Thornthwaite v Commissioner for Social Housing

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

THORNTHWAITE and COMMISSIONER FOR SOCIAL HOUSING IN THE ACT (Residential Tenancies) [2012] ACAT 11

AA 30 of 2011

Catchwords:             RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES- appeal from tribunal decision – eviction – rental arrears – whether the ex parte order may be vacated - applicability of the Human Rights Act 2004 and the tribunal’s jurisdiction – appeal hearing: hearing de novo or rehearing – matters to consider if the decision of the original tribunal is to be overturned on appeal – whether there is new evidence – weakness of the appellant’s evidence

Tribunal:                  Mr W G Stefaniak, Appeal President
  Mr P Thompson, Member

List of legislation:     ACT Civil and Administrative Act 2008, s.82

Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities Act 2006 (Vic)

Human Rights Act 2004, ss.30, 32, 33, 40, 40A, 40B, 40C and

40D

Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (Vic)

List of cases:              Canberra Fathers and Children Services Inc & Michael Watson (Residential Tenancies) [2010] ACAT 74
Director of Housing v Sudi [2011] VSCA 266

In the Matter of an Application for Bail by Isa Islam
[2010] ACTSC 147

Date of Orders:  9 November 2011     

Date of ex-tempore

Reasons for Decision:  9 November 2011

Published Reasons for Decision:     4 April 2012

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY            )
CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          AA 30 OF 2011

BETWEEN:

JANELLE THORNTHWAITE

Appellant

AND:

COMMISSIONER FOR SOCIAL HOUSING

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:            Mr W.G Stefaniak, Appeal President
  Mr P.R Thompson, Member

DATE:  9 November 2011

ORDER

1.          The appeals are dismissed.

2.          The residential tenancy agreement is terminated.  Possession  

of the premises shall be given to the lessor at 9 am on
Tuesday 29 November 2010. 

3.           The tenant and any other person claiming right of possession

through the tenancy is to vacate the premises in accordance with the above order.

4.           The deputy registrar is to issue a warrant for eviction for the

Premises, if vacant possession is not given by the appellant at 9 am on Tuesday 29 November 2010.

5.        The tenant shall pay the lessor an occupation fee at the rate
                      of $47.15 per day in addition to the rent from today until the
     date possession of the premises is given to the lessor.

6.        The tenant is to remove all goods and return the premises
                       in clean condition by 9 am on Thursday 29 November 2011.

7.        The tenant is to pay the lessor the sum of $13,770.92,
  payment details to be worked out between the lessor and
  the tenant.

………………………………..

Mr W G Stefaniak

Appeal President

For and on behalf of the Appeal Tribunal

EX-TEMPORE

REASONS FOR DECISION

Application of the Human Rights Act 2004

1.I will first deal with some legal points, which have application well beyond this case.  The first point to deal with is the point raised in relation to the Human Rights Act 2004.  The tribunal is well aware of a couple of recent ACT cases involving residential tenancies where the Human Rights Act has actually been used.

2.In Canberra Fathers and Children Services…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thornthwaite v Commissioner for Social Housing and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] ACAT 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Thornthwaite v Commissioner for Social Housing involved a dispute between a tenant, Mr. Thornthwaite, and the Commissioner for Social Housing, the lessor, over the termination of a residential tenancy agreement. The dispute reached the court after Mr. Thornthwaite had lost an appeal to vacate an ex parte order for eviction based on rental arrears. The central legal issues in the case included the applicability of the Human Rights Act 2004 and the tribunal’s jurisdiction in these matters, as well as the nature of the appeal process from the tribunal’s decision—whether it should be a hearing de novo or a rehearing. Additionally, the court had to consider the factors that would warrant overturning the original tribunal’s decision, such as new evidence or weaknesses in the appellant’s evidence.

The court thoroughly examined the Human Rights Act 2004 and found it did not affect the tribunal's jurisdiction over this matter. The court also determined that the appeal was not a rehearing but a hearing de novo, meaning it was not bound by the tribunal's findings. The court scrutinised the evidence presented and concluded that there was no new evidence, and the appellant's evidence was weak. Consequently, the court upheld the tribunal's decision and dismissed the appeals.

As a result of the court’s decision, the residential tenancy agreement was terminated, and possession of the premises was to be given to the lessor at 9 am on Tuesday 29 November 2010. The tenant was ordered to vacate the premises by the specified date, and a warrant for eviction was to be issued if the tenant did not comply. The tenant was also required to pay an occupation fee and the outstanding rent, and to return the premises in a clean condition. Finally, the court mandated the payment of a lump sum to the lessor to cover the total outstanding amount.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeals are dismissed.

2. The residential tenancy agreement is terminated. Possession

of the premises shall be given to the lessor at 9 am on

Tuesday 29 November 2010.

3. The tenant and any other person claiming right of possession

through the tenancy is to vacate the premises in accordance with the above order.

4. The deputy registrar is to issue a warrant for eviction for the

Premises, if vacant possession is not given by the appellant at 9 am on Tuesday 29 November 2010.

5. The tenant shall pay the lessor an occupation fee at the rate

of $47.15 per day in addition to the rent from today until the

date possession of the premises is given to the lessor.

6. The tenant is to remove all goods and return the premises

in clean condition by 9 am on Thursday 29 November 2011.

7. The tenant is to pay the lessor the sum of $13,770.92,

payment details to be worked out between the lessor and

the tenant.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.