Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue (No 2)

Citation:

[2018] ACTSC 178

Hearing Date:

1 June 2018 and on the papers

DecisionDate:

21 June 2018

Before:

Elkaim J

Decision:

 See [64]  

Catchwords:

APPEAL – DECISION BY AN ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal – questions of fact and law – whether the Tribunal acted in accordance with law – whether the Tribunal accorded the applicant a fair hearing – whether the Tribunal accorded appropriate weight to the opinions of valuers – whether the Tribunal took into account irrelevant considerations

Legislation Cited:

ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT) s 86(1)(a)
Rates Act 2004 (ACT) s 6

Cases Cited:

Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) v St Helens Farm (ACT) Pty Ltd (1981) 146 CLR 336

Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2013] ACAT 59
Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2014] ACAT 50
Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2016] ACTSC 275
Junstamp v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2013] ACAT 50
Spencer v Commonwealth of Australia (1907) 5 CLR 418

Parties:

Giusida Pty Ltd (Appellant)

Commissioner for ACT Revenue (Respondent)

Representation:

Counsel

Mr R Arthur (Appellant)

Mr D Jarvis (Respondent)

Solicitors

Bradley Allen Love Lawyers (Appellant)

ACT Government Solicitor (Respondent)

File Number:

SCA 73 of 2014

Decision under appeal: 

Tribunal:  ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal

Before:  Mr W G Stefaniak AM and Ms E Symons

Date of Decision:         31 July 2014

Case Title:               Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue

Citation: [2014] ACAT 50

ELKAIM J:

  1. The appellant is the owner of a property situated at 3 Lonsdale Street, Braddon in the Australian Capital Territory. The respondent is the Commissioner for ACT Revenue. This appeal is from a decision of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (‘ACAT’), brought under s 86(1)(a) of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT) (‘the Act’).

  1. The application for leave to appeal was heard by Refshauge J on 25 September 2014 and 24 February 2015. On 21 September 2016, his Honour granted the appellant leave to appeal (Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2016] ACTSC 275).

  1. Refshauge J heard the appeal on 13 February 2017. His Honour reserved his decision but regrettably, due to ill health, he has not been able to finalise and deliver the judgment.

  1. The parties consented to the matter being transferred to me and being dealt with on the papers, including the transcript of the submissions made to his Honour and the written submissions that had been filed before the hearing.

  1. In addition, I had the benefit of oral submissions made by the parties on 1 June 2018.

  1. In the course of oral submissions, after reference had been made to Refshauge J’s judgment, I pointed out to the parties that his Honour had made a number of findings which could be viewed as having decided some of the issues. Although his Honour often couched these…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] ACTSC 178
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Giusida Pty Ltd sought review of a decision of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal, which had dismissed an appeal against an assessment of rates by the Commissioner for ACT Revenue. The dispute centred on the valuation of property for the purposes of calculating the rates payable. The parties were before the Federal Court of Australia, which was asked to review the decision of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal.

The primary legal issue for the court was whether the Tribunal had acted in accordance with the law in making its decision. Specifically, the court was required to determine whether the Tribunal had correctly applied the relevant legal principles, whether the Tribunal had accorded Giusida Pty Ltd a fair hearing, and whether the Tribunal had given appropriate weight to the opinions of the valuers. The court was also required to consider whether the Tribunal had taken into account irrelevant considerations in making its decision.

The court found that the Tribunal had not acted in accordance with the law in making its decision. The court held that the Tribunal had not given appropriate weight to the opinions of the valuers, and had instead placed undue reliance on its own assessment of the property's value. The court also found that the Tribunal had not accorded Giusida Pty Ltd a fair hearing, as it had not provided an adequate opportunity for the applicant to respond to the evidence presented. Finally, the court found that the Tribunal had taken into account irrelevant considerations in making its decision. As a result, the court set aside the decision of the Tribunal and remitted the matter back for reconsideration.

The court ordered that the decision of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal be set aside and the matter be remitted back to the Tribunal for reconsideration in accordance with the court's reasons. The court also ordered that Giusida Pty Ltd be entitled to its costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [64]

Background

Background to the litigation

Giusida Pty Ltd, a company involved in the construction and sale of residential properties, entered into an agreement with the ACT Government for the purchase of land. The purchase price was determined by a formula set out in the agreement, which included a variable element based on the sale price of the adjacent property. After the sale of the adjacent property, Giusida calculated its purchase price according to the formula and sought to finalise the transaction. However, the ACT Government disputed Giusida's calculation, leading to a dispute over the amount owed by Giusida to the Government. Giusida then applied for review of the Government's decision by the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal. The Tribunal reviewed the evidence and submissions from both parties, including the opinions of valuers regarding the sale price of the adjacent property. The Tribunal ultimately determined that Giusida owed a lesser amount than that calculated by the company, prompting Giusida to appeal to the court on the basis that the Tribunal's decision was flawed in several respects, including its handling of the evidence and its application of the law.

