Kelly v Atanaskovic Hartnell Corporate Services Pty Limited (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Kelly v Atanaskovic Hartnell Corporate Services Pty Limited (No 2) [2022] FedCFamC2G 112

File number: SYG 1194 of 2017
Judgment of: JUDGE DRIVER
Date of judgment: 31 March 2022
Catchwords:

EMPLOYMENT LAW – Fair Work – claim for unpaid entitlements and compensation for adverse action

CONTRACT – claim for damages for breach of an implied term to avoid exposure to risk of injury

CROSS-CLAIM – negligence – principles of equitable set‑off in the context of employment

Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 15AA

Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), s 21

Constitution of Australia (Cth)

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 3, 12, 14, 44, 90, 323, 324, 340, 341, 342, 360, 361, 539, 545, 547, 550, 566

Industrial Relations Act 1988 (Cth) s 170EE

Industrial Relations Act 1996 (NSW) s 120

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) ss 79, 80

Long Service Leave Act 1955 (NSW) s 4

Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (NSW) ss 3, 19, 28

Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) s 151H

Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth), ss 298K, 298L

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Active Adult Management Pty Ltd v Milstern Retirement Living Pty Ltd [2017] NSWSC 1238

Adami v Maison de Luxe Ltd (1924) 35 CLR 143

Aerospace Publishing Ltd v Thames Water Utilities Ltd [2007] EWCA Civ 3

Aitken v Construction, Mining, Energy, Timberyards, Sawmills & Woodworkers Union of Australia (WA Branch) (1995) 63 IR 1

Amponsem v Laundy (Exhibition) Pty Limited [2014] FCCA 2206

Andrews v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited (2012) 247 CLR 205

Astley v Austrust Ltd (1999) 197 CLR 1

Auimatagi v Australian Building and Construction Commissioner [2018] FCAFC 191

Australian Licensed Aircraft Engineers Association v International Aviation Service Assistance Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 333

Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union v Greater Dandenong City Council [2000] FCA 1231

BHP Coal Pty Ltd v O&K Orenstein & Koppel AG [2008] QSC 141

Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical and  Further Education v Barclay (No 1) (2012) 248 CLR 500

Chamberlain Early Learning Centre Pty Limited v Precious 1 Pty Limited [2017] NSWSC 189

Commercial Union Assurance Company of Australia Limited v Ferrcom Pty Ltd (1991) 22 NSWLR 389

Community and Public Sector Union v Telstra Corporation Ltd [2001] FCA 267

Construction, Forestry, Mining & Energy Union v Pilbara Iron Company (Services) Pty Ltd (No 3) [2012]   FCA 697

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Coal Pty Ltd (2014) 253 CLR 243

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v De Martin & Gasparini Pty Limited (No 2) [2017] FCA 1046

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Eco Recyclers Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 24

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v State of Victoria & Ors [2013] FCA 445

Dafallah v Fair Work Commission (2014) 225 FCR 559

F.Y.D. Investments Pty Ltd v Promptair Pty Ltd (No 2) [2019] FCA 419

Fair Work Ombudsman…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kelly v Atanaskovic Hartnell Corporate Services Pty Limited... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FedCFamC2G 112
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case, Kelly v Atanaskovic Hartnell Corporate Services Pty Limited (No 2), was before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia and involved a dispute between Mrs Kelly and Atanaskovic Hartnell Corporate Services Pty Limited (AHCS). Mrs Kelly was employed by AHCS and had responsibilities for human resources, administration, information technology, and finance. AHCS submitted that Mrs Kelly's performance of her duties caused it to incur significant costs and damages, and thus sought to set off these costs and damages against any entitlement Mrs Kelly had to accrued but untaken long service leave entitlements. Mrs Kelly denied any liability for the costs and damages claimed by AHCS.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether AHCS could set off the claimed costs and damages against Mrs Kelly's long service leave entitlements, and whether the Workers Compensation Act applied to regulate any damages payable for breach of the Safe Workplace Term. The court considered whether the set-off of judgments was available, and whether this was precluded by section 90(2) of the Fair Work Act or rule 24.09 of the Federal Circuit Court Rules.

The court found that the set-off of judgments was a practice of the courts that allowed one judgment for the payment of money to be set off against another judgment for the payment of money, and did not depend upon statutory set-off. The court also found that there was no inconsistency between section 90(2) and rule 24.09 so as to preclude the use of the power in rule 24.09 in proceedings for accrued but untaken annual leave. However, the court found that the Workers Compensation Act was not applicable to regulate any damages payable for breach of the Safe Workplace Term in this case.

