Scarati v Republic of Italy

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Scarati v Republic of Italy [2023] FCA 1264

File number: VID 536 of 2020
Judgment of: THOMAS J
Date of judgment: 20 October 2023
Catchwords:

CONTRACT – construction of contract – whether preamble incorporated into the terms of the contract – intention of parties – where preamble referred to the 1967 Presidential Decree, the 2000 Legislative Decree and the 2006 DFAT Agreement – whether 2006 DFAT Agreement incorporated into the contract – held: preamble does not impose any contractual obligation – contract does not incorporate the 1967 Presidential Decree, the 2000 Legislative Decree and the 2006 DFAT Agreement

INDUSTRIAL LAW – construction of industrial awards – whether applicant’s duties fall within the Clerks Award or the Miscellaneous Award – where there is disagreement in the nature of the applicant’s duties – question of the level at which the applicant is employed at – held: applicant falls within the Clerks Award – applicant’s duties primarily clerical and administrative in nature – applicant employed as Level 3 employee

PRECEDENT – single judge decision – where respondent submits a decision of the Full Court is plainly wrong – whether single judge bound to follow the Full Court

SUPERANNUATION – whether respondent failed to make employer superannuation contributions – where respondent does not dispute that it failed to make employer superannuation contributions – where applicant seeking declaration that he was entitled to superannuation contributions – whether applicant has standing to obtain declaratory relief – whether applicant has real and not theoretical interest to seek a declaration – distinguishing seeking declarations to recover superannuation contributions with seeking declarations of entitlement to superannuation contributions – held: applicant can seek declaratory relief in relation to statutory entitlement

COURTS AND JUDGES – jurisdiction – whether Federal Court can exercise jurisdiction – whether Long Service Leave Act 2018 (Vic) (LSL Act) reposes exclusive jurisdiction on the Industrial Division of the Magistrates’ Court of Victoria – whether under s 79 of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), rights and remedies under State legislation can be applicable in federal jurisdiction – held: this Court can exercise jurisdiction to deal with applicant’s claim under the LSL Act

FAIR WORK ACT – obligation for employer to keep employee records – whether respondent contravened s 535(3) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) – whether respondent failed to provide applicant with a copy of employee records – where applicant’s solicitors requested employee record – where respondent refused to provide employee records on grounds of “confidentiality obligations” – where respondent not satisfied that employee’s solicitors were authorised to make the request – where respondent did not provide employee records until after proceedings had been commenced – held: respondent failed to provide employee records and contravened r 3.42(1) of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth)

Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)

Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Foreign States Immunity Act 1985 (Cth)

Superannuation Guarantee (Administration)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scarati v Republic of Italy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1264
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Mr Scarati, an employee of the Republic of Italy, brought a proceeding against the Republic in the Federal Court of Australia. He sought various declarations and remedies related to his employment, including whether certain legislative decrees and agreements were incorporated into his employment contract, which industrial award applied to his employment, whether he was entitled to superannuation contributions, and whether the Republic contravened certain employment obligations under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The Republic admitted to some of the claims but denied others.

The court had to decide several legal issues, including whether certain legislative decrees and agreements were incorporated into Mr Scarati's employment contract, which industrial award applied to his employment, whether he was entitled to seek declaratory relief in relation to superannuation contributions, whether the Federal Court had jurisdiction to hear the claim under the Long Service Leave Act 2018 (Vic), and whether the Republic contravened certain employment obligations under the Fair Work Act.

The court found that the Preamble to Mr Scarati's employment contract did not incorporate the 1967 Presidential Decree, the 2000 Legislative Decree, and the 2006 DFAT Agreement into the contract. The court also found that Mr Scarati's duties fell within the Clerks Award rather than the Miscellaneous Award. The court held that Mr Scarati could seek declaratory relief in relation to his entitlement to superannuation contributions. The court found that it had jurisdiction to hear the claim under the Long Service Leave Act, despite the Act reposing exclusive jurisdiction on the Industrial Division of the Magistrates’ Court of Victoria. Lastly, the court found that the Republic failed to provide Mr Scarati with a copy of his employee records and contravened certain employment obligations under the Fair Work Act.

In conclusion, the court found in favour of Mr Scarati on several claims, including that the Republic failed to incorporate certain legislative decrees and agreements into his employment contract, that his employment fell within the Clerks Award, that he could seek declaratory relief in relation to superannuation contributions, and that the Republic contravened certain employment obligations under the Fair Work Act. The court reserved costs and requested the parties to confer and provide draft orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties confer and provide to Chambers draft orders, if agreed, which reflect these reasons.

