Gutierrez v Mur Shipping Australia Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Gutierrez v MUR Shipping Australia Pty Limited [2023] FCA 399

Appeal from: Gutierrez v MUR Shipping Australia Pty Limited [2021] FedCFamC2G 56
File number(s): NSD 1366 of 2021
Judgment of: BURLEY J
Date of judgment: 4 May 2023
Catchwords:

HUMAN RIGHTS – discrimination – age discrimination in employment – appeal from Federal Circuit Court and Family Court – where appellant was treated less favourably in his employment because of his age in relation to continuing in his role or retiring – assessment of general damages and damages for economic loss challenged on appeal – appeal allowed

DAMAGES – assessment of general damages – whether award of damages inadequate – whether trial judge’s assessment of award of general damages contained errors of fact and law – where error in trial judge’s assessment of damages and characterisation of evidence of harm – reassessment of trial judge’s award of general damages

DAMAGES – assessment of damages for economic loss – where trial judge concluded damages for economic loss not available because appellant had elected to terminate his employment – where evidence indicated appellant unable to work as a result of discrimination – damages for economic loss awarded  

Legislation:

Age Discrimination Act 2004 (Cth) ss 14, 15, 18

Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) s 46PO

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 119

Cases cited:

Amaca Pty Ltd v King [2011] VSCA 447; 35 VR 280

Branir Pty Ltd v Owston Nominees (No 2) Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 1833; 117 FCR 424

Clarke v Nationwide News Pty Ltd [2012] FCA 307; 201 FCR 389

Fox v Percy [2003] HCA 22; 214 CLR 118

Gutierrez v MUR Shipping Australia Pty Limited [2021] FedCFamC2G 56

House v The King [1936] HCA 40; 55 CLR 499

Hughes trading as Beesley and Hughes Lawyers v Hill [2020] FCAFC 126; 277 FCR 511

Hull v Thompson [2001] NSWCA 359

Knight v Beyond Properties Pty Ltd [2007] FCAFC 170; 242 ALR 586

Koehler v Cerebos (Australia) Ltd [2005] HCA 15; 222 CLR 44

Kozarov v Victoria [2022] HCA 12; 273 CLR 115

Lloyd v Thornbury [2019] NSWCA 154

Nationwide News Pty Ltd vNaidu [2007] NSWCA 377; 71 NSWLR 471

O’Brien v Dunsdon (1965) 39 ALJR 78

Precision Plastics Pty Ltd v Demir [1975] HCA 27; 132 CLR 362

Qantas Airways Ltd v Gama [2008] FCAFC 69; 167 FCR 537

Reurich v Club Jervis Bay Ltd [2018] FCA 1220

Richardson v Oracle Corporation Australia Pty Limited [2014] FCAFC 82; 223 FCR 334

Soulemezis v Dudley (Holdings) Pty Ltd (1987) 10 NSWLR 247

Swan v Monash Law Book Co-operative [2013] VSC 326; 235 IR 63

Taupau v HVAC Constructions (Queensland) Pty Ltd & Ors [2012] NSWCA 293

Walker v Citigroup Global Markets Pty Ltd [2006] FCAFC 101; 233 ALR 687

Willett v Victoria [2013] VSCA 76; 42 VR 571

Division: Fair Work Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area:
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gutierrez v Mur Shipping Australia Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 399
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal heard an appeal from the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia in the case of Gutierrez v Mur Shipping Australia Pty Limited. The appellant, Mr Gutierrez, was an employee of the respondent, Mur Shipping Australia Pty Limited, who claimed that he was subjected to age discrimination in his employment, leading to his dismissal. The primary judge had found in favour of Mr Gutierrez and awarded him $20,000 in general damages and no damages for economic loss. The respondent appealed against the decision, arguing that the award of damages was inadequate and that the trial judge had erred in law and fact in assessing the damages. The appeal focused on the assessment of general damages and damages for economic loss, with the respondent arguing that the primary judge had mischaracterised the evidence of harm and that the award of damages was not justified.

