Kelly v Atanaskovic Hartnell Corporate Services Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia

(DIVISION 2)

Kelly v Atanaskovic Hartnell Corporate Services Pty Ltd (No 3) [2023] FedCFamC2G 1

File number(s): SYG 1194 of 2017
Judgment of: JUDGE GIVEN
Date of judgment: 2 February 2023
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – Fair Work – assessment of penalty for multiple contraventions established – deliberate contraventions – absolute lack of contrition  – “eleventh hour” corrective action  – significant need for specific and general deterrence – where respondents brought cross-claims alleging equitable set-off as part of scheme to avoid paying entitlements  – employer and individual respondents engaged in the legal industry

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – reconstitution of the Court following retirement of Judge who determined liability – Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 (Cth) does not mandate that same Judge must hear both stages of a proceeding – liability and penalty are separate, distinct stages of a proceeding – where respondents urge second primary Judge to stray from factual findings of first primary Judge – absent appeal outcome, liability judgment should be treated by second primary Judge as being correct – absent appeal outcome, penalty should be determined by second primary Judge on basis of factual findings of first primary Judge

COSTS – competing costs applications - whether conduct of respondents satisfies s 570(2) of Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – indemnity costs – whether adverse action claim is unreasonably maintained in face of express denials that action was taken because of the exercise of a workplace right– s 361 reverse onus

WORDS AND PHRASES – Contrivance – Artifice

Legislation:

Constitution s 72

Crimes Act 1900 (Cth) s 4AA

Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (NSW) s 17

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 44, 90, 323, 324, 340, 346, 361, 539, 546, 550, 570, 557

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 (Cth) ss 10, 137, 214

Federal Circuit Court of Australia Act 1999 (Cth) s 79

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 29

Federal Magistrates Act 1999 (Cth) ss 8, 11

Long Service Leave Act 1955 (NSW) ss 4, 10

Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) s 719

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth) rr 17.05, 22.02, 25.04, 25.12

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 36.08

Cases cited:

Australian and International Pilots Association v Qantas Airways Ltd (No 3) (2007) 162 FCR 392

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Pattinson (2022) 175 ALD 383

Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary-Smith (2008) 165 FCR 560

Australian Workers Union vLeighton Contractors Pty Ltd(No 2) (2013) 232 FCR 428

Bell Lawyers Pty Ltd v Pentelow (2019) 269 CLR 333

BKW17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCAFC 1

Cai v Tiy Loy & Co Ltd [2015] FCCA 715

Chua Chee Chor v Chua Kim Yong [1962] 1 WLR 1464; [1963] 1 All ER 102

Colgate-Palmolive Company v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225

Commonwealth Bank of Australian v Barker [2012] FCA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kelly v Atanaskovic Hartnell Corporate Services Pty Ltd (No... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC2G 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case Kelly v Atanaskovic Hartnell Corporate Services Pty Ltd (No 3) concerns a dispute between Mrs Kelly, the plaintiff, and several respondents, including Mr Atanaskovic and Hartnell Corporate Services Pty Ltd. The central issue pertains to the alleged contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 by the respondents, specifically regarding the failure to pay statutory and contractual entitlements and claims of adverse action for a prohibited reason. The proceedings also involve the imposition of penalties and the determination of costs. The matter was initially heard in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, with subsequent developments involving the Federal Court of Australia.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the findings of contraventions against Mr Atanaskovic and Hartnell Corporate Services Pty Ltd could be relied upon for imposing penalties and whether the procedural fairness afforded to Mr Atanaskovic warranted a re-determination of facts or a reconsideration of penalties. The respondents argued that the initial findings should not be used due to procedural unfairness, and thus, no penalty should be imposed against Mr Atanaskovic. Additionally, the court needed to address whether it could impose penalties on Hartnell Corporate Services Pty Ltd based on the initial findings, given the alleged procedural deficiencies.

The court examined the procedural fairness arguments and determined that the initial findings made by the first primary judge could indeed be relied upon for imposing penalties. The court found no merit in the argument that procedural fairness had not been afforded to Mr Atanaskovic, and thus, there was no basis to re-determine the facts or to decline imposing penalties. The court held that it was entitled to make its own findings regarding the contraventions and could proceed with imposing penalties based on the established evidence and findings from the liability judgment. The court also considered the timing and procedural aspects of the applications for costs and penalties, concluding that the initial findings were valid and could be used in the penalty determination.

