Pruessner v Caelli Constructions Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Pruessner v Caelli Constructions Pty Ltd [2022] FedCFamC2G 206

File number(s): MLG 4184 of 2020
Judgment of: JUDGE MCNAB
Date of judgment: 25 March 2022 
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – FAIR WORK – question of whether the applicant was an employee or independent contractor engaged through a third party – terms of oral contract – subsequent conduct – applicant not an employee – claims for superannuation and long service leave – application dismissed.  
Legislation:

Construction Industry Long Service Leave Act 1997 (Vic) ss 5, 6(1), 12.

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 13.

Superannuation Guarantee (Administration) Act 1992 (Cth) s 12(3).

Cases cited:

Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 1

Oze–Igehion v Uber Technology Inc [2017] FCA 1024

Regreen Asset Holdings Pty Ltd v Castricum Brothers Australia Pty Ltd [2015] VSCA 286

ZG Operations Australia Pty Ltd v Jamsek [2022] HCA 2

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 70
Date of last submission/s: 19 November 2021
Date of hearing: 16-19 November 2021 
Place: Melbourne
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Howard
Solicitor for the Applicant: Holding Redlich
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr Fetter
Solicitor for the Respondent: Davies Lawyers Pty Ltd

ORDERS

MLG 4184 of 2020

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

MR PETER PRUESSNER

Applicant

AND:

CAELLI CONSTRUCTIONS (VIC) PTY LTD

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE MCNAB

DATE OF ORDER:

25 MARCH 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application filed 3 December 2020 be dismissed.

2.Any application for costs by the Respondent be made within 7 days of these orders supported by written submissions with the Applicant to file written submissions in response within 14 days.

3.The question of costs be determined on the papers in chambers.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Judge McNab

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant Mr Peter Pruessner (“the Applicant”), makes claims against the Respondent Caelli Constructions (Vic) Pty Ltd (“CC”) that from about August 2012 until about


    15 July 2020 he was employed by CC pursuant to an employment contract made in


    August 2012.

  2. Paragraph [5] and [6] of the statement of claim filed to the Court on 3 December 2020 provide:

    5.In about August 2012, Mr Caelli asked Mr Pruessner to work at Caelli as a full-time employee in the position of formwork supervisor, and Mr Pruessner agreed to do so (Employment Contract).

    Particulars

    The discussion and agreement was oral, constituted by an informal discussion between Mr Caelli and Mr Pruessner during which Mr Caelli…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pruessner v Caelli Constructions Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FedCFamC2G 206
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Pruessner v Caelli Constructions Pty Ltd involved the Applicant, who sought to establish that he was an employee of Caelli Constructions Pty Ltd (CC) from August 2012 until 15 July 2020. The Applicant claimed that as a result of this employment, he was entitled to benefits such as annual leave pay, redundancy pay, long service leave, and superannuation contributions. Additionally, he sought pecuniary penalties for alleged contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). CC denied that the Applicant was their employee, asserting that they engaged Pruessner Holdings Pty Ltd (PH) as a supplier of services under a contractor agreement. The Applicant supplied services to CC on behalf of PH.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Applicant was an employee of CC from August 2012 to July 2020. The court had to determine the nature of the relationship between the Applicant and CC, considering the evidence presented regarding the terms of their engagement, control, and the conduct of PH. The court also needed to examine whether the Applicant was entitled to employee benefits and penalties under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) if he was found to be an employee.

The court analysed the evidence provided by both parties, including the invoices issued by PH to CC, the tax returns filed by PH, and the testimonies of the Applicant and Mr Caelli. The court found that the evidence did not support the claim that the Applicant was an employee of CC. Instead, the evidence indicated that there was an agreement between the Applicant, as a director and shareholder of PH, and Mr Caelli, on behalf of CC, for PH to supply services to CC. The court highlighted that the Applicant's work was billed through PH, and PH treated the income from CC as its own. Furthermore, PH paid superannuation contributions on behalf of the Applicant in several years, which further indicated that the Applicant was not an employee of CC.

Based on the court's findings, it dismissed the Applicant's claims for employee benefits and penalties. The court concluded that since the Applicant was not an employee of CC, he was not entitled to the relief sought in respect of redundancy, notice, and penalties for record-keeping obligations.

