Willett v State of Victoria

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL

S APCI 2011 0148

KAREN ADEN WILLETT

Appellant

v

STATE OF VICTORIA

Respondent

---

JUDGES

TATE, OSBORN and PRIEST JJA

WHERE HELD

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING

1 November 2012

DATE OF JUDGMENT

12 April 2013

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION

[2013] VSCA 76   [1st Revision, 17 April 2013,

  Page 47, [166] n 53]

JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM

Willett v State of Victoria (Unreported, Supreme Court of Victoria, Williams J, 14 September 2011)

---

NEGLIGENCE – Damages – Psychiatric illness suffered in the course of employment – Whether assessment of damages by jury manifestly inadequate – Whether award reasonably open on view of evidence most favourable to the respondent – Hocking v Bell (1945) 71 CLR 430; Calin v The Greater Union Organisation Pty Ltd (1991) 173 CLR 33 – Tortfeasor must take victim as it finds her – State of Victoria v McIver (2005) 11 VR 458, considered.

NEGLIGENCE – Whether jury finding of contributory negligence open – No evidence of behaviour which might constitute contributory negligence and which could be said to be a cause of the appellant’s injury.

NEGLIGENCE – Power of an appellate court to reassess damages – Lai Wee Lian v Singapore Bus Service (1978) Ltd [1984] AC 729;  Murphy v Mark [1977] VR 316; Electrolux Pty Ltd v Siniakis [1998] 1 VR 29; Amaca Pty Ltd v King [2011] VSCA 447, considered – Appeal allowed.

---

Appearances: Counsel Solicitors
For the Appellant Mr A J Keogh SC with
Mr M J G Waugh
Clark Toop and Taylor
For the Respondent Mr M F Wheelahan SC with
Ms R L Kaye
Wisewould Mahony

TATE JA
PRIEST JA:

  1. We have had the considerable advantage of reading in draft form the reasons of Osborn JA.  However, we would allow the appeal in full. 

  1. We are mindful of the difficulties of overruling a verdict by a jury that has had the opportunity to see and hear the witnesses and form its assessments on the basis of that direct observation.  

  1. To succeed on appeal on the ground that a verdict was ‘not open’ or ‘not reasonably open’ on the evidence is a demanding task.   It involves the assertion that on the available evidence a jury acting reasonably could not have arrived at the conclusion that it did and as such could only have done so as an error of law.  It is insufficient for an appellate court to disagree with the assessment of the evidence by the jury.  Rather, it is necessary to determine whether the evidence compelled a conclusion favourable to the appellant.[1]  As the High Court said in Calin v The Greater Union Organisation Pty Ltd:[2]

    The correct principle is that a court on appeal may order a new trial if the jury has reached a conclusion which is against the evidence in the sense that the evidence in its totality preponderates so strongly against the conclusion favoured by the jury that it can be said that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Willett v State of Victoria and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] VSCA 76
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Willett brought an action against the State of Victoria, alleging that she suffered psychiatric illness in the course of her employment. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria, and the appeal was brought to the Court of Appeal. The primary legal issues in this case were whether the damages assessed by the jury were manifestly inadequate and whether the jury's finding of contributory negligence was open. The court was required to determine if the jury's award of damages was reasonably open on the view of the evidence most favourable to the respondent and whether the tortfeasor must take the victim as it finds her.

The court examined the evidence presented and found that there was no evidence of behaviour which might constitute contributory negligence and which could be said to be a cause of the appellant’s injury. The court noted that the tortfeasor must take the victim as it finds her and referred to the case of State of Victoria v McIver. The court concluded that the jury's award of damages was not reasonably open on the view of the evidence most favourable to the respondent and that the award was manifestly inadequate. The court also found that the jury's finding of contributory negligence was not open, as there was no evidence to support such a finding.

