Official Trustee in Bankruptcy v Kent (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Official Trustee in Bankruptcy v Kent (No 2) [2023] FCA 1396  

File number: NSD 272 of 2022
Judgment of: RARES J
Date of judgment: 13 November 2023
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where declarations made giving effect to principal reasons – where trustee applied for judicial advice together with binding declarations of right – whether settlement sum trustee received from person allegedly liable to bankrupt in respect of dealings before bankruptcy is property of bankrupt or vested in bankrupt estate or trustee under ss 58 and 116 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) – where declarations that settlement sum not part of bankrupt estate – whether judicial advice unnecessary, inappropriate or would repeat determinative effect of declarations

COSTS – where trustee in bankruptcy unsuccessful in seeking declarations of right together with judicial advice – whether trustee liable for costs personally or only to extent of assets in bankrupt estate – where proceeding in nature of test case with general public importance for administration of bankrupt estates – where trustee applied for declarations that money paid to it by person to settle claim by bankrupt was property of bankrupt or vested in trustee or bankrupt estate – where trustee acted as protagonist and not as defender in proceeding – where trustee sought judicial advice and binding declarations of right to justify its conduct in­­ entering into deed to settle claim by bankrupt – where applicant is official trustee in bankruptcy with statutory right to indemnity from Commonwealth for costs ordered against it under s 18A(2)(a) of Bankruptcy Act – where Court has discretion to order costs against official trustee personally in s 18A(1)(a) and s 90-15(3)(d) and (5) in Sch 2 of Bankruptcy Act - where bankrupt estate without funds – whether official trustee personally liable to pay bankrupt’s costs on indemnity basis – Held: judicial advice inappropriate; trustee ordered to pay costs personally on indemnity basis

Legislation:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) ss 18(1), (2)(c), 18A(1)(a), (2)(a), 30(1), 55(4), 58, 116(2)(g)(i), 134(1), Sch 2 s 90-‍‍15(1), (3)(a), (d), (5), (7)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 43(2)

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 78B

National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (Cth) ss 178(1), 179(1)

Trustee Act 1925 (NSW) ss 63, 93

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) r 42.25

Cases cited:

Adsett v Berlouis (1992) 37 FCR 201

Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission (1992) 175 CLR 564

Australian Federation of Consumer Organisations Inc v Tobacco Institute of Australia Ltd (1991) 100 ALR 568

Baltic Shipping Co v Dillon (“Mikhail Lermontov”) (1991) 22 NSWLR 1

Baltic Shipping Co v Dillon (1993) 176 CLR 344

BCI Finances Pty Ltd (in liq) v Binetter (2018) 362 ALR 597

Chief Commissioner of Stamp Duties for New South Wales v Buckle (1998) 192 CLR 226

Ex parte Angerstein; Re Angerstein (1874) LR 9 Ch App 479

Ex parte James; Re Condon (1874) LR 9 Ch App 609

Goyal, in the matter of Cape Technologies Pty Ltd (administrators appointed) [2021] FCA 1654

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Official Trustee in Bankruptcy v Kent (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1396
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Official Trustee in Bankruptcy applied to the Federal Court seeking declarations and judicial advice to support its decision to enter into a deed to settle a complaint against a bank. Mr Kent, who had been declared bankrupt, cross-claimed for costs. The court had to decide whether the trustee was entitled to judicial advice and direction concerning its claims and whether the trustee should be ordered to pay Mr Kent's costs on an indemnity basis. The court found that the trustee was not entitled to judicial advice on matters of commercial or business judgment, but only on issues of substance, procedure, power, propriety or reasonableness. The trustee's application for judicial advice was inappropriate because it did not raise any legal issue that called for the exercise of legal judgment. The court also found that the trustee should be ordered to pay Mr Kent's costs on an indemnity basis because the proceeding was a test case with general public importance for the administration of bankrupt estates. The trustee, as the protagonist, was personally liable for the costs, and the bankrupt estate had no funds to pay them. The court ordered the trustee to pay Mr Kent's costs on an indemnity basis and to repay the settlement sum to the bank.

