Gutierrez v Mur Shipping Australia Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Gutierrez v MUR Shipping Australia Pty Limited [2021] FedCFamC2G 56

File number(s): SYG 2845 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE DRIVER
Date of judgment: 1 December 2021
Catchwords:

HUMAN RIGHTS – Age discrimination – whether applicant was treated less favourably in his employment because of his age, whether the contract of employment was breached and whether his position was made redundant considered – discrimination established – no breach of contract and no redundancy established

EMPLOYMENT LAW – Fair Work – claim for redundancy benefits and penalty dismissed

Legislation:

Age Discrimination Act 2004 (Cth) ss 14, 15, 18

Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) ss 46PD, 46PF, 46PH, 46PO

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 (Cth) s 211

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 117, 119, 546

Cases cited:

Alameddine v Glenworth Valley Horse Riding Pty Ltd [2015] NSWCA 219

Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary-Smith (2008) 165 FCR 560

Buittendag v Ravensthorpe Nickel Operations Pty Limited [2012] WASC 425

Chen v Monash University  [2016] FCAFC 66

Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited v Fardous [2015] NSWCA 82

Dibb v Commissioner of Taxation  (2004) 136 FCR 388

Evans v Ikkos Holdings Pty Ltd [2019] SAET 222

Ewin v Vergara [2014] FCAFC 100

Fetherston v Peninsula Health [2004] FCA 485

Gama v Qantas Airways Limited (No 2) [2006] FMCA 1767

Haider v Hawaiian Punch Pty Limited [2015] FCA 37

Hem v Cant (2007) 159 IR 113

Hill v Hughes (2019) 287 IR 86

Hughes v Hill [2020] FCAFC 126

Jones v Department of Energy and Minerals  (1995) 60 IR 304

Kerkofs v Abdallah [2019] VCAT 259

Koutalis v Pollett [2015] FCA 1165

McDonald v Parnell Laboratories (Aust) Pty Ltd(2007) 168 IR 375

Naidu v Group 4 Securitas Pty Ltd [2005] NSWSC 618

Nationwide News Pty Limited v Naidu (2007) 71 NSWLR 471

Orchard v Higgins [2020] TASADT 11

PIA Mortgage Services Pty Ltd v King (2020) 274 FCR 225

Poniatowska v Hickinbotham [2009] FCA 680

Power v Robot Trading Company Pty Limited [2013] FCCA 21

Qantas Airways Limited v Gama (2008) 167 FCR 537

Ramos v Good Samaritan Industries [2013] FCA 30

Re Kilcran [2014] FCAFC 6

Re Termination, Change and Redundancy Case (1984) 8 IR 34

Reurich v Club Jervis Bay Ltd [2018] FCA 1220

Richardson v Oracle Corporation Australia Pty Limited (2014) 223 FCR 334

Richardson v Oracle Corporation Australia Pty Limited (2018) 232 IR 31

Suridge v Boral Window Systems Pty Ltd [2012] FWA 3126

The Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Limited (1991) 174 CLR 64

Thompson v Big Bert Pty Ltd trading as Charles Hotel (2007) 168 IR 309

Thomson v Orica Australia Pty Ltd  (2002) 116 IR 186

Ulan Coal Mines Ltd v Howarth (2010) 196 IR 32

Watts v Australian Postal Corporation (2014) 222 FCR 220

Wotton v State of Queensland (No 5) [2016] FCA 1457

Wotton v State of Queensland (No 6) [2017] FCA 245

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gutierrez v Mur Shipping Australia Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FedCFamC2G 56
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Gutierrez v Mur Shipping Australia Pty Limited, the Fair Work Commission (FWC) considered claims of age discrimination, breach of contract, and redundancy by Mr. Gutierrez against MUR Shipping. Mr. Gutierrez, a long-serving employee of MUR Shipping, alleged he was subjected to age discrimination when he was pressured to retire and replaced by Ms. Fernandez, despite not having provided a specific retirement date. He further claimed that his employment contract was breached and that his position was made redundant.

The FWC found that Mr. Gutierrez was indeed subjected to age discrimination as he was treated less favourably than his intended replacement, Ms. Fernandez. The pressure to retire and the replacement decision were influenced by his age, which contravenes anti-discrimination laws. However, the FWC concluded that there was no breach of contract as Mr. Gutierrez chose to resign. The court also ruled that his position was not made redundant because the redistribution of his duties occurred after he had resigned and left the company.

