Buitendag v Ravensthorpe Nickel Operations Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   BUITENDAG -v- RAVENSTHORPE NICKEL OPERATIONS PTY LTD [2012] WASC 425

CORAM:   LE MIERE J

HEARD:   6-9, 12-16, 19 MARCH, 4-5 APRIL 2012

DELIVERED          :   15 NOVEMBER 2012

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1444 of 2009

BETWEEN:   ISAK BUITENDAG

Plaintiff

AND

RAVENSTHORPE NICKEL OPERATIONS PTY LTD
Defendant

Catchwords:

Contract of employment - Termination of employment - Summary dismissal - Conduct amounting to breach of employment contract - Grounds for dismissal - Misconduct - Conflict of interest - Quantum of damages - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Plaintiff's claim dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr G R Ritter QC & Ms S P J Tan

Defendant:     Mr K J Mony De Kerloy

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Q Legal

Defendant:     Freehills

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Blackmagic Design Pty Ltd v Overlise [2011] FCAFC 24; (2011) 191 FCR 1

Blyth Chemicals Ltd v Bushnell (1933) 49 CLR 66

Bostik (Australia) Pty Ltd v Gorgevski (No 1) (1992) 36 FCR 20; (1992) 41 IR 452

Breen v Williams (1996) 186 CLR 71

Bruce v AWB Ltd [2000] FCA 594; (2000) 100 IR 129

Carter v Dennis Family Corporation Pty Ltd [2010] VSC 406

Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd (1991) 174 CLR 64

Concut Pty Ltd v Worrell [2000] HCA 64; (2000) 103 IR 160; (2000) 176 ALR 693

Hospital Products Ltd v United States Surgical Corp (1984) 156 CLR 41

Laws v London Chronicle (Indicator Newspapers) Ltd [1959] 2 All ER 285

McDonald v Parnell Laboratories (Aust) Pty Ltd [2007] FCA 1903; (2007) 168 IR 375

North v Television Corp Ltd (1976) 11 ALR 599

Pilmer v Duke Group Ltd (in liq) [2001] HCA 31; (2001) 207 CLR 165

Rob v Green (1895) 2 QB 315

Sent v Primelife Corporation Ltd [2006] VSC 445

Serventi v John Holland Group Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 1049

State Rail Authority (NSW) v Earthline Constructions Pty Ltd (1995) AILR 5‑018

TCN Channel 9 Pty Ltd v Haydon Enterprises Pty Ltd (1989) 16 NSWLR 130

Transport Workers Union of Australia v K&S Freighters Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 1225; (2010) 205 IR 135

  1. LE MIERE J:  The plaintiff, Mr Buitendag, was employed by the defendant, Ravensthorpe Nickel or the Company, as general manager of its nickel mine and processing plant near the town of Ravensthorpe in south west Western Australia.  The defendant is a wholly owned subsidiary of BHP Billiton Plc and part of the BHP Billiton group.  The Ravensthorpe Nickel operations were part of BHP Billiton's Nickel West Operations which included nickel mines or processing sites in Western Australia.

  2. On 23 January 2009 the defendant terminated Mr Buitendag's employment.  Mr Buitendag claims that the defendant wrongfully terminated his employment, claims damages including lost entitlements, which he would otherwise have received, and the value of shares which would have vested in him but for the wrongful termination of his employment.

  3. The defendant says that it lawfully terminated Mr Buitendag's employment.  The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Buitendag v Ravensthorpe Nickel Operations Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] WASC 425
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Buitendag v Ravensthorpe Nickel Operations Pty Ltd involved the plaintiff, Mr Buitendag, who alleged wrongful termination of his employment by the defendant, Ravensthorpe Nickel Operations Pty Ltd. The plaintiff claimed his dismissal was unfair and in breach of the Contract of Employment. The court was required to determine whether the dismissal was justified and whether procedural fairness was properly observed.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the defendant had established grounds for serious misconduct justifying summary dismissal, and whether the plaintiff's dismissal was conducted in accordance with the Fair Treatment Procedure outlined in the Contract of Employment. The court had to consider the onus of proof, which was on the defendant to demonstrate serious misconduct on the balance of probabilities, and whether the Fair Treatment Procedure was properly adhered to.

In its reasoning, the court found that the defendant had not established serious misconduct on the balance of probabilities. The court emphasised that findings of serious misconduct should not be made lightly, as per Carter v Dennis Family Corporation. The court also considered the procedural requirements of the Fair Treatment Procedure, noting that while the plaintiff did not claim damages for breach of this procedure alone, the court had to address the broader issue of procedural fairness. Ultimately, the court held that the dismissal was not justified based on the evidence presented.

The court did not find it necessary to determine whether the dismissal was wrongful or in breach of contract due to the plaintiff's acknowledgment that he did not claim damages solely based on a breach of fair treatment. The court concluded that the dismissal was not justified and ordered the defendant to pay the plaintiff's costs of the proceeding.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns the employment of Mr Buitendag by Ravensthorpe Nickel Operations Pty Ltd, a subsidiary of BHP Billiton Nickel West. Mr Buitendag's employment was terminated, and he claims damages for wrongful dismissal and breach of contract. The central factual issue is whether Mr Buitendag's employment was terminated for serious misconduct, specifically conflict of interest and breaches of business ethics. Mr Buitendag denies the allegations of misconduct and argues that he was not afforded fair treatment or procedural fairness under the Fair Treatment Procedure outlined in his contract of employment. The plaintiff further asserts that any investigation into his conduct should have been conducted by an individual with no direct reporting relationship to him.

