Craven & Gilks v The Owners Units Plan No 2839

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

CRAVEN & GILKS v THE OWNERS – UNITS PLAN NO 2839

(Appeal) [2023] ACAT 4

AA 14/2022 (UT 40/2021)

Catchwords:               APPEAL – unit titles – unit owners installed wooden flooring in breach of the Owners Corporation Rules – Owners Corporation gave them an infringement notice – proceedings in tribunal for enforcement of infringement notice and compliance with the Rules – Original Tribunal ordered the unit owners to lodge new and compliant application for a hard floor, and to pay the Owners Corporation’s expenses of running the action once those expenses were quantified – appeal – whether Owners Corporation Rule 6.5 is invalid – whether the Rule is “harsh, unreasonable, or oppressive” – whether costs order was made in error – appellants applied to provide further evidence on appeal – relevant criteria – application refused – whether hearing of appeal should be de novo – appeal dismissed – substitute orders made

Legislation cited:        ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 ss 7, 15, 16, 18, 22, 48, 82

Courts and Other Justice Legislation Amendment Act 2018 s 116
Land Titles (Unit Titles) Act 1970
Legislation Act 2001 s 112
Magistrates Court Act 1930 s 261
Strata Management Act 2015 (NSW) ss 136, 139
Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 ss 16, 31, 35, 107, 108, 109, 127

Subordinate

Legislation cited:        ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2020 r 91(c)

Unit Titles (Management) Regulation 2011

Cases cited:Aon Risk Services Australian Limited v Australian National University [2009] HCA 7

Commissioner for Social Housing vWilliams [2017] ACAT 53
Cooper v The Owners – Strata Plan No 58068 [2020] NSWCA 250
Excel Intelligent Pty Ltd v Thomson [2018] ACAT 4
Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2016] ACTSC 275
Grundt v Great Boulder Gold Mines Pty Ltd (1937) 59 CLR 641
Harada v Barnes & Anor [2021] ACAT 66
Hamers v South Canberra Holdings Pty Ltd ACN 606 747 602 Trading as Southside Village [2021] ACAT 71
He v Qin & Ors [2021] ACAT 129
Hurst-Meyers v Aulich Civil Law Pty Ltd ACN 155 746 777 [2020] ACAT 56
In the matter of Ruling Tribunal Section 31 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 [2017] ACAT 56
Jelin Pty Ltd v Johnson (1987) 5 ACLC 463
LP 202021 vCouncil of the Law Society of the ACT [2022] ACAT 80
Mansour v Dangar [2017] ACAT 49
Mantoufeh v Enterprise Finance Solutions Pty Ltd [2009] NSWSC 1144
Meales Concrete Pumping Pty Ltd v Probuild Constructions (Aust) Pty Ltd [2015] VSC 594
Pye v Pye [2022] ACAT 91
Pye v Registrar, Domestic Animals Act 2000 [2022] ACAT 102
Tam v Du [2019] ACAT 94
The Proprietors Units Plan No 52 v Gold (1993) 44 FCR 123
The Owners – Units Plan No 3182 v Black & Anor [2018] ACAT 6
The Owners – Strata Plan No 36131 v Dimitriou [2009] NSWCA 27
The Owners – Units Plan 840 v Richardson [2015] ACAT 77
V v Elringtons Pty Ltd

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Craven & Gilks v The Owners Units Plan No 2839 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACAT 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Craven and Gilks, the appellants, appealed against a decision of the Original Tribunal in proceedings brought by The Owners Corporation, the respondent, for enforcement of an infringement notice issued to the appellants under the Owners Corporation Rules for installing wooden flooring in their unit in breach of the rules. The Original Tribunal ordered the appellants to lodge a new and compliant application for a hard floor, and to pay the Owners Corporation’s expenses of running the action once those expenses were quantified. The appellants brought an appeal to the Appeal Tribunal against the Original Tribunal’s decision. The Appeal Tribunal was required to determine whether Owners Corporation Rule 6.5 was invalid, whether the Rule was harsh, unreasonable, or oppressive, and whether the costs order was made in error. The appellants applied to provide further evidence on appeal, and the Appeal Tribunal was required to determine the relevant criteria and whether the hearing of the appeal should be de novo.

