GIUSIDA PTY LIMITED & COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE(Appeal)

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



GIUSIDA PTY LIMITED & COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE

(Appeal) [2014] ACAT 50

AA 39 of 2013

Catchwords:             APPEAL -  ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW -  redetermination of unimproved value (UV) of land – ambit of appeal jurisdiction – whether the tribunal’s conclusions were open to it – questions of fact and law – effect of possibility of contamination and remediation – appellant accorded fair hearing in relation to hearsay evidence –open to original tribunal not to accept expert opinions not supported by evidence – no irrelevant consideration taken into account – treatment of adjoining land owner influence - appeal tribunal does not revisit discretionary merits of competing arguments or opinions of expert witnesses

Legislation: ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008, ss 26 and 68

Rates Act 2004, ss 6, 10, 11 and 11A
Taxation Administration Act 1999, ss 101 and 108A

Cases:Challenger Property Asset Management Pty Ltd v Stonnington City Council [2011] VSC 184

Coutts v Close [2014] FCA 19
Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs
(1979) 2 ALD 60
English Exporters (London) Ltd  v Eldonwell Ltd
[1973] Ch. 415

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v St Helen’s Farm (ACT) Pty Ltd (1981) 145 CLR 336

Giusida & Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2013] ACAT 59
ISPT Pty Ltd & Commissioner for ACT Revenue
[2013] ACAT 43

Junstamp Pty Ltd and Ors & Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2013] ACAT 50

Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Spowles (2001) 52 NSWLR 705
Mangubat & Commissioner for Social Housing in the ACT [2013] ACAT 6

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Pochi (1980) 4 ALD 139

R v War Pensions Entitlement Appeals Tribunal; ex parte Bott (1933) 50 CLR 228

Re De Brett Investments Pty Ltd v Australian Fisheries Management Authority (2004) 82 ALD 163
Re Grove and Minister for Capital Territory (1979) 2 ALD 128

Spencer v Commonwealth (1907) 5 CLR 418
The Medical Practitioner & The ACT Medical Board
[2010] ACAT 63
Thornthwaite and Commissioner for Social Housing in the ACT [2012] ACAT 11
Yates Property Corporation Pty Ltd (in liq) v Darling Harbour Authority (1991) 24 NSWLR 156
Warren v Coombes  (1979) 142 CLR 531

Texts/Papers:            Cairns, BC, Australian Civil Procedure (

7th Edition, Lawbook
Co. 2007)


Hyam, Alan A, The Law Affecting Valuation of Land
In Australia
(Federation Press)

Lexis Nexis, Administrative Law Service

Appeal Tribunal:     Mr W.G. Stefaniak AM - Appeal President
  Ms E. Symons - Presidential Member

Date of Orders:  31 July 2014              
Date of Reasons for Decision:         31 July 2014

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

AA 13/39; AT 12/19

BETWEEN:    GIUSIDA PTY LIMITED
Appellant

AND:   COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE
Respondent

APPEAL TRIBUNAL:        Mr W.G. Stefaniak AM - Appeal President
  Ms E. Symons - Presidential Member

DATE:  31 July 2014

ORDER

The Tribunal Orders that:

  1. The original Tribunal’s decision dated 10 September 2013 in AT 12/19 is confirmed.

………………………………..

Mr W.G. Stefaniak AM
 Appeal President
for and on behalf of the Appeal Tribunal

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. At all material…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read GIUSIDA PTY LIMITED & COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE(Appeal) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] ACAT 50
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, Giusida Pty Limited, sought an appeal against the decision of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT) that set aside and remitted a reviewable decision made by the respondent, the Commissioner for ACT Revenue. The original decision had ordered the reviewable decision to be set aside and remitted for reconsideration, with specific directions regarding the unimproved value (UV) of the subject land and a requirement to deduct the cost of removing a sand-filled underground fuel storage tank. The appellant contested the tribunal's approach in several areas, including its consideration of the potential contamination of the land, the use of hearsay evidence, and the assessment of the valuer's opinion on adjoining owner influence. The appeal was heard on the existing evidence, and both parties presented arguments regarding the tribunal's jurisdiction and its function in conducting the review.