In conclusion, the court found in favour of Mrs Kelly and against AHCS on the set-off issue. The court held that any order made pursuant to rule 24.09 would necessarily be premised on a judgment in Mrs Kelly's favour in which it was found that Mrs Kelly was entitled to be paid her statutory entitlements within one month of the cessation of her employment. As AHCS failed to do so, it would have breached a civil remedy provision and would be liable to pay penalties.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondents note that AH (an unincorporated partnership) is not a separate legal entity but accept that AH may be a convenient shorthand reference to the then partners that constituted that partnership.Factual background bearing upon the amended defence and cross-claims At all material times, an unincorporated partnership known as “Atanaskovic Hartnell” operated the business of a law firm and provided legal services in Australia.[28][28] see FASOC, [5], [6]; amended defence filed on 10 May 2019, [5(a)], [6]; see also applicant opening submissions, [1] At all material times, AHCS provided corporate and general management services to AH.[29][29] see FASOC, [5], [6]; amended defence, [5], [6]; amended cross-claim filed 10 May 2019, [2]; reply to amended cross-claim filed 11 June 2019, [2]; Kelly, [13]; applicant opening submissions, [1] As noted above, on 13 March 2004, AHCS entered into a written contract of employment with Mrs Kelly dated 9 March 2004 (Employment Contract) .[30][30] see FASOC, [8]; amended defence, [8]; amended cross-claim, [5]; reply to amended cross-claim, [5]; Kelly, [12] On 19 April 2004, Mrs Kelly commenced employment with AHCS.[31][31] see FASOC, [1]; defence, [1]; amended cross-claim, [3]; reply to amended cross-claim, [3]; Kelly [12]; applicant opening submissions, [1] From 19 April 2004, Mrs Kelly was the General Manager of the AHCS.[32][32] see amended cross-claim, [3]; reply to amended cross-claim, [3]; Kelly, [12]; applicant opening submissions, [1] As General Manager, Mrs Kelly regarded herself as responsible for human resources, administration, information technology and finance at AHCS.[33] [33] see Kelly, [17]; applicant opening submissions, [1]Responsibilities for AH LLP As noted earlier, on 19 May 2011, AHCS established AH LLP, a limited liability partnership to provide legal services in England and Wales.[34] [34] see amended cross-claim, [8]; reply to amended cross-claim, [8]; Kelly, [19]; applicant opening submissions, [13] From 19 May 2011, Mrs Kelly is said to have provided regular financial management assistance to AH LLP, including payroll and the preparation of accounts.[35] [35] see Kelly, [30] From 19 May 2011, Mrs Kelly is said to have regarded herself as responsible for the payroll of AH LLP.[36] [36] see Kelly [123] To that end, Mrs Kelly designed a payslip to provide to AH LLP employees, completed the payslips on a monthly basis and emailed the payslips to the AH LLP employees on a monthly basis.[37] [37] See Kelly, [127], [128]; second Kelly affidavit, [13] To that end, Mrs Kelly deducted pay as you earn (PAYE) tax and national insurance contribution (NIC) payments and remitted such tax and payments to Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs (HMRC).[38] [38] see amended cross-claim, [15(b)]; reply to amended cross-claim, [15(c)] To that end, Mrs Kelly also handled (and was solely responsible for) the filing of monthly returns to HMRC for PAYE tax and NIC payments.[39][39] see amended cross-claim, [15(b)]; reply to amended cross-claim, [15(b)]; Kelly, [97]LexisNexis Contract