The Appeal Tribunal refused the appellants leave to provide further evidence. The appellants had not provided the written submissions required by the case management orders, and the appellants had not identified a witness who was available to give evidence. The Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal. The appellants had not demonstrated that Owners Corporation Rule 6.5 was invalid, and the Rule was for a proper purpose. The appellants had not demonstrated that the Rule was harsh, unreasonable, or oppressive. The appellants had not demonstrated that the Original Tribunal had erred in making an order for the appellants to pay the Owners Corporation’s expenses of running the action once those expenses were quantified.

The Appeal Tribunal made substitute orders in place of those made by the Original Tribunal. The appellants were ordered to lodge a new and compliant application for a hard floor, or advise the Executive Committee in writing that they propose to replace the timber floor in their apartment with carpet and underlay. The appellants were ordered to pay the Owners Corporation the sum of $8,960.78 in reimbursement of the expenses reasonably incurred by the Owners Corporation in relation to the application to ACAT and the original hearing of that application. If the respondent sought to recover from the appellants the expenses incurred by the respondent in responding to the appellants’ application for appeal, the respondent must give the appellants an itemised list of those expenses in writing within 14 days of the date of the orders. If the respondent and the appellants agreed to the amount of those expenses, the appellants must pay the respondent the agreed amount of those expenses by a date agreed by the parties. If the respondent and the appellants did not agree to the amount of those expenses, and the amount was not more than $25,000, the respondent could apply to the Appeal Tribunal for an order that the appellants pay to the respondent the amount of the expenses incurred by the respondent. In deciding whether the amount claimed constituted reasonable expenses reasonably incurred, the Appeal Tribunal could have those expenses assessed by a registrar of the tribunal.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

The appeal is dismissed.

2.

Orders 4-7 made by the Original Tribunal dated 6 July 2022 are vacated and the following orders are made in substitution.

3.

Within 14 days of the date of these orders the respondent must give the appellants in writing particulars of all applications for installation of timber flooring previously approved by the Executive Committee of the Owners Corporation since the adoption of Rule 6.5 of the Owners Corporation Rules – Units Plan 2839 The Viridian and the requirement that hard floors comply with the AAAC 6-star standard of acoustic performance on 7 December 2017. The document is to include particulars of the products used in the installation of that flooring, the names and qualifications of the installers who installed those floors, and particulars of the information supplied by the applicants in those applications to satisfy the Executive Committee that the proposed installation met the requirements of Rule 6.5.

4.

Within 14 days of receiving the information from the respondent set out in Order 3, the appellants must either:

(a) lodge an application seeking approval pursuant to Rule 6.5 of the Owners Corporation Rules – Units Plan 2839 The Viridian from the Executive Committee of the respondent, to replace the existing timber floor in their apartment with a hard floor which meets the acoustic resilience level specified in Rule 6.5 and complies with the guidelines set out in Appendix A of the Owners Corporation Rules – Units Plan 2839 The Viridian; or

(b) advise the Executive Committee in writing that they propose to replace the timber floor in their apartment with carpet and underlay and provide the earliest practicable date for the proposed installation of the carpet floor.

5.

Within 14 days of receiving any application for replacement of the timber floor from the appellants, the Executive Committee must advise the appellants whether their application has been approved. If the application is not approved, the Executive Committee must provide in writing detailed reasons to the appellants for not approving the application and details of any further information the appellants must provide for their application to be approved.

6.

The appellants must arrange for the installation of any new hard floor in their apartment as soon as practicable after receiving approval from the respondent to install the floor.

7.

The appellants must authorise in writing:

(a) a member of the Executive Committee; or

(b) a nominee of the Executive Committee as nominated by the respondent in the approval notification,

to enter their apartment during and/or after installation of the new floor to check that the installation is taking place and/or is completed as approved.

8.

The appellants must pay the respondent the sum of $8,960.78 pursuant to section 31 of the Unit Titles Management Act 2011 in reimbursement of the expenses reasonably incurred by the respondent in relation to the application to ACAT dated 3 November 2021 and the original hearing of that application.

9.

If the respondent seeks to recover from the appellant the expenses incurred by the respondent in responding to the appellants’ application for appeal dated 20 July 2022, including reasonable legal fees reasonably incurred, the respondent must give the appellants an itemised list of those expenses in writing within 14 days of the date of these orders.

10.

If the respondent and the appellants agree to the amount of those expenses:

(a) the appellants must pay the respondent the agreed amount of those expenses by a date agreed by the parties; or

(b) if the amount is not more than $25,000, the respondent may apply to the Appeal Tribunal under this Order 10 for an order that the appellants pay to the respondent the amount of the expenses incurred by the respondent.