2. Costs be reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

This judgment concerns the liability aspect of the proceeding.FACTUAL BACKGROUND There is a limited factual contest as the parties agreed upon a large number of facts relevant to Mr Scarati’s claims, as set out in a Statement of Agreed Facts dated 26 October 2022. The only factual contest related to the duties which are, and were, performed by Mr Scarati at the Melbourne Consulate. The background facts which are relevant for present purposes are set out below. Facts which directly concern any one of Mr Scarati’s claims are set out where that claim is addressed in the judgment.The parties Mr Scarati is an employee of the Republic and is currently employed on a full time basis at the Republic’s Consulate in Melbourne, Victoria. Prior to commencing his employment at the Melbourne Consulate in 2008, Mr Scarati was employed at the Republic’s Consulate in Perth, Western Australia. The Republic is a foreign state for the purposes of the Foreign States Immunity Act 1985 (Cth). By its Amended Defence, the Republic abandoned its invocation of any potential immunities arising under that Act. The parties agreed that Mr Scarati is a national system employee and the Republic a national system employer, as those terms are defined in the FW Act.The employment contracts On 9 August 2002, Mr Scarati entered into a written contract of employment with the Republic to work at the Republic’s Perth Consulate (Perth Contract). The Preamble to the Perth Contract contained the following statement (as translated into English): In compliance with the provisions under sub-section II, section title VI of the [Italian] Presidential Decree nr.18 of the 05/01/1967 and subsequent amendments and inclusions- in particular the [Italian] Legislative Decree of 07/04/2000, no. 103, as well as “The [Australian] Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade Certified Agreement 2002-2003”, the Italian Consulate in Perth appoints Mr. Antonio Scarati, an Italian citizen, born in [XXXX] on the [XXXX], [Italian] tax-file number [XXXX], (fiscal resident of the Municipality of Milan, Lombardy [Italy]), an Australian resident since [XXXX], based on the following terms and conditions to which Mr. Scarati declares to adhere entirely. Pursuant to the Perth Contract, Mr Scarati was employed at the Perth Consulate on a full time basis from 2 December 2002 to 30 June 2008. During this period, Mr Scarati was paid in Australian dollars. His pay rate upon commencement was $53,172 gross per annum. On 12 February 2008, the Republic and Mr Scarati entered into a second written contract of employment for Mr Scarati’s work to be based at the Republic’s Melbourne Consulate (Melbourne Contract). Pursuant to the Melbourne Contract, Mr Scarati has been (and continues to be) employed at the Melbourne Consulate on a full time basis since 1 July 2008. The Preamble to the Melbourne Contract was as follows (as translated into English): In compliance with the provisions under sub-section II, section title VI of Decree No. 18 of 05.01.1967 - by the President of the Italian Republic and subsequent amendments and inclusions - with particular reference to Legislative Decree No.103 of 07.04.2000, as well as the [Australian n.d.t.] Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade Certified Agreement 2006-2009, the Italian Consulate General in Melbourne appoints Mr. Antonio SCARATI, an Italian citizen born in [XXXX] on [XXXX], [Italian n.d.t.] tax file number [XXXX] (resident for tax purposes of the Municipality of Milan, Lombardy [Italy n.d.t.]), and an Australian resident since [XXXX], on the following terms and conditions to which Mr. Antonio SCARATI declares to agree entirely.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The surrounding circumstances identified by Mr Scarati do not support the conclusion that the parties intended that the 2000 Legislative Decree and the 2006 DFAT Agreement be incorporated into the contractual arrangements between the parties.Conclusion In the result, by reference to the proposed list of liability questions to be determined, provided to me by the parties, I conclude (as to the questions raised in paragraph 2) that:(b)Upon its true construction, the Melbourne Contract, in relation to employment at the Republic’s Melbourne Consulate, did not incorporate by reference (and in so doing afford to them contractual force) the following documents identified therein:(i)the 1967 Presidential Decree;(ii)the 2000 Legislative Decree;(iii)the 2006 DFAT Agreement and subsequent agreements, as updated from time to time;(iv)in view of the ruling as to 2(b)(iii), it is not necessary to answer this question.(c) In view of the ruling as to 2(b)(iii) it is not necessary to answer this question.THE AWARD COVERAGE CLAIMOverview By this claim, Mr Scarati sought a declaration pursuant to s 21 of the FCA Act that, at all material times from 1 January 2010, the Clerks Award applied (and continues to apply) to his employment with the Republic. In the event the Clerks Award does apply, Mr Scarati contended that the Republic breached cl 32.3 of that Award by failing to pay him any annual leave loading. This, he said, amounted to a contravention of s 45 of the FW Act. If the Clerks Award does not apply to his employment, Mr Scarati claimed in the alternative that the Republic breached the Miscellaneous Award for the same failure to pay him any annual leave loading. The Republic admitted that the Miscellaneous Award applied to Mr Scarati’s employment, but denied that the Clerks Award applies. It was common ground that the Republic has never paid any annual leave loading to Mr Scarati under this modern award. Accordingly, the Republic has contravened the Miscellaneous Award 2010 and 2020 by not paying annual leave loading of 17.5% to Mr Scarati. The question to be resolved is whether the Clerks Award applies. If it is established that the Clerks Award applies, the factual question of where Mr Scarati’s duties fall within the scope of that Award can then be considered.Relevant principles – construction of Industrial Awards Both parties correctly acknowledged that the approach to the construction of industrial awards was recently summarised by the Full Court in King v Melbourne Vicentre Swimming Club Inc (2021) 308 IR 171; [2021] FCAFC 123. In that case, it was said (at [40]) that:The principles governing the construction of awards are well-established … The construction of an industrial instrument depends on its language, understood in light of its industrial context and purpose: see Amcor Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2005) 222 CLR 241; 138 IR 286 at [2] (Gleeson CJ and McHugh J). In City of Wanneroo v Holmes (1989) 30 IR 362 at 378-379, French J said (most citations removed):The interpretation of an award begins with a consideration of the natural and ordinary meaning of its words. The words are to be read as a whole and in context.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