The Court of Appeal found that the appeal should be allowed and that Mr Gutierrez was entitled to an award of $90,000 for general damages and an amount for economic loss. The Court found that the primary judge had erred in his assessment of the award of general damages, as he had mischaracterised the evidence of harm and had not considered the full extent of the impact of the discrimination on Mr Gutierrez. The Court also found that the primary judge had erred in his assessment of damages for economic loss, as he had concluded that damages were not available because Mr Gutierrez had elected to terminate his employment. However, the evidence showed that Mr Gutierrez was unable to work as a result of the discrimination, and therefore damages for economic loss were available.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and set aside the order for general damages, ordering that Mr Gutierrez be paid $90,000 in general damages. The Court also directed the parties to provide short further submissions addressing the quantum of damages for economic loss. The Court found that the provisional view was that the amount claimed by Mr Gutierrez should be awarded, but some adjustment may be necessary. The respondent was ordered to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal. The Court noted that any party wishing to be heard in relation to the submissions in relation to the assessment of damages for economic loss was to notify the associate to Justice Burley by the time identified in the judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The order made by Judge Driver on 1 December 2021 that “Pursuant to s 46PO(4)(d) the respondent shall pay to the applicant general damages of $20,000” be set aside and in lieu thereof order: “Pursuant to s 46PO(4)(d) the respondent shall pay to the applicant general damages of $90,000.”

3. The respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.

4. Within 14 days of these orders, the appellant file and serve any written submissions of no more than 4 pages on the issue of the assessment of damages for economic loss addressing bases (3)-(5) as identified in the judgment at [103] (and which were raised in the proceedings at first instance by the respondent in opposition to the appellant’s calculation).

