HTI Watson Pty Limited v Commissioner for ACT Revenue

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

HTI WATSON PTY LIMITED v COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE (Administrative Review) [2020] ACAT 30

AT 33/2019

Catchwords:               ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – land valuation – lease variation charge – methods of valuation – comparable sales method – full hypothetical development method – hybrid method – principle in Toohey’s case – comparable sale method preferable

Legislation cited:        ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 s 68

Planning and Development Act 2007 ss 276B, 277, 277A, 407, 408A
Rates Act 2004 s 6

Cases cited:Boland v Yates Property Corporation Pty Ltd (1994) 74 ALJR 209

Commonwealth Custodial Services Pty Ltd v Valuer-General (2007) 156 LGERA 186
Doherty v Commissioner of Highways (1974) 7 SASR 57
Estate of James v Valuer-General (1942) 15 LGR (NSW) 110
Fenton Nominees v Valuer-General (1981) 27 SASR 258
Giusida Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2016] ACTSC 275
ISPT Pty Ltd and City of Melbourne [2007] VCAT 652
Krisgay Pty Ltd v Valuer-General [2007] NSWLEC 600
Maurici v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue (2003) 212 CLR 111
Marroun v Roads and Maritime Services [2012] NSWLEC 199
Nap Nap Station Pty Ltd v Valuer-General (1989) 72 LGRA 275
Toohey’s Ltd v Valuer-General (1925) AC 439
Valuer-General v Fenton Nominees Pty Ltd (1982) 150 CLR 160
Waalt Homes Pty Ltd v Road Construction Authority (1984) 64 LGRA 346
Western Australian Planning Commission v Arcus Shopfitters Pty Ltd [2003] WASCA 295

Texts/Papers cited:     Alan A Hyam, The Law Affecting Valuation of Land in Australia (4th ed, 2014)

Tribunal:  Senior Member R Orr QC (Presiding)

Senior Member D Lovell

Date of Orders:  5 May 2020

Date of Reasons for Decision:      5 May 2020

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          AT 33/2019

BETWEEN:

HTI WATSON PTY LIMITED

Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:Senior Member R Orr QC (Presiding)

Senior Member D Lovell

DATE:5 May 2020

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The decision of the respondent in a notice dated 18 October 2018, as confirmed in a notice dated 11 April 2019, in relation to the lease variation charge payable by the applicant for the variations concerning the Crown lease of  block 2 section 64 Watson is set aside and replaced by a substitute decision that the before value (V2) is assessed to be $7,100,000 and the after value (V1) is assessed to be $26,350,000.

  2. The matter is remitted to the respondent for a determination of the lease variation charge based on these amounts.

………………………………..

Senior Member R Orr QC

Senior Member D Lovell

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. On about 1 April 2016 HTI Watson Pty Limited (HTI Watson or applicant) agreed to purchase block 2 section 64 Watson which was about 44,215 square metres (subject site) for $8,600,000. [1]

    [1] Exhibit T1 page T180; exhibit A2, tab 2

  2. On about 13 December 2016 the applicant lodged a lease variation and development application (DA 201630707) (development application or DA ) in relation to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read HTI Watson Pty Limited v Commissioner for ACT Revenue and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] ACAT 30
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

HTI Watson Pty Limited, the applicant, was involved in a dispute with the Commissioner for ACT Revenue, the respondent, regarding the valuation of land for the purpose of determining a lease variation charge. This matter was heard in the Australian Capital Territory Civil and Administrative Tribunal. The Tribunal was tasked with resolving the dispute concerning the appropriate method of valuation and the subsequent assessment of the land's value before and after the lease variation.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was the selection of an appropriate method for valuing the land in question for the purposes of determining the lease variation charge. The Tribunal considered the various methods proposed by the parties, including the comparable sales method, the full hypothetical development method, and a hybrid method. The Tribunal needed to determine which method best aligned with the principle in Toohey’s case and which method would provide the most accurate and reliable valuation.