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondents assert that any damages payable by reason of the breach of the Safe Workplace Term (as defined in [9] of the Statement of Claim) are regulated by Part 5, Division 3 of the Workers Compensation Act. It is Mrs Kelly’s position that the Workers Compensation Act is of no application in the present case because on the facts, properly construed, and separately, on the respondents’ pleaded defence, the injuries occasioned by Mrs Kelly were not caused by the negligence or other tort of AHCS. I accept the construction of the Workers Compensation Act advanced on behalf of Mrs Kelly.THE EVIDENCE Mrs Kelly relies upon her affidavits made on 3 May 2018, 28 June 2018, 3 August 2018, 16 September 2019, 30 October 2019 and 13 November 2019. She was cross-examined at length on her affidavits. Mrs Kelly also relies upon the affidavits of her husband Mr Rodger Kelly and medical evidence from Dr Enrico Parmegiani, which was tested at the trial, and the affidavit of Mr Alan Clare made on 13 December 2018 annexing a report on Mrs Kelly’s employment prospects. Mr Clare was cross-examined on his affidavit. The respondents rely upon seven affidavits by Mr Atanaskovic made on 3 May 2018, 25 June 2018, 2 August 2018, 12 November 2018, 8 February 2019, 5 July 2019, and 11 November 2019; three affidavits by Mr Michael Sophocles made on 2 May 2018, 20 June 2018 and 20 May 2019, and an affidavit by Mr Hartnell made on 19 June 2018. All those deponents were cross-examined. The respondents also rely upon medical evidence by Dr Doron Samuell contained in two reports made on 2 April 2019 and 1 May 2019 and an affidavit of Ms Rosemary Enderley made on 1 August 2018. I also received a very substantial bundle of exhibits, including a volume of confidential material the subject of a suppression order I made on 18 November 2019. I also received the following documents tendered at the trial: A1 AHCS Minutes and two letters, 18 May 2017;A2 handwritten letter of resignation from Mr Hartnell;A3 Historical company extract;A4 Two folders of UK Immigration Rules as at 19 May 2016;A5 Notice to produce, 8 November 2019;A6 Mr Hartnell’s bank statements – 12 January 2016 – 12 February 2016;A7 photo of Mr Atanaskovic’s passport;R1 Mr Atanaskovic’s application for UK – Tier 1 visa;R2 letter from UK Home Office, 11 June 2014;R3 email exchange re lease renewal;R4 UK Limited Liability Partnership Act. The parties filed exceptionally detailed closing submissions, which were augmented orally.CONSIDERATIONFactual backgroundAtanaskovic Hartnell The general factual background to this matter is set out above. Some facts are uncontroversial and some are disputed. The uncontroversial factual background bearing upon my decision is as follows. At all material times, an unincorporated (common law) partnership known as “Atanaskovic Hartnell” (AH) operated the business of a law firm and provided legal services in Australia.[83][83] see amended statement of claim, [5], [6]; amended defence, [5(a)], [6]; see also Kelly, [13]; applicant opening submissions, [1]; affidavit of Mr Atanaskovic made on 25 June 2018 (second Atanaskovic affidavit), [6]

Decision

Reasons for decision

AHCS submits that the NSW Parliament has thus not legislated to preclude a set-off of the claims by AHCS against the accrued but untaken long service leave entitlements of Mrs Kelly.AHCS submissions concerning set-off of judgments A set-off of judgments is a practice of the courts that allows one judgment or order for the payment of money to be set-off against another judgment or order for the payment of money.[69] The set-off of judgments extends to a judgment for damages.[70] [69] see, for example, Amponsem at [146] per Manousaridis J; see also Derham, [2.98], page 51[70] see Derham, [2.98], page 51 The set-off of judgments does not depend upon, and is independent of, any statutory set-off, such as under s 21 of the Civil Procedure Act.[71] The set-off of judgments involves the inherent jurisdiction of a court[72] and its purpose is to prevent absurdity or injustice.[73][71] see Derham, page 52; see also Amponsem at [148][72] see Derham, [2.104], page 55; see also Amponsem at [146][73] see Amponsem at [147]; Derham, [2.104], page 55 There is said to be no indicator in s 90(2), or the Fair Work Act more generally, that a set-off of judgments is unavailable where one of the judgments is based on s 90(2). It is unlikely that, by enacting s 90(2), Parliament intended to remove the inherent jurisdiction to prevent absurdity or injustice.Order under rule 24.09 Rule 24.09 provides:If a respondent establishes a cross-claim against the applicant and there is a balance in favour of one of the parties, the Court may give judgment for the balance. This Court has exercised the power in the former equivalent to rule 24.09 to make a single order in favour of an employer after recognising an entitlement to accrued but untaken annual leave.[74][74] see Amponsem at [153] This Court has held that there is no inconsistency between s 90(2) and the former equivalent to rule 24.09 so as to preclude the use of the power in rule 24.09 in proceedings for accrued but untaken annual leave.[75][75] see Amponsem at [152]Application to facts The respondents submit that the amounts to be set off are:(a)the damages payable by Mrs Kelly to AHCS in respect of the payment made by AHCS to AH LLP ($71,991.58) representing the costs incurred (and paid to Deloitte) from August to September 2016 for obtaining advice and submitting a second visa application in September 2016 following the negligent performance by Mrs Kelly of her duties (as General Manager of AHCS) relating to the first visa application;[76] (b)the damages payable by Mrs Kelly to AHCS in relation to the diversion to and disruption of the business of AHCS[77] ($154,241) from late 2014 to July 2016 in defending and settling proceedings instituted against it by LexisNexis in relation to the automatic renewal of the LexisNexis Contract in circumstances where AH has required that AHCS compensate AH for its losses arising from the “negligent” performance by Mrs Kelly of her duties (as General Manager of AHCS) relating to the LexisNexis Contract;[78] and(c)alternatively to (b), the damages payable by Mrs Kelly to AHCS (in circumstances where the value of Mr Sophocles’ time spent in defending and settling the LexisNexis Litigation is said to be the best estimate of the loss suffered by AH) flowing from Mrs Kelly’s breaches in relation to the LexisNexis Contract.[76] see response, page 2, “Further Orders Sought by Respondents”, [1]; see also amended cross-claim, [48], [52], [53]; Kelly, [154] and exhibit EK-1, pages 79-80[77] more accurately AH[78] see response, page 2, “Further Orders Sought by Respondents”, [3]; see also cross-claim, [84], [87]