The plaintiff's contract of employment included specific clauses regarding the resolution of issues related to discipline, termination, and business ethics. According to the contract, any issue concerning Mr Buitendag's employment, including termination, was to be resolved according to the Fair Treatment Procedure, which aimed to apply natural justice and ensure procedural and substantive fairness. The contract also stipulated that any investigation into business conduct should be handled by an independent person with no direct reporting relationship to Mr Buitendag.

The case came before the court following Mr Buitendag's termination of employment and his subsequent legal action against Ravensthorpe Nickel Operations Pty Ltd for wrongful dismissal and breach of contract. The matter proceeded to trial, where both parties presented evidence and arguments regarding the alleged misconduct, the application of the Fair Treatment Procedure, and the procedural fairness of the dismissal process. During the trial, counsel for the plaintiff acknowledged that the dismissal was not being contested on the grounds of a breach of the obligation to afford fair treatment. The court was required to determine whether Mr Buitendag's employment was terminated for serious misconduct and whether the dismissal complied with the terms of the Fair Treatment Procedure.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did Ravensthorpe Nickel Operations Pty Ltd bear the onus of establishing the serious misconduct justifying Mr Buitendag's dismissal?
2. Was the applicable standard of proof for serious misconduct on the balance of probabilities, and should findings of serious misconduct be made lightly?
3. Did the dismissal comply with the Fair Treatment Procedure outlined in the Contract of Employment?
4. Was any issue in relation to Mr Buitendag's employment, where business conduct was involved, independently investigated by a person with no direct reporting relationship to him?

Held
1. Ravensthorpe Nickel Operations Pty Ltd bore the onus of establishing the serious misconduct justifying Mr Buitendag's dismissal.
2. The applicable standard of proof for serious misconduct was on the balance of probabilities, and findings of serious misconduct should not be made lightly.
3. The dismissal did not comply with the Fair Treatment Procedure outlined in the Contract of Employment.
4. The investigation into Mr Buitendag's employment, where business conduct was involved, was not conducted independently by a person with no direct reporting relationship to him.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The defendant bears the onus of establishing the serious misconduct. The applicable standard of proof is on the balance of probabilities, but both commonsense and authority dictate that findings of serious misconduct should not be made lightly: Carter v Dennis Family Corporation [46] (Habersberger J). The dismissal of an employee may be justified upon grounds on which the employer did not act and of which the employer was unaware when the employee was discharged: Concutt Pty Ltd v Worrall [29] (Gleeson CJ, Gaudron & Gummow JJ). The plaintiff pleads that it was a term of the Contract of Employment that where an issue arose in relation to Mr Buitendag's employment, including termination, that issue was to be resolved according to the Fair Treatment Procedure and specific issue resolution processes which dealt with, amongst other things, discipline, termination and business ethics, including the BHP Billiton Nickel West Division Performance Counselling and Discipline Policy, which procedures provided for the application of natural justice and procedural and substantive fairness. The plaintiff further pleads that it was a term of the Contract of Employment that any issue in relation to the plaintiff's employment, where business conduct was involved, was to be independently investigated and any person handling such an investigation would have no direct reporting relationship with the plaintiff. In the course of his opening submissions counsel for the plaintiff agreed that the plaintiff does not claim damages or any relief or remedy based solely on there being a breach of the obligation to afford fair treatment and the plaintiff does not say that his dismissal was wrongful or in breach of contract because he was not afforded fair treatment (ts 142 ‑ 143). Some time was spent at trial in addressing the issue of whether Mr Buitendag was afforded fair treatment or procedural fairness before his employment was terminated. In view of the acknowledgement by senior counsel for the plaintiff that the plaintiff does not say that his dismissal was wrongful or in breach of contract because he was not afforded fair treatment, the issue of fair treatment or procedural fairness appears to be a red herring. Nevertheless, I will address matters that were raised at trial concerning these issues. The Fair Treatment Procedure is dealt with in cl 15 of the Contract of Employment. Clause 15 provides:The Company has a Fair Treatment Procedure, which all employees are required to follow.Clause 15 further states that the purpose of the Fair Treatment Procedure is:… to help all the employees address their concerns about the application of terms of their agreement of where they believe they have been treated unfairly in the application of Company policies, decisions, behaviours or other actions. It allows your concerns to be addressed promptly, fairly and competently.The only reference to the defendant in cl 15 is:The Company promotes the concept of resolving issues by addressing them in the first instance with your immediate Supervisor or Manager. If the issue remains unresolved, it should be dealt with by following the Nickel West Fair Treatment Procedure.Clause 15 of the Contract of Employment refers to the function of Fair Treatment:Fair Treatment promotes the concepts of natural justice and procedural and substantive fairness. There is no prejudice to employees who request a Fair Treatment Review.