Moffat & Anor v Rezo & Anor (Appeal)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

MOFFAT & ANOR v REZO & ANOR (Appeal) [2023] ACAT 62

AA 18/2023 (RT 415/2023)

Catchwords:                APPEAL – RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES – whether an outgoing report made by the lessor’s agent meets the requirement of section 30A of the Residential Tenancies Act, and if it does not, whether the lessor’s application should be dismissed– whether a lessor must obtain two quotes in support of any damage/compensation claim – whether compensation for the cost of repairs to damaged walls and ceiling should be depreciated having regard to the depreciated value of the paint – appeal dismissed

Legislation cited:        ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 ss 7, 26

Legislation Act 2011 s 140
Residential Tenancies Act 1997 ss 29, 30, 30A, 35, 53A, 71AB, Division 3.4
Residential Tenancies Legislation Amendment Act 2016

Cases cited:Commonwealth v Amann Aviation P/L [1991] HCA 54

Pawley, Lynda & Harvey, Trent v Loibner, Franz [1995] NSWRT 48
Tankard and Anor v Obgonna and Anor [2017] ACAT 72
Hoad v Scone Motors P/L [1977] NSWLR 88

List of

Texts/Papers cited:     Allan Anforth et al, Residential tenancies Law and Practice New South Wales (The Federation Press, 7th ed, 2017)

ATO, ‘Residential rental property items’, Rental Properties 2023 (Web Page, 10 August 2023)
Peter Butt, Butterworths Concise Australian Legal Dictionary (LexisNexis Butterworths, 3rd ed, 2004)

Tribunal:Presidential Member H Robinson

Date of Orders:  17 October 2023

Date of Reasons for Decision:      17 October 2023

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          AA 18/2023

BETWEEN:

SAM MOFFAT
First Appellant/Tenant

AND:

VANESSA LAMANNA
Second Appellant/Tenant

AND:

MIRO REZO
First Respondent/Lessor

AND:

JURE REZO
Second Respondent/ Lessor

APPEAL TRIBUNAL:       Presidential Member H Robinson

DATE:17 October 2023

CORRECTED ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The appeal is dismissed.

………………………………

Presidential Member H Robinson

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This is an appeal against a decision of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (the tribunal) in the matter of RT 415/2023. In that matter, the member who heard the application (the Original Tribunal) awarded the lessor the sum of $1,430 in compensation for damage in the form of small holes in the ceiling and walls, such compensation to be deducted from the bond.

  2. The appellants allege that the Original Tribunal made several errors of fact and law. The main issues for the Appeal Tribunal are:

    (a)whether an outgoing condition report that is finalised by the lessor’s agent some hours after the inspection took place meets the requirements of section 30A of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (RT Act) and, if it does not, whether the lessor’s application should be dismissed;

    (b)whether a lessor must obtain two quotes in support of any damage/compensation claim; and

    (c)whether compensation for the cost of “patch and paint” repairs to damaged walls and ceiling should be depreciated having regard to the depreciated value of the original paintwork.

Background

  1. On 1 June 2020, Sam Moffat and Vanessa Lamana (the appellants or tenants) and Miro Rezo and Juro Rezo…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moffat & Anor v Rezo & Anor (Appeal) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACAT 62
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Moffat & Anor v Rezo & Anor (Appeal) concerns a dispute between the appellants, Moffat and another, and the respondents, Rezo and another. The core issue revolves around the condition of a leased property and the respective responsibilities of the lessor and lessee regarding its maintenance and repair. The dispute escalated to the court, which was required to determine whether the failure to comply with statutory requirements regarding condition reports rendered subsequent claims for compensation invalid. The case particularly focused on the implications of not providing an ingoing condition report and the consequences of not having an outgoing condition report, as outlined in section 30 of the Residential Tenancies Act (RT Act).

The legal issues at the heart of this case were whether the non-compliance with the statutory requirements for an ingoing condition report and the absence of an outgoing condition report invalidated the lessor's claims for compensation. The court had to interpret section 30 of the RT Act, which provides that evidence of the condition of the premises at the start and end of the tenancy can be presented even if the statutory requirements are not followed. The court was also required to determine the practical implications of such non-compliance on the ability of the lessor to substantiate claims against the lessee for damage to the property.

The court ruled that non-compliance with the statutory requirements for an ingoing condition report does not render the lessor's subsequent claim for compensation invalid. Instead, section 30(3) of the RT Act provides that evidence from the tenant about the condition of the premises at the start of the tenancy is still admissible, even if it does not satisfy the requirements of sections 29(1) and (3). This means that while a lessor may find it difficult to satisfy the evidentiary burden if they fail to properly complete an ingoing condition report, they are not precluded from making a claim altogether. Regarding the outgoing condition report, the court found that its absence does not affect the validity of a claim, but it is still evidence of the condition of the property at the end of the tenancy. The appellants' admission to causing damage to several parts of the property, supported by photographs, rendered their argument regarding liability for the repairs unconvincing.

In conclusion, the court determined that the appellants were liable for the cost of repairing the damage they admitted to causing. The failure to provide an ingoing condition report did not prevent the lessor from making a claim, and the absence of an outgoing condition report did not negate the validity of the lessor's claim. The court's decision highlighted the importance of adhering to statutory requirements for condition reports but also underscored that non-compliance does not automatically invalidate a claim for compensation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Returning to section 30 of the RT Act, this deals with that happens when there is no ingoing condition report.[11] It creates an evidentiary rule, as follows:30 Evidence of condition of premises(1) If section 29 (1) and (3) have been complied with, a statement in a report mentioned in section 29 about the state of repair or general condition of the premises, and of any goods leased with the premises, (other than a statement in relation to which the tenant, by endorsement, has indicated disagreement) is evidence of that state of repair or general condition on the day the tenant was given the report.(2) If only section 29 (1) has been complied with, a statement in