There are a number of documents to which the parties referred. Details of the relevant contracts are set out in “[t]he employment contracts” section above.Consideration The Republic submitted that the Preamble clearly delineated itself from the operative terms – by reference to its title and also its content – and that, whilst recitals can be used as an aide to construction of an operative provision in an agreement, the recitals are not themselves operative. Where the express term of a provision is clear and unambiguous, a recital cannot cut down the operative words. The Republic continued that the Preamble was not a term and could not properly be described as a “Preamble term” as was done by Mr Scarati. The Preamble imposed no obligation on Mr Scarati or the Republic. Underpinning this position was the use of the title “Preamble” and the fact that the Preamble referred to the “following terms and conditions”, which were described as the terms and conditions to which Mr Scarati “declare[d] to agree entirely”. Mr Scarati submitted that the Republic’s submissions regarding the Preamble should be rejected as they did not grapple with what the Preamble sought to achieve, namely “it constructs an architecture obligation by incorporating by reference certain other instruments/documents which, in their language, impose their own clear obligations on the parties”. Mr Scarati further contended that the Court should not determine the meaning and significance of the words used in a contract by simply “relying on some form of taxonomical nomenclature deployed by the parties”. Mr Scarati submitted that the Preamble performed a critical function and it would be erroneous for the Court to construe it as a “mere recital”. In relation to recitals, Mr Scarati referred in oral submissions to the comments made by Lord Esher, MR in Ex parte Dawes. In re Moon (1886) 17 QBD 275, where it was said (at 286):Now there are three rules applicable to the construction of such an instrument. If the recitals are clear and the operative part is ambiguous, the recitals govern the construction. If the recitals are ambiguous, and the operative part is clear, the operative part must prevail. If both the recitals and the operative part are clear, but they are inconsistent with each other, the operative part is to be preferred. The words in question appear at the beginning of the contract under the heading “Preamble”. Whether called “preamble” or “recitals”, typically, this first section of an agreement exists to provide context and may outline the parties’ intentions or purpose in forming the agreement. For that reason, where there is ambiguity in a term of the contract, the contents of that section may provide a guide to resolve ambiguity. Conventionally, operative terms of a contract are not usually to be found in the preamble or recitals section. Of course, the effect of the words used under the heading “Preamble” and what impact they have on the terms of the Melbourne Contract depends upon the text of the Melbourne Contract considered within that document as a whole. To that end, the “taxonomical nomenclature” chosen by the parties (whether it be “Recital” or “Preamble”) is not decisive in its own right. It may, however, contribute to an understanding of the words used.