Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal be allowed.
2. The orders of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia dated 7 September 2018 be set aside and, in lieu thereof, it be ordered that:
(a) a writ of certiorari be issued quashing the decision of the second respondent made on 9 September 2015 in case number 1412486;
(b) a writ of mandamus be issued directed to the second respondent requiring it to determine the application for review of the decision made by a delegate of the first respondent on 3 July 2014 according to law; and
(c) the first respondent pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the application filed by or on behalf of the applicant on 7 October 2015.
3. The first respondent pay the appellant’s costs of and incidental to the appeal, as agreed or assessed.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Decision
Reasons for decision
The information in question consisted of the Tribunal’s ruling on the application made by the appellant’s parents and sister (respectively, the “Previous Tribunal Decision” and the “Previous Tribunal Application”). As stated above at [9], the Tribunal in the appellant’s case made the same findings with respect to S and the threat that he posed as it did in the Previous Tribunal Decision (namely, that he did not exist and, therefore, posed no threat, neither directly nor derivatively through the appellant’s parents’ families). The possibility that equivalent findings would be made in the appellant’s case was adverted to during the appellant’s hearing before the Tribunal (albeit in a manner that ground 2 challenges). The transcript of that hearing, of which evidence was led in the court below, records a lengthy exchange between the Tribunal member and the appellant’s representative about the significance of the Previous Tribunal Decision. That exchange assumes some importance and it is appropriate to record it (without correction of typographical and other errors):MEMBER: I have carefully assessed the evidence [from the previous Tribunal hearing] for myself and I may agree with many of the previous Tribunal’s findings. In particular I may not accept the claims relating to [S], including that either of you was harmed in the past, that either of you was abducted, that you had to flee Togo, that your relatives were opposed to your marriage and that you have a subjective fear of returning to Nigeria. If I do not accept these claims I may find that [S] does not exist, and that your daughter, [the appellant], is not going to be persecuted or subjected to significant harm by [S] by anyone associated with [S] or by your family, either of your families for not marrying [S] or for getting married to each other. I may further find that [the appellant] is not going to have to hide from anybody, whether it’s [S], anyone associated with [S] or your families. And I may find that you may relocate to Lagos where you will be able to look for employment and [the appellant] will be able to go to school when she is the right age and receives medical care as she needs it. Based on the evidence from the previous hearing, the previous case, I may also find that you’re not credible witnesses. The information we’ve accepted would be a reason or part of the reason for affirming the decision of the Department in relation to [the appellant]. Do you understand, what the adverse information is do you understand why it’s relevant?REPRESENTATIVE: So you’re saying that the entire decision and the assessment previously is the adverse information?MEMBER: Yes.REPRESENTATIVE: Rather than assessing any of it individually, they need to respond to an entire previous assessment even though we have put forward responses already to that?…What in particular from [the previous Tribunal member’s] findings do you support in relation to her findings that they’ve not been credible witnesses given all of the submissions we’ve put in to show that those findings are not based on anything concrete? Is there anything in particular that you find they’ve been inconsistent on or reasons why their claims aren’t credible aside from the plausibility findings which are a lot of the findings?MEMBER: Look I think with the exception of [the previous Tribunal member’s] harsh assessment of [another] witness, I do not consider that the other allegations you have made about the errors [alleged to have been made by the previous Tribunal member] are actually supported by the evidence.REPRESENTATIVE: So do you not accept that [S] exists at all and not take on board any of the medical material, or we sort of right back to that, I’m not sure exactly what issues in particular are going to lead you to making an adverse credibility finding unless it’s just [the previous Tribunal member’s] opinion, a lot of the decision was her opinion. And likewise a lot of the decision was the [Minister’s delegate’s] opinion, so it’s hard to I guess make a follow-up submission in relation to your new assessment of their credibility unless it is just a case of everything that they ever said is not credible… [I]t’s hard to know exactly which issues in particular the applicants have, you think the applicants have not been credible on…MEMBER: Well, if your view is that this is way too general and you cannot respond, I might have to go away and write a very long 424A letter outlining each individual issue that is of concern and most of them would be issue that were of concern to [the previous Tribunal member] and give you an opportunity to respond to them, but my view is that most, that things have been covered to an incredible level of detail and so -REPRESENTATIVE: I have concern in relation to the fact that so many of the findings were based on opinion and plausibility, not actual inconsistencies and material facts, and those then affecting your ability to make your own plausibility finding because they’ve been previously made by a different Member is of concern. And it’s obviously something that we can’t even respond to, because there is no ability for us to have it considered based on what we are saying now, by you as a fresh mind then there’s no real need for us to actually respond any further, because we’ve put it as highly as we can…All the findings [of the previous Tribunal] in relation to plausibility are placing a value judgement on [the appellant’s parents’] claims and I just I just don’t see that we can then respond again to the decision if that’s sort of how the adverse information is put. Because that’s what we’ve done in preparing the applicants case at the Department in this case. And also in responding -MEMBER: Which also begs the question though what I could do if I say that I have reviewed all the evidence, what I could do, and what would be the purpose of me writing to you and covering ground that has been covered by the previous Tribunal?…REPRESENTATIVE: So you’re following the findings of the previous Tribunal, rather than assessing it –MEMBER: Well, I’m following the finding of the previous Tribunal, I may follow a finding from the previous Tribunal because I may agree having looked for myself at all the evidence, not because, not because she’s another Tribunal member and therefore I think that I must follow it without turning my own eye to all the evidence.REPRESENTATIVE: But we then put in further submissions and evidence to contradict her findings, those then need to be what’s responded to rather than the step before that which were her findings before that new information was submitted. So I guess my, my request would be that we clearly understand or the applicants clearly understand what um in response to what we’ve raised in response to those previous decisions, what concerns you then have in terms of our responses? If it’s that just you don’t accept them, some understanding of why so that we can respond to that, would be the only way we can actually respond to this adverse information.MEMBER: Well my view is that, that would be probably lead to you covering ground that you have already covered but I’m, I’m, I’m, I can see the difficulty from your point of view as well. But in a sense when I look at it, its, its almost as if there has been a change of Tribunal members and it’s still the same case. You would ordinarily expect that a new Tribunal member who picks up the case from a previous Tribunal member has to cover all the claims from beginning to end.REPRESENTATIVE: But we aren’t asking you to do that.MEMBER: Based on the concerns of the previous member.REPRESENTATIVE: We’re not, I guess the applicants aren’t putting forward their previous case and saying assess this and make a different decision.MEMBER: That is exactly what is happening.…I’m not saying that [the previous Tribunal member] is a very experienced Member that court didn’t overturn the decision, therefore I can just take copy and paste her decision into my decision and say that’s it, and I don’t have to turn my mind to all the claims for myself.REPRESENTATIVE: I guess there’s nothing further we can put in responding to her decision if that is the adverse information being put to us. Because that’s essentially how [the appellant’s] case has been run, is both a response to that previous decision and also of course raising the claims that relate to her as the applicant. So if that is the only adverse information, there is no further response we can put forward that hasn’t been done in the submissions, and the statements to the Department and now the submission to your Tribunal and of course here at the hearing today.