Downe v Sydney West Area Health Service (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

Reported Decision:

218 FLR 268

New South Wales


Supreme Court


CITATION: Downe v Sydney West Area Health Service (No 2) [2008] NSWSC 159
HEARING DATE(S): 29 January 2007-2 February 2007, 5 February 2007-9 February 2007, 12 February 2007-16 February 2007, 19 February 2007-23 February 2007, plus subsequent written submissions.
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

3 July 2008
JURISDICTION: Common Law
JUDGMENT OF: Rothman J
DECISION: i.The defendants' direction to Dr Downe to perform work at Westmead Hospital in a manner inconsistent with the fulfilment by Dr Downe of her duties as Director of the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit at Nepean Hospital is unlawful as a breach of the contract of employment between Dr Downe and the defendants;
ii. The defendants' purported continued suspension of Dr Downe from the performance of duties as the Director of the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit at Nepean Hospital is unlawful as a breach of the contract of employment between Dr Downe and the defendants;
iii. During the subsistence of the current contract of employment between the plaintiff and the defendants, the defendants, and each of them, their servants or agents, shall refrain from directing the plaintiff to perform or not to perform any work or act, which direction is inconsistent with the performance by Dr Downe of her functions as Director, Neonatal Intensive Care Unit, Nepean Hospital;
iv. The defendants and each of them shall refrain from treating as valid, lawful or binding its or their direction to the plaintiff to work as a Staff Specialist at Westmead Hospital;
v. Each party has liberty to file and serve, within 14 days from the date hereof, a written submission on costs and each party may, within a further 7 days, respond in writing to any such submission;
vi. The parties have liberty within 35 days to approach the Court for any further or consequential order, including any order for damages, for the purpose of giving effect to or clarifying these reasons for judgment or ameliorating any administrative inconvenience arising from these orders;
vii. Order iii above shall be stayed for a period of 14 days from the date hereof;
viii. Otherwise the proceedings are dismissed.
CATCHWORDS: EMPLOYMENT – contract of employment – right to direct not to work – incorporation of disciplinary procedure – "suspension" – implied duties – good faith – relationship with award and statutory rights – injunction – personal service - INDUSTRIAL LAW – unfair contracts for performance of work – contract or arrangement – excludes award and statutory obligations – "remuneration cap" excludes payment under award and liability under statute - TRADE PRACTICES – employment not in "trade or commerce" – not unconscionable - CROWN PRIVILEGE – operation of s 47 of the Interpretation Act – right to suspend or remove – specific overrides general – public employment distinguished from officers with statutory powers or discretions
LEGISLATION CITED: Area Health Services Act 1986
Health Services Act 1997
Industrial Arbitration Act 1940
Industrial Relations Act 1996
Interpretation Act 1987
Police Service Act 1990
Protected…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Downe v Sydney West Area Health Service (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NSWSC 159
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Downe, an employee of the Sydney West Area Health Service, contested the health service's right to suspend him and the legality of certain contractual provisions. The dispute arose from the Health Service's imposition of a disciplinary measure and the subsequent contract changes that Downe claimed were invalid. The central legal issues revolved around the enforceability of the contract, particularly the clauses that Downe argued were inconsistent with statutory rights and awards. The court had to determine whether the contract's provisions, including the right to direct Downe not to work and a "remuneration cap," were lawful and whether these provisions could exclude statutory obligations and awards. Furthermore, the court examined whether the employment fell under the Trade Practices Act and whether the contract was unconscionable.

The court concluded that the contract did not exclude the application of the award and statutory rights, as the Health Service had the right to direct Downe not to work during a suspension. The court found that the "remuneration cap" did not exclude payments under the award and liability under the statute. It also ruled that the employment was not in "trade or commerce" and thus not subject to the Trade Practices Act. Regarding the contract's fairness, the court held that it was not unconscionable. Finally, the court interpreted section 47 of the Interpretation Act and determined that the right to suspend or remove, coupled with specific provisions, did not conflict with the general statutory protections.

The court's decision was that the contract provisions at issue were lawful, and the Health Service's actions were justified under the terms of the employment contract. The injunction sought by Downe was denied, and the Health Service's right to direct Downe not to work during the suspension was upheld. The court did not find the contract to be unfair or in breach of statutory rights, and the employment was not considered to be in "trade or commerce" under the Trade Practices Act. The final order was that the Health Service's actions were lawful, and the injunction was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established