The court ordered that the deed between the trustee, the bank and the Australian Financial Complaints Authority did not affect the complaint, and the tripartite agreement remained valid and binding. The settlement sum the trustee received from the bank was not property of the bankrupt estate. The trustee's costs were an expense in the administration of the bankrupt estate, and the trustee had a right of indemnity against the bankrupt estate for its personal liability for costs. The originating application was dismissed, and there were no orders as to costs in respect of the bank and the Australian Financial Complaints Authority.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. It be declared that:

(a) by entering into the deed dated 21 January 2021, the applicant (the trustee) and the second respondent (the bank) did not compromise, resolve, settle, bring to an end or do anything that had any force or effect on, the complaint that the first respondent (Mr Kent) made on 29 June 2020 to the third respondent (AFCA);

(b) the tripartite agreement between Mr Kent, the bank and AFCA formed by the making of the complaint remains valid and binding on each of them and each remains bound to perform his or its obligations in respect of the complaint pursuant to, and in accordance with, the dispute resolution scheme operated by AFCA under Pt 7.10A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth); and

(c) the settlement sum of $433,512.47 that the trustee received from the bank on 28 February 2021 is not property of Mr Kent’s bankrupt estate that has vested in the trustee pursuant to s 58 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) or otherwise.

2. The trustee’s costs of the proceeding (including the cross-claim) be an expense in the administration of Mr Kent’s bankrupt estate.

3. The trustee, personally, pay Mr Kent’s costs of the proceeding (including the cross-‍claim) on an indemnity basis.

4. It be declared that the trustee has a right of indemnity against Mr Kent’s bankrupt estate in respect of its personal liability for costs under order 3 above.

5. The originating application be dismissed.

THE COURT NOTES, BY CONSENT, THAT:

6. There be no orders as to costs in respect of each of the bank and AFCA.

7. Having regard to the declarations in order 1 above, the trustee has agreed to repay the settlement sum (including any accruals thereon) to the bank.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Official Trustee in Bankruptcy sought judicial advice and binding declarations of right regarding a settlement sum of $433,512.47 received from a bank in relation to a complaint made by a bankrupt, Mr Kent, to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA). The Official Trustee entered into a deed with the bank to settle the complaint. Mr Kent subsequently argued that the settlement sum was property of his bankrupt estate, and therefore should have vested in the Official Trustee as the trustee of his estate. The Official Trustee applied to the Court for declarations that the settlement sum was not property of Mr Kent’s bankrupt estate, and for an order that any costs payable by the Official Trustee be limited to the extent of the assets vested in the trustee in Mr Kent’s bankrupt estate. Mr Kent, in turn, applied for an order that the Official Trustee pay his costs of the proceeding on an indemnity basis.

The matter came before the Court as an application by the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy for judicial advice and declarations of right. The Official Trustee filed an originating application seeking declarations that the settlement sum was not property of Mr Kent’s bankrupt estate and that the Official Trustee should not be required to pay Mr Kent’s costs on an indemnity basis. Mr Kent filed a cross-claim in response, seeking declarations that the settlement sum was property of his bankrupt estate, and an order that the Official Trustee pay his costs on an indemnity basis. The Court heard submissions from both parties and required the Official Trustee to file and serve a notice under s 78B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) to raise the constitutional issue of how State legislation could operate to condition or qualify the Court’s express powers to order costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ordinarily, the court will not give judicial advice to a trustee about a matter of commercial or business judgment. Goldberg J explained why in Re Ansett Australia Ltd (No 3) (2002) 115 FCR 409 at 428 [65], where he said that:the prevailing principle adopted by the courts, when asked by liquidators and administrators to give directions, is to refrain from doing so where the direction sought relates to the making and implementation of a business or commercial decision, either committed specifically to the liquidator or administrator or well within his or her discretion, in circumstances where there is no particular legal issue raised for consideration or attack on the propriety or reasonableness of the decision in respect of which the directions are sought. There must be something more than the making of a business or commercial decision before a court will give directions in relation to, or approving of, the decision. It may be a legal issue of substance or procedure, it may be an issue of power, propriety or reasonableness, but some issue of this nature is required to be raised. It is insufficient to attract an order giving directions that the liquidator or administrator has a feeling of apprehension or unease about the business decision made and wants reassurance. There must be some issue which arises in relation to the decision. A court should not give its imprimatur to a business decision simply to alleviate a liquidator’s or administrator’s unease. There must be an issue calling for the exercise of legal judgment.(emphasis added) McLelland J expressed a similar view in Re G B Nathan and Co Pty Ltd (in liq) (1991) 24 NSWLR 674 at 679F–680C; see also Goyal, in the matter of Cape Technologies Pty Ltd (administrators appointed) [2021] FCA 1654 at [19]–[20] per Yates J; Leroy (Trustee), in the matter of Vitale and Vitale (Bankrupts) [2016] FCA 999 at [37] per Wigney J; Heenan (as joint and several receivers of Ruby Apartments Pty Ltd (recs and mgrs apptd) (in liq)) v Ralan Paradise No 1 Pty Ltd (recs and mgrs apptd) (in liq) (No 2) (2021) 156 ACSR 86 at 95–97 [50]–[55] per Downes J; see too JD Heydon and MJ Leeming, Jacobs’ Law of Trusts in Australia (8th ed, LexisNexis Butterworths, 2016) at [21-34]. As Gummow ACJ, Kirby, Hayne and Heydon JJ explained in Macedonian Church 237 CLR at 93–94 [69]–[71], one reason why a trustee may seek judicial advice is to protect his, her or its right to indemnity from the trust estate for the costs that the trustee, as a party to the litigation, will be personally liable to pay to the other party if he, she or it is ordered to pay costs as well as for the expenses that the trustee incurs in pursuing the litigation. That is because the trustee, not the abstract entity (without a separate legal personality) comprising the trust estate, holds the assets the subject of the trust in the trustee’s own name and the trustee, not the trust estate, is the party to the litigation and has a duty to act in the best interests of the trust. The right of a trustee to be indemnified for expenses properly incurred in the administration of the trust (including the trustee’s own costs of pursuing or defending litigation and any liability to pay another party’s costs in the litigation) is a beneficial proprietary interest of the trustee in the trust estate: Chief Commissioner of Stamp Duties for New South Wales v Buckle (1998) 192 CLR 226 at 246–247 [50]–[51] per Brennan CJ, Toohey, Gaudron, McHugh and Gummow JJ. SHOULD THE ADVICE DECLARATION BE MADE?