In conclusion, the court made orders dismissing the application, finding that the Applicant was not an employee of CC from August 2012 to July 2020. Consequently, he had no entitlement to the benefits and penalties claimed under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

CC denies that the Applicant was an employee from August 2012 until 15 July 2020. It is said by CC that it engaged Pruessner Holdings Pty Ltd (“PH”) as a supplier of services from time to time under a contractor agreement, and that the Applicant supplied services to CC on behalf of PH. BACKGROUND The Applicant is 58 years of age. He commenced working in the building industry as a bricklayer at age 14. He does not hold formal qualifications but says that he learned his trade working with his Father who was also a bricklayer by trade. The Applicant’s Father also performed work for CC in the past. Through that work he came to know Mr Caelli and subsequently formed a friendship with him. In about 1992, PH was incorporated involving the Applicant, his wife and other members of his family, and in 1999 they established a family trust. Through PH and the trust, they conducted business growing proteas and also selling flowers through a florist shop in Templestowe. PH continued to conduct the protea growing, florist business, then subsequently a hobby type business selling finger boards (miniature skate boards) and a construction contracting business. Since 2011, the Applicant has also been a partner in a crane hire business, known as PGP, together with Mr Caelli. The protea growing and the florist shop ceased operation in or about 2005. The Applicant gave evidence that in about 2000 he went back to work as a bricklayer and that in about 2005 commenced completing work for CC. He did that work through PH rendering invoices under that companies ABN. This was not claimed to be employment but was in the nature of jobs that came up and that were offered through contract managers with CC. The Applicant (through PH) also worked for other parties at that time. From about 2008 until about 2012, for reasons that are not relevant, the Applicant was in a financial position where he did not have to work.THE APPLICANT’S CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE At the final hearing, the Applicant gave oral evidence before the Court on 16 & 17 November 2021. Mr Caelli, the former managing director of CC during the relevant period was called on behalf of the Applicant as well as Mr Madjeric, a Project Manager who was an employee of CC. Outlines of evidence were filed by each of the witnesses who gave evidence before the Court, however both witnesses gave evidence in their own words and evidence was elicited through examination in chief and each of the witnesses were cross-examined.The Applicant’s Evidence regarding the Employment Contract The Applicant claims he was employed during the relevant period. As a consequence of that employment, it is claimed he was entitled to benefits as an employee including annual leave pay, redundancy pay upon termination of his employment, long service leave and superannuation-contributions based on the salary he was paid. The Applicant also seeks pecuniary penalties for contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (“the FW Act”) by reason of the failure to pay the benefits outlined above.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Outlines of evidence were filed by each of the witnesses who gave evidence before the Court, however both witnesses gave evidence in their own words and evidence was elicited through examination in chief and each of the witnesses were cross-examined.The Applicant’s Evidence regarding the Employment Contract The Applicant claims he was employed during the relevant period. As a consequence of that employment, it is claimed he was entitled to benefits as an employee including annual leave pay, redundancy pay upon termination of his employment, long service leave and superannuation-contributions based on the salary he was paid. The Applicant also seeks pecuniary penalties for contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (“the FW Act”) by reason of the failure to pay the benefits outlined above. In relation to questions from his Counsel as to what occurred in 2012 with respect to dealings with CC, the Applicant gave the following evidence:Paul said “You know, you are just bumming around so you may as well do something. I’ve got some – We have – just signed a couple of big projects so there will be a lot of work coming up”[1][1] Transcript page 12, line 24. The following exchange indicates the evidence that was given by the Applicant in relation to the agreement pleaded to have been made in August 2012. I set the exchange out in full because it shows the flavour of the evidence given and demonstrates the lack of connection between the evidence and contract as pleaded. So, Mr Pruessner, we just need to go a bit slower. And so we will just go back to 2012 when you started. And your evidence that you were approached by Paul to start working. Now, can you tell the Court what the terms were of that; firstly, what were the hours that you negotiated?---Well, it was a – you know, it was a eight hour day. So I started at 7 o’clock and – and knocked off at 3.30.Yes. Okay. Pause there. What were the duties that you were asked to do?---Well, I – I started because they – they had a – a lot of factory sites which was called a yard, and it was like a bog hole so I started putting down crushed rock and ---Yes?---And vibrating it in to – I actually had a little jig that we use on the farm. I started with that, doing some work so they could use all the land for storing, you know cord. Yes. Did you discuss any other duties that you were going to do?---Well, then I started putting down hard sand, so – because I had a lot – lot of scaffold and – and so – and to get all the drainage right, so we started putting down a lot of concrete.Okay?--- That I was looking after. Yes. Did you – what were the terms you negotiated regarding pay?---Well, I just kept billing through Pruessner Holdings, so ---Yes. What was the amount?