FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Unsworth v Tristar Steering and Suspension Australia Limited [2008] FCA 1224
INDUSTRIAL LAW – conduct by employer – alleged breach of s 792 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) – employer’s business substantially ceased – where redundancy clause in certified agreement included generous redundancy provisions if long term employees involuntarily retrenched – where no breach of redundancy clause alleged – whether employer’s failure to dismiss some employees was conduct of the employer – whether failure to dismiss caused injury to, or prejudicial alteration to, the position of those employees – whether failure to dismiss for prohibited reason – proceeding dismissed
WORDS AND PHRASES – “injure”, “alter … to the prejudice”, “for a prohibited reason”
Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth), ss 3, 170LJ, 298K, 400, 402, 778, 779, 789, 790, 791, 792, 793, 794, 795, 796, 797, 798, 799, 800, 801, 802, 803, 804, 805, 807, 809, 810, 811, 812, 813
Australian and International Pilots Association v Qantas Airways Ltd [2006] FCA 1441, (2006) 160 IR 1 cited
Australian Collieries’ Staff Association v BHP Coal Pty Ltd (2000) 99 FCR 137 referred to
Australian Workers’ Union v BHP Iron-Ore Pty Ltd (2001) 106 FCR 482 followed
BHP Iron Ore Pty Ltd v Australian Workers’ Union (2000) 102 FCR 97 followed
Blackadder v Ramsey Butchering Services Pty Ltd (2005) 221 CLR 539 cited
Blair v Australian Motor Industries Ltd (1982) 61 FLR 283 cited
Brackenridge v Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Ltd (1996) 142 ALR 99 cited
Burnie Port Corp Pty Ltd v Maritime Union of Australia (2000) 104 FCR 440 cited
Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Finance Sector Union of Australia (2007) 157 FCR 329 discussed
Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Finance Sector Union of Australia (2002) 125 FCR 9 cited
Community and Public Sector Union v Telstra Corp Ltd (2001) 107 FCR 93 cited
Connington v Municipality of Kogarah [1913] AR (NSW) 40 cited
Downe v Sydney West Area Health Service (No 2) [2008] NSWSC 159 cited
Finance Sector Union of Australia v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2001] FCA 1613, (2001) 111 IR 241 cited
Grayndler v Broun [1928] AR (NSW) 46 cited
Grayndler v Cunich (1939) 62 CLR 573 cited
Greater Dandenong City Council v Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union (2001) 112 FCR 232 discussed
Hunt v Railway Commissioners (NSW); Ex parte Brown-Smith [1928] AR (NSW) 151 cited
Klanjscek v Silver (1961) 4 FLR 182 cited
Maritime Union of Australia v CSL Australia Pty Ltd [2002] FCA 513, (2002) 113 IR 326 cited
Maritime Union of Australia v Geraldton Port Authority (1999) 93 FCR 34 discussed
Martech International Pty Ltd v Energy World Corp Ltd [2007] FCAFC 35 cited
Moss v Fantil Pty Ltd t/as Central Coast Security Services (1994) 58 IR 118 cited
National Union of Workers v Qenos Pty Ltd (2001) 108 FCR 90 followed
Patrick Stevedores Operations No 2 Pty Ltd v Maritime Union of Australia (No 3) (1998) 195 CLR…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Unsworth v Tristar Steering and Suspension Australia Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] FCA 1224
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that while the length of service was indeed a factor in the decision not to dismiss certain employees, this did not establish a prohibited reason under the Act. The court reasoned that the retention was primarily due to the potential for remanufacturing work and overseas ventures, which were genuine pursuits. Moreover, the court held that there was no causal link between any adverse impact on the employees and the alleged prohibited reason. Consequently, the court concluded that Tristar's actions did not contravene the Act.
Based on the reasoning and findings, the court dismissed Unsworth's case. No further consideration was given to the position of other employees not covered by the Certified Agreement, and no order regarding costs was made. The court found that the proceeding was not instituted vexatiously or without reasonable cause but ultimately determined that there was no basis for the relief claimed.
Orders
Orders of the court
The proceeding be dismissed.