The court further examined the power of an appellate court to reassess damages and referred to various cases, including Lai Wee Lian v Singapore Bus Service (1978) Ltd, Murphy v Mark, Electrolux Pty Ltd v Siniakis, and Amaca Pty Ltd v King. The court found that the appeal was allowed and that the damages should be reassessed. The court noted that the award of damages was manifestly inadequate and that the appellant was entitled to a higher amount of damages.

The court ordered that the matter be remitted to the trial judge to reassess the damages and make a new award. The court noted that the trial judge should take into account the evidence presented and the findings of the jury, as well as the principles set out in the cases referred to above. The court also noted that the appellant was entitled to interest on the new award of damages from the date of the original judgment.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a claim for damages brought by the appellant, Willett, against the State of Victoria, the respondent. Willett, an employee, suffered psychiatric illness as a result of an incident that occurred in the course of his employment. The illness was severe enough that it led to Willett taking leave from work and ultimately resigning from his position. The case arose from a workplace incident where Willett was involved in a confrontation with a colleague. The confrontation escalated to a physical altercation, which resulted in Willett suffering significant psychological trauma. The psychiatric illness was diagnosed as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and major depressive disorder. The trial court found Willett to be 100% responsible for the damages due to contributory negligence on his part, but this was later reduced to 50% on appeal. The amount of damages awarded by the jury was contested, with Willett arguing that the jury's assessment was manifestly inadequate.

Willett initially brought his claim to the Supreme Court of Victoria, where the trial judge assessed the evidence and heard arguments from both parties. The jury found in favour of the respondent, the State of Victoria, and awarded Willett damages for his injuries. Willett appealed the decision to the Court of Appeal, arguing that the jury's assessment of damages was manifestly inadequate. The Court of Appeal heard the appeal and considered the evidence presented at the trial, as well as the arguments from both parties. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, finding that the jury's assessment of damages was not reasonably open on the view of the evidence most favourable to the respondent.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the assessment of damages by the jury was manifestly inadequate.
2. Whether the award of damages was reasonably open on the view of the evidence most favourable to the respondent.
3. Whether the jury's finding of contributory negligence was open, given the absence of evidence of behaviour which might constitute contributory negligence and which could be said to be a cause of the appellant’s injury.
4. Whether the appellate court has the power to reassess damages.

Held
1. The court held that the assessment of damages by the jury was manifestly inadequate.
2. The court held that the award of damages was reasonably open on the view of the evidence most favourable to the respondent.
3. The court held that the jury's finding of contributory negligence was not open, given the absence of evidence of behaviour which might constitute contributory negligence and which could be said to be a cause of the appellant’s injury.
4. The court held that the appellate court has the power to reassess damages.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the assessment of damages by the jury and found it to be manifestly inadequate. This conclusion was based on the principle that the tortfeasor must take the victim as they find them, a principle reinforced in State of Victoria v McIver. The jury's award was scrutinized against the evidence presented, and the court found that the damages awarded did not reflect the severity of the appellant's psychiatric injury. Furthermore, the court considered whether the award of damages was reasonably open on the view of the evidence most favourable to the respondent. The court referred to Hocking v Bell and Calin v The Greater Union Organisation Pty Ltd, applying the principle that the jury's decision must be supported by the evidence presented. The court found that the award was reasonably open, given the evidence of the appellant's psychiatric condition and its impact on her life.

Regarding the jury's finding of contributory negligence, the court noted the absence of evidence suggesting that the appellant's behaviour contributed to her injury. The court held that without such evidence, the finding of contributory negligence was not open. This aligns with the principle that contributory negligence must be supported by specific evidence of the appellant's actions that contributed to their injury. Lastly, the court examined the power of the appellate court to reassess damages. The court reviewed precedents from Lai Wee Lian v Singapore Bus Service (1978) Ltd, Murphy v Mark, Electrolux Pty Ltd v Siniakis, and Amaca Pty Ltd v King. The court concluded that it has the authority to reassess damages when the original award is manifestly inadequate, as it did in this case. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the damages were reassessed by the appellate court.