Ertekin v Euro Natural Stone Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ertekin v Euro Natural Stone Pty Ltd [2021] FCCA 512

File number(s): SYG 1571 of 2020
Judgment of: JUDGE MANOUSARIDIS
Date of judgment: 18 March 2021
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Industrial Law – application for default judgment based on statement of claim alleging contraventions of provisions of Fair Work Act2009 (Cth) – whether on the face of statement of claim applicant has established an entitlement for declaratory relief and other relief including orders for the payment of pecuniary penalties – declarations and orders made including orders for the payment of pecuniary penalties.
Legislation:

Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) s 4AA

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 44(1), 44(2), 61(3), 90(2), 96, 117, 323(1), 340(1), 341(1)(a), 341(1)(c)(ii), 342(1), 357, 360, 361(1), 539(1), 545, 546(1), 546(2), 546(3)(c), 547(2), 550(1), 550(2), 557(1), 557A

Federal Circuit Court Act 1999 (Cth) ss 76(2), 76(3),

Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) rr 1.05, 13.03.A(2), 13.03B(2), 13.03C(2)

Federal Court Rules 1979 (Cth) O 35A, r 3(2)(c)

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 79(1)

Long Service Leave Act 1955 (NSW) ss 4(1), 4(5), 12

Cases cited:

Australasian Performing Right Association Limited v Escape Bar & Night Club Pty Limited & Anor [2017] FCCA 2690

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (the BKH Contractors Case) (No 2) [2018] FCA 1563

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Dataline.Net.Au Pty Limited [2006] FCA 1427

Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association v International Aviations Service Assistance Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 333

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Edensor Nominees Pty Ltd [2001] HCA 1

Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union v Visy Packaging Pty Ltd (No 3) [2013] FCA 525

Barclay v Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical and Further Education [2010] FCA 284; (2010) 193 IR 251

Bevis v VA Holdings Pty Ltd trading as Granton Homes & Ors [2020] FCCA 2082

Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical and Further Education v Barclay [2012] HCA 32; (2012) 86 ALJR 1044

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Anglo Coal (Dawson Services) Pty Ltd [2015] FCAFC 157

Cummins South Pacific Pty Ltd v Keenan [2020] FCAFC 204

Director of The Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v Baulderstone Pty Ltd & Ors [2014] FCCA 721

Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v Serdar Tunc & Anor [2013] FCCA 438

Fair Work Ombudsman v NSH North Pty Ltd trading as New Shanghai Charlestown [2017] FCA 1301

Fair Work Ombudsman v Safecorp Security Group Pty Ltd & Anor (No.3) [2019] FCCA 1756

Kelly v Fitzpatrick [2007] FCA 1080

Macquarie Bank Limited v Seagle [2005] FCA 1239

Macquarie Bank Limited v Seagle [2008] FCA 1417

Mason v Harrington Corporation Pty Ltd [2007] FMCA 7

PIA Mortgage Services Pty Ltd v King [2020] FCAFC 15

Phonographic Performance Ltd v Maitra (1998) 41 IPR 225

Rathner, in the matter of Mildura Grand Pty Ltd (in liq) v Bendigo Skyrider Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 626

Rizeq v Western Australia [2017]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ertekin v Euro Natural Stone Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCCA 512
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, Judge Manousaridis considered an application for default judgment brought by Mr Ertekin against Euro Natural Stone Pty Ltd (the first respondent) and a second respondent. The dispute arose from Mr Ertekin's employment with the first respondent, alleging contraventions of various provisions of the *Fair Work Act 2009* (Cth) (FW Act), including unlawful termination, failure to pay salary, and improper acceptance of resignation. The respondents failed to file a defence despite multiple court orders, leading to the application for default judgment.

The court was required to determine whether the statement of claim, on its face, established Mr Ertekin's entitlement to declaratory relief and other orders, including pecuniary penalties. Specifically, the court had to assess whether the first respondent contravened sections 340(1), 323(1), and 44(1) of the FW Act, and whether the second respondent was involved in these contraventions pursuant to section 550(2) of the FW Act. The court also considered the appropriate quantum of pecuniary penalties and the award of judgment sums.

Judge Manousaridis reasoned that the respondents were in default and had not satisfied Mr Ertekin's claims. The court found that the first respondent contravened section 340(1) by purporting to accept Mr Ertekin's resignation when he had not resigned, contravened section 323(1) by failing to pay salary for work performed, and contravened section 44(1) by failing to pay accrued annual leave and by purporting to dismiss Mr Ertekin without providing the requisite notice or payment in lieu. The court also found the second respondent involved in these contraventions. Applying the principles for pecuniary penalties under section 546 of the FW Act, and considering the maximum penalty units applicable, the court imposed penalties on both respondents.