Note:
Background
Background to the litigation
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: GYLES J
The Certified Agreement was between Tristar, on the one hand, and four unions, on the other. It was certified pursuant to s 170LJ of the Act, as it stood in 2003 and 2004. The relevant terms of the Agreement were as follows:“6. OPERATION AND APPLICATION OF AGREEMENT6.1 This agreement shall take effect from the beginning of the first pay period to commence on or after the date upon which it is certified by the Australian Industrial Relations Commission.6.2 This agreement shall remain in force until the 30 September 2006. Three months prior to the end of the life of this agreement, the parties agree to commence negotiations with the aim of formulating a new agreement before the expiry date of this agreement is reached.6.3 This agreement shall apply to each of the parties referred to in clause 4 in respect of the employment by Tristar Steering and Suspension Australia Limited of employees covered by the Metal Engineering and Associated Industries Award, 1998 Parts 1 and 2.…10. RELATIONSHIP TO PARENT AWARDThis agreement shall be read wholly in conjunction with the Metal Engineering and Associated Industries Award 1998 Part 1 and 2. Where there is any inconsistency between this agreement and the Award, this agreement shall apply. The Company will not during the life of this Agreement offer employees an Australian Workplace Agreement.11. CONSULTATION11.1 The parties acknowledge that an important factor in meeting the aims and objectives of this agreement is to develop and maintain consultative processes in all sections by which employees will be kept informed about developments at TSSA and have the opportunity to input into decisions that affect their work and their working environment.11.2 Both parties accept that they have a responsibility for creating and maintaining a consultative working environment and will work together to create such a culture.11.3 Introduction of Change – Duty to NotifyWhere the company has made a definite decision to introduce major changes in production, programme, Organisation, structure or technology that are likely to have significant effects on employees, the Company shall notify the employees and their respective unions, through their delegates who may be affected by the proposed changes.11.4 “Significant effects” include termination of employment, major changes in the composition, operation or size of the workforce or in the skills required, the elimination or diminution of job opportunities, promotion opportunities or job tenure; alteration of hours of work, the need for re-training or transfer of employees to other work or locations and the restructuring of jobs. Provided that where the Award makes provision for alterations of any of the matters referred to herein an alteration shall be deemed not to have significant effect.Duty to Discuss Change11.5 The Company shall discuss with the effected [sic] employees and their union, the introduction of the changes referred to in paragraph 11.3 above, the effects the changes are likely to have on employees, measures to avert or mitigate possible adverse effects of such changes on employees. The Company shall give prompt consideration to matters raised by the employees and/or their union in relation to the changes.11.6 The discussions with employees affected and their union shall commence as early as practicable after the activities referred to in paragraph 11.4 hereof.11.7For the purposes of such discussion, the Company shall provide to the employees concerned and their union all relevant information about the changes, including the nature of the changes proposed, the expected effects of the changes on employees and any other matters likely to affect employees. Provided that the company shall not be required to disclose confidential information the disclosure of which would be damaging to the company’s interests.11.8 Where requested the employer shall provide information in languages other than English for employees of non-English speaking background.…21. REDUNDANCY21.1Where the company has made a definite decision that it no longer wishes the job an employee has been doing performed by anyone, and that decision may lead to termination of employment, the company shall hold discussions with the employees affected and with their union.21.2 The discussions shall take place as soon as is practicable after the employer has made a definite decision which will invoke the provisions of paragraph 1 hereof and shall cover any reasons for the proposed terminations, measures to avoid or minimise the terminations and measures to mitigate any adverse effects of any terminations on the employees concerned.21.3 For the purposes of the discussion the company shall, as soon as practicable after making a decision but before any terminations, provide in writing to the employees concerned and their union, all relevant information about the proposed terminations. Provided that the company shall not be required to disclose confidential information, the disclosure of which would be inimical to the company’s interests.21.4 NoticeRetrenched employees will be given four weeks notice of termination of employment or four weeks pay in lieu of notice at the Company’s discretion. Employees aged over 45 years with at least 2 years service shall be entitled to 1 extra weeks notice as per clause 4.3.1 (b) of the Metal Engineering and Associated Industries Award, 1998.21.5 Severance PaymentEmployees who are retrenched involuntarily and voluntarily will be paid on the following basis:Less than 1 year of service Nil1 or more years of service Rate of 4 weeks per year (including pro-rata for partially completed year)computed from the commencement of employmentIn the event of a voluntary redundancy, the maximum severance payment shall be capped at 52 weeks. 21.6Loading of 17.5% to be applied to full pro-rata Annual Leave entitlements on retrenchment.21.7Subject to satisfactory evidence of an arranged job interview, employees will be given up to 1 day during each worked week of notice without loss of pay to attend such interviews.21.8All employees will be supplied with a Certificate of Service and Separation Certificate at the time of the retrenchment. An itemised Statement of Entitlements will be supplied to all retrenched employees. 21.9Selection of redundant employees – where surplus staff exists:(a)Identify the number of redundant positions, their employment categories and their location of employment.(b)Call for volunteers within the identified area of employment and employment category. The Company will attempt to accommodate requests for voluntary retrenchment; however, the final decision on acceptance or rejection of the request will lie with the Company.(c)Should there be insufficient acceptable volunteers to fill the identified numbers, then the following will apply:(d)Compulsory redundancy will have regard to maintaining a balance of skill and experience within the department. The Company will nominate those employees they wish to be made redundant.21.10Employees retrenched may leave at any time during the notice period to take up another position. In this event, the employee will be paid only for the period of notice he/she worked, and the severance entitlement under the redundancy provision.21.11Retrenched employees will receive payment of all accumulated sick leave.21.12An employee who elects for voluntary redundancy and who has untaken RDOs at the date of termination shall be paid in lieu for such days at ordinary rates. In the event of compulsory retrenchment the employee shall receive payment in lieu for untaken RDOs and such payment will be at penalty rates (each day to stand alone) to a maximum of 3 days. In the event that untaken RDOs exceed 3 days then such additional days shall be paid at ordinary rates.In the case of compulsory retrenchment where an employee is required to take RDOs during the notice period and is unable to do so because of absence or other exceptional circumstance the employee shall be paid for up to 3 days at penalty rates (each day to stand alone). Untaken days in excess of 3 shall be paid at ordinary rates.21.13Long Service Leave for forcibly retrenched employees will be paid based on prorata years of service from the commencement of employment.21.14Shift allowance will be used in calculations only when the employee at the date of termination has been on afternoon or nightshift (including rotating shifts) for at least 6 months in the immediate 12 months prior to termination of employment.21.15In the event of an employee under notice of retrenchment, dying prior to the actual date of termination, all benefits payable in relation to provisions of this agreement shall apply and will be paid into the employee’s estate.21.16In the event of redundancies the Company agrees to make available suitable financial counseling and/or outplacement services, provided that the cost to the company of providing such services shall not exceed $300 per employee.”(Emphasis added.)STATUTORY PROVISIONS