Roads and Traffic Authority (NSW) v Refrigerated Roadways Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:
Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW v Refrigerated Roadways Pty Limited [2009] NSWCA 263
This decision has been amended. Please see the end of the judgment for a list of the amendments.

FILE NUMBER(S):
40270/08

HEARING DATE(S):
11 & 12 March 2009

JUDGMENT DATE:
22 September 2009

PARTIES:
Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW (Appellant)
Refrigerated Roadways Pty Limited (Respondent)

JUDGMENT OF:
McColl JA Campbell JA Sackville AJA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):
4508/04

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:
Hungerford ADCJ

LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION:
2 June 2008

LOWER COURT MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:
Refrigerated Roadways Pty Ltd v Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW [2008] NSWDC 91

COUNSEL:
J Maconachie QC; P Perry (Appellant)
R Sheldon (Respondent)

SOLICITORS:
Crown Solicitor's Office, Sydney (Appellant)
Bartier Perry, Sydney (Respondent)

CATCHWORDS:
TORTS – negligence – breach of duty – standard of care for a statutory authority – whether a court should take account of the budgetary constraints and competing priorities of a statutory authority – distinction between policy and operational decisions – relevance to whether a decision can be made that a roads authority failed to take reasonable care - TORTS – negligence – breach of duty – standard of care – nature of the question of whether there has been a failure to exercise reasonable care – question must be one that can be answered by a jury – relevance of the fact that the statutory authority carries out activities with no private analogue – relevance of budgetary constraints and competing priorities - TORTS – negligence – duty of care – whether duty of care of a roads authority extends to the taking of reasonable care to prevent harm to motorists resulting from the criminal conduct of others – whether duty of care is owed in the exercise of a statutory duty - TORTS – negligence – breach of duty – section 42 Civil Liability Act 2002 – whether the section prohibits allegations of negligence in general or particular allegations of negligence – nature of the particular allegation of negligence prohibited – meaning of “functions” – meaning of “general allocation” – meaning of “resources reasonably available to the authority” - TORTS – negligence – breach of duty – section 43A Civil Liability Act 2002 – type of “reasonableness” involved – need for a “special statutory power”

LEGISLATION CITED:
Civil Liability (Personal Responsibility) Act 2002
Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW)
Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld)
Civil Liability Amendment Act 2003
Constitution Act 1902
Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979
Environmental Planning and Assessment Regulation 1994
Environmental Planning and Assessment Regulation 2000
Local Government Act 1919
Mental Health Act 1990
Roads Act 1993
Transport Administration Act 1988
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005
Workers Compensation Act 1987

CATEGORY:
Principal judgment

CASES CITED:
Adeels Palace Pty Ltd v Moubarak [2009] NSWCA 29; [2009] Aust Torts Reports 81-997 (62,722).
Aiken v Kingborough Corporation (1939) 62 CLR 179
Alcock v Fergie (1867) 4 WW & a’B…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Roads and Traffic Authority (NSW) v Refrigerated Roadways Pt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NSWCA 263
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a decision of the District Court of New South Wales, which found the Roads and Traffic Authority (RTA) liable to indemnify Refrigerated Roadways Pty Ltd for workers' compensation payments made following the death of an employee, Mr Evans. Mr Evans died when a rock was dropped from the Glenlee Bridge onto the F5 freeway below, causing his vehicle to crash. Refrigerated Roadways sought indemnity from the RTA, arguing that the RTA owed a duty of care to motorists and had breached that duty by failing to take reasonable steps to prevent such incidents.

The central legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the RTA owed a duty of care to motorists to prevent harm arising from criminal conduct, such as objects being thrown from bridges, and if so, whether this duty had been breached. This involved considering the standard of care expected of a statutory authority, the relevance of budgetary constraints and competing priorities, and the distinction between policy and operational decisions. The court also had to determine the application of sections 42 and 43A of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) to the RTA's conduct.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, setting aside the judgment of the court below. The court reasoned that the RTA's duty of care did not extend to taking reasonable care to prevent harm to motorists resulting from the criminal conduct of third parties. While acknowledging that a roads authority owes a duty of care to motorists, the court found that the specific allegation of negligence in this case, relating to the failure to install screening on bridges to prevent objects being thrown, was not a matter that could be answered by a jury in the context of a negligence claim against a statutory authority. The court also considered the evidence regarding prior incidents and the RTA's response, but ultimately concluded that no breach of duty had been established, particularly in light of the provisions of the Civil Liability Act.

Consequently, the Court of Appeal ordered that the proceedings be dismissed and that Refrigerated Roadways Pty Ltd pay the RTA's costs of the appeal and the proceedings below.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed

2. Set aside the judgment and orders in the court below

3. In lieu thereof, order that the proceedings be dismissed with costs

4. Order Respondent to pay Appellant’s costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

When there is no breach of duty, the question that was argued about causation of loss does not arise. The Types of Evidence Called The case of the Respondent in the court below consisted of calling an expert witness on the topic of crash investigation, Mr John Jamieson, and tendering documents, many of which were derived from the records of the RTA. The case of the RTA in the court below consisted of calling evidence from various RTA officers who had been involved in the RTA’s activities relating to bridges over freeways, expert evidence from Mr Bruce Fishburn (an engineer) and Professor White (a criminologist), and tender of further documents, again mainly from RTA internal records.Some Relevant Roads and Bridges Details of several freeways around the Sydney region other than the F5 appear in the evidence. These include the F3, the M4, the M5, and the M2. There are eight bridges over the F5 in the Campbelltown region. As one proceeds south along the F5, there is a bridge that carries Campbelltown Road over the F5 near Prestons and Glenfield, another at Brooks Road, then a bridge that carries Campbelltown Road over the F5 between Ingleburn and Minto, then the St Andrews bridge, then the Raby Road bridge, then a bridge that carries Narellan Road over the F5 at Mt Annan, then one comes to the Glenlee Bridge and finally the Menangle Road bridge.Knowledge of the Problem of Items Dropped from Overpasses Mr Bruce Fishburn is an engineer who had previously worked for the DMR and then the RTA, but had become a consultant in private practice by the time of the hearing. He gave both expert and lay evidence. He had responsibility for the erection of the Glenlee Bridge. He was unaware of any incidents involving items thrown from an overpass to the freeway below until about 1994. Analysis of the RTA’s internal documentation assembled for the purpose of this case shows the following concerning the period before Mr Evans’ death:(a)On 17 February 1990 a bag full of sand was dropped from the Mount Kiera Road overpass onto a vehicle on the F5 freeway, resulting in lacerations to the arm of the driver.(b)When the first stages of the M5 motorway were opened in 1992 numerous incidents occurred of objects being dropped from bridges over it.(c)On 2 April 1992 Mr Ron Clayton wrote to the RTA saying that on 28 March 1992 a plastic bag filled with water and eggs was thrown at the windscreen of his vehicle, and three other vehicles, while they were travelling on the Hume Highway between Campbelltown and Liverpool. His letter concluded:“It is extremely disappointing at a time when the NSW RTA is Blitzing nearly every vehicle that moves on the States[’] Roads that they cannot protect motorists from harm and damage through the use of their structures for people to launch missiles. Fortunately in Victoria the RTA saw the error of these structures and erected high wire fences on all Freeway Overhead bridges. I only hope that something can be done about this sort of thing before someone is killed.”An RTA officer replied to Mr Clayton, saying:“No other cases have been reported to the Authority of any person or persons throwing objects from the bridge to which you refer or other bridges on the Freeway.The provision of preventative fencing on bridges along the road could not be justified at this time. However, the Authority will continue to monitor the situation and liaise with the Police Department.”(d)On 16 October 1992 a rock was thrown by “juveniles” from the River Road overpass onto a vehicle travelling on the M5 freeway, injuring the driver.(e)On 8 February 1993 Mr Glen Morgan of the RTA wrote to another RTA officer, saying:“Have discussed these incidents with Picton Police. They indicate that there is a real problem along the freeway in this area & Campbelltown. Suggest discussions with Police or at Traffic Committees to develop strategy.”(f)On 22 July 1993 a concrete block was dropped by “unknown persons” from the Avon Dam Road overpass bridge into the path of a vehicle travelling on the F5.(g)On 24 September 1993 a Mr Saville wrote to the Premier, who was also his Local Member of Parliament, Mr John Fahey. Mr Saville complained that he was the driver of one of three cars damaged when rocks were dropped on the southern expressway from an overpass “near Glen Alpine, several kilometres south of Campbelltown”. That overpass is conceded to be the Glenlee Bridge. His letter continued:“The Campbelltown police officers who were called to the scene were familiar with this form of madness. The only thing that surprised them was that it usually happened closer to Campbelltown. The tow truck driver had had a log dropped on his truck further down the highway and the claims clerk with whom I spoke this morning had seen a similar occurrence on the Central Coast.”Mr Fahey passed this complaint on to the RTA. The Director of the RTA replied to Mr Fahey on 26 October 1993, saying:“Unfortunately there is little the Authority can do. The enclosure of bridges with wire mesh is only practicable in the case of pedestrian bridges. On the M5 only the pedestrian bridge at Mackenzie Street has been treated in this way.On vehicle bridges the height of fencing required may impose loadings on the bridges which they have not been designed to withstand. Given the large number of overhead bridges on the road network any such treatment program would be hugely expensive, and no doubt in the view of many aesthetically undesirable, with no guarantee that it would ultimately deter those determined to carry out these senseless activities.”The reference to “enclosure” of bridges with wire mesh refers to their total enclosure, not to the erection of protective screens at the side.(h)In 1994 the dropping of an object from an overbridge in Victoria caused a fatality. This incident became known to the RTA in NSW. So far as the evidence discloses, it was the first death resulting from this sort of activity in Australia.(i)In March, September and December 1994 there were separate incidents of rocks being dropped from overpasses at three separate Sydney locations (none of which was on the F5) resulting in vehicle damage.(j)In January 1995 a rock was dropped onto the M5, causing a vehicle to overturn. The finding was “RTA and Minister then advising that pedestrian bridges were not being considered”. I take that cryptic statement to mean that screening of pedestrian bridges was not being considered.(k)In April 1995 there were three separate instances, on three different Sydney roads (not including the F5) in which objects were dropped and either the driver was injured or the windscreen was broken.(l)In May 1995 the RTA received a report of an incident that had occurred in March 1994 when an object was dropped from a bridge on the M4, damaging the vehicle.(m)In June 1995 the RTA received a letter from a motorist complaining that on 20 January 1995, while driving along the F5 in a southerly direction, his vehicle was hit by a rock thrown from the Campbelltown Road overpass. The letter stated:“Why the RTA does not install safety net? Before someone gets killed. I am very lucky person to be alive.”(n)In August 1995 there was an incident involving a rock on the M4 at Pomeroy Street, in which a window was broken.(o)In October 1995 there was an incident at a bridge on the M4 that resulted in a window being broken.(p)In October 1995 a pipe was suspended from a bridge on the M4.(q)In January 1996 a brick was dropped from the Raby Road, Campbelltown overbridge and through the windscreen of a vehicle travelling on the F5.(r)There were two incidents in February 1996, one in March 1996, one in April 1996, one in June 1996, one in September 1996, one in February 1997, one in May 1997, one in December 1997, and one April 1998 causing either injury to the driver, windscreen damage or other vehicular damage.(s)An RTA ministerial briefing note dated 24 January 1996 reports that in the year prior to 24 January 1996 there were seven incidents known to the RTA when objects were intentionally thrown from an overbridge onto vehicles travelling beneath. Motorists were injured in three of those incidents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It was only after making the factual findings in [60] that the judge turned to any comparison of expert evidence in the case. He accepted Mr Jamieson’s criticism of the risk analysis and priority rating exercise “as not being based on any formal risk engineering principles but more on a subjective process by the rater.” His only reference to the RTA’s expert engineering evidence was (at [64]):“Mr Fishburn presented a very detailed and comprehensive report dated 1 May 2007 in which he attended to financial restrictions placed on the defendant in maintaining and upgrading the F5, the system in place prior to August 1998 for the construction of screens over the F5, the priority system and criteria used, any undue delay in screening and the defendant’s reaction to the dropping of objects from the Glenlee Bridge on 10 August 1998. Mr Fishburn reasoned that the defendant’s risk management technique ‘was a very good method to use’ and that generally its response to the problem was reasonable for a prudent road authority to take. It will be apparent from my findings that I do not accept Mr Fishburn’s views.”Decision About Negligence in the Evaluation Process I do not accept that it has been shown that it was more likely than not that the evaluation matrix “was flawed”. Mr Jamieson’s evidence did not explain how such views as he expressed were based upon any established body of knowledge, or on any experience that he had. He ultimately accepted that his view that isolated locations were more risky than populated, and the opposing view that a higher risk should be attributed to areas near schools, could each be open. I do not accept that it has been established that there was any failure to proceed as a reasonable authority would have proceeded by not treating the Glenlee Bridge as one that had pedestrian access. There was no expert evidence to that effect. The fact that a bridge carries a road over a freeway will always bring about some risk that an object might be dropped from the bridge. That a bridge is included in the evaluation matrix at all recognises that that risk exists. What Mr Onggo’s methodology did, by allocating points to the fact that there was a walkway or footpath for pedestrians, was to evaluate the extra risk that would arise from pedestrians crossing the bridge in the course of their ordinary activities, as they would have a greater tendency to do if the bridge were solely a pedestrian bridge, or a bridge that made special provision for pedestrians to cross it by having a pedestrian walkway on it. Mr Onggo was wrong in assigning a score of zero to the Glenlee Bridge for “history of incidents/graffiti”.At least a significant part of the history of incidents at that bridge was already contained in the RTA’s files, as the evidence tendered in this case demonstrated. No satisfactory explanation has been given of how it came about that the data that was relevant to the exercise Mr Onggo was undertaking was not collected from the RTA’s own files.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

At the time of the accident, and at all times since the commencement of the Transport Administration Act 1988 the Appellant (the “RTA”) had the care and control of the Glenlee Bridge and the Hume Highway at Menangle below the bridge. The Glenlee Bridge was constructed by a statutory predecessor of the RTA, the Commissioner for Main Roads (“DMR”). Design work for the Glenlee Bridge appears, from the date on a plan in evidence, to have been carried out in and about June 1975. While the evidence is not precise about when construction occurred, its construction had been completed by June 1978. Mr Evans’ widow and children did not take any action for damages against the RTA. In the court, below the Respondent sued the RTA contending that Mr Evans’ death arose in circumstances that created a liability on the part of the RTA to pay damages to the widow and children. In consequence, the Respondent contended, it was entitled, pursuant to section 151Z(1)(d) Workers Compensation Act, to indemnity from the RTA for the payments of workers’ compensation made, plus interest on the death benefit component of compensation. The trial proceeded on the basis that if the RTA had a liability to the widow and children the damages recoverable by them would be approximately $710,000. The trial proceeded on the basis that, as the total amount of compensation plus interest for which the Respondent sought indemnity was less than $710,000, there was no occasion for the trial judge to quantify the amount of damages to which the widow and children would have been entitled with any greater precision than this. Adopting that basis was contrary to the principle that a trial judge hearing the first application for an indemnity under section 151Z(1)(d) should determine the quantum of damages to which the worker (or those claiming under him), would have been entitled if the worker, or those claiming under him, had sued: Grant v Royal Rehabilitation Centre Sydney [1999] NSWCA 250; (1999) 47 NSWLR 263. The obvious purpose of this is that, where there are continuing payments of workers’ compensation being made, the amount of damages to which the worker or those claiming under him or her would have been entitled, will provide the basis for calculating the maximum amount of indemnity that will become payable in the future concerning those ongoing payments. The error in proceeding in this way at the trial does not affect the outcome of this appeal. His Honour Judge Hungerford ADCJ found that the RTA was liable to indemnify the Respondent for the amount it claimed: Refrigerated Roadways Pty Ltd v Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW [2008] NSWDC 91; (2008) 7 DCLR(NSW) 45. The RTA appeals against the finding of liability in the court below. The issues argued on the appeal were:(1)Even though the RTA admits it owes a duty of care to motorists of the type described in Brodie v Singleton Shire Council [2001] HCA 29; (2001) 206 CLR 512, whether its duty extends to requiring it, either at the time of construction of the Glenlee Bridge or later, to take reasonable care that motorists not be injured by criminal behaviour like that involved in rocks being thrown or dropped from an overhead bridge onto a freeway.(2)If such a duty existed, whether the RTA breached it in the present case (bearing in mind section 42 Civil Liability Act 2002) by either (a)not having installed screening on the bridge when it was first constructed, or(b)not having retrofitted screening to the bridge prior to 23 August 1998.There are several sub-issues to these issues concerning breach of duty:(1)Whether the judge was right in making a number of findings that he described as findings of fact.(2)What, if any, significance there is in any limitations on the RTA’s ability to spend money or the usual way in which the RTA obtained money to spend on the F5.(3)Whether it is open to the RTA to rely on section 43A Civil Liability Act in this appeal, and if so what, if any, difference section 43A makes to the result that would otherwise arise.(4)Whether it is open to the Respondent to rely in the appeal on a particular of negligence that had not been pleaded concerning the manner in which RTA decided the order of priority in which bridges should be screened.(3)Whether any breach of duty by the RTA caused Mr Evans’ death.Summary of Decision Reached