Kazmar v Commissioner for Social Housing (Appeal)

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

KAZMAR v COMMISSIONER FOR SOCIAL HOUSING (Appeal) [2024] ACAT 83

AA 6/2024 (RT 1185/2023)

Catchwords:               APPEAL – residential tenancy – termination and possession order under section 51A of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 – whether conduct of the tenant is threatening, intimidating, harassing or abusive – notice requirements – purpose of notice requirements – whether sufficient notice provided – effect of failure to comply with notice requirements – conduct of the lessor in responding to complaints by the tenant about noise from neighbour – whether conduct likely to continue in future due to sensitivity to noise – whether consequence of homelessness of tenant considered – whether Tribunal can order lessor provide alternative housing to the tenant – whether transfer of housing application decision can be reviewed

Legislation cited:        ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 ss 7, 32, 82

Legislation Act 2001 ss 139, 140, 146

Residential Tenancies Act 1997 ss 4A, 45A, 51, 51A, 72, 83

Residential Tenancies Legislation Amendment Act 2023

Cases cited:Council of the Law Society of the ACT v LP 201920 [2021] ACAT 16

Ezekiel-Hart v Council of the Law Society of the Australian Capital Territory (Appeal) [2021] ACAT 116
Giusida Pty Limited v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2016] ACTSC 275
House v R [1936] HCA 40
Legal Practitioner v Council of the Law Society of the ACT [2011] ACTSC 207
Lockwood v The Commonwealth [1954] HCA 31
Norbis v Norbis [1986] HCA 17
Ogilvie v Jemena Networks (ACT) Pty Ltd & Anor [2023] ACAT 20
Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority [1998] HCA 28

List of

Texts/Papers cited:     Revised explanatory statement, Residential Tenancies Legislation Amendment Bill 2022

Appeal Tribunal:       Acting Presidential Member D Stewart

Senior Member R Orr KC

Date of Orders:  29 October 2024

Date of Reasons for Decision:      29 October 2024

Date of Publication:  7 November 2024

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          AA 6/2024

BETWEEN:

STEVEN KAZMAR
Appellant

AND:

COMMISSIONER FOR SOCIAL HOUSING
Respondent

APPEAL TRIBUNAL:        Acting Presidential Member D Stewart

Senior Member R Orr KC

DATE:29 October 2024

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The appeal is upheld.

  2. The orders made by the Original Tribunal on 11 January 2024 are set aside.

  3. The respondent’s application dated 8 December 2023 for a termination and possession order is dismissed.

    ………………………………..

Acting Presidential Member D Stewart
For and on behalf of the Appeal Tribunal

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. Steven Kazmar (Mr Kazmar or appellant) is the tenant of premises in Amaroo, Australian Capital Territory, under a residential tenancy agreement (tenancy) which commenced on 11 December 2019 with the Australian Capital Territory, as represented by the Commissioner for Social Housing (Commissioner or respondent).

  2. In the reasons that follow, a reference to ‘ACAT’ or ‘tribunal’ refers to the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal generally, whereas ‘Appeal Tribunal’ refers to the presently constituted tribunal. When referring to the first instance decision, the Tribunal uses the expression ‘original proceedings’ or ‘Original…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kazmar v Commissioner for Social Housing (Appeal) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ACAT 83
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Kazmar v Commissioner for Social Housing (Appeal) involved the appellant, Kazmar, challenging a decision by the Original Tribunal to terminate his occupancy agreement with the respondent, the Commissioner for Social Housing. The dispute centred on whether the Original Tribunal had correctly applied the statutory requirements outlined in section 51A of the Residential Tenancies Act when issuing a notice for the termination of Kazmar's lease. The appeal was heard by the tribunal, which was tasked with determining whether the notice provided complied with the statutory requirements and whether the Original Tribunal had properly exercised its discretion in ordering the termination and possession of the property.

The key legal issues before the court were whether the notice given to Kazmar complied with the statutory requirements of section 51A, and if not, whether this non-compliance was significant enough to set aside the Original Tribunal's decision. The appellant argued that the notice failed to specify that section 51A was being relied upon and did not clearly outline the conduct against the lessor that was threatening or harassing. The respondent, on the other hand, contended that even if there were shortcomings in the notice, these did not excuse Kazmar's own conduct, which was deemed inappropriate regardless of the respondent's actions.

The tribunal found that the notice did not adequately inform Kazmar that section 51A was being relied upon and did not clearly indicate that the conduct in question was against the lessor or a related party, as required by the statute. The tribunal emphasised the importance of clear and specific notice under section 51A to allow the tenant to understand the case against them and prepare a defence. Despite acknowledging the seriousness of Kazmar's conduct, the tribunal concluded that the failure to provide a compliant notice was a significant procedural error. This error warranted setting aside the Original Tribunal's decision and dismissing the respondent's application for termination and possession.

The tribunal ordered that the appeal be upheld, the orders made by the Original Tribunal on 11 January 2024 be set aside, and the respondent’s application dated 8 December 2023 for a termination and possession order be dismissed. This decision underscored the necessity for compliance with statutory notice requirements to ensure fair process and protect the rights of tenants under the Residential Tenancies Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

The appeal is upheld.

2.

The orders made by the Original Tribunal on 11 January 2024 are set aside.

3.

