relevant issues for each in much more detail and it is intended they be read as part of this decision. THE APPLICATIONThe issues Counsel for the Applicant submitted that:[18]The Tribunals’ task on review is to determine whether the correct and preferable decision is to grant the Applicant’s application for a transitional (permanent) visa under s 501(1) of the Migration Act. [18] Applicant’s SOFIC, filed 21 April 2015, [5]. Counsel for the Respondent made submissions to the same effect. In doing the Applicant submitted two primary issues arose:[19](a)First, whether the power to refuse the applicant’s application is enlivened, that is, whether the Tribunal is satisfied of any of the matters stated in ss 501(1) and (2) as in force immediately before 1 June 1999 (the applicable s 501).(b)Secondly, if the refusal power under the applicable s 501 is enlivened, whether the correct and preferable exercise of the residual discretion is to grant or refuse the applicant’s application. The Tribunal accepts those propositions to be correct.[19] Applicant’s SOFIC, filed 21 April 2015, [6].The applicable law It is necessary to explain why the relevant legislative provisions governing the refusal of Mr Guo’s visa in this review are those which existed as in force immediately before 1 June 1999 rather than the current provisions of s 501. The Migration Legislation Amendment (Strengthening of Provisions Relating to Character and Conduct) Act 1998 (Cth) (Strengthening Act) introduced a number of significant procedural and substantive changes to s 501 of the Migration Act which came into force as from 1 June 1999. However, the Strengthening Act also made provision for transitional instances.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In common with many others in his position, he was permitted to remain in Australia beyond the period normally applied to persons holding student visas as a result of Australia’s compassionate response to the suppression of the Tiananmen Square protests by the Chinese authorities. Special visa arrangements were put in place to allow Chinese nationals who held fears about returning to the PRC to claim protection.The visa application and decision On 30 June 1994, Mr Guo applied for a Class 815 (PRC) (Permanent) entry permit. That class of entry permit had been introduced by the Migration (1993) Regulations (Amendment) (No 11/1994) (1993 Regulations). The 1993 Regulations commenced operation on 1 March 1994. Under the 1993 Regulations an application for the Class 815 entry permit was taken also to be an application for a Class 437 entry permit. Mr Guo subsequently was granted a Class 437 entry permit on 1 July 1994. The 1993 Regulations provided that where the holder of a Class 437 entry permit was also an applicant for a Class 815 entry permit, the Class 437 entry permit would remain in force until the holder of that permit was notified in accordance with the those Regulations of the decision made in relation to the holder’s application for the Class 815 permanent entry permit. As from 1 September 1994, the Migration Reform (Transitional Provisions) Regulations 1994 (Transitional Regulations) applied. These were new transitional regulations which had the effect of:·taking the Applicant’s application for a Class 815 entry permit to be an application for a transitional (permanent) visa, that application to be decided according to the criteria that applied to the entry permit for which the Applicant’s original application was made; and·ensuring that the Applicant’s Class 437 entry permit would continue in effect as a transitional temporary visa until the Applicant was notified of the decision made in relation to the application for a transitional (permanent) visa. Correspondence dated 21 August 1995 from (then) Detective Sergeant (Det Sgt) Timothy O’Connor, of the NSW Police Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA), alerted the Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (the Department) to his belief that Mr Guo was a more serious criminal than his formal record of convictions might suggest.[2] The information provided was considered in the preparation of a draft submission in relation to Mr Guo’s entitlement to a permanent visa. That draft was prepared by Ms Baumhammer, the acting Assistant Director ‘November 1 Task Force’. She replied to Det Sgt O’Connor:[3]…Mr Guo meets all the core requirements. As there are no major convictions against [him], it is likely that his application…would be granted. Information available to the Department relates to activities Mr Guo is believed to have be involved in, and not to positive knowledge and evidence of involvement in criminal activities or membership of Triad or criminal gangs. Would it be possible for you to provide positive information on [Mr Guo] that would confirm his involvement in criminal activities. [2] Exhibit R1, G9, letter to Ms Baumhammer. [3] Exhibit A2, Annexure A, letter dated 30 August 1995.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In reply the following arguments, inter alia, were advanced: ·Mr Guo’s past criminal conduct is limited to minor convictions and “does not require a finding now that the applicant is not of good character.”[184] ·The Respondent has failed to prove “that the applicant was involved in the criminal conduct of any person alleged to be an associate.”[185]·On the evidence available to it, “the Tribunal cannot find that the applicant would be more likely than not to engage in criminal conduct in Australia.”[186] ·There is insufficient evidence that the “the applicant would more likely than not represent a danger to the Australian community.”[187]·Given the family circumstances of the Applicant it would be preferable that he remain in Australia.[188]·The evidence is largely hearsay or remote hearsay and the “conclusions sought by the Minister cannot follow as rational inferences from such circumstantial facts as have been established.”[189] ·Consideration should be given to the duration of residency in Australia.[190][184] Applicant’s closing reply, [1(a)]. [185] Applicant’s closing reply, [1(b)]. [186] Applicant’s closing reply, [1(c)]. [187] Applicant’s closing reply, [1(d)]. [188] Applicant’s closing reply, [1(e)].[189] Applicant’s closing reply, [4]-[8].[190] Applicant’s closing reply, [9]-[10].EXERCISE OF THE DISCRETION: CONSIDERATION We have rejected that Mr Guo’s past criminal conduct can be categorised as minor. That proposition is inconsistent with the Tribunal’s findings. We are satisfied that the findings we have made entitle the Tribunal to exercise the discretion to refuse Mr Guo a visa. That discretion must be exercised within the boundaries, express or implicit, required by s 501(1) as was in force. The terms of s 501 as was in force point to the protection of the Australian community as a relevant consideration to the exercise of that discretion. The Respondent submits that the seriousness of Mr Guo’s conduct strongly favours the discretion being exercised to affirm the original decision. However the provisions of s 501 as was in force require the Tribunal to balance against that the consequences to Mr Guo personally, to his family and the wider community of an adverse decision. We therefore turn to the considerations that are in favour of the balance being otherwise struck. We accept the submission advanced on Mr Guo’s behalf that the consequences of an adverse decision for Mr Guo are relevant and will be significant. If Mr Guo is refused the visa he will be required to return to China. It is not implausible that a person with Mr Guo’s background might already have come to the notice of the Chinese authorities such that, if he was to return, he would become subject to law enforcement surveillance. However, it is equally likely that he would be subject to similar law enforcement attention if permitted to remain in Australia. We reject the proposition that a prospect of his coming under police surveillance if returned should be accorded any weight as a factor in exercising our discretion in his favour.