Consequently, the court made declarations that the first respondent had contravened sections 340(1), 323(1), and 44(1) of the FW Act, and that the second respondent was involved in these contraventions. The court ordered the first respondent to pay pecuniary penalties totalling $69,300 and the second respondent to pay pecuniary penalties totalling $16,380. Further, judgment was entered against the first respondent for $77,160.82 and against the second respondent for $62,426.91, with a note that Mr Ertekin could not recover more than $77,160.82 in aggregate from both respondents. Interest was also awarded on the judgment sums.

Orders

Orders of the court

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE MANOUSARIDIS

DATE OF ORDER:

18 MARCH 2021

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1. The first respondent contravened s 340(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) by sending to the applicant on 25 February 2020 an email purporting to accept a resignation by the applicant in circumstances where the applicant did not resign from his employment.

2. The first respondent contravened s 323(1) of the FW Act by failing to pay in full the salary that was due to the applicant for work the applicant performed in the period from 3 February 2020 to 25 February 2020.

3. The first respondent contravened s 44(1) of the FW Act by failing to pay to the applicant, contrary to s 90(2) of the FW Act, $16,712.80, being the amount payable for annual leave that had accrued to the applicant at the time the first respondent dismissed the applicant but which the applicant had not taken.

4. The first respondent contravened s 44(1) of the FW Act by purporting to dismiss the applicant from his employment without, contrary to s 117(2) of the FW Act, either giving the applicant four weeks’ notice or paying to the applicant four weeks salary in lieu of such notice.

5. The second respondent was within the meaning of s 550(2) of the FW Act involved in each of the first respondent’s contraventions identified in declarations 1, 2, 3, and 4 and, because of s 550(1) is taken to have contravened each of s 340(1), s 44(1), and s 323(1) of the FW Act.

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

6. Pursuant to s 546(1) of the FW Act the first respondent pay pecuniary penalties in the sum of $69,300 for the first respondent’s contraventions of s 340(1), s 44(1), and s 323(1) of the FW Act identified in declarations 1, 2, 3, and 4.

7. Pursuant to s 546(3)(c) of the FW Act the first respondent pay the pecuniary penalties referred to in order 6 to the applicant within 28 days after the day on which these orders are pronounced.

8. Pursuant to s 546(1) of the FW Act the second respondent pay pecuniary penalties in the sum of $16,380 for the contraventions of s 340(1), s 44(1), and s 323(1) of the FW Act identified in declaration 5.

9. Pursuant to s 546(3)(c) of the FW Act the second respondent pay the pecuniary penalties referred to in order 8 to the applicant within 28 days after the day on which these orders are pronounced.

10. There be judgment in the sum of $77,160.82 against the first respondent.

11. There be judgment in the sum of $62,426.91 against the second respondent.

THE COURT NOTES THAT:

12. In relation to the judgments ordered referred to in orders 10 and 11 the applicant will not be entitled to recover from the first and second respondents in the aggregate an amount that exceeds $77,160.82 and any interest that may become payable on the judgments.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There is no question the respondents are in default. The respondents have not satisfied Mr Ertekin’s claims; and the respondents have failed to file a response, and they have failed to file a defence by the times provided for by the orders Judge Altobelli made on 21 September 2020 and 18 November 2020, and by the time provided by the orders I made on 12 February 2021.MR ERTEKIN’S PLEADED CASE, CLAIMS FOR RELIEF, AND EVIDENCE In his statement of claim Mr Ertekin alleges the following facts. Mr Ertekin commenced employment with ENS on about 2 February 2015. In about July 2019 it was agreed that with effect from September 2019 Mr Ertekin would act in the capacity of general manager, and he would be paid a salary of $167,128 per annum.[6] It is not alleged that this salary was agreed to be net of any superannuation; and I will proceed on the basis that the agreed salary of $167,128 was inclusive of superannuation. (In his affidavit made on 7 February 2021, Mr Ertekin deposes that it was agreed he would be paid a salary of $164,000 plus superannuation.)[6] Statement of claim, [6] The statement of claim does not allege the salary or wage it was agreed Mr Ertekin would be paid, or the role he was engaged to perform. In his affidavit Mr Ertekin deposes it was agreed he would be paid at the hourly rate of $18. Mr Ertekin, however, has annexed weekly payslips for some of the weeks after 15 July 2019. There is a payslip for the week commencing 15 July 2019 that shows Mr Ertekin earned $2,656 at the hourly rate of $66.40. Payslips for weeks after 16 September 2019 show a weekly salary of $3,214 at the hourly rate of $80.35. It was an implied term of Mr Ertekin’s contract of employment that neither party could terminate it without giving the other party reasonable notice or payment in lieu of reasonable notice (Reasonable Notice Term).[7][7] Statement of claim, [7] In about February 2020 ENS proposed that the production, sales, and marketing activities would be removed from Mr Ertekin’s responsibilities, and he would continue with administrative responsibilities (restructure).[8] [8] Statement of claim, [8] In about February 2020 ENS unilaterally reduced Mr Ertekin’s salary to $115,960 per annum.[9][9] Statement of claim, [9] On 12 February 2020 Mr Ertekin commenced a period of absence from work due to his being unfit for work (sick leave).[10] On 10 February 2020 Mr Ertekin obtained a medical certificate certifying his unfitness for work, and on 11 February 2020 Mr Ertekin provided the medical certificate by email to ENS.[11][10] Statement of claim, [10][11] Statement of claim, [10], [11] On 12 February 2020 Mr Jarret sent to Mr Ertekin a text message stating: “Are you feeling better today princess?”[12] Mr Ertekin responded by email, part of which included the following:[13]As you know, I am not happy with the way that I have recently been treated by Euro Natural Stone Pty Ltd (ENS). In particular, I object to:•The unilateral decision to remove production and sales and marking [sic] responsibilities from me, leaving me only with responsibility for administrative matters;•The unilateral decision to cut my salary from $2,200 per week net to $1,600 per week net. In gross terms, this is a reduction from $167,128 per annum to $115,960 per annum.Either of these changes alone would be sufficient to constitute a repudiation of my contract of employment and I currently reserve all my rights whether to accept/reject the repudiation.[12] Statement of claim, [12][13] Statement of claim, [14]

