Collingwood Hotel Pty Ltd v O'Reilly

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      COLLINGWOOD HOTEL PTY LTD v O'REILLY; NIGHT KNOWLEDGE SECURITY PTY LTD v O'REILLY [2007]  NSWCA 155

FILE NUMBER(S):
40333/06
40363/06

HEARING DATE(S):               30 April 2007

JUDGMENT DATE: 27 June 2007

PARTIES:
CA 40333/06
Collingwood Hotel Pty Ltd - First Appellant
Rex Porter - Second Appellant
Vanessa O'Reilly - First Respondent
Night Knowledge Security Pty Ltd - Second Respondent
CA 40363/06
Night Knowledge Security Pty Ltd - Appellant
Vanessa O'Reilly - First Respondent
Collingwood Hotel Pty Ltd - Second Respondent
Rex Porter - Third Respondent

JUDGMENT OF:       Tobias JA Basten JA Handley AJA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          DC 4079/04

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Ashford DCJ

LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION:    2 June 2006

COUNSEL:
G. Curtin – Appellants (40333/06); Second and Third Respondents (40363/06
D.L. Williams SC/D. Priestley – Second Respondent (40333/06); Appellant (40363/06)
S. Norton SC/E.E. Welsh – First Respondent (40333/06 and 40363/06)

SOLICITORS:
Griffin Hilditch – (Collingwood Hotel Pty Ltd and Rex Porter)
Thomson Playford – (Night Knowledge Security Pty Ltd)
Brydens Law Office – (Vanessa O’Reilly)

CATCHWORDS:
NEGLIGENCE – duty of care – duty of occupier and licensee of hotel to patrons on licensed premises – duty of security guards to patrons of licensed premises
NEGLIGENCE – breach – whether hotel staff should have informed security guards that patrons had been refused service of alcohol – whether security guards should have attended to patron injured in fight – whether risk of fight breaking out was reasonably foreseeable
NEGLIGENCE – causation – whether failure to take steps to prevent fight caused the plaintiff’s injury

LEGISLATION CITED:
Liquor Act 1982 (NSW), ss 103, 125
Supreme Court Rules 1970 (NSW), Pt 51, r33(d)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r36.11

CASES CITED:
Bennett v Minister of Community Welfare (1992) 176 CLR 408
Chappel v Hart (1998) 195 CLR 232
Chordas v Bryant (Wellington) Pty Ltd (1988) 20 FCR 91 (FCAFC)
Elbourne v Gibbs [2006] NSWCA 127
Glynn v Challenge Recruitment Australia Pty Ltd [2006] NSWCA 203
John Pfeiffer Pty Ltd v Canny (1981) 148 CLR 218
Naxakis v Western General Hospital (1999) 197 CLR 269
Oxley County Council v Macdonald [1999] NSWCA 126
Rosenberg v Percival (2001) 205 CLR 434
Seltsam Pty Ltd v McGuiness (2000) 49 NSWLR 262
Spedding v Nobles; Spedding v McNally [2007] NSWCA 29
Speirs v Caledonian Collieries Ltd & Fenwick (1957) 57 SR (NSW) 483
Sutherland Shire Council v Heyman (1985) 157 CLR 424
The Bywell Castle (1879) 4 PD 219
Timberland Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Bundy [2005] NSWCA 419
Wagstaff v Haslam and Anor [2007] NSWCA 28

DECISION:
In relation to matter 40333 of 2006 (the appeal by Collingwood Hotel Pty Ltd and Rex Porter)
(1)  Allow the appeal and set aside the judgment and orders of the District Court given and made on 2 June 2006
(2)  In lieu thereof
      (a)  give judgment for the first and second defendants against the plaintiff
      (b)  order the plaintiff to pay the costs of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Collingwood Hotel Pty Ltd v O'Reilly and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWCA 155
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved an appeal to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales by Collingwood Hotel Pty Ltd and Night Knowledge Security Pty Ltd (the appellants) against a judgment of the District Court. The respondent, Ms O'Reilly, had brought proceedings alleging negligence against the appellants, arising from injuries sustained during a fight at the Collingwood Hotel. The core of the dispute concerned whether the hotel and its security staff had breached their duty of care to patrons by failing to take reasonable steps to prevent the fight or to intervene effectively.