In its decision, the FWC awarded Mr. Gutierrez $20,000 in damages for non-economic loss, including hurt feelings and a mild adjustment disorder. The court also ordered an apology from MUR Shipping and interest on the damages up to the date of judgment. The application for redundancy benefits and penalties was dismissed. The case highlights the importance of treating employees fairly and without discrimination based on age, while also underscoring the necessity for employees to understand their contractual rights and obligations.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

During the consultation on 7 May 2019, Mr Gutierrez informed Dr Kaplan:(a)he intended to retire in September 2019;[27](b)he was informed at a meeting that the Board had met and the intention was to terminate him in December 2018;[28](c)he objected to the intended termination on the basis it was “illegal”;[29] and(d)he had commenced proceedings but had been informed that he only had a 65 per cent chance of success.[30][27] see Dr Kaplan’s affidavit, annexure RMK2, page 2 and page 5 (CB: 250, 253); Dr Kaplan’s affidavit, annexure RMK4, page 2 and page 5 (CB: 259, 262); Dr Kaplan’s Notes (Exhibit R3), page 2; Mr Gutierrez’s Cross Examination (3 May 2021 (T86.28 – T86.30)).[28] see Dr Kaplan’s affidavit, annexure RMK2, page 2 (CB: 250); Dr Kaplan’s affidavit, annexure RMK4, page 2 (CB: 259); Dr Kaplan’s Notes (Exhibit R3), page 1.[29] see Dr Kaplan’s affidavit, annexure RMK2, page 2 (CB: 250); Dr Kaplan’s affidavit, annexure RMK4, page 2 (CB: 259); Dr Kaplan’s Notes (Exhibit R3), page 2.[30] see Dr Kaplan’s affidavit, annexure RMK2, page 2 (CB: 250); Dr Kaplan’s affidavit, annexure RMK4, page 2 (CB: 259); Dr Kaplan’s Notes (Exhibit R3), page 2. The matter proceeded on the basis that any privilege in the advice had been waived.THE EVIDENCE AND SUBMISSIONS Mr Gutierrez relies upon two affidavits made by him on 3 December 2020 and 1 April 2021. Mr Gutierrez was cross-examined on his affidavits. I also received the affidavit of Mr Gutierrez’s wife, Aida Gutierrez made on 3 December 2020 and the affidavit of Robert M Kaplan made on 17 December 2020, to which are annexed letters of instruction, a medico-legal report and a revised version of the report. MUR Shipping relies upon the affidavit of Brian Getty made on 19 February 2021 and the affidavit of Jason Smith made on the same day. Both were cross-examined on their affidavits. The parties filed pre-hearing written submissions and also made oral submissions at the trial which was conducted over four days on 3, 4 and 5 May and on 9 and 11 June 2021. All documents to be relied upon were provided in the form of a Court Book. At the trial I received the following exhibits:·Exhibit A1 – email from Mr Getty to Mr Muirhead 06/04/2018;·Exhibit R1 – record of electronic access events;·Exhibit R2 – extract from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th ed;·Exhibit R3 – handwritten notes prepared by Dr Kaplan of his consultation with Mr Gutierrez on 07/05/2019;·Exhibit R4 – email correspondence between parties’ solicitors, 29/04/2021. The parties also provided post hearing written submissions[31] which deal with the assessment of the evidence at trial as well as the pleadings which were amended during the course of the trial. CONSIDERATION[31] which apparently have not been filed.Mr Gutierrez’s contentions Mr Gutierrez had been a long serving faithful employee, working for MUR Shipping since 1993. He became entitled to receive bonuses from around 2004 and was paid bonuses of:(a)$7,739 for the year ending 31 December 2014;[32](b)$8,000 for the year ending 31 December 2015;[33](c)nothing for 2016, which was a bad year;[34] and(d)$2,467.89 year ending 31 December 2017.[35][32] Mr Gutierrez’s first affidavit: [19].[33] Mr Gutierrez’s first affidavit: [20].[34] Mr Gutierrez’s first affidavit: [21].[35] Mr Gutierrez’s first affidavit: [22].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, there is a distinction between a redistribution of functions, duties and responsibilities of an employee that results in the termination of employment of that employee (a redundancy) and a redistribution of functions, duties and responsibilities of an employee after a termination of employment of that employee on independent grounds (a non-redundancy). There was a re-distribution of duties but it occurred after Mr Gutierrez had resigned[276] and after he had left.[277] The re-distribution thus occurred after Mr Gutierrez had ceased employment on independent grounds.[276] see Mr Smith’s Cross Examination (4 May 2021 (T153.17)).