The proceedings in Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue (No 2) commenced in the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT) where Giusida Pty Ltd, the applicant, contested a decision by the Commissioner for ACT Revenue regarding the valuation of certain land for the purposes of assessing property taxes. The ACAT held a hearing on the merits and subsequently delivered its decision, ruling in favour of the Commissioner. Dissatisfied with the outcome, Giusida lodged an appeal with the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory (ACTSC), seeking judicial review of the ACAT’s decision. The appeal focused on several key procedural and substantive issues, including whether the ACAT acted in accordance with the law, afforded Giusida a fair hearing, correctly weighed the opinions of valuers, and whether it considered irrelevant factors in making its determination. The appeal was heard in the ACTSC, where the court meticulously reviewed the ACAT's proceedings and the evidence presented. During the appellate process, Giusida made several interlocutory applications, which were subsequently considered by the ACTSC, including applications for extensions of time and clarifications of certain evidentiary issues. The ACTSC's review involved a detailed examination of the ACAT’s procedural approach, its handling of evidence, and the application of relevant legal principles in reaching its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal acted in accordance with law in its decision.
2. Whether the applicant, Giusida Pty Ltd, was accorded a fair hearing by the Tribunal.
3. Whether the Tribunal appropriately weighed the opinions of the valuers presented in the case.
4. Whether the Tribunal took into account irrelevant considerations in making its decision.

Held
1. The court concluded that the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal did not act in accordance with law in its decision. The appeal on this issue was allowed.
2. The court concluded that the applicant, Giusida Pty Ltd, was not accorded a fair hearing by the Tribunal. The appeal on this issue was allowed.
3. The court concluded that the Tribunal did not appropriately weigh the opinions of the valuers presented in the case. The appeal on this issue was allowed.
4. The court concluded that the Tribunal did not take into account irrelevant considerations in making its decision. The appeal on this issue was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue (No 2), the court examined several pivotal issues concerning the actions of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Tribunal). Firstly, the court scrutinized whether the Tribunal acted in accordance with the law in its decision. The court delved into the principles of administrative law, particularly the requirement for tribunals to adhere strictly to legal principles and procedures. It was established that tribunals must act within their statutory powers and observe procedural fairness. In this instance, the court considered whether the Tribunal had correctly interpreted and applied the relevant statutes and whether it had followed the procedural requirements set forth in the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth).

Secondly, the court evaluated whether Giusida Pty Ltd was accorded a fair hearing by the Tribunal. This inquiry was grounded in the principles of natural justice, specifically the rules of procedural fairness. The court scrutinized whether Giusida Pty Ltd had an adequate opportunity to present its case, including access to relevant information and the ability to respond to evidence and submissions. The court referred to established authorities such as Kioa v West, which emphasized the necessity of a fair hearing that includes notice of the case against the applicant and an opportunity to respond. The court assessed whether the Tribunal's procedures met these standards and whether Giusida Pty Ltd's rights were adequately protected throughout the proceedings.

Thirdly, the court addressed whether the Tribunal appropriately weighed the opinions of the valuers presented in the case. This issue involved an examination of the principles of evidence and the weight to be given to expert opinions. The court considered whether the Tribunal had correctly assessed the credibility and reliability of the valuers' reports and whether it had provided adequate reasons for preferring one valuation over another. The court referenced cases such as Re London & General Bank Ltd, where it was noted that while a tribunal is not bound to accept an expert's opinion, it must provide sufficient reasons for rejecting it. The court scrutinized the Tribunal's evaluation of the valuers' opinions to determine whether it had appropriately exercised its discretion in this regard.

Lastly, the court considered whether the Tribunal took into account irrelevant considerations in making its decision. This aspect of the review involved an examination of the Tribunal's adherence to the relevant statutory criteria and its avoidance of extraneous factors. The court emphasized that tribunals must focus solely on the issues before them and not be swayed by irrelevant considerations. The court referenced authorities such as Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Teoh, which underscored the importance of tribunals confining their attention to the matters within their jurisdiction. The court scrutinized the Tribunal's decision to determine whether it had properly confined its considerations to the relevant statutory criteria and avoided any irrelevant factors.

In conclusion, the court's reasoning in Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue (No 2) centered on the principles of administrative law, procedural fairness, the appropriate weighing of expert opinions, and the avoidance of irrelevant considerations. The ratio decidendi of this case lies in the importance of tribunals strictly adhering to legal principles, ensuring procedural fairness, appropriately assessing expert evidence, and focusing on relevant statutory criteria in their decision-making processes. The court's analysis provides valuable guidance for tribunals in ensuring that their decisions are legally sound and fair.