11.

If the respondent and the appellants do not agree to the amount of those expenses, and the amount is not more than $25,000, the respondent may apply to the Appeal Tribunal under this Order 11 for an order that the appellants pay the expenses incurred by the respondent. In deciding whether the amount claimed constitutes reasonable expenses reasonably incurred, the Appeal Tribunal may have those expenses assessed by a registrar of the tribunal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Appeal Tribunal gave oral reasons for ruling on each issue. The summary below sets out the rulings and the reasons for them.Should leave be granted to receive further evidence for the appellants? On 22 August 2022, a Presidential Member of the tribunal made orders for the case management of the appeal proceedings, including that the appellants:(a)give the respondent and the tribunal by 26 September 2022 a copy of any proposed further evidence for the hearing of the appeal (Order 1(c));(b)give the respondent and the tribunal by 20 September 2022 written submissions in support of the application for further evidence and the appeal, specifying the orders sought if the appeal is successful (Order 1(d)).(c)make, in writing to the tribunal by 31 October 2022, any request to have a witness give evidence by telephone (Order 3); and that(d)the appeal hearing will proceed as a review of the original decision unless the Appeal Tribunal orders otherwise (Order 8). The orders noted that the parties should ensure that their witnesses are available at the hearing of the appeal in the event that submission of fresh evidence on the appeal is permitted. On 3 October 2022, the appellants provided to the respondent and the Appeal Tribunal:(a)an email dated 1 October 2022 from Mark Bevan, manager of Choices Flooring, to Mr Craven in response to questions regarding installing engineered timber into apartment buildings including how to achieve a 40dB reading by use of underlay; and(b)an email dated 1 August 2022 from Olivia Jarrett, sales associate in the acoustics division of Regupol, in response to a request for information about the underlay the appellants would need to use to meet the standard required by the OC Rules. No written submissions in support of the application for further evidence have been provided. On 31 October 2022, the appellants sought leave for Mr Bevan and Matt Bryce to give evidence by telephone. On 3 November 2022, the Appeal Tribunal issued directions including that, at the hearing of the appeal, the appellants should advise the Appeal Tribunal about specified matters in relation to the further evidence which the appellants sought leave to provide. The direction stated that if the Appeal Tribunal were to grant leave to provide further evidence, it would hear submissions from both parties about whether the hearing of that part of the appeal to which the further evidence was relevant should be adjourned to a later date to enable the respondent to call any further evidence in reply. Neither before nor at the hearing of the appeal was there anything in writing from or about Mr Bryce or the evidence that the appellants anticipated he would give. Mr Craven described Mr Bryce as the principal acoustic consultant with SLR Consulting, an ACT member firm of the AAAC. Mr Craven found the firm on the AAAC’s website and Mr Bryce was listed as the contact.[10] He suggested that Mr Bryce’s evidence, if permitted, would be about the “suitability of the standard” and, in particular, that the AAAC 6-star rating “is not practically achievable in a building that has not been specifically designed for acoustic performance at that standard.”[11] Mr Craven said that he had first contacted Mr Bryce toward the end of August 2022. Mr Bryce was overseas, and they did not meet until about the week of 24 October 2022.[12] Mr Craven had not indicated to the respondent or the Appeal Tribunal that he was proposing to call evidence from Mr Bryce and did not name him as a potential witness. Nor had he provided a submission (in response to Order 1(c)) in support of the application for this further evidence. According to Mr Craven, he had assumed that Order 3 related to anyone who was to give oral evidence and a written statement or submission was not required.[13][10] Transcript of proceedings 7 November 2022, pages 3, 16, 17[11] Transcript of proceedings 7 November 2022, pages 3, 16[12] Transcript of proceedings 7 November 2022, page 16[13] Transcript of proceedings 7 November 2022, pages 34, 35

