Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Giusida Pty Limited v Commissioner for ACT Revenue

Citation:

[2016] ACTSC 275

Hearing Date(s):

25 September 2014 and 24 February 2015

DecisionDate:

21 September 2016

Before:

Refshauge ACJ

Decision:

1.   Leave should be granted to Giusida Pty Limited to appeal against the decision in Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2014] ACAT 50 each of the questions set out in its draft Notice of Appeal except Question 5.

2.   The costs of a grant of leave should ordinarily be costs in the appeal, subject to the reservation that the costs of the adjournment should be paid by the Applicant.

3.   The parties be heard as to further directions for disposal of the appeal.

Catchwords:

APPEAL – DECISION BY AN ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal – question of fact or law –evidence – expert evidence – hearsay evidence – form of questions and issues on appeal – requirement of “obvious” or a “manifestly obvious” error – consideration

REGULATION AND ADMINISTRATION – PLANNING – variation – valuation – comparable sales – costs of remediation of contamination – purchase by an adjoining owner – expert evidence

Legislation Cited:

ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT), ss 82, 82(b), 86(1)(a)

Rates Act 2004 (ACT), ss 6(1), 10, 11A, Dictionary
Taxation Administration Act 1999 (ACT), ss 104, 107A, 108A

Cases Cited:

ACT Human Rights Commission v Raytheon Australia Pty Ltd [2009] ACTSC 55

A v Director of Family Services (1996) 132 FLR 172
Boland v Yates Property Corporation Pty Ltd (1998) 74 ALJR 209
Challenger Property Asset Management Pty Ltd v Stonnington City Council (2011) 34 VR 445
City Hill Pty Ltd v ACTPlanning and Land Authority [2015] ACTSC 40; 207 LGERA 48
Commonwealth Custodial Services Ltd v Valuer-General [2006] NSWLEC 400

Coutts v Close [2014] FCA 19
Doherty v Commissioner of Highways (1974) 7 SASR 57
Doney v The Queen (1990) 171 CLR 207
Duffy v Minister for Planning [2003] WASCA 294
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v St Helen’s Farm (ACT) Pty Ltd (1981) 146 CLR 336
Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2013] ACAT 59
Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2014] ACAT 50
Haritos v Commissioner of Taxation (2015) 233 FCR 315
ISPT Pty Ltd and Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2013] ACAT 43
John Flynn Community Group Inc v ACT Heritage Council (2012) 6 ACTLR 266
Junstamp v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2013] ACAT 50
Legal Practitioner v Council of the Law Society of the ACT (2011) 257 FLR 118
Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles (2001) 52 NSWLR 705
Mangubat and Commissioner for Social Housing of the ACT [2013] ACAT 6
Minister of Environment v Petroccia (1982) 30 SASR 333
Murdesk Investments Pty Ltd v Roads Corporation [2006] VSC 363
O’Donnell v Environment Protection Authority [2012] ACTSC 140
Pires v Dibbs Barker Canberra Pty Ltd [2014] ACTSC 283
R v War Pensions Entitlement Tribunal;  ex parte Bott (1933) 50…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] ACTSC 275
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Giusida Pty Ltd appealed against the decision of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT) in Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2014] ACAT 50. The tribunal had confirmed the original decision made on Giusida’s application for review, Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2013] ACAT 59. The dispute centred on the valuation of the subject land for the purposes of a varied lease, which allowed for residential use subject to the condition that the site be decontaminated to the satisfaction of the Territory. Giusida argued that the tribunal had made errors in its assessment of the potential contamination and its impact on the land's value.

The legal issues before the court involved the interpretation of evidence, specifically expert evidence and hearsay evidence, regarding the potential contamination of the land and its impact on its value. Giusida contested the tribunal's findings on the potential contamination sources, the costs associated with remediation, and the impact of these factors on the land's valuation. The court was required to determine whether the tribunal had made an error in its assessment of the evidence and the valuation of the land.

The court examined the tribunal's reasoning and found that there was no "obvious" or "manifestly obvious" error in the tribunal's approach to the evidence and its valuation of the land. The court noted that the tribunal had considered the expert evidence and the possibility of contamination, but had reasonably concluded that the risk of contamination was already factored into the land's sales price in the area. The court held that the tribunal's findings were not so flawed as to warrant an appeal. Consequently, leave to appeal was granted except for one specific question regarding the tribunal's assessment of the underground storage tank's impact on the land's value.

The final orders of the court included granting Giusida Pty Ltd leave to appeal against the decision in Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2014] ACAT 50, except for one specific question. The court also ordered that the costs of the grant of leave should ordinarily be costs in the appeal, with a reservation that the costs of the adjournment should be paid by the applicant. The parties were to be heard regarding further directions for the disposal of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave should be granted to Giusida Pty Limited to appeal against the decision in Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2014] ACAT 50 each of the questions set out in its draft Notice of Appeal except Question 5.

2. The costs of a grant of leave should ordinarily be costs in the appeal, subject to the reservation that the costs of the adjournment should be paid by the Applicant.

3. The parties be heard as to further directions for disposal of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Giusida seeks leave to appeal from a decision of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (the ACAT) in Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2014] ACAT 50 (the Appeal Decision) which confirmed the decision of the ACAT originally made on Giusida’s application for review: Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2013] ACAT 59 (the Original Decision). On 18 December 2009, Giusida was granted what was called in the Original Decision at [5] a “new varied lease”, which appears to refer to the variation of the Crown Lease of the subject land to permit it to be used for residential purposes as well as various community, commercial, transport and retail uses. It is not necessary in these reasons to set out the purposes clause of the Crown Lease as varied, save to note that the new purpose of “residential use” was subject to a proviso that the “site is decontaminated to the satisfaction of the Territory”. In the Original Decision at [45], the ACAT described the subject land as follows: Giusida submitted that three matters raised the possibility of contamination on the subject land which, in accordance with the proviso referred to above (at [3]), would require it to be remediated, if contamination were found on the site, before the land could be used for residential use as part of its highest and best use. As noted, the subject land is adjacent to an operating service station, but it was also 200 metres south of a former dry cleaner’s business and another former service station. It was common ground between the parties that the subject land had an underground storage tank that had been decommissioned and filled with sand. The underground tank was not an improvement, but, in a term used by Biscoe J (called in error twice in the Original Decision at [7] Briscoe J) in Commonwealth Custodial Services Ltd v Valuer-General [2006] NSWLEC 400 at [69], a “worsement”. Giusida’s submission was that the contamination may come in three ways: An expert employed by Giusida, Dr Gunton, a geologist with Robson Environmental, gave evidence that the underground tank was “a potential primary contaminant source” to the subject land. In the Original Decision at [36], it was held that the tank was not an improvement on the land, and it was found at [72] that it would have to be removed and any “resulting damage ... made good”. This cost would ultimately have to be deducted from the unimproved value of the subject land. In the Original Decision, such an allowance was made when calculating the value of the land. As to the other matters of potential contamination, they were dealt with in the Original Decision at [40]-[42] as follows: No direct evidence was given of actual contamination on the subject land but it appears that the respondent, the Commissioner for ACT Revenue (the Commissioner), accepted that there was a possibility of contamination on land in the Braddon area, though submitting that the cost of such risk was already built into the sales of land in that area.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.