Hunter Area Health Service v Presland

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

Reported Decision:

63 NSWLR 22

Court of Appeal


CITATION:

HUNTER AREA HEALTH SERVICE & ANOR v PRESLAND [2005] NSWCA 33

HEARING DATE(S):

15 November 2004, 16 November 2004, 17 November 2004

 
JUDGMENT DATE: 


21 April 2005

JUDGMENT OF:

Spigelman CJ at 1; Sheller JA at 103; Santow JA at 309

DECISION:

1 Appeal allowed; 2 Set aside the verdict and judgment for the plaintiff; 3 In lieu thereof verdict and judgment for the defendants; 4 The plaintiff to pay the defendants' costs of the trial and of the appeal but to have a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951, if so entitled.

CATCHWORDS:

NEGLIGENCE - duty of care - nature and content of duty of care owed to psychiatric patient - Mental Health Act 1900 - ex turpi causa non actio - public policy - causation

LEGISLATION CITED:

Crimes Act 1958 (Vic)
Fatal Accidents Act 1975
Mental Health (Criminal Procedure) Act 1990
Mental Health Act 1990

CASES CITED:

Adamson v Jarvis (1827) 4 Bing 66
AMP v RTA (2001) Aust Torts Rep 81-619
Anderson v Hotel Capital Trading Pty Ltd [2003] NSWSC 1195
Ashrafi Persian Trading Co Pty Ltd v Ashrafinia (2002) Aust Torts Rep 81-636
Barnes v Hay (1998) 12 NSWLR 337
Bennett v Minister for Community Welfare (1992) 176 CLR 408
Beresford v Royal Insurance Company Ltd [1937] 2 KB 197; [1938] AC 586
Boruschewitz v Kirts 554 NE 2d 1112
Burrows v Rhodes [1899] 1 QB 816
Carson v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd (1993) 178 CLR 44
Cattanach v Melchior (2003) 215 CLR 1
Champagne v United States, Supreme Court of North Dakota (513 NW 2d 75) (N.D. 1994)
Chappel v Hart (1998) 195 CLR 232
Chief Constable of West Yorkshire [1989] AC 53
Cleaver v Mutual Reserve Fund Life Association [1892] 1 QB 147
Clunis v Camden & Islington Health Authority [1998] QB 978
Cole v South Tweed Heads Rugby (2004) 78 ALJR 933
Cole v Taylor 301 NW 2d 766 (1981)
Crimmins v Stevedoring Industry Finance Committee (1999) 200 CLR 1
Cross v Kirkby The Times, 5 April 2000
Czarnikow Limited v Koufos [1969] 1 AC 350
Devries v Australian National Railways Commission (1993) 177 CLR 472
Diamond v Minter [1941] KB 656
Diamond v Simpson (No 1) (2003) Aust Torts Reports 81-695
Dorset Yacht Co Ltd v Home Office [1970] AC 1004
Edwards v Attorney General (NSW) (2004) 208 ALR 605
Environment Agency v Empress Car Co (Abertillery) Ltd [1992] 2 AC 22
Everett v Griffiths [1920] 3 KB 163; [1921] 1 AC 631
Finance Facilities Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1971) 127 CLR 106
Fitzgerald v Penn (1954) 91 CLR 268
Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118
Gala v Preston (1991) 172 CLR 243
Glazier v Lee 171 Mich. App. 216, 429 NW 2d 857 (1988)
Godbolt v Fittock (1964) NSWR 22
Gollan v Nugent (1988) 166 CLR 18
Graham Barclay Oysters Pty Ltd v Ryan (2002) 211 CLR 540
Gray v Barr [1971] 2…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hunter Area Health Service v Presland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWCA 33
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The New South Wales Court of Appeal considered a claim in negligence brought by Mr Presland against the Hunter Area Health Service. Mr Presland alleged that the Health Service owed him a duty of care in its treatment of him as a psychiatric patient, and that a breach of this duty caused him harm. The Health Service contended that Mr Presland's own conduct, specifically his commission of criminal offences, precluded him from recovering damages.

The central legal issues before the Court of Appeal were the nature and content of the duty of care owed by a health service to a psychiatric patient, and whether the principle of *ex turpi causa non oritur actio* (from a dishonourable cause an action arises not) applied to bar Mr Presland's claim. The Court also had to consider the application of the *Mental Health Act 1900* (NSW) and the question of causation.

The Court found that while a health service does owe a duty of care to its psychiatric patients, the principle of *ex turpi causa* was applicable in this instance. Spigelman CJ, with whom Sheller and Santow JJA agreed, held that public policy dictated that a person should not be able to profit from their own criminal wrongdoing. Therefore, Mr Presland's claim was barred because the harm he suffered was a direct consequence of his own criminal acts, which were inextricably linked to the events for which he sought compensation.

The Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the verdict and judgment for the plaintiff. In lieu thereof, a verdict and judgment were entered for the defendants, the Hunter Area Health Service. Mr Presland was ordered to pay the defendants' costs of the trial and the appeal, with a provision for a certificate under the *Suitors' Fund Act 1951* if he was otherwise entitled.

Orders

Orders of the court

1 Appeal allowed; 2 Set aside the verdict and judgment for the plaintiff; 3 In lieu thereof verdict and judgment for the defendants; 4 The plaintiff to pay the defendants' costs of the trial and of the appeal but to have a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951, if so entitled.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established