Plaintiff S99/2016 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Plaintiff S99/2016 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 483

SUMMARY

In accordance with the practice of the Federal Court in cases of public interest, importance or complexity, the following summary has been prepared to accompany the orders made today.  This summary is intended to assist in understanding the outcome of this proceeding and is not a complete statement of the conclusions reached by the Court.  The only authoritative statement of the Court’s reasons is that contained in the published reasons for judgment which will be available on the internet at the Court’s website.  This summary is also available there.

This proceeding commenced in the High Court and was referred for hearing and determination by this Court.  As will be apparent, it required an urgent hearing and an urgent determination.  By reason of the exemplary efforts of the parties, their legal advisors and the staff of the Court, for which I am grateful, that has been achieved.  

The applicant is a young African woman.  The respondents are the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and the Commonwealth of Australia (collectively, the Minister).

The applicant arrived in Australia on 17 October 2013 having travelled by boat from Indonesia to Christmas Island. On arrival and by virtue of s 14 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act), the applicant was designated an “unlawful non‑citizen” and therefore an “unauthorised maritime arrival” within the meaning of s 5AA of the Act. On arrival, the applicant was detained by the Minister under s 189 of the Act. In the exercise of the power conferred by s 198AD of the Act, on 19 October 2013, the applicant was taken from Australia by an officer of the Minister and placed in the Republic of Nauru, a country designated to be a “regional processing country” under s 198AB(1) of the Act. Upon her removal from Australia, the applicant became a “transitory person” within the meaning of s 5 of the Act. She was detained in a detention centre in Nauru until November 2014. On being recognised as a refugee she was released from detention and is awaiting resettlement. She has no independent means. She has been and remains dependant on the Minister for food, shelter, security and healthcare.

Despite the nomenclature used by the Act to describe her, the applicant remains entitled to the protection of Australian law. Principally, that is because the Minister is bound by the law and, as my reasons explain, the Minister and the applicant are parties to a relationship recognised and enforced by the law out of which legal rights and obligations flow.

The applicant claims that by reason of a legal relationship recognised by the common law, the Minister must take reasonable care of her.  She claims to be a vulnerable woman in desperate circumstances.  It is undeniable that she needs care.  On 31 January 2016, she was raped whilst unconscious and suffering a seizure likely to have been caused by epilepsy.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Plaintiff S99/2016 v Minister for Immigration and Border Pro... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 483
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the Plaintiff, an adult female refugee, brought an action against the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and others, seeking relief in respect of the circumstances of her removal from Nauru and her forced travel to Papua New Guinea for the purpose of procuring an abortion. The Plaintiff claimed that she had been raped while on Nauru and fell pregnant as a result. Upon her request, the respondents agreed to procure for her a termination of pregnancy. The Plaintiff alleged that there was a legal risk attendant upon the abortion in Papua New Guinea arising out of its criminal law dealing with abortion, and a medical risk arising out of the unavailability of medical equipment, experience and expertise required to adequately guard against risk. The Plaintiff sought declarations, injunctions and damages.

The legal issues the court was required to decide included whether the respondents owed a duty of care to the Plaintiff, whether there was an apprehended breach of that duty, and what the applicable law was in relation to the tort of negligence. The court was also required to consider whether there was a breach of a fiduciary duty and whether section 474 of the Migration Act precluded the issue of injunctive relief in proceedings other than judicial review proceedings.

The court found that the respondents owed a duty of care to the Plaintiff to exercise reasonable care in procuring for her a safe and lawful abortion. The court rejected the argument that the standard of care should be determined by reference to the medical services available in Papua New Guinea, and found that the magnitude of both the legal and medical risks of the abortion were high to extreme, and the probability of materialisation of the risk material, and neither trivial nor insignificant. The court found that the respondents had not discharged their duty of care by procuring the abortion in Papua New Guinea. The court also found that the applicable law in relation to the tort of negligence was Australian law.

The court made orders for the respondents to cease to fail to discharge their responsibility to procure for the Plaintiff a safe and lawful abortion, and to take steps to ensure that the abortion was procured in accordance with the court’s directions. The court also made orders for the publication of certain information to be prohibited and for the respondents to take no step to remove the Plaintiff from Papua New Guinea.

This case highlights the importance of considering the legal and medical risks of forced removal and medical procedures for refugees and the duty of care owed to them by the relevant authorities.

Orders

Orders of the court

2. On or before 15 May 2016, the Respondents cease to fail to discharge the responsibility that they assumed to procure for the Applicant a safe and lawful abortion.

3. Unless otherwise agreed in writing between the legal representative of the Applicant and the Respondents, upon the Respondents discharging their duty of care to exercise reasonable care to procure for the Applicant a safe and lawful abortion:

(a) the abortion not be procured so that it takes place in Papua New Guinea; and

(b) the abortion not be procured so that it takes place in any location where a person who participates in an abortion is exposed to criminal liability; and

(c) the abortion not be procured so that it takes place in a hospital or other medical facility that does not have, or that cannot make available to the treating doctor or doctors who perform the abortion:

(i) the neurological expertise and neurological facilities referred to in the expert medical report of Associate Professor Ernest Somerville dated 19 April 2016, together with his expert medical report dated 27 April 2016; and

(ii) the psychiatric expertise, and other resources including cross-cultural expertise, referred to in the expert medical report of Professor Louise Newman dated 18 April 2016, together with her email dated 27 April 2016; and

(iii) the anaesthetic expertise and anaesthetic facilities referred to in the expert medical report of Dr Gregory Purcell dated 20 April 2016; and

(iv) the gynaecological expertise and experience, and the gynaecological facilities, referred to in the expert medical report of Professor Caroline de Costa dated 19 April 2016, together with her expert medical report dated 27 April 2016, and the expertise, experience and facilities referred to in the expert medical report of Dr Miriam O’Connor dated 20 April 2016, together with her expert medical report dated 27 April 2016.

4. On or before 13 May 2016, the Respondents file and serve any submission in relation to the costs of the application.

5. If the Respondents file and serve any submission in relation to costs pursuant to Order 4, then on or before 20 May 2016 the Applicant file and serve any submission in reply.

6. Should no submission as to costs be made pursuant to Order 4, the Respondents pay the Applicant’s costs of and incidental to the application.

7. On the grounds set out at s 37AG(1)(a) and (c) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), publication of the following information be prohibited under s 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), until further order or six months from today, whichever first occurs:

(a) the name of the Applicant.

(b) the age of the Applicant.

(c) the applicant’s country of origin, and the country in which she lived before she came to Australia.

(d) the identification number of the boat on which the Applicant first arrived in Australia.

(e) the procedure that the Applicant had when she was seven years old.

8. There be liberty to apply to extend or vary Order 7.

9. Unless otherwise agreed in writing between the legal representatives of the Applicant and the Respondents, the Respondents, whether by their officers, servants, agents, contractors or otherwise, take no step, on or before 5:00 pm on 15 May 2016, to remove the Applicant from Papua New Guinea.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, being an adult, does not access these services. However, adult English language education and other adult education, including vocational training, is provided or facilitated by Connect.The Salient Facts It is necessary to record other salient facts and convenient to do that in chronological order. The evidence was almost entirely uncontroversial. There was a contest as to whether the applicant had consented to be taken from Nauru to Papua New Guinea and the quality of that consent. I will make some findings as to that issue. Otherwise, unless indicated to the contrary and insofar as the evidence dealt with the facts, the evidence which I recount is accepted. Providing a full description of the evidence raises some sensitivity. Some of the facts concern information which is the subject of a non‑publication orders made by me pursuant to s 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The information the subject of those orders is:(a) the name of the Applicant.(b)the boat identification number of the boat on which the Applicant first arrived in Australia.(c) the age of the Applicant.(d)the country from which the Applicant came [applicant’s ethnicity], and the country in which the Applicant lived prior to her arrival in Australia.(e) the procedure that the Applicant had when she was seven years old. In view of the non-publication order, I have prepared two versions of my reasons for judgment, a redacted version for publication on the internet and a complete version which is to be provided to the parties. The applicant is of XXXXX XXX ethnicity. She was born in XXXXX and is currently about XX years of age. At the age of about seven, she was subjected to XXXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX. An examination by Dr O’Connor, to whose evidence I shall later return, revealed a XXXX XXXXX X which Dr O’Connor defined as:XXXXX XXXXX XXXXX XXXXX XX XXXXX XXXX XXXXX XXXX XXXXX X XXXXX X XXXXX X XXXXX XXX XXXXX XXXXX XXXXX XXXX X XXXXX XXXXX X When the applicant was about 16, she witnessed her sister being murdered. She began to suffer seizures soon after. She had some schooling in XXXXX X and learned some English from watching TV. While 16, she was taken to XXXXX XX where her father had arranged her marriage to a 45 year old man with other wives. She was mistreated. She was severely abused, physically, sexually, and emotionally. She said she was bashed and beaten by her first husband. She described the marriage as “very bad”. After several years and when pregnant with her first and only child, the applicant ran away to XXXXX X where her mother lived. Her son was born there. The applicant’s mother arranged her divorce from her first husband. The applicant met and married a second husband about two years later. Her second marriage was better. She returned to XXXX with her second husband, but her first husband tried to force her to return to him. Her first husband accused her of adultery and threatened to inform the government and XXX XXX. Assisted by her second husband, the applicant fled, fearing that she would be killed by stoning. She left her son with her mother. She sought refuge in Australia, where she thought she could be safe. With that objective, she travelled to Indonesia and then by boat to Australia. The applicant’s son remains in XXXX in the care of the applicant’s mother.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BROMBERG J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BROMBERG J