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In practical terms, this is of no significance in respect of any orders for compensation and damages. However, it is said to be of great significance on the topic of penalties. Any order made pursuant to rule 24.09 would necessarily be premised on a judgment in Mrs Kelly’s favour in which it was found that Mrs Kelly was entitled to be paid her statutory entitlements within one month of the cessation of her employment. AHCS failed to do so and accordingly, Mrs Kelly submits it would have breached a civil remedy provision (being s 323 of the Fair Work Act) and would be liable to pay penalties. Rule 24.09 does not disturb this position.The operation of the Workers Compensation Act The respondents assert that any damages payable by reason of the breach of the Safe Workplace Term (as defined in [9] of the Statement of Claim) are regulated by Part 5, Division 3 of the Workers Compensation Act. It is Mrs Kelly’s position that the Workers Compensation Act is of no application in the present case because on the facts, properly construed, and separately, on the respondents’ pleaded defence, the injuries occasioned by Mrs Kelly were not caused by the negligence or other tort of AHCS. I accept the construction of the Workers Compensation Act advanced on behalf of Mrs Kelly.THE EVIDENCE Mrs Kelly relies upon her affidavits made on 3 May 2018, 28 June 2018, 3 August 2018, 16 September 2019, 30 October 2019 and 13 November 2019. She was cross-examined at length on her affidavits. Mrs Kelly also relies upon the affidavits of her husband Mr Rodger Kelly and medical evidence from Dr Enrico Parmegiani, which was tested at the trial, and the affidavit of Mr Alan Clare made on 13 December 2018 annexing a report on Mrs Kelly’s employment prospects. Mr Clare was cross-examined on his affidavit. The respondents rely upon seven affidavits by Mr Atanaskovic made on 3 May 2018, 25 June 2018, 2 August 2018, 12 November 2018, 8 February 2019, 5 July 2019, and 11 November 2019; three affidavits by Mr Michael Sophocles made on 2 May 2018, 20 June 2018 and 20 May 2019, and an affidavit by Mr Hartnell made on 19 June 2018. All those deponents were cross-examined. The respondents also rely upon medical evidence by Dr Doron Samuell contained in two reports made on 2 April 2019 and 1 May 2019 and an affidavit of Ms Rosemary Enderley made on 1 August 2018. I also received a very substantial bundle of exhibits, including a volume of confidential material the subject of a suppression order I made on 18 November 2019. I also received the following documents tendered at the trial: A1 AHCS Minutes and two letters, 18 May 2017;A2 handwritten letter of resignation from Mr Hartnell;A3 Historical company extract;A4 Two folders of UK Immigration Rules as at 19 May 2016;A5 Notice to produce, 8 November 2019;A6 Mr Hartnell’s bank statements – 12 January 2016 – 12 February 2016;A7 photo of Mr Atanaskovic’s passport;R1 Mr Atanaskovic’s application for UK – Tier 1 visa;R2 letter from UK Home Office, 11 June 2014;R3 email exchange re lease renewal;R4 UK Limited Liability Partnership Act.