--- Well, it – it was an hourly rate at that stage every week, and you know, I put an invoice in maybe every fortnight or something. And to pause there, did you discuss with Paul at that time the invoicing? Was there a discussion about how you were going to be paid?---Not particularly, no. No?---He knew that I had that company that – because I – I worked previous, you know, in the early or mid-2000s, so I worked through – through the same company, so - - - Did you discuss whether it was going to be ongoing?---Yes, he said, “You could come on full board because we have got a lot of work to do.” So - - - Did you discuss anything about leave?---No. Did you work - so this is 2012 onward in the chronology?---yes.Now, just on and from this point, did you work for anyone else?---No.Okay. When did your work with Caelli end?---When was it? July 2020.[2] [2] Transcript page 13, line 22 to page 14, line 18.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As to the balance of the Applicant’s claims to redundancy, notice and penalties in relation to record keeping obligations, I find that those matters arise as an incident of employment and in circumstances where I have determined that the Applicant is not an employee of CC, he has no entitlement to the relief sought in respect of those matters. CONCLUSION For the reasons outlined I will make orders dismissing the application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Findlay provided oral evidence in relation to WorkCover that:Subcontractors supply their own WorkCover, and Peter did supply his own WorkCover.[10] [10] Transcript page 219 line 2. CONSIDERATION The evidence in the form of invoices show that from about August 2012, PH rendered invoices to CC for services such as bricklaying, painting of cranes, steel fixing, pumping concrete and supervision. The invoices do not show that there was a fixed minimum number of hours to be worked and there are periods where no invoices were recorded as the Applicant did not work. The invoices show that the Applicant completed work hours at a rate of $65.00 per hour later increasing to $75.00 per hour and also regularly included the cost of other labour engaged by PH to perform the work for CC. On occasions, the labour included the cost of the Applicant’s son’s labour (he was described as “Mini-me” in the invoices). The Applicant gave evidence that the labour engaged by PH would receive less than the amount invoiced for their work and that PH would retain the difference. GST was added to each of the invoices and PH obtained tax credits for the GST paid on business expenses. The tax returns of PH for the relevant period show that the money received by PH in respect of services supplied by the Applicant to CC was treated as income of that company, whilst PH’s business expenses of the construction contracting business were deducted. Director’s fees, trust distributions and for a time wages, were paid to the Applicant and his wife. By the terms of the discussion between the Applicant and Mr Caelli set out above, the Court finds that there was an agreement that PH agreed to supply services to CC, with that agreement made between the Applicant as a director and shareholder of PH and Mr Caelli on behalf of CC. As is apparent from the evidence of both the Applicant and Mr Caelli, the evidence does not support a finding that as at August 2012, the Applicant and Mr Caelli as managing director of CC agreed that the Applicant would do work as an employee of CC. The evidence does not support a finding that this arrangement was forced on the Applicant. Nor is it the case that the Applicant was engaged as an employee and that arrangement was unilaterally changed at the behest of CC so that he was transferred from being an employee to being a subcontractor. If there is any doubt about this finding, the evidence in relation to the conduct of PH, point to the fact that a business was being conducted by PH. The evidence in relation to the conduct is set out below:(a)the rendering of invoices to CC by PH;(b)the filing of tax returns by PH which accounted for the income received based on the invoices rendered by PH to CC; and(c)that PH paid superannuation contributions on behalf of the Applicant in a number of years . By way of outline of submissions filed to the Court on 19 November 2021 at paragraph [11] the Applicant contends that the evidence presented to the Court establishes that on and from August 2012:a)Mr Pruessner worked on a full-time basis according to site schedules, averaging 38 hours per week. He had no choice as to the timing of his work, or the amount he was to deliver. His duty was to generally obey, according to a span of hours, just like every other Caelli employee. b)Mr Pruessner’s day to day tasks involved supervision of concrete pours, support tasks associated with the same, remodelling safety screens, ordering and collecting materials, and general management and administration duties. He was to serve on the instructions of Caelli’s project managers, foreman, contract managers and directors. He had no control over what he was to do each day, nor how he was to do it. c)Mr Pruessner was paid $65 per hour between August 2012 and March 2015, $70 or $75 per hour between April 2015 and June 2015, and $75 per hour from July 2015 to July 2020. GST was paid in addition to these amounts. Mr Pruessner was paid by the hour for his labour, rather than on the completion of a task or result. d)Mr Pruessner was an emanation of Caelli’s business. He was given authority to represent Caelli when dealing with third parties. He worked exclusively for Caelli. He wore Caelli uniform, undertook training at Caelli’s direction and expense, was provided with a Caelli email address, and was given a Bunnings ordering card for the purposes for and on behalf of Caelli. He could not delegate his tasks to other contractors. He was not treated as if he was in business on his own account. e)Commercial risk for Mr Pruessner’s work was borne by Caelli, rather than Mr Pruessner. Mr Pruessner was not required to maintain any insurance. Caelli provided all of the equipment and materials for the purposes of Mr Pruessner to carry out his tasks. Caelli assumed responsibility for the quality of the Mr Pruessner’s work as they did for every employee.