The respondent’s application dated 8 December 2023 for a termination and possession order is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is true that the Respondent’s Application for Termination made to ACAT does refer to sections 51 and 51A of the RT Act.[48] Also the hearing before the Original Tribunal on 11 January 2024 considered both sections.[49] If the claim by the appellant had been based on the general law concept of procedural fairness, or natural justice, in relation to the tribunal hearing, there would be an argument that this was provided. But the claim was rather based on the express requirements in section 51A, which as we have discussed provided significant statutory rights to the appellant, based on a clear policy. The statute provided expressly for significant notice in addition to the application to the tribunal, and the hearing.Conclusion[48] Respondent’s Application for Termination, page 13[49] Transcript of original hearing dated 11 January 2024, pages 16-20, 46-48 We regard the conduct of the appellant as serious. We also recognise that the provisions should not be read to require unnecessary formal or technical measures. But, we do not think requiring identification of the key elements of the basis for the proposed termination is doing so, especially when it is clear that the purpose of section 51A(3) was to specifically require this. We note that if the respondent thinks it appropriate to do so, a further notice can be issued. This finding is sufficient to allow the appeal. However, given the orders sought by the appellant depend to some extent on the success of other submissions, we consider them below. Section 57A(7) lists various factors which must be taken into account by the tribunal in deciding whether it is appropriate to make a termination and possession order. Paragraph (b) lists “the circumstances of the conduct, including any behaviour of the lessor or related person”. Mr Kazmar submitted that the Original Tribunal had failed to consider, or at least adequately consider, the respondent’s conduct in responding to the appellant’s complaints about the noise and abuse from his neighbour. The appellant had made numerous complaints, taken all the steps outlined by the respondent including making multiple reports to the EPA, and provided evidence of the significant distress and damage caused by his neighbour’s conduct. In response, on the evidence before the Appeal Tribunal, the respondent had issued only one notice to remedy to the neighbour and, in investigating the more recent complaints leading up to the conduct of the appellant in question, only spoken to one other neighbour. The appellant submitted that the respondent had “not taken proper steps to investigate the [appellant’s] complaints and take action accordingly to protect his right to quiet enjoyment of the property”.[50][50] Appellant’s outline of submissions on appeal at [54] The respondent accepted that the appellant had made a large number of complaints about the neighbour’s conduct, but submitted that any conduct by the respondent could not excuse the conduct of the appellant. The conduct of the respondent was sufficient given the rights of other tenants and when considered in conjunction with the steps appropriately being taken by the appellant.[51] Proceedings against the respondent were dismissed. There were also limits on the ability of the respondent to transfer the appellant without a complete application and the difficulties of finding appropriate premises. In those circumstances, the respondent submitted that even if the Appeal Tribunal considers that the respondent might have done more, that does not suggest that the Original Tribunal committed an error in exercising their discretion as to the appropriateness of the order.[51] Transcript of appeal hearing dated 20 June 2024, page 108

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

These differences suggest that it is important the decision-makers have regard to which section is being relied upon, and that the lessee be notified of this.Summary of considerations Therefore, in our view and in summary, the text of section 51A(3), and section 51A(5), requires that the notice set out the conduct against the lessor that is threatening etc. This requirement implements the purpose of the provision which is to enable the tenant to understand the case against them and consider their position and put their case in negotiations and at any hearing. The notice requirement is particularly important in light of the fact that section 51A provides one of a range of possible bases for termination in the RT Act, with differing requirements. In our view, this means the notice needs to make it clear that section 51A is being relied upon and deal with the four specified issues, including that the conduct was against the lessor or a related person.Was there compliance with section 51A(3) notice requirements? In our view, there are several reasons why this requirement was not met in this case.Not clear from notice that section 51A is relied on First, the notice does not make it clear that section 51A is being relied upon. The second notice refers expressly to section 51, suggesting that this is what is being relied upon.[47] The first notice referred to “section 13.2 of the Occupancy Agreement,” which makes the notices even more unclear. It is not necessary that there be express reference to section 51A, but it is necessary to indicate in some way that this is what is being relied upon. There is nothing in the notices which stated or implied that section 51A was being relied upon.Not clear from notice that conduct against the lessor is relied on[47] There is a general presumption an act purporting to be done under one statutory power may be supported under another statutory power, see for example Lockwood v The Commonwealth [1954] HCA 31. But here the requirements of the notice in relation to section 51A are specifically set out in the Act Second, the notice does not make it clear that it is conduct “against a lessor or related party” that is relied on, as required by section 51A. In our view, section 51A means that the conduct must be directed at, or the harms occasioned by the conduct experienced by, the lessor or their representatives. As the appellant accepted that their conduct met the requirements of section 51A(1) we do not need to explore the limits of when threatening etc. conduct, which only indirectly relates to the lessor, may still be against them for the purposes of that section.Conduct was threatening In our view, the appellant's conduct in this matter was threatening etc. Even though the threat was most immediately of harm to the lessor's property or the safety of the appellant or other tenants, it still involved an attempt to use menace to influence the respondent. The frequency and potential harm involved with the conduct may also constitute harassment. There is no need for the respondent to establish that any action to burn down the building may also have directly harmed employees of the respondent caught up in any fire. The objective nature of section 51A(1)(b) requires only that the lessor believe that the conduct can be reasonably considered threatening etc.