Nationwide News Pty Ltd v Naidu

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Nationwide News Pty Ltd v Naidu & Anor;  ISS Security Pty Ltd v Naidu & Anor [2007]  NSWCA 377
This decision has been amended. Please see the end of the judgment for a list of the amendments.

FILE NUMBER(S):
40182/06
40198/06

HEARING DATE(S):               30 and 31 July 2007

JUDGMENT DATE: 21 December 2007

PARTIES:
CA 40182/06
Nationwide News Pty Ltd (Appellant)
Devanar Naidu (First Respondent)
ISS Security Pty Ltd (Second Respondent)
CA 40198/06
ISS Security Pty Ltd (Appellant)
Devandar Naidu (First Respondent)
Nationwide News Pty Ltd (Second Respondent)

JUDGMENT OF:       Spigelman CJ Beazley JA Basten JA    

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court - Common Law Division

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          SC 20188/01

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Adams J

LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION:    24 June 2005 and 15 March 2006

LOWER COURT MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:
Naidu v Group 4 Securitas Pty Ltd & Anor [2005] NSWSC 618;  Naidu v Group 4 Securitas Pty Ltd & Anor [2006] NSWSC 144
Naidu v Group 4 Securitas Pty Ltd & Anor [2005] NSWSC 618;  Naidu v Group 4 Securitas Pty Ltd & Anor [2006] NSWSC 144

COUNSEL:
C Bridge SC;  S Torrington (Nationwide News Pty Ltd)
G Little SC;  G Parker (ISS Security Pty Ltd)
D T Kennedy SC;  S E McCarthy (Devandar Naidu)

SOLICITORS:
Lander & Rogers (Nationwide News Pty Ltd)
Turks Legal (ISS Security Pty Ltd)
Albert A Macri Partners (Devandar Naidu)

CATCHWORDS:
CONTRACTS
General contractual principles
Construction and Interpretation of Contracts
Implied terms
Terms essential to enable performance
Employment contract
Whether trial judge erred in finding additional implied terms
DAMAGES
Measure and remoteness of damages in actions for tort
Mental and nervous shock
Failure to provide safe place of work
Whether double compensation for breach of contract and tort
DAMAGES
Exemplary damages
Focus upon conduct of wrongdoer
Whether trial judge erred in awarding exemplary damages
s 151M of Workers Compensation Act 1987 and Pt 33 r 8A of Supreme Court Rules 1970
whether trial judge erred in awarding interest
LIMITATION OF ACTIONS
Contracts, torts and personal actions
Personal injury cases
Workers Compensation Act 1987 s 151D
Whether trial judge erred in granting leave to bring proceedings
Fairness underlying principle as to whether to allow action
TORT
Negligence
Essentials of action for negligence
Where nervous shock or mental disorder
Common law
Reasonable foreseeability of damage
As between employer and employee
Workplace bullying and racial taunts
TORT
Negligence
Essentials of action for negligence
Duty of Care
Special relationships and duties
Employer and Employee
Where employee is subcontracted to workplace where bullying occurs
Third party’s duty to provide safe place and safe system of work
TORT
Negligence
Liability for other’s negligence
Contractors
Direct liability of employer for actions of site supervisor
TORT
Negligence
Apportionment of responsibility and damages
Liability of employer and contracting party
Whether trial judge erred in apportionment
TORT
Negligence
Vicarious liability
Sufficient connection with duties and responsibilities as employee
Site supervisor bullied and intimidated contractor under his control
Whether conduct in course…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nationwide News Pty Ltd v Naidu and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWCA 377
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved an appeal and cross-appeal concerning a judgment awarded to Mr. Naidu against Nationwide News Pty Ltd. Mr. Naidu, a security officer employed by ISS Security, alleged he suffered psychiatric injury as a result of mistreatment by a Nationwide News employee, Mr. Chaloner, while working at Nationwide News' premises. Nationwide News admitted Mr. Chaloner's conduct was "indefensible and outrageous" but denied vicarious liability. The appeal concerned the trial judge's findings regarding implied terms in Mr. Naidu's employment contract, the assessment of damages for breach of contract and tort, the award of exemplary damages, and the granting of leave to bring proceedings under the *Workers Compensation Act 1987*.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the trial judge erred in finding that Nationwide News breached implied terms of Mr. Naidu's employment contract by failing to provide a safe place of work, and whether this breach, along with a tortious duty of care, led to Mr. Naidu's psychiatric injury. The court also had to consider whether the trial judge correctly assessed damages, including whether there was an impermissible double recovery for the same injury under both contract and tort, and whether the award of exemplary damages was justified based on Nationwide News' conduct. Further issues included the proper application of the *Workers Compensation Act 1987* regarding the granting of leave to commence proceedings and the award of interest on the judgment sum.

The Court of Appeal, comprising Spigelman CJ, Beazley JA, and Basten JA, dismissed Nationwide News' appeal, finding no error in the trial judge's determination that Nationwide News was vicariously liable for Mr. Chaloner's conduct and that this conduct constituted a breach of implied terms of Mr. Naidu's employment contract, including the duty to provide a safe place of work. The court upheld the trial judge's assessment of damages, concluding that while there was overlap, the compensation awarded did not amount to impermissible double recovery. The court also found that the exemplary damages were appropriately awarded due to the egregious nature of the conduct and Nationwide News' response to it. The appeal by ISS Security Pty Ltd was allowed, and the cross-appeal by Nationwide News was dismissed. The court ordered Nationwide News to pay Mr. Naidu a significant sum, along with costs on an indemnity basis from a certain date, reflecting the severity of the findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

The orders are; (1) In matter No. CA 40182 of 2006 (appeal by Nationwide News Pty Ltd); (i) dismiss the appeal; (ii) dismiss the cross-appeal of ISS Security Pty Ltd; (iii) order the Appellant to pay the costs of the Respondents of the appeal; (2) In matter No. CA 40198 of 2006 (appeal by ISS Security Pty Ltd); (i) allow the appeal and set aside the orders of Adams J entered on 12 May 2006; (ii) in place thereof, make the following orders; (a) judgment for the plaintiff against the second defendant, Nationwide News Pty Ltd; (b) order the second defendant to pay the plaintiff $1,946,189.40, such judgment to have effect from 12 May 2006; (c) order the second defendant to pay the plaintiff's costs of the proceedings in the Common Law Division on an ordinary basis up to 26 March 2004 and thereafter on an indemnity basis; (d) order the plaintiff to pay the first defendant's costs of the proceedings in the Common Law Division; (3) Dismiss the cross-appeal of Nationwide News Pty Ltd; (4) Order the cross-appellant to pay the costs of the cross-respondents to the cross-appeal; (5) Order the Respondents to pay the Appellant's costs of the appeal; (6) Grant the First Respondent (Mr Naidu) a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 (NSW) in relation to the costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

To the extent that the issues raise common matters of fact or principle, they will be dealt with together, but I will otherwise deal with the grounds raised in the order set out above.Background facts The background facts in this matter, although lengthy, are substantially not in dispute. Accordingly, I will draw directly upon Adams J’s judgment for the purposes of explaining the facts insofar as they are relevant to the issues on the appeal: Naidu v Group 4 Securitas Pty Ltd & Anor [2005] NSWSC 618. Where necessary, I will also refer to additional material in the evidence. The factual background as reviewed below should be understood in the context that the trial judge accepted Mr Naidu’s evidence of the treatment he received at the hands of Mr Chaloner, but did not accept in totality the complaints he said he had made to his employer in respect of that conduct. It is convenient at this stage to record the statement made on behalf of Nationwide News during the course of final submissions, in respect of Mr Chaloner, who did not give evidence:“[Nationwide] News does not seek to defend or in any way excuse Mr Chaloner's conduct, which is indefensible and outrageous. The cornerstone of our [defence] is, once we found out about it, we immediately terminated him.” (Judgment [4]) Notwithstanding this admission, Nationwide News denied that it was vicariously liable for his conduct. Mr Naidu was a Fijian national who came to Australia in 1982. He married in Australia and has two children. He had a number of different jobs in Australia and then, after completing a security industry course, was employed by ISS Security as a security officer in March 1990. ISS Security had a contract with Nationwide News to provide 24 hour on-site security services at its premises at Surry Hills and Chullora. Mr Naidu, in the course of his employment with ISS Security, was required to perform security work at both sites, but mainly at Surry Hills. The security work essentially involved Mr Naidu checking the identity of persons entering the site, patrolling the building and generally ensuring the safety of Nationwide News’ personnel and premises. Mr Naidu received on-the-job training from more experienced security staff employed by ISS Security. In about September or October 1990, Mr Naidu was promoted to the position of senior security officer and then, about three months later, to the position of leading hand. He was further promoted to the position of supervisor of the site, a position which he held jointly with two other supervisors. Mr Naidu’s immediate supervisor at ISS Security was Mr Blinkworth. Mr Blinkworth was the liaison officer or manager for ISS Security and was responsible for the security provided to Nationwide News pursuant to the contractual arrangements between ISS Security and Nationwide News. Mr Blinkworth’s assistant, Mr Miles, also had a supervisory role in relation to Mr Naidu. However, Mr Naidu’s work was arranged in such a way that it was not necessary for Mr Naidu to attend ISS Security’s own premises and he in fact did not attend there until after the events with which these proceedings are concerned. Mr Blinkworth attended the Surry Hills premises monthly and was in weekly telephone contact (judgment [11]).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

SPIGELMAN CJ

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: SPIGELMAN CJ

Full text does not contain this section.