[277] see Mr Smith’s Cross Examination (4 May 2021 (T153.36; T153.41 – T153.42)).CONCLUSION Mr Gutierrez has succeeded in establishing that he was discriminated against in the course of his employment by reason of his age. He took offence at being treated less favourably than his intended replacement Ms Fernandez and being subjected to pressure, as he saw it, to retire. However, Mr Gutierrez chose to resign his employment when there was no need to do so. He could have continued in his employment, at least until the end of 2018 and probably until his intended retirement date at his 70th birthday. This presupposes that he would have rejected the proffered change to his employment contract. Unless MUR Shipping had taken steps to terminate Mr Gutierrez’s employment early, or make his position redundant, it would have been forced to follow its previous acceptance on his then current terms and conditions of his employment. It follows that Mr Gutierrez has not suffered any economic loss by reason of the conduct of MUR Shipping. He was, however, affronted and offended by the way he was treated and he should receive damages to compensate him for his hurt feelings. There is also some evidence of a mild adjustment disorder. In my view, an appropriate award of damages for non economic loss is $20,000 and an order for interest up to judgment. He should also receive an apology. This is in my mind a case where an apology is likely to be at least as valuable to Mr Gutierrez as the payment of damages. The application will be otherwise dismissed. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The parties also provided post hearing written submissions[31] which deal with the assessment of the evidence at trial as well as the pleadings which were amended during the course of the trial. CONSIDERATION[31] which apparently have not been filed.Mr Gutierrez’s contentions Mr Gutierrez had been a long serving faithful employee, working for MUR Shipping since 1993. He became entitled to receive bonuses from around 2004 and was paid bonuses of:(a)$7,739 for the year ending 31 December 2014;[32](b)$8,000 for the year ending 31 December 2015;[33](c)nothing for 2016, which was a bad year;[34] and(d)$2,467.89 year ending 31 December 2017.[35][32] Mr Gutierrez’s first affidavit: [19].[33] Mr Gutierrez’s first affidavit: [20].[34] Mr Gutierrez’s first affidavit: [21].[35] Mr Gutierrez’s first affidavit: [22]. Mr Gutierrez submits that he intended to work until he was at least 75 years of age and made it clear to MUR Shipping it was his intention to work as long as possible[36]. MUR Shipping never raised any performance issues with him prior to Mr Gutierrez making a complaint of age discrimination to the AHRC in August 2018.[37][36] Mr Gutierrez’s first affidavit: [23]-[24].[37] Complaint to the AHRC dated 27 August 2018 (Complaint), attached to Notice of Termination dated 18 September 2019 (NoT) and both attached to the Application filed in these proceedings. Mr Gutierrez’s first affidavit: [16]. Mr Gutierrez contends that, in around February 2018, Mr Brian Getty (the then Managing Director of MUR Shipping) told him the company had a retirement age of sixty-five and asked Mr Gutierrez to tell him when he would retire. Mr Gutierrez told him there was no mandatory retirement age in Australia (except in certain professions) and making people retire based on their age was unlawful. Mr Gutierrez told Mr Getty he would give Mr Getty three months’ notice of his retirement[38]. In early March 2018, Mr Getty told Mr Gutierrez a Ms Fernandes from MUR Shipping’s affiliated office in Dubai was “coming to visit Sydney”. [39] A short time later Mr Gutierrez was part of a conversation with Mr Getty, Mr Smith and Ms Fernandes in which he was asked to explain to her what he did without any further explanation.[40] Later in that same month of March 2018, he was told that Ms Fernandes would take over from him,[41] even though he had not given any firm date for his retirement. He was not asked for his view on whether she was an appropriate person to replace him and was not involved in any interview MUR Shipping may have conducted.[42] At this stage Mr Gutierrez told Mr Getty that he did not understand why they were looking to engage someone to replace him when he had not yet retired, at which time Mr Getty said, “I know you have a retirement unit in Manila” and Mr Gutierrez felt compelled to give a date, being July 2019.[43][38] Mr Gutierrez’s first affidavit: [25].[39] Mr Gutierrez’s first affidavit: [27].[40] Mr Gutierrez’s first affidavit: [28].[41] Mr Gutierrez’s first affidavit: [30].[42] Mr Gutierrez’s first affidavit: [29].[43] Mr Gutierrez’s first affidavit: [30].