Rooty Hill RSL Club Ltd v Karimi

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:
Rooty Hill RSL Club Ltd v Karimi  [2009] NSWCA 2

FILE NUMBER(S):
40623/07
40626/07

HEARING DATE(S):
18/9/08

JUDGMENT DATE:
30 January 2009

PARTIES:
Allied Security Group Pty Ltd (Appellant)
Tarique Karimi by his tutor Qudsia Askarzada (First Respondent)
Rooty Hill RSL Club Limited (Second Respondent)

JUDGMENT OF:
Allsop P Basten JA Bell JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
Supreme Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):
20092/06

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:
Grove J

LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION:
24/8/07

COUNSEL:
Mr SG Campbell SC / Mr AB Parker (Appellant/Allied Security)
Mr PJ Doherty SC / Mr P Biggins (First Respondent/Karimi)
Mr ML Williams SC / Mr RC Scruby (Second Respondent/Rooty Hill RSL)

SOLICITORS:
Curwoods Lawyers (Appellant/Allied Security)
David Legal (First Respondent/Karimi)
McCabe Terrill Lawyers (Second Respondent/Rooty Hill RSL)

CATCHWORDS:
ASSOCIATIONS AND CLUBS – occupier of licensed premises – duty to patron – club security standard operating procedures – policy that all parties to dispute evicted without assessment of aggressor’s identity – whether club delegated responsibility for security of patrons to security firm
NEGLIGENCE – duty of care owed by occupier of licensed premises to patron – assault by another patron – breach of duty of care – plaintiff and third defendant evicted from club through separate entrances after altercation – whether reasonably foreseeable that third defendant might return and assault plaintiff – security guards’ assessment of third defendant’s condition – additional steps available but not taken – whether conduct unreasonable

LEGISLATION CITED:
Evidence Act 1995 (NSW)
Registered Clubs Act 1976 (NSW)

CATEGORY:
Principal judgment

CASES CITED:
Chordas v Bryant (Wellington) Pty Ltd [1988] FCA 462; (1988) 20 FCR 91
Collingwood Hotel Pty Ltd v O’Reilly [2007] NSWCA 155
Modbury Triangle Shopping Centre Pty Ltd v Anzil [2000] HCA 61; (2000) 205 CLR 254
Newcastle Entertainment Security Pty Ltd v Simpson [1999] NSWCA 351; (1999) Aust Torts Reports 81-528
Oxlade v Gosbridge [1998] NSWCA 167; (Court of Appeal, 18 December 1998, unreported)
Roads and Traffic Authority of New South Wales v Dederer [2007] HCA 42; (2007) 234 CLR 330
Spedding v Nobles [2007] NSWCA 29; (2007) 69 NSWLR 100
Vairy v Wyong Shire Council [2005] HCA 62; 223 CLR 422
Wagstaff v Haslam [2007] NSWCA 28; 69 NSWLR 1

TEXTS CITED:

DECISION:
In proceedings CA 40626 of 2007 (the appeal by Rooty Hill RSL Club):
(1) Grant leave to appeal.
(2) Direct that the draft Notice of Appeal be treated as if filed pursuant to leave.
(3) Allow the appeal and set aside the judgment and orders made by the primary judge on 24 August 2007. 
(4) In lieu thereof:
(a) Judgment for the first defendant, Rooty Hill RSL Club, against the plaintiff Tarique Karimi;
(b) Order the plaintiff to pay the costs of the first defendant of the trial;
(c) Dismiss the cross-claim brought by the first defendant against the second defendant with no order as to costs.
(5) Order the first respondent, Tarique Karimi, to pay the appellant’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rooty Hill RSL Club Ltd v Karimi and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NSWCA 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved an appeal by Rooty Hill RSL Club Ltd and Allied Security Group Pty Ltd against a primary judge's decision concerning a patron, Mr. Karimi, who was assaulted after being evicted from the club. Mr. Karimi had been involved in an altercation and was removed from the premises by security. The club had a policy of evicting all parties involved in a dispute without assessing individual culpability. The legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the club, as the occupier of licensed premises, owed a duty of care to Mr. Karimi, and if so, whether that duty was breached, leading to his subsequent assault.

The Court of Appeal considered the duty of care owed by an occupier of licensed premises to its patrons. It examined whether it was reasonably foreseeable that the third party, who was also evicted, might return and assault Mr. Karimi. The court analysed the actions of the security guards, including their assessment of the third party's condition and whether additional steps, which were available but not taken, should have been implemented to prevent the assault. The court also considered the extent to which the club had delegated its security responsibilities to the security firm.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeals, setting aside the primary judge's judgment. It found that the club had not breached its duty of care to Mr. Karimi. Consequently, judgment was entered for the first defendant, Rooty Hill RSL Club, against the plaintiff, Mr. Karimi, and Mr. Karimi was ordered to pay the club's costs of the trial. The cross-claim brought by the club against the second defendant, Allied Security Group, was dismissed. Mr. Karimi was ordered to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

In proceedings CA 40626 of 2007 (the appeal by Rooty Hill RSL Club): (1) Grant leave to appeal. (2) Direct that the draft Notice of Appeal be treated as if filed pursuant to leave. (3) Allow the appeal and set aside the judgment and orders made by the primary judge on 24 August 2007. (4) In lieu thereof: (a) Judgment for the first defendant, Rooty Hill RSL Club, against the plaintiff Tarique Karimi; (b) Order the plaintiff to pay the costs of the first defendant of the trial; (c) Dismiss the cross-claim brought by the first defendant against the second defendant with no order as to costs. (5) Order the first respondent, Tarique Karimi, to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal and make no order as to the costs of the second respondent, Allied Security Group. (6) Grant the first respondent a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 (NSW). In relation to proceedings CA 40623 of 2007 (the appeal by Allied Security Group Pty Ltd): (1) Grant leave to appeal. (2) Direct that the draft Notice of Appeal be treated as if filed pursuant to leave. (3) Allow the appeal and set aside the judgment and orders of the primary judge made on 24 August 2007; (4) In lieu thereof: (a) Judgment for the second defendant against the plaintiff; (b) The plaintiff to pay the second defendant's costs of the trial; (3) The first respondent to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal, and no order as to the costs of the second respondent of the appeal. (4) Grant the first respondent a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 (NSW).

Background

Background to the litigation

The orders made in consequence of the determination of the separate question are interlocutory. The Club and Allied sought leave to appeal against them. The leave application was heard concurrently with the appeal. It is appropriate that leave be granted to bring each appeal.The factual background It appears that Mr Karimi has no memory of the events of the evening. He did not give evidence. Oral evidence was led in his case from Ali Baryalei, who was one of his companions; Michael Newson, a security guard employed by Allied who had been on duty at the time of these events; Brett Dale, one of the Club’s first aid officers; Ms Cameron and Richard Jennings, a security consultant. The Club called no evidence. Allied led evidence from the three security guards who were involved in the removal of Mr Smith from the Club that night; Mr Pale-Eli; Mr Scholes and Mr Peterson. His Honour appears to have accepted the evidence of each of the witnesses save that of Ms Cameron, whom he found to be unreliable. Nothing turns on the rejection of her account. The facts were largely uncontroversial. In addition to the oral evidence, there were documents in evidence which contained contemporaneous accounts of the initial incident and its aftermath, which included an incident report prepared by Mr Namrawi, the security guard responsible for Mr Karimi’s removal from the Club (Exhibit “M”); an incident report prepared by Mr Pale-Eli, the security guard responsible for Mr Smith’s removal from the Club (Exhibit “N”); a typed, fuller, incident report submitted to the Club by Allied (Exhibit “O”); and an incident report prepared by Mr Avery, one of the Club’s first aid officers (Exhibit “F”). A recording taken by the Club’s security cameras showing the interaction between Mr Smith and security staff inside the Club and on the front footpath, and the interaction between Mr Karimi and security staff at the western foyer, was also in evidence (Exhibit “J”). The Club is one of the largest licensed clubs in New South Wales and has over 48,000 members. On a busy Saturday night, such as this one was, there would have been several hundred people in the Club. The complex includes bars, restaurants, theatres, dance facilities, a fitness/aquatic centre, a TAB lounge and gaming area. The building is constructed on a north-south axis. At the northern end a motel belonging to the Holiday Inn chain adjoins it. Glass doors give out onto the western foyer and a ramp with five steps at either end leads down to the western car park. There are entrances to the car park at the northern and southern ends. The northern entrance is closed late at night. The evidence did not establish whether it was open or closed at the time of these events. The eastern entrance to the Club gives out onto Sherbrooke Street. The front car park is located on the opposite side of Sherbrooke Street. Allied security guards patrolled inside the Club and an external team of Allied guards patrolled the outside of the complex including the car parks. Allied security staff wore uniforms bearing the Rooty Hill RSL Club emblem. They were equipped with two-way radios which enabled them to communicate with one another via the operator in the control room. The staff in the control room were also Allied employees. They controlled the security cameras which were located throughout the complex. Screens in the control room displayed images taken by the security cameras. In the event of an incident the control room operator was able to move the camera in order to film the incident. Security cameras were located in the western car park but the evidence did not disclose whether they could be trained on the entrances to it.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.