5. The respondent file and serve any submissions in answer of no more than 4 pages within a further 14 days.

6. The appellant file any submission in reply of no more than 2 pages within 7 days thereafter.

7. Any party wishing to be heard in relation to the submissions in orders 4-6 is to notify the associate to Justice Burley by the time identified in order 6, failing which the question will be determined on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the reasons set out below, I find that the appeal must be allowed with costs. I find that Mr Gutierrez is entitled to an award of $90,000 for general damages and is entitled to an amount for economic loss. I will make directions for the parties to provide short further submissions addressing the quantum of that economic loss. My provisional view is that it should be in the amount claimed by Mr Gutierrez, but some adjustment may be necessary. 2. THE DECISION BELOW The primary judge records that Mr Gutierrez was born on 5 September 1949 and commenced employment with a predecessor of the business of MUR on 15 June 2003. He signed a contract of employment with MUR, then known as SSM Australia Pty Limited, on 13 February 2004 after having commenced employment with MUR on 1 August 2003. His position was as Chief Accountant.2.1 The primary judge’s summary of the submissions In summarising the contentions advanced by Mr Gutierrez ([35]-[42]), the primary judge noted his evidence and submissions that:(1)In around February 2018 the then Managing Director of MUR, Brian Getty, told him that the company had a retirement age of 65 and asked Mr Gutierrez to tell him when he would retire. He responded by saying that there was no mandatory retirement age in Australia and making him retire based on age was unlawful. Mr Gutierrez told him that he would give Mr Getty three months’ notice of his retirement.(2)In early March 2018, Mr Getty told Mr Gutierrez that Dorin Fernandes from MUR’s affiliated office in Dubai was coming to visit, and shortly thereafter he participated in a conversation with Mr Getty, Mr Smith and Ms Fernandes in which he was asked to explain to her what he did. (3)Later in March 2018 Mr Gutierrez was informed that Ms Fernandes would take over from him, even though he had not given any firm date for his retirement. He told Mr Getty that he did not understand why MUR was looking to engage someone to replace him when he had not yet retired, to which Mr Getty replied “I know you have a retirement unit in Manila”. (4)Mr Gutierrez then felt compelled to give a retirement date, which he gave as July 2019.(5)In April 2018 Mr Gutierrez was informed that Ms Fernandes was to start work that month. (6)In May or June 2018 Mr Gutierrez obtained leave to take paid time off to update his skills. He told Mr Smith, who replaced Mr Getty as Managing Director in July 2018, that he was educating himself further so that he could continue working after MUR “kicked him out”. (7)On 19 July 2018 Mr Gutierrez was informed by Mr Smith that his contract of employment would come to an end on 31 December 2018 and that he would be on a new contract to train Ms Fernandes from 1 January 2019. Mr Gutierrez informed Mr Smith that what he was doing was illegal and left the meeting in distress (the employment discussion).(8)On 24 July 2018 Mr Gutierrez sent an email to Mr Smith in the following terms:From: Alex GutierrezSent: Tuesday, 24 July 2018 10:52 AMTo: Jason Smith [redacted]Subject: notice of terminationI am still waiting for your written confirmation that I requested after our meeting at your office last Thursday, July 19th at 8.45 am. In that meeting you told me of the following:1. The board of directors had a meeting on Wednesday, July 18th at the Sydney office.2. Wanda Langenfeld Harris informed the board that beside myself, Mur has no employees over the age of 65.3. The Board has decided to terminate my employment as Chief Accountant at December 31, 2018.4. I will be on contract from January 1, 2019 whereby I will train and turnover my duties to Dorin Fernandes.When asked if there was a redundancy money involved, you answered in the negative as the position of Chief Accountant is not being made redundant because Dorin Fernandes is taking over.(9)Mr Gutierrez contended that at no time after sending this email did MUR respond to inform him that he was incorrect to consider: that his employment was scheduled to end on 31 December 2018; that thereafter he would be on a fixed term contract as a contractor rather than an employee; that MUR considered that he should retire because he was 65; or that he was being offered a contract in order to train Ms Fernandes to take over his position. Mr Smith’s response to the email was that he would “take it up with the board”. (10)In advising Mr Gutierrez that it would bring his contract of employment to an end in December 2018, MUR repudiated the contract. (11)On 1 August 2018 Mr Gutierrez’s solicitors sent a letter to MUR informing it that its action in advising Mr Gutierrez that it would bring his ongoing employment to an end in December 2018 was a clear repudiation of his employment that Mr Gutierrez accepted, thereby bringing his employment to an end. (12)From the date of the discussion on 19 July 2018, Mr Gutierrez’s health deteriorated rapidly and he was told to take some time off given the stress reaction that the discussion had caused. (13)If MUR had responded at any point after 19 July 2018 to bring Mr Gutierrez back into the fold, these proceedings would likely not have been commenced.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In relation to (c), Mr Gutierrez relies on his submissions before the primary judge as to the error of law. MUR contends that whilst the primary judge referred to some principles of contract law relating to damages when considering and assessing compensation for economic loss at [155(b)], he did not apply those principles when considering general damages. 4.2 Consideration 4.2.1Introduction It is convenient first to address an issue arising from the way that Mr Gutierrez in his submissions incorrectly characterises the reasoning of the primary judge in relation to liability before turning to ground 2.4.2.2The primary judge’s liability finding In [149] of his reasons the primary judge found that two types of proscribed action had been established by Mr Gutierrez, the first in relation to s 18(2)(a) of the AD Act because MUR raised with him the prospect that his terms of employment were prospectively to be changed to his detriment by terminating his ongoing contract of employment and placing him on a fixed contract until his chosen retirement date, and the second in relation to s 18(2)(d) because Mr Gutierrez was disrespected in his employment because his own word as to his retirement was not respected, but rather a fixed term was to be imposed. He was further demeaned by having to train his replacement, Ms Fernandes. Contrary to the submissions advanced by Mr Gutierrez, I do not consider that the primary judge found at [162] that the discrimination commenced with the Retirement Discussions, the Offer, and carried on from then to the Retraining and then the Termination. It is the case, however, that the primary judge’s finding at [162] as to the cause of the “mild adjustment disorder” is perplexing and requires close consideration. That paragraph states first that the cause of the adjustment disorder was the employment discussion on 19 July 2018 because of the conduct of MUR in proposing a future change to Mr Gutierrez’s terms of employment and a future change to the nature of his duties. This indicates a view that the age discrimination conduct itself was short-lived, because the primary judge found that Mr Gutierrez elected to resign from his employment on 1 August 2018 having erroneously concluded that MUR had on that day repudiated his contract of employment. However, in the final sentence of [162] the primary judge states that the cause of the adjustment disorder was the Retirement Discussions (in February and March 2018), the making of the Offer (in March 2018) and the direction of Redeployment (in April 2018), thereby suggesting ongoing age discrimination over a longer period. The final sentence is internally inconsistent with the rest of the paragraph. It is also inconsistent with the primary judge’s earlier reasoning where he rejects Mr Gutierrez’s claims that he had been placed under pressure to retire (at [122]), finds that Mr Gutierrez had not been informed of the Offer, or indeed that any such Offer was made (at [123]-[134]), and in effect finds that Mr Gutierrez had not been directed to train Ms Fernandes at least prior to April 2018 (at [135]-[137], see also [39], [90]). Furthermore, it is inconsistent with the primary judge’s finding at [149] of the two types of proscribed action established, which are referable to the 19 July 2018 employment discussion and not the earlier conduct or conversations.