The central legal issues before the court involved the tribunal's interpretation and application of the Rates Act 2006, the principle in Spencer v Commonwealth, and its procedural fairness in handling evidence. Specifically, the appellant challenged the tribunal's requirement for actual contamination to be shown before a deduction for remediation costs could be made, the tribunal's reliance on hearsay evidence, and its rejection of an experienced valuer's opinion on adjoining owner influence. The respondent argued that the tribunal's decisions were not manifestly erroneous and were supported by the evidence. The court had to determine whether the tribunal's decisions were justified and whether they adhered to the principles of natural justice.

The court examined the tribunal's appellate jurisdiction and its role in conducting a review under section 82(b) of the ACAT Act. It found that the tribunal did not err in its interpretation and application of the Rates Act 2006 or in its adherence to the principle in Spencer v Commonwealth. The tribunal correctly held that a deduction for remediation costs could only be made when actual contamination was shown, and it appropriately considered the potential effect of contamination. Regarding the hearsay evidence, the court found no procedural unfairness as the evidence emerged during cross-examination, and the appellant had the opportunity to challenge it. The tribunal was also justified in rejecting the valuer's opinion on adjoining owner influence, as the valuer had not provided sales evidence to support his opinion. The court confirmed the original tribunal's decision, finding no substantial error in its reasoning or process.

ORDERS:
1. The original Tribunal’s decision dated 10 September 2013 in AT 12/19 is confirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The original Tribunal’s decision dated 10 September 2013 in AT 12/19 is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 10 September 2013, the original tribunal ordered (the original decision[1]) pursuant to section 68 of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 that the reviewable decision should be set aside and remitted to the Commissioner for reconsideration in accordance with the direction determining the UV as at 1 January 2009 - $4,225,600; at 1 January 2010 - $4,882,440 and at 1 January 2011 - $4,882,440. The respondent was directed to obtain an informed opinion on the cost of removal of the sand filled underground fuel storage tank (UST) on the subject land and of making good, and to deduct this sum from the above UVs. On 8 October 2013, the appellant lodged an application for appeal from the original decision which set out the following eleven questions of fact or law:1. Did the Tribunal act in accordance with section 6 of the Rates Act 2006 (sic) and the principle in Spencer v Commonwealth when it:a. held that a deduction for the cost of remediation could be properly made only when actual contamination had been shown to exist on the subject land, andb. ignored the effect on value of the possibility of contamination?2. Did the Tribunal fail to accord the applicant a fair hearing when it relied on hearsay evidence as to the payment of a premium of 5% in relation to Sale 1, the evidence emerging for the first time in cross examination?3. Was the Tribunal entitled to ignore the opinion of Mr Green as an experienced valuer that a 10% deduction for adjoining owner influence in relation to Sale 1 was proper on the basis that he had not provided sales evidence in support? The appellant stated, in the application for appeal, that:The appeal should proceed because the original decision has substantial financial implications for the applicant ratepayer, and because several of the challenged findings involve matters of principle which are of general application. At a directions hearing held on 15 November 2013, it was ordered that the appeal proceed by way of a rehearing on the existing evidence. In other words the appeal was to be dealt with pursuant to section 82(b) of the ACAT Act. Directions were made in relation to the parties filing their material and the matter was set down for hearing on 17 and 18 March 2014, which was subsequently changed to 25 and 26 March 2014. Mr Arthur appeared for the appellant and Mr McCarthy appeared for the respondent at the hearing. At the conclusion of the hearing, the Tribunal reserved the decision. In the appellant’s outline of submissions filed on 17 March 2014, the appellant did not press question 6, thereby reducing the questions of fact or law for consideration to ten. The respondent asks the Tribunal to reject each of the appeal grounds because either the original tribunal did not act as alleged or the original tribunal’s response to the questions now raised was open to it on the evidence: contending that there was no “obviously manifest error.” [2][2] Outline of Respondent’s Submissions at [9] However, at the commencement of the hearing, the ambit of the tribunal’s appellate jurisdiction and the tribunal’s function when conducting a review under section 82(b) of the ACAT Act were the subject of both parties’ submissions. The Tribunal will consider this before turning to the questions of fact or law raised by the appellant.The Tribunal’s appellate jurisdiction and functions

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established