The court made orders that the penalties and costs be determined based on the established findings and evidence presented. The penalty/costs application was to proceed as scheduled, with the submissions being exchanged as per the proposed orders. The court found that the procedural fairness arguments did not affect the validity of the initial findings and thus allowed the penalty/costs hearing to proceed. The court did not accept the respondents' submissions regarding procedural unfairness and proceeded with the penalty and costs determination based on the initial findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In support of that submission, the respondents rely upon the interlocutory judgment delivered by the first primary Judge on 11 March 2021: see Kelly v Atanaskovic Hartnell Corporate Services Pty Ltd [2021] FCCA 552 (interlocutory judgment). The respondents contend that findings in relation to the contraventions (in which Mr Atanaskovic was found to be involved/an accessory within the meaning of s 550 of the Act), remain open to this Court to make for itself (despite this not being a course they now actively pursue). Instead, the respondents say because of the alleged denial of procedural fairness to Mr Atanaskovic that, rather than making new findings, the Court should simply not impose any penalty on him. It was submitted that the Court could also not rely upon the findings of the first primary Judge in imposing a penalty against AHCS, for the same reasons.[50] [50] Transcript 24 October 2022 T24.26 to T24.30 The interlocutory judgment relied upon by the respondents in support of this proposition is brief and can be summarised as follows. Once evidence had closed in the liability stage of the proceedings, Mrs Kelly made a formal application to amend her Further Amended Statement of Claim to formalise the question of accessorial liability against the individual respondents. After making observations that this Court is not generally a court of pleadings,[51] and summarising the nature of the claims (in a manner which was consistent with the later liability judgment)[52] his Honour found as follows at [7] to [8] (emphasis added): Another part, and perhaps an important part, of Ms Kelly’s claim relates to alleged adverse action for a prohibited reason, in respect of which she claims compensation. There are, as has been pointed out, seven respondents in the proceedings, and it has been pressed upon me that the case always carried within it the proposition that both the first respondent (service company) and the individual respondents are said to be liable to pay compensation, either as principals or as accessories.To the extent that the amendments now proposed are considered unnecessary, but are put forward on a precautionary basis, then, in my view, the leave sought is not required. The Court has, as I have noted, taken a liberal attitude to the drafting of pleadings, and I have myself had cause to express some frustration with demands for different pleadings on the basis of perceived technical defects. To the extent that the respondents see the present application as one potentially depriving them of technical drafting objections, that expectation may well be disappointed even if the Application in a Case fails.[51] Interlocutory judgment at [3][52] Interlocutory judgment at [5] to [6] As noted, the respondents contend that this Court should now re-determine certain facts for itself or entirely decline to impose penalty against Mr Atanaskovic. It is submitted for the respondents that if the Court were to:…nonetheless contemplate a penalty against Mr Atanaskovic, then the court should approach the matter on the basis that the findings made by [the first primary Judge] against Mr Atanaskovic were made in the context of him not having been afforded procedural fairness.[53][53] Transcript 24 October 2022 T38.41 to T38.45 (and also T29.45 to T29.46 where the Court was also urged to not assume that procedural fairness had been afforded).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Upon delivery of the liability judgment the first primary Judge made the following declaration (March Declaration) and orders (March Orders): THE COURT DECLARES THAT:1.The first and third respondents breached ss 90(2) and 323 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by failing to pay the applicant her statutory and contractual entitlements.THE COURT ORDERS THAT:1.The first and third respondents shall pay the sum of $130,427.84 to the applicant within 21 days, plus interest up to judgment.2.The first and third respondents shall pay general damages to the applicant in the sum of $30,000.3.The application as amended is otherwise dismissed.4.The cross-claim as amended is dismissed. Despite order 3 of the March Orders, it was clear from the liability judgment[26] that the parties sought to, and would, be heard separately in relation to the penalty and costs stage of proceedings (penalty/costs hearing). At the delivery of the liability judgment, the first primary Judge reminded the parties that any application for costs was required (pursuant to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth) (Rules)) to be made within 28 days, by application to the Court. His Honour indicated to the parties that the Court would expect to receive any application seeking penalty within that same period, but that an order to said effect would not be formally made.[27][26] Liability judgment at [262] and [302][27] Transcript 31 March 2022 T2.37 to T2.45 On 28 April 2022, being the last date under the Rules to do so, Mrs Kelly filed an Application in a Proceeding seeking the imposition of penalties against AHCS and Mr Atanaskovic, and costs (penalty/costs application). The penalty/costs application was given a return date of 13 May 2022 by the Registry. On 28 April 2022, the respondents filed an appeal from the liability judgment with the Federal Court of Australia (appeal). While commenced (and styled) as an appeal by reference to the March Orders having ostensibly been made on a final basis, it was not in dispute between the parties that the intention of the first primary Judge was not properly reflected by order 3 of the March Orders. Namely, the proceedings in this Court had not yet completed because the penalty/costs stage had not yet been heard and determined. On 10 May 2022, 12 days beyond the time provided for the making of an application for costs pursuant to r 22.02(1)(b) of the Rules, and three days before the penalty/costs application was to be first returned before the Court, the respondents also filed an Application in a Proceeding seeking orders that Mrs Kelly pay their costs in relation to part of the Adverse Action Claims (see [196] below) (respondents’ costs application). Consequent upon that development, the parties agreed proposed orders for the exchange of written submissions in relation to the respective applications, and that the applications be listed for the penalty/costs hearing at a time convenient to the Court, but after 26 July 2022 (being upon the expiry of the proposed submissions regime). Those proposed orders were sent to the Chambers of the first primary Judge for consideration on 12 May 2022.