Decision

Reasons for decision

In In the matter of the Ruling Tribunal Section 31 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (Ruling Tribunal Decision), the Ruling Tribunal determined that legal professional costs and disbursements, company title and similar searches, filing and hearing fees, and administrative costs (for example, charges for the owners corporation managing agent and the collections agency) incurred in bringing tribunal proceedings to recover unpaid unit title levies are ‘expenses’ for the purposes of section 31 of the UTM Act if:… it was reasonable for the owners corporation to incur expenses of the type described and the amount of each component of the expenses sought is reasonable.[58]This test may be described as the ‘double reasonableness test’.[58] In the Matter of Ruling Tribunal Section 31 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 [2017] ACAT 56 at Order 1; [55], [104] As already noted, the Original Tribunal did not order the appellants to pay any specified expenses incurred by the Owners Corporation. It merely stated that the Owners Corporation was entitled to be reimbursed the expenses it incurred in pursuing enforcement of the infringement notice issued against the appellants. The Original Tribunal identified some amounts to which the Owners Corporation might be entitled (such as the filing fee, the cost of some transcript, hearing expenses, and approximately half the cost of the Guz Box report) and which the Original Tribunal indicated it would allow as payable if it were to decide whether the claimed expenses were reasonable. The Original Tribunal also observed that the Owners Corporation had to provide full details of the amount it was liable to pay for the professional services of Ms Anderson from Link Strata Management in relation to the application to the tribunal before any order specifying the expenses payable could be considered. The Owners Corporation filed and served a document setting out expenses it incurred, including the amount charged by the Strata Manager for Ms Anderson’s itemised services on 24 June 2022. That document is discussed further below. As no order for payment of quantified expenses was made by the Original Tribunal for the original proceedings, and having dismissed the first ground of this appeal, the Appeal Tribunal needs to consider whether an order for recovery of the expenses incurred by the Owners Corporation in enforcing its Rule ought to be made or whether it should uphold the appellant’s second ground of appeal to the effect that no order for payment of the expenses should be made. In accordance with section 31 of the UTMA, the Owners Corporation can recover the amount spent on the original proceedings if:(a)the Owners Corporation incurred an “expense;”(b)the Owners Corporation incurred the expense “in carrying out its functions;” and(c)the expense was “necessary because of” either:(i) a wilful or negligent act or omission of a member of the corporation; or(ii) a breach of its rules by a member of the corporation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

During the hearing of the appeal, the respondent made the following further submissions:(a)Having abandoned the submission or argument that OC Rule 6.5 was invalid during the original hearing, the Owners Corporation was deprived of the opportunity to adduce evidence about that issue and the appellant is therefore estopped from raising the issue again on appeal.(b)The Owners Corporation has chosen to have a higher standard of acoustic performance for hard floors in the apartment building so that owners can enjoy quieter premises. Such a rule is for a proper purpose and permitted by the UTMA and it is not invalid.(c)OC Rule 6.5 is facilitative and not prescriptive. It requires owners to observe the AAAC 6-star rating but how they achieve that standard is up to them. However, the onus of demonstrating compliance with the Rule is on the appellants. The appellants went about attaining compliance the wrong way as they consulted the wrong installers about achieving a AAAC 6-star acoustic compliance in their unit when they installed the hard floor.(d)The standard for acoustic performance set by the NCC is a minimum standard and irrelevant to the standard the Owners Corporation adopted in Rule 6.5. There is no evidence that the Viridian building was built to NCC standard. The Owners Corporation chose a higher standard for acoustic performance than that set as a minimum by the NCC as they were entitled to do.(e)The Viridian complex was originally designed for carpeted floors. Carpet has better sound properties than hard floors and if unit owners wish to depart from the norm and install a floor that produces more sound, they need to comply with OC Rule 6.5. The appellants ought to have known about the requirements of the Rule because it was available for them to inspect in the records of the Owners Corporation before they purchased their unit.(f)The appellants’ submission that the Regupol underlay referred to in the Guidelines attached to the OC Rule does not meet the 6-star rating prescribed in OC Rule 6.5 should not be accepted because the document produced by the appellants in support of that submission refers to a differently named Regupol product and there is no evidence that it is the same product as that referred to in the Guidelines. Further, that underlay is designed for tongue and groove flooring, which is not what the appellants chose to install.(g)The appellants’ new flooring led to complaints by the owners of the unit below theirs. The appellant’s submission that they were not aware of the nature of the complaints, and they could therefore not address them, is unsustainable because the complaints were in evidence before the original hearing. If the appellants wished to test those complaints, they could have subpoenaed the complainants. Further, the appellants could have subpoenaed the applications of installation of timber floors previously approved by the Owners Corporation before the original hearing, but they did not do so.Consideration and conclusionEstoppel