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

However, the trustee and Mr Kent disagreed on whether I should order:first, as the trustee sought: (a)a declaration under s 90-15 in Sch 2 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) that the trustee would not be justified in treating the settlement sum as property of the bankrupt that has vested in it pursuant to s 58 of that Act (the advice declaration); (b)orders that: (i)Mr Kent’s costs of the proceeding (including the cross-claim) be taxed and paid by the trustee and such liability to be limited to the extent of the assets vested in the trustee in its capacity as the trustee of the property of Mr Kent’s bankrupt estate (the capped costs order); and(ii)the trustee’s originating application be otherwise dismissed; orsecondly, as Mr Kent sought: (a)orders that: (i)the trustee’s originating application be dismissed;(ii)the trustee pay Mr Kent’s costs of the proceeding (including the cross-‍claim) on an indemnity basis (the indemnity order); and(b)a notation that the trustee’s liability to Mr Kent with respect to his costs of the proceeding is not limited to the assets vested in the trustee in Mr Kent’s bankrupt estate. Thus, the substantive issues for determination are whether:(1)the trustee is entitled to: (a)judicial advice or direction in the terms of the advice declaration in respect of my resolution of its claims in the amended originating application, first, under ss 30(1) and 134(1) of the Bankruptcy Act and s 63 of the Trustee Act 1925 (NSW) or, secondly, under s 90-15 in Sch 2 of the Bankruptcy Act; and(b)an order that it pay Mr Kent costs but that its liability be limited to the extent of the assets in his bankrupt estate based on equitable principles as well as s 93 of the Trustee Act and r 42.25 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) (UCPR); and(2)the trustee should be ordered to pay Mr Kent’s costs on an indemnity basis. On 20 October 2023, the trustee confirmed that the bankrupt estate is without funds, so that the order for costs that the trustee proposes is a simulacrum that is of no substantive value to Mr Kent. On 27 October 2023, I required the trustee, after receiving the last of the parties’ submissions on 26 October 2023, to file and serve a notice under s 78B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) to raise the constitutional issue of how State legislation (being s 93 of the Trustee Act and r 42.25 of the UCPR) could operate to condition or qualify the Court’s express powers to order costs in a matter such as this that the Parliament had conferred on it in s 43 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Federal Court Act), s 18A(1)(a) and (2)(a) of the Bankruptcy Act and s 90-15(1), (3)(a), (d), (5) and (7) in Sch 2 of that Act and in light of decisions such as Wing v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd (2017) 255 FCR 61. On 31 October 2023, the trustee withdrew its reliance on s 93 of the Trustee Act and r 42.25 of the UCPR as one of the bases on which it supported its application that any order for costs against it be limited to the assets of the bankrupt estate. THE LEGISLATIVE CONTEXT