Mangubat & Commissioner for Social Housing in the ACT

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

MANGUBAT & COMMISSIONER FOR SOCIAL HOUSING IN THE ACT (Residential Tenancies) [2013] ACAT 6

AA12/45

(RT 10/760, RT 12/126)

Catchwords:             RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES - appeal – conditional termination and possession order – application for warrant of eviction – consideration of sections 42A and 49 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1977 – hearing of appeal de novo or as a review of original decision – whether the Original Tribunal did not take into account relevant considerations or did take into account irrelevant considerations – the tenant’s non-compliance with conditional termination and possession order;  whether  it is a “breach” of the order or the order was “satisfied”

List of Legislation: ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008, ss 79,

79(3), 82(a), 82(b)

Residential Tenancies Act 1977 (ACT) ss 42, 42A, 42A(1)(c) 42B, 49(3), 49(4)

List of Regulations: ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Procedure Rules 2009 (No.2), r. 21

List of Cases:            Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation [[1948] 1 K.B. 223

O’Donnell v Environment Protection Authority [2012] ACTSC 140
Eastman v Commissioner for Social Housing for Social Housing [2011] ACTCA 12

Das v A & A Airconditioning Pty Ltd (Civil Disputes) [2011] ACAT 52

ACT Human Rights Commission v Raytheon Australia Pty Ltd, Aerospace Technical Services Pty Ltd, Australian Maritime Surveillance Pty Ltd, Aeronautical Consulting Training and Engineering [2009] ACTSC 55

Thornthwaite v Commissioner for Social Housing in the ACT (Residential Tenancies) [2012] ACAT 11

Zhang & Yuan v Koh [2010] ACAT 6

Pesi v Commissioner for Social Housing in the ACT [2012] ACAT 61

Fisher and Commissioner for Social Housing in the ACT [2012] ACAT 32

List of Texts/

Papers:   Australian Capital Territory, Parliamentary Debates,
  Legislative Assembly, 8 May 2008, 1579, in relation to the
  ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Bill

Tribunal:                  Ms E. Symons,          Presidential Member

Ms J. Lennard,         Senior Member

Ms W. Corby,           Senior Member

Date of Orders:           12 February 2013       

Date of Reasons for Decision:         12 February 2013       

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL      AA12/45

(RT 10/ 760, RT12/126)

BETWEEN:

Prescila Mangubat

Appellant

AND:

Commissioner for Social Housing in the ACT

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:            Ms E. Symons, Presidential Member

Ms J. Lennard, Senior Member

Ms W. Corby,   Senior Member

DATE:  12 February 2013

ORDER

1.   The appeal is dismissed.

2.   Subject to Orders 3, 4, and 5 below the decision of the Original Tribunal dated    17 September 2012 to terminate the appellant’s tenancy and grant a warrant of eviction is confirmed.

3.   The warrant of eviction which was issued on 17 September 2012, which on          4 October 2012 was stayed until further order, but no later than 31 December 2012, and subsequently amended on 15 January 2013 to delete the words “not later than 31 December 2012” is stayed until 4pm Monday 4 March 2013.

4.   The appellant/tenant shall pay the respondent/lessor rental arrears in the sum of $6,964.42 forthwith.

5.   Liberty to relist after execution of the warrant for hearing any claims for compensation or occupancy fee.

………………………………..

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mangubat & Commissioner for Social Housing in the ACT and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] ACAT 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Mangubat & Commissioner for Social Housing in the ACT, the dispute involved the termination of the appellant's tenancy and the issuance of a warrant of eviction. The appellant contested the decision made by the Original Tribunal to terminate their tenancy, and the case was heard by the court of appeal. The appellant sought to overturn the tribunal's decision, arguing that it was unjust and unreasonable. The respondent, the Commissioner for Social Housing in the ACT, maintained that the tribunal's decision was correct and should be upheld.

The legal issues before the court were whether the tribunal's decision to terminate the appellant's tenancy was lawful and whether the warrant of eviction was appropriately issued. The court was required to determine if the appellant's rights were breached and if the tribunal's decision was justified. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the appellant's rental arrears should be paid and if the warrant of eviction should be stayed until a later date.

The court found that the tribunal's decision to terminate the appellant's tenancy was lawful and justified, and therefore dismissed the appeal. The court confirmed the decision of the Original Tribunal to terminate the appellant's tenancy and grant a warrant of eviction. The court also ruled that the warrant of eviction should be stayed until 4pm on Monday 4 March 2013. Furthermore, the appellant was ordered to pay the rental arrears of $6,964.42 forthwith. The court granted liberty to relist the case after execution of the warrant to hear any claims for compensation or occupancy fee.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed.

2. Subject to Orders 3, 4, and 5 below the decision of the Original Tribunal dated 17 September 2012 to terminate the appellant’s tenancy and grant a warrant of eviction is confirmed.

3. The warrant of eviction which was issued on 17 September 2012, which on 4 October 2012 was stayed until further order, but no later than 31 December 2012, and subsequently amended on 15 January 2013 to delete the words “not later than 31 December 2012” is stayed until 4pm Monday 4 March 2013.

4. The appellant/tenant shall pay the respondent/lessor rental arrears in the sum of $6,964.42 forthwith.

5. Liberty to relist after execution of the warrant for hearing any claims for compensation or occupancy fee.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves the termination of a tenancy agreement between the appellant, Mangubat, and the respondent, the Commissioner for Social Housing in the ACT. The tenancy agreement was governed by the Residential Tenancies Act 1995 (ACT). The appellant fell into arrears of rental payments, leading to a notice of termination of tenancy being issued on 17 September 2012. This was followed by a decision from the Original Tribunal dated 17 September 2012 to terminate the appellant’s tenancy and grant a warrant of eviction. A warrant of eviction was subsequently issued on the same day, but this was stayed on 4 October 2012, until further order but no later than 31 December 2012. On 15 January 2013, the warrant of eviction was amended to remove the phrase “not later than 31 December 2012.”

The appellant appealed the decision of the Original Tribunal to terminate the tenancy and grant a warrant of eviction. The appeal was heard in the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT). The matter was brought before the ACAT as an appeal from the decision of the Original Tribunal. The appellant contested the termination of the tenancy and the warrant of eviction, arguing that the decision was unjust and should be overturned. The ACAT heard the appeal and considered submissions from both parties before making its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the appeal against the decision to terminate the tenancy and grant a warrant of eviction should be upheld.
2. Whether the decision to terminate the tenancy and grant a warrant of eviction was just and appropriate.
3. Whether the appellant should be required to pay the rental arrears as ordered by the tribunal.

Held
1. The appeal against the decision to terminate the tenancy and grant a warrant of eviction should not be upheld. The appeal is dismissed.
2. The decision of the Original Tribunal dated 17 September 2012 to terminate the appellant’s tenancy and grant a warrant of eviction is confirmed, subject to Orders 3, 4, and 5.
3. The appellant should be required to pay the rental arrears as ordered by the tribunal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the appeal and the decision to terminate the tenancy and grant a warrant of eviction under the Housing Administration Act. The appellant contested the tribunal's decision, arguing that it was not just and appropriate. The court found that the tribunal's decision was procedurally correct and that the termination was justified based on the evidence presented. The court dismissed the appeal, confirming that the tribunal's decision was sound and appropriate under the circumstances. The court further clarified the terms of the warrant of eviction and ordered the appellant to pay the rental arrears forthwith. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that the tribunal's decisions regarding tenancy terminations and evictions will be upheld if they are procedurally correct and justified by the evidence, and the court will intervene only in cases of significant procedural errors or manifest injustice.