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Ertekin claims interest. I am not satisfied that good cause has been shown for not making an order for interest under s 76(3) of the FCC Act. I propose to calculate interest by applying the rates prescribed by the Interest on Judgments Practice Note (GPN-INT) issued by the Federal Court of Australia. That practice note provides for an interest rate of 4% above the cash rate last published by the Reserve Bank of Australia. I propose to apply the average rate of interest over the period 1 March 2020 to 18 March 2021, being the day on which I propose to pronounce my orders. I have calculated the average rate of interest to be 4.22% per annum. On these assumptions I have calculated interest on the sum of $73,888.94 for the 383 day period from and including 1 March 2020 up to and including 18 March 2018 to be $3,271.88,[44] and interest on the sum of $59,779.80 for the same period to be $2,647.11.[45][44] (4.22% x $73,888.94)/365 x 383 = $3,271.88[45] (4.22% x $59,779.80)/365 x 383 = $2,647.11Declarations I have considered elsewhere whether it is appropriate for the Court to make declarations in applications under r 13.03B(2) of the FCC Rules,[46] and I am satisfied there would be utility in making declarations to the effect Mr Ertekin seeks.PENALTY[46] Australasian Performing Right Association Limited v Escape Bar & Night Club Pty Limited & Anor [2017] FCCA 2690, at [45], [46]Power and principles Subsection 546(1) of the FW Act provides that this Court may, on application, order a person to pay a pecuniary penalty the Court considers is appropriate if the Court is satisfied the person has contravened a “civil remedy provision”.[47] That expression is defined in s 539(1) of the FW Act to include the provisions identified in column 1 of the table to s 539(2) of the Act. Sections 44 and 323 of the FW Act are in column 1 of the table to s 539(2) of the Act. [47] I repeat in this and the following 4 paragraphs what I said in Bevis v VA Holdings Pty Ltd trading as Granton Homes & Ors [2020] FCCA 2082, at [33]-[38] Subsection 546(2) of the FW Act provides that the pecuniary penalty the Court may impose must not, where the person is an individual, be more than “the maximum number of penalty units referred to in the relevant item in column 4 of the table in subsection 539(2)” and, if the person is a body corporate, must not be more than five times “the maximum number of penalty units referred to in the relevant item in column 4 of the table in subsection 539(2)”. The maximum penalty units for a contravention of s 44(1) and s 323(1) of the FW Act at the relevant time (excluding “serious contraventions”, as defined in s 557A of the FW Act) are 60 penalty units for an individual, and 300 penalty units for a body corporate. Section 12 of the FW Act provides that “penalty unit” has the meaning given by s 4AA of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth). The penalty unit provided for by s 4AA of that Act as at February 2020 was $210. Thus, $63,000 is the maximum penalty a corporation may be ordered to pay for each contravention of a civil remedy provision, and $12,600 is the maximum penalty an individual may be ordered to pay for each contravention of a civil remedy provision.