Hurst-Myers v Aulich Civil Law Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

HURST-MEYERS v AULICH CIVIL LAW PTY LTD ACN 155 746 777 (Appeal) [2020] ACAT 56

AA 10/2020 (XD 694/2019)

Catchwords:               APPEAL – application by appellant to adduce further evidence – power of appeal tribunal to grant leave to receive further evidence about questions of fact – appeal dealt with as a review of the original decision – factors taken into account in exercise of discretionary power to receive further evidence – application dismissed – cross-appeal lodged 45 days after appeal period expired – application for leave to appeal out of time – power of tribunal to grant leave to appeal out of time - factors to be considered in exercise of discretionary power to grant leave – application dismissed

Legislation cited:        ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 ss 6, 7, 48, 79, 82

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 27
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) s 93A

Subordinate

Legislation cited:        ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Procedures Rule 2020 rr 38, 91, 94

Cases cited:Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27

Allesch v Mauntz (2000) 203 CLR 172
Aulich Civil Law Pty Ltd ACN 155 746 777 v Hurst-Meyers [2020] ACAT 26
CDJ v VAJ (No 1) [1998] HCA 67
Commissioner for Social Housing v Williams [2017] ACAT 53
Concerned Citizens of Canberra Inc v Chief Executive (Planning and Land Authority) [2015] ACTCA 56
Fox v Percy [2003] HCA 22
Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2016] ACTSC 275
Legal Practitioner v Council of Law Society (ACT) (2011) 257 FLR 118

Tribunal:  President G Neate AM

Date of Orders:  17 July 2020              

Date of Reasons for Decision:         23 July 2020

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL           AA 10/2020

XD 694/2019

BETWEEN:

RALPH HURST-MEYERS

Appellant

AND:

AULICH CIVIL LAW PTY LTD ACN 155 746 777

Respondent

APPEAL TRIBUNAL:       President G Neate AM

DATE: 17 July 2020

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The application by Ralph Hurst-Meyers in the matter AA 10/2020 for the grant of leave to provide further evidence about questions of fact on appeal is dismissed.

  2. The application by Aulich Civil Law Pty Ltd ACN 155 746 777 in matter number XD 694/2019 for the grant of leave to cross-appeal out of time is dismissed.

……………Signed……..

President G Neate AM

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. The present proceedings involve formal responses by Aulich Civil Law Pty Ltd ACN 155 746 777 (Aulich Law or the firm), a firm of solicitors, and Ralph Hurst-Meyers, a former client of the firm, to a decision of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (the Original Tribunal) that:

    (a)Mr Hurst-Meyers pay the sum of $24,258.32 to Aulich Law;

    (b)Mr Hurst-Meyers’ counterclaim is dismissed; and

    (c)Aulich Law’s application for an order for costs is dismissed.

  2. Those orders were made in response to two claims. The first was made by Aulich Law for unpaid fees for legal services that it provided to Mr Hurst-Meyers in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hurst-Myers v Aulich Civil Law Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] ACAT 56
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hurst-Meyers, the appellant, sought leave to adduce further evidence on appeal against a decision of the Original Tribunal, while Aulich Civil Law Pty Ltd, the respondent, lodged a cross-appeal 45 days after the appeal period had expired. The appellant applied for leave to appeal out of time, and the appeal tribunal was required to decide whether to grant leave to adduce further evidence and to grant leave to cross-appeal out of time. The tribunal considered the relevance of the evidence and whether it was available to the Original Tribunal. The tribunal dismissed the application to adduce further evidence because the appellant had failed to establish that it was relevant and not already before the tribunal. The tribunal also dismissed the application to cross-appeal out of time because the delay was significant and there was no justification for it.

The tribunal found that the appellant had not demonstrated that the further evidence was relevant or that it was not already before the tribunal. The tribunal noted that the appellant had filed documents and a recording concerning the ACT Supreme Court matter, but had not sought to adduce this evidence before the tribunal. The tribunal also found that the appellant had failed to establish that the evidence was necessary to determine the appeal. The tribunal concluded that the appellant had not discharged the onus of showing that the further evidence was necessary and relevant. The tribunal further found that the cross-appeal was lodged 45 days after the appeal period had expired and there was no justification for the delay. The tribunal concluded that the delay was significant and there was no good reason for it.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1. The application by Ralph Hurst-Meyers in the matter AA 10/2020 for the grant of leave to provide further evidence about questions of fact on appeal is dismissed.

2. The application by Aulich Civil Law Pty Ltd ACN 155 746 777 in matter number XD 694/2019 for the grant of leave to cross-appeal out of time is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Aulich Law submitted that:(a)the relevance of the Supreme Court transcript was dealt with on the first day of the hearing before the Original Tribunal;(b)the summary of evidence was in evidence before the Original Tribunal; (c)the Supreme Court proceedings were dealt with in detail at the hearing before the Original Tribunal.Consideration and conclusion On 4 November 2019, Mr Hurst-Meyers filed four bundles of documents and a four hour recording concerning the ACT Supreme Court matter[25] in which Aulich Law formerly acted for him.[25] Hurst-Meyers v Public Trustee and Guardian for the ACT [2018] ACTSC 61 The orders made by Senior Member Warwick on 6 November 2019:(a)noted that Mr Hurst-Meyers had filed documents comprising materials relevant to the application before the Original Tribunal and materials relevant only to a proposed application by him for costs; and(b)included an order that Mr Hurst-Meyers advise Aulich Law and the Tribunal by 20 November 2019 which materials he relied on for the determination of the application before the Original Tribunal and confirming that the remaining materials are not relied upon for the determination. At the hearing before the Original Tribunal on 26 February 2020, Mr Hurst- Meyers agreed on what material would be tendered as exhibits. In particular, Mr Hurst-Meyers agreed not to tender all the documents contained in what he identified in the ‘yellow folder’, which included a chronology. The Original Tribunal went through the documents in the folder with Mr Hurst-Meyers. Among the evidence that he agreed not tender was a summary of the Supreme Court proceedings and the recording of the proceedings at the Supreme Court, which he is now seeking leave to adduce. As the transcript shows: MR HURST-MEYERS: After the chronology, you’ve got the transcripts from McWilliam. They’re just related to the - what’s on discs handed to the tribunal and also Aulich. PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER McCARTHY: Okay. But what I want to know about this is, look down here. It’s not clear to me at the moment what purpose is served because looking at the first group when you talk about words to the effect, and then you’ve got 1.28, I take it these are comments that McWilliam AsJ said during the hearing. Is that right? MR HURST-MEYERS: Yes, both McWilliam and also Sharwood. PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER McCARTHY: Well, that's the second page. Just focus on the first bit. Looking at the little summary there, it seems to me that that is very brief summary of what ultimately ends up in the decision anyway. MR HURST-MEYERS: YesPRESIDENTIAL MEMBER McCARTHY: You agree? MR HURST-MEYERS: I do.PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER McCARTHY: So given that we’ve got the decision where that substance is recorded in the decision I mean, - - - MR HURST-MEYERS: YesPRESIDENTIAL MEMBER McCARTHY: - - - I can't see any value in us hearing what McWilliam had to say in the hearing. Would you agree? MR HURST-MEYERS: Yes PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER McCARTHY: Okay, so can we put that section aside? MR HURST-MEYERS: Yes.[26][26] Transcript of the proceedings of 26 February 2020, pages 78-79