The Tribunal concluded that while Mr Swinbourne, the applicant's valuer, believed the most appropriate method was by direct comparison of sales, there were insufficient comparable sales available to meaningfully apply this method. However, the Tribunal found that Mr Swinbourne's analysis of the available sales data was inadequate, lacking detailed and specific information. Consequently, the Tribunal determined that the comparable sales method, despite its shortcomings, was preferable over the alternative methods proposed by the parties. The Tribunal also noted that there was significant evidence suggesting that the property was purchased for development, casting doubt on the reliability of the before value derived solely from the sale price.

Based on the Tribunal's findings, it set aside the respondent's decision and substituted it with a new assessment. The Tribunal assessed the before value (V2) at $7,100,000 and the after value (V1) at $26,350,000. The Tribunal further remitted the matter to the respondent to determine the lease variation charge based on these revised valuations.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

The decision of the respondent in a notice dated 18 October 2018, as confirmed in a notice dated 11 April 2019, in relation to the lease variation charge payable by the applicant for the variations concerning the Crown lease of block 2 section 64 Watson is set aside and replaced by a substitute decision that the before value (V2) is assessed to be $7,100,000 and the after value (V1) is assessed to be $26,350,000.

2.

The matter is remitted to the respondent for a determination of the lease variation charge based on these amounts.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr McInerney, in his original assessment, looked primarily at the sale of the subject site. He took that sale price of $8,600,000, deducted the value of buildings and car parking, driveways, service lines and landscaping, which he assessed at $4,860,000, to give a before value of $3,740,000.[30] He used $80/sqm to get a rounded value of $3,530,000.[31] A similar approach was taken on the review, though with some regard to comparable sales.[32] Further, a similar approach was taken in Mr McInerney’s statement for these proceedings (exhibit R2) [33] and his oral evidence, though with some regard to comparable sales. The Tribunal thinks there is some doubt about this approach, as there is significant evidence that the property was purchased for development, and was not therefore a useful basis for a before value.Conclusion on before value (V2)[30] Exhibit T1 page T576[31] Exhibit T1 pages T576 and T584[32] Exhibit T1 pages T188-T192[33] Pages 13-15 The Tribunal therefore thinks it is appropriate to accept the agreement of the parties that the applicant’s before value should be accepted. The remaining dispute is therefore about the after value (V1). Mr Swinbourne for the applicant and Mr McInerney for the respondent provided detailed reports, gave oral evidence and were cross-examined in relation to their assessment of the after value (V1). They each provided a list of sales which they considered to be evidence of the value of the subject land in the after sale (V1) scenario. They generally analysed the sales to derive unit rates, either on a per dwelling basis or a per square metre basis, to apply to the subject site. As to dwellings, it was accepted by both sides that the whole development would consist of 320 residential dwellings, made up of 170 apartments, 125 townhouses and 25 terraces and commercial and childcare uses.[34] Mr Swinbourne also used two other approaches, a full hypothetical development method and his preferred hybrid method for the after value scenario.[34] Exhibit A1 page 45(36); exhibit R2 page 32; exhibit T1 page T574 The relevant date of valuation is 31 October 2017. The land has an area of about 44,211- 44,217 square metres; the difference is of no consequence. Mr Swinbourne tendered a table (exhibit A7) which indicated an increase in the moving annual median price for townhouses over the period March 2014 to October 2017 of 5.19%. Both valuers agreed that the market had been relatively stable over the period 2014 to 2018 and so no adjustment was necessary to most of the sales to account for time. Mr Swinbourne’s evidence was that the most appropriate method of valuation was by direct comparison sales, but that there were no sufficiently comparable sales to allow the direct comparison method to be meaningfully utilised, and therefore it was necessary to use another approach.[35] [35] Exhibit A1 page 43(34); transcript of proceedings 5 September 2019 page 152; applicant’s closing submissions at [108] Mr Swinbourne did identify 45 sales in his table 4 of his report, but he said that these generally represent the sale of development ready sites, and the subject site was not in this condition.[36] We make an important point here, which we return to below; in relation to the 45 sales, Mr Swinbourne provides very little information. Mr Swinbourne’s comments about them are very generalised, broad brush and conclusionary. Mr Swinbourne does identify three sales of larger land areas in his table 5. He does seem to admit that these are more useful as comparable sales.[37][36] Exhibit A1 page 43(34)[37] Exhibit A1 page 47(38)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established