Permanent Trustee Australia Co Ltd v FAI General Insurance Co Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:     Permanent v FAI [2001]  NSWCA 20

FILE NUMBER(S):
40332/98

HEARING DATE(S):           29/01/01, 30/01/01, 31/01/01, 01/02/01, 02/02/01

JUDGMENT DATE:            12/03/2001

PARTIES:
Permanent Trustee Australia Company Limited & Anor
v
FAI General Insurance Company Limited

JUDGMENT OF:      Meagher JA Handley JA Powell JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court - Equity Division

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):        ED 3032/96, ED 3037/96

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Hodgson CJinEq

COUNSEL:
R J Ellicott QC/J C Campbell QC/J Svehla (Appellants)
C J Gee QC/G Inatey SC (Respondent)

SOLICITORS:
Church & Grace (Appellants)
Colin Biggers & Paisley (Respondent)

CATCHWORDS:
AGENCY - agent to effect contract - knowledge of principal relevant if contract made by principal - knowledge of agent relevant if contract made by agent - knowledge relevant however acquired
FRAUD - representation - representor intended one meaning - representee to knowledge of representor takes different meaning - different meaning false to knowledge of representor - representor fails to correct representee’s mistake - fraud established
INSURANCE - Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) - duty of disclosure - definition of knowledge - knowledge of agent to insure attributable to principal - negligent misrepresentation - misrepresentation by omission or silence - fraudulent misrepresentation and non-disclosure
KNOWLEDGE - whether belief equivalent to knowledge

LEGISLATION CITED:
Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth)
Marine Insurance Act 1909 (Cth)

DECISION:
Appeal dismissed with costs
Cross-appeal allowed in part with costs.

JUDGMENT:

THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

40332/98
ED 3032/96; ED 3037/96

MEAGHER JA

HANDLEY JA

POWELL JA

12 March 2001

PERMANENT TRUSTEE AUSTRALIA COMPANY LIMITED & ANOR
v

FAI GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED

AGENCY - agent to effect contract - knowledge of principal relevant if contract made by principal - knowledge of agent relevant if contract made by agent - knowledge relevant however acquired

FRAUD - representation - representor intended one meaning - representee to knowledge of representor takes different meaning - different meaning false to knowledge of representor - representor fails to correct representee’s mistake - fraud established

INSURANCE - Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) - duty of disclosure - definition of knowledge - knowledge of agent to insure attributable to principal - negligent misrepresentation - misrepresentation by omission or silence - fraudulent misrepresentation and non-disclosure

KNOWLEDGE - whether belief equivalent to knowledge

The respondent had provided professional indemnity cover for the appellants for the 1990/91 year.  The proceedings arose out of arrangements for the renewal of cover for a further twelve month period commencing 30 September 1991.  On 26 September the appellants’ broker arranged for the respondent to extend its expiring covers for 30 days.  During the extension the appellants became aware of possible claims for which they sought indemnity.  The appellants had earlier decided not to renew their covers with the respondent for the subsequent year but the broker did not inform the respondent.

Hodgson CJinEq upheld the respondent’s defences of misrepresentation and non-disclosure. His Honour held that the appellants’ broker should have disclosed their provisional decision not to offer…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Permanent Trustee Australia Co Ltd v FAI General Insurance C... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWCA 20
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Permanent Trustee Australia Co Ltd (the appellant) appealed from a decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales concerning an insurance policy issued by FAI General Insurance Co Ltd (the respondent). The dispute arose from the respondent's refusal to indemnify the appellant under the policy, alleging fraudulent misrepresentation and non-disclosure by the appellant's agent. The appeal concerned the extent to which an agent's knowledge is attributable to their principal in the context of insurance contracts and the definition of fraud in such circumstances.

The court was required to determine whether the knowledge of an agent, acquired during the course of their agency, was to be imputed to the principal for the purposes of assessing non-disclosure and misrepresentation under the *Insurance Contracts Act 1984* (Cth). Specifically, the court considered whether the agent's knowledge, even if not directly communicated to the principal, could render the policy voidable. Furthermore, the court had to consider the elements of fraudulent misrepresentation, particularly where a representor intends one meaning but is aware that the representee understands a different, false meaning, and fails to correct that misunderstanding.

The court applied established principles of agency and insurance law. It affirmed that the knowledge of an agent acting within the scope of their authority is generally attributable to their principal. This principle extends to the duty of disclosure in insurance contracts, meaning that material facts known to the agent, even if not personally known to the insured, can affect the validity of the policy. The court also considered the concept of fraud, noting that it can arise not only from an express false statement but also from a deliberate omission or silence when there is a duty to speak, particularly when the representor is aware of a misunderstanding by the other party that renders the situation false. The court distinguished between negligent misrepresentation and fraudulent misrepresentation, emphasizing the element of intent in the latter.

The appeal was dismissed with costs, meaning the original decision of the Supreme Court was upheld in relation to the appeal. However, a cross-appeal by FAI General Insurance Co Ltd was allowed in part, also with costs, indicating that some aspects of their counter-arguments or claims were successful.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs

Cross-appeal allowed in part with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Lord Watson said at 539-40:“It is, in my opinion, a condition precedent of every contract of marine insurance that the insured shall make a full disclosure of all facts materially affecting the risk which are within his personal knowledge at the time when the contract is made. Where an insurance is effected through the medium of an agent, the ordinary rule of law applies, and non-disclosure of material facts, known to the agent only, will affect his principal, and give the insurer good ground for avoiding the contract … In the present case it is sought to extend the imputed knowledge of the insured to all facts which during the period of his employment became known to any agent, other than the agent effecting the policy in question, who was employed at any time, successfully or unsuccessfully, to insure the whole or part of the same risk with that covered by the policy”. (emphasis supplied) Lord Fitzgerald adopted the reasons of Lord Halsbury and Lord Watson. In the following year Blackburn Low & Co v Haslam (1888) 21 QBD 144 (Haslam) brought before the Divisional Court an action on another policy taken out about the same time by the same insured on the same ship. The negotiations with this underwriter were initiated through a different agent in Glasgow but completed by the principals through agents in London. The underwriter relied on the non-disclosure of information received in confidence by the Glasgow agent from an outside source (145). This was the same information that the House of Lords held in Vigors did not affect the validity of the policy then in suit which had not been arranged through that agent. Pollock B, who delivered the judgment of the Court, said at 149-150:“Starting with the telegram of May 1 … there can be no doubt that when that was sent Messrs Rose, Murison and Thomson [of Glasgow] were agents for Messrs Blackburn Low & Co, to effect the insurance proposed thereby, and that any knowledge by them of facts material to the risk would be equivalent to a knowledge by their principals … it is clear that up to the time when Messrs Rose, Murison and Thomson received the last telegram addressed to themselves they were the agents of the plaintiffs to effect … the particular re-insurance … and that any knowledge possessed by them which was material to the risk would be equivalent to a knowledge by the plaintiffs themselves”. (emphasis supplied) The Divisional Court understood that the responsibility of a principal for non-disclosure by an agent to insure was based on the knowledge of the agent being treated as the knowledge of the principal and not on the breach of a personal duty owed by the agent to the underwriter. This was the state of the common law when the Marine Insurance Act 1906 was passed. In El Ajou v Dollar Holdings plc [1994] 2 All ER 685, which did not concern insurance at all, Hoffmann LJ discussed the circumstances in which the knowledge of an agent was relevant to a contract made with his principal. The first category concerned cases such as those involving the vitiating effect of non-disclosure of material facts known only to the agent. His Lordship referred to the speech of Lord Macnaghten in Vigors and said that such cases, and the case of Dresser v Norwood, referred to hereafter, did not depend on imputation of knowledge to the principal but were cases where “the agents’ knowledge affects the terms or performance of the contract which he concludes on behalf of his principal” (702).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established