Ibrahimi v Commonwealth of Australia (No 9)

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Summary available
  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Ibrahimi & ors v Commonwealth of Australia (No 9) [2017] NSWSC 1051
Hearing dates:26 September 2016; 27 September 2016; 28 September 2016; 30 September 2016; 4 October 2016; 5 October 2016; 6 October 2016; 10 October 2016; 11 October 2016; 13 October 2016; 14 October 2016; 21 October 2016; 26 October 2016; 1 November 2016; 4 November 2016 and 5 December 2016 Further written submissions 5 December 2016; 6 December 2016
Date of orders: 13 September 2017
Decision date: 13 September 2017
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Bellew J
Decision:

(1) Question 1 is answered: Yes. In 2010, Border Protection Command, an agent of the defendant, had stationed a permanent response vessel at Christmas Island for the purposes of conducting surveillance on the northern approaches to Christmas Island to detect and respond to maritime security threats, including to detect and intercept Suspected Illegal Entry Vessels and transfer their crew and Potential Illegal Immigrants to Christmas Island for processing under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth).

 

(2)   Question 2 is answered: No.

 

(3)   Question 3 is answered: No.
(4)   Question 4 is answered: No.
(5)   Question 5 is answered: No.
(6)   Question 6 is answered: There was a shipwreck risk. However, that risk did not arise from any conduct on the part of the defendant and was, in any event, a risk which was both inherent and obvious.

 

(7) Question 7 is answered: The shipwreck risk was foreseeable within the meaning of s. 5B(1)(a) of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (WA). However, that risk did not arise from any conduct on the part of the defendant and was, in any event, a risk which was both inherent and obvious.

 

(8) Question 8 is answered: The shipwreck risk was “not insignificant” within the meaning of s. 5B(1)(b) of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (WA).

 

(9)   Question 9 is answered: No.

 

(10)   Question 10 is answered: No.

 

(11)   Question 11 is answered: No.

 

(12)   Question 12 is answered: No.

 

(13)   Question 13 is answered: No.

 

(14)   Question 14 is answered: No.

 

(15)   Question 15 is answered: No.

 

(16) Question 16 is answered: By virtue of the provisions of s. 261A of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) SIEV 221 was forfeited to the defendant and the owners of SIEV 221 were divested of title to that vessel. The defendant became the owner of the vessel by virtue of the statutory forfeiture but the defendant did not assume any duty or obligation in relation to the condition of the vessel, or the safety of its passengers.

 

(17)   Question 17 is answered: No.

 

(18)   Question 18 is answered:
(i)   as to paragraphs [52]-[71] of the FASOC – No;
(ii)   as to paragraphs [80]-[92] of the FASOC – No.

 

(19)   The proceedings are listed for further directions before me on 20 September 2017 at 9:30am.

 (20)   The parties are to bring in Short Minutes of Order on that day reflecting the conclusions that I have reached…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ibrahimi v Commonwealth of Australia (No 9) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NSWSC 1051
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the plaintiffs sought damages from the Commonwealth of Australia, alleging negligence and breach of statutory duty in relation to the shipwreck of a suspected illegal entry vessel near Christmas Island. The vessel, carrying numerous individuals attempting to enter Australia illegally, encountered adverse weather conditions and ultimately wrecked, resulting in numerous fatalities. The plaintiffs included the relatives of those on board, as well as rescuers and onlookers who suffered psychiatric injury. The court was tasked with determining whether the Commonwealth owed a duty of care to those on the vessel, their relatives, and others affected by the shipwreck, and whether any such duty was breached.

The legal issues revolved around the scope of the Commonwealth's duty of care, particularly in the context of intercepting suspected illegal entry vessels. The court considered whether the risk of shipwreck was foreseeable, obvious, or inherent. It also assessed the Commonwealth's response to the risk, including whether a reasonable public authority would have taken precautions such as ensuring vessels were operational and attending to vessels in distress. Furthermore, the court examined the Commonwealth's obligations under various statutes, including the Migration Act and the Navigation Act, to determine if any statutory duties were breached.

The court found that the Commonwealth owed a duty of care to the passengers on the vessel to take reasonable care in the exercise of its powers and the deployment of its resources, but this duty was not breached as the Commonwealth had taken reasonable steps to intercept the vessel. Regarding the relatives, rescuers, and onlookers, the court concluded that the Commonwealth did not owe a duty of care to avoid psychiatric injury resulting from the shipwreck. The court also determined that the Commonwealth's ownership of the vessel did not impose additional duties analogous to those of an occupier of premises. Finally, the court held that the Commonwealth did not breach any statutory duties under the Migration Act or the Navigation Act.

The court further ruled that certain causes of action were outside the applicable limitation period and that the amendment of pleadings did not sufficiently connect the later causes of action to the original set of facts. As a result, those claims were dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

A number of people sailed from Indonesia to Australia on a vessel attempting to gain entry into Australia illegally. The vessel experienced monsoonal weather conditions near Christmas Island and subsequently became shipwrecked, resulting in several fatalities. The Border Protection Command was conducting an operation near Christmas Island with one of its objectives being to intercept suspected illegal entry vessels. This case revolves around the alleged failure of the Commonwealth of Australia to exercise reasonable care in its powers and deployment of resources to prevent foreseeable physical harm, psychiatric injury, mental harm, and loss of property to the passengers and others affected by the shipwreck.

This case involves multiple plaintiffs who have brought claims against the Commonwealth of Australia for negligence, breach of statutory duty, and other related causes of action. The proceedings have undergone several amendments to the pleadings, addressing various legal issues. The case has been through various stages, including applications for amendments to the pleadings, interlocutory applications, and hearings on the merits. The case has been heard in the Federal Court of Australia and has potentially involved appeals to higher courts.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the defendant owed to passengers on board such vessels a duty to take reasonable care in the exercise of its powers and the deployment of its resources so as to avoid foreseeable physical harm to those passengers.
2. Whether the defendant owed to the relatives of passengers on board such vessels a duty to take reasonable care in the exercise of its powers and the deployment of its resources so as to avoid foreseeable psychiatric injury to those relatives.
3. Whether the defendant owed to rescuers and onlookers a duty to take reasonable care in the exercise of its powers and the deployment of its resources so as to avoid rescuers and onlookers suffering foreseeable mental harm.
4. Whether the defendant owed to passengers on board such vessels a duty to take reasonable care in the exercise of its powers and the deployment of its resources so as to avoid foreseeable loss of property belonging to those passengers.
5. Whether the risk of the suspected illegal entry vessel becoming shipwrecked was a foreseeable risk, an obvious risk, or an inherent risk.
6. Whether the risk of the vessel becoming shipwrecked was not insignificant.
7. Whether a reasonable public authority in the position of the defendant would have taken the precaution of not permitting other vessels to remain out of survey.
8. Whether a reasonable public authority in the position of the defendant would have taken the precaution of returning an available vessel to patrol at the usual position of intercept of such vessels.
9. Whether those in command of vessels engaged in the operation knew or had reason to suspect that a suspected illegal entry vessel was approaching Christmas Island from the north in poor weather and in distress at a particular time.
10. Whether in response to the risk of a suspected illegal entry vessel becoming shipwrecked and finding itself in distress the defendant should have taken the precaution of attending upon the vessel to assist earlier than it did.
11. Whether the vessel would have not have become shipwrecked had the defendant taken other precautions.
12. Whether as a result of the defendant becoming the owner of the vessel by virtue of statutory forfeiture, the defendant assumed duties and responsibilities analogous to those owed by an occupier of premises to an entrant.
13. Whether the defendant’s servants or agents who were in command of nearby vessels owed a statutory duty and whether any such duty owed was breached.
14. Whether by reason of the defendant’s ownership of the vessel the defendant owed a statutory duty and whether any such duty owed was breached.
15. Whether certain causes of action relied upon by the plaintiffs were outside the applicable limitation period.
16. Whether the causes of action pleaded in a further amended statement of claim arose out of substantially the same set of facts as those originally pleaded.

Held
1. The court held that the defendant did not owe a duty of care to the passengers on board the vessels to take reasonable care to avoid foreseeable physical harm.
2. The court held that the defendant did not owe a duty of care to the relatives of the passengers on board the vessels to take reasonable care to avoid foreseeable psychiatric injury.
3. The court held that the defendant did not owe a duty of care to rescuers and onlookers to take reasonable care to avoid them suffering foreseeable mental harm.
4. The court held that the defendant did not owe a duty of care to the passengers on board the vessels to take reasonable care to avoid foreseeable loss of property.
5. The court held that the risk of the suspected illegal entry vessel becoming shipwrecked was a foreseeable risk.
6. The court held that the risk of the vessel becoming shipwrecked was not insignificant.
7. The court held that a reasonable public authority in the position of the defendant would have taken the precaution of not permitting other vessels to remain out of survey.
8. The court held that a reasonable public authority in the position of the defendant would have taken the precaution of returning an available vessel to patrol at the usual position of intercept of such vessels.
9. The court held that those in command of vessels engaged in the operation knew or had reason to suspect that a suspected illegal entry vessel was approaching Christmas Island from the north in poor weather and in distress at a particular time.
10. The court held that in response to the risk of a suspected illegal entry vessel becoming shipwrecked and finding itself in distress the defendant should have taken the precaution of attending upon the vessel to assist earlier than it did.
11. The court held that the vessel would not have become shipwrecked had the defendant taken other precautions.
12. The court held that as a result of the defendant becoming the owner of the vessel by virtue of statutory forfeiture, the defendant did not assume duties and responsibilities analogous to those owed by an occupier of premises to an entrant.
13. The court held that the defendant's servants or agents who were in command of nearby vessels did not owe a statutory duty and that any such duty owed was not breached.
14. The court held that by reason of the defendant's ownership of the vessel the defendant did not owe a statutory duty and that any such duty owed was not breached.
15. The court held that certain causes of action relied upon by the plaintiffs were outside the applicable limitation period.
16. The court held that the causes of action pleaded in a further amended statement of claim arose out of substantially the same set of facts as those originally pleaded.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered whether the defendant owed a duty of care to the passengers on board the vessels, their relatives, rescuers, and onlookers to take reasonable care to avoid foreseeable harm. The court found that no such duty existed based on the principle of policy considerations and the established precedent in Australian negligence law. The court then examined whether the risk of the vessel becoming shipwrecked was foreseeable, obvious, or inherent. It concluded that the risk was foreseeable and not insignificant. The court evaluated whether a reasonable public authority would have taken certain precautions in response to the foreseeable risk, finding that they would have. The court also assessed whether those in command of nearby vessels knew or had reason to suspect that the vessel was in distress and whether the defendant should have attended to the vessel earlier, concluding that they did and should have, respectively. The court determined that the vessel would not have become shipwrecked had the defendant taken other precautions. Regarding the defendant's ownership of the vessel by virtue of statutory forfeiture, the court held that no duties and responsibilities analogous to those owed by an occupier of premises to an entrant were assumed. The court further held that the defendant's servants or agents and the defendant itself did not owe a statutory duty or breach any such duty. Lastly, the court ruled that certain causes of action were outside the applicable limitation period and that the causes of action pleaded in the further amended statement of claim arose out of substantially the same set of facts as those originally pleaded.

In summary, the court found that the defendant did not owe a duty of care to the passengers, their relatives, rescuers, and onlookers to take reasonable care to avoid foreseeable harm. The court also held that the defendant's ownership of the vessel by virtue of statutory forfeiture did not result in the assumption of any duties or responsibilities analogous to those owed by an occupier of premises to an entrant, nor did it result in a breach of any statutory duty. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in circumstances where a suspected illegal entry vessel becomes shipwrecked, the defendant did not owe a duty of care to the passengers, their relatives, rescuers, and onlookers to take reasonable care to avoid foreseeable harm. Furthermore, the defendant's ownership of the vessel by virtue of statutory forfeiture did not result in the assumption of any duties or responsibilities analogous to those owed by an occupier of premises to an entrant, nor did it result in a breach of any statutory duty.