The legal issues before the Court of Appeal included whether the trial judge had erred in finding the appellants liable for negligence. Specifically, the court was required to determine if the hotel and security personnel owed a duty of care to patrons, if that duty had been breached by failing to inform security of patrons refused alcohol service or by not attending to an injured patron, and whether any such breach caused the plaintiff's injuries. The court also considered the foreseeability of the risk of a fight breaking out and the adequacy of the evidence presented to establish these elements.

The Court of Appeal found that the factual findings of the trial judge did not support an ultimate finding of liability against any of the defendants. The court reasoned that the trial judge had failed to identify with sufficient precision the specific manner in which the relevant duties of care had been breached by either the hotel or the security company. Furthermore, the court concluded that the evidence presented at trial was insufficient to establish a relevant breach of duty that had a causal connection to the plaintiff's injury. Consequently, the court determined that a retrial was not warranted due to this lack of evidence.

The Court of Appeal allowed both appeals, setting aside the judgment and orders of the District Court. Judgment was entered for the appellants against the plaintiff, and the plaintiff was ordered to pay the costs of the trial. The court also ordered the plaintiff to pay the appellants' costs of the appeal, while making no order as to the costs of the other respondent in each appeal. The plaintiff was granted a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 (NSW).

Orders

Orders of the court

In relation to matter 40333 of 2006 (the appeal by Collingwood Hotel Pty Ltd and Rex Porter);

(1) Allow the appeal and set aside the judgment and orders of the District Court given and made on 2 June 2006;

(2) In lieu thereof;

(a) give judgment for the first and second defendants against the plaintiff;

(b) order the plaintiff to pay the costs of the first and second defendants of the trial, and;

(c) dismiss the cross-claim of the first and second defendants, as against the third defendant, with no order as to costs;

(3) Order the First Respondent (Ms O'Reilly) to pay the Appellants' costs of the appeal, but make no order as to the costs of the Second Respondent (Night Knowledge Security Pty Ltd) of the appeal;

(4) Grant the First Respondent a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 (NSW).

In relation to matter 40363 of 2006 (the appeal by Night Knowledge Security Pty Ltd);

(1) Allow the appeal and set aside the judgment and orders of the District Court given and made on 2 June 2006;

(2) In lieu thereof;

(a) give judgment for the third defendant against the plaintiff;

(b) order the plaintiff to pay the costs of the third defendant of the trial, and;

(c) dismiss the cross-claim of the third defendant, as against the first and second defendants, with no order as to costs;

(3) Order the First Respondent (Ms O'Reilly) to pay the Appellant's costs of the appeal, but make no order as to the costs of the Second Respondent (Collingwood Hotel Pty Ltd) of the appeal;

(4) Grant the First Respondent a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 (NSW).

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Security did not contest the proposition that it owed a duty of care to patrons in the hotel, nor that there was a foreseeable risk of harm to patrons if there were an outbreak of violent behaviour. Accordingly, Security, through its employees, had a duty, not to ensure the safety of patrons (as was pleaded), but to take reasonable measures to protect them from foreseeable harm. Those measures included, but were not limited to, taking steps to “turn out” patrons from whom violent conduct ought reasonably to have been anticipated. These principles were not in doubt: the issues in the case turned largely on their application in the circumstances revealed by the evidence, subject to one qualification with respect to the proper approach to causation which is more conveniently discussed after the facts have been considered.Evidence: overview The trial judge was required to determine the events of the evening by reference to the evidence of three primary witnesses. These were the plaintiff herself, Ms Amy van Huyssen, a young woman working behind the bar, and Mr Paulo Lafaele, one of the security guards. The accounts given by these witnesses reflected their differing perspectives on the events as they unfolded. There were at the time four security guards on duty at the hotel, each in uniform. One, it appears, was on duty in the car park and appears not to have been involved in the activities in the front (or public) bar which preceded the injury to the plaintiff. A second security guard, Mr Suameli Levao, who appears to have been the responsible officer of Security on the night (Tcpt, 23 May 2006, p 16), and who was also said to be present in the public bar at the time of the fracas, did not give evidence, because he could not be located. However, Mr Levao prepared a written report for the director of Security, Mr Dione Blissett, which was included in a letter written by Mr Blissett to the Hotel. Somewhat curiously, this document was tendered by the plaintiff in reply, without objection. Apart from Ms van Huyssen, there were three other employees of the Hotel who played some part in the events of the evening, but were not called. Seemingly, the most junior was Ms Emma Salmon, who was also working in the public bar and witnessed the first assault. Her evidence consisted of a brief handwritten statement, also tendered by the plaintiff in reply, without objection. In addition to the two bar attendants, there was a third employee, Mr Chris Dower, who appears to have been in what was variously described as “the casino” and the “gaming lounge” at the time of the first incident, but who entered the public bar when he heard someone screaming “call a bloody ambulance”. He returned to the gaming lounge before the second fracas broke out. His statement was tendered by the plaintiff, at the close of her case. Finally, the person who appears to have been hotel manager on the night in question, identified as Mr Justin Penny, was upstairs at the time of the events in question but, according to Ms van Huyssen, came downstairs and spoke with her between the two fights: Tcpt, 23 May 2006, p 33. Ms Genevieve Porter, who agreed that she, together with her husband, was an ‘owner’ of the Collingwood Hotel stated that both Mr Dower and Mr Penny were still working for her at the date of the trial. Mr Blissett, the director of Security, also continued at the date of the trial to provide security services at the hotel, although it appears that Security itself may have been in liquidation and the services provided through another company.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Reliance on the dictum of Gaudron J in Bennett should not be taken so far as to undermine well-established principle. Nor does it assist the plaintiff in the present case, in the absence of a finding as to what the precise breach was in relation to each of the defendants. On the other hand, the difficulty in establishing the precise breach may reflect a difficulty in establishing causation. As Brennan J noted in Canny in relation to duty, breach and consequential damage, “in a given case, each element can be defined only in terms of the others”: pp 241-242.Conclusions In my view, the factual findings made by the trial judge did not warrant an ultimate finding of liability on the part of any of the defendants. That is not merely because her Honour failed to make a relevant finding as to causation in relation to the respective breaches of duty: it is because her Honour failed to identify with adequate precision the manner in which the relevant duties had been breached. That conclusion leads to a question whether this Court can make any relevant findings, or whether there should be a retrial, or whether the Appellants are entitled to judgments in their favour. It is not possible for this Court to make relevant findings on the evidence. Accepting that, to the extent it is unfavourable to the plaintiff’s case, the evidence of Mr Lafaele should not be accepted, there remains a paucity of evidence upon which to make relevant findings. That is not because of any inconsistency between the evidence of the plaintiff and other witnesses, but because the attention of the plaintiff was directed to specific matters, including the state of health of the injured man. As a result, she did not, understandably, observe all of the actions of the hotel staff or the security guards. Nor did she give evidence of any relevant behaviour before the first fight which might lead to the inference that steps should reasonably have been taken, which were not, for the safety of patrons. Nor does the plaintiff gain sufficient assistance from the third witness to the events of the evening, Ms van Huyssen. Although the plaintiff argued, on the appeal, that if there were error in her Honour’s judgment, the only proper order was a retrial, such an order would not be appropriate if the evidence called at trial was insufficient to establish a relevant breach of duty on the part of either the Hotel or Security. In my view, for the reasons given, the evidence failed to demonstrate relevant breaches which might have a causal connection with the injury suffered. The plaintiff is not entitled to a second trial to attempt to make good the lack of such evidence. I would propose the following orders:In relation to matter 40333 of 2006 (the appeal by Collingwood Hotel Pty Ltd and Rex Porter):(1)Allow the appeal and set aside the judgment and orders of the District Court given and made on 2 June 2006.(2)In lieu thereof:(a)give judgment for the first and second defendants against the plaintiff;(b)order the plaintiff to pay the costs of the first and second defendants of the trial, and(c)dismiss the cross-claim of the first and second defendants, as against the third defendant, with no order as to costs.(3)Order the First Respondent (Ms O’Reilly) to pay the Appellants’ costs of the appeal, but make no order as to the costs of the Second Respondent (Night Knowledge Security Pty Ltd) of the appeal.(4)Grant the First Respondent a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951 (NSW).In relation to matter 40363 of 2006 (the appeal by Night Knowledge Security Pty Ltd):(1)Allow the appeal and set aside the judgment and orders of the District Court given and made on 2 June 2006.(2)In lieu thereof:(a)give judgment for the third defendant against the plaintiff;(b)order the plaintiff to pay the costs of the third defendant of the trial;(c)dismiss the cross-claim of the third defendant, as against the first and second defendants, with no order as to costs.(3)Order the First Respondent (Ms O’Reilly) to pay the Appellant’s costs of the appeal, but make no order as to the costs of the Second Respondent (Collingwood Hotel Pty Ltd) of the appeal.(3)Grant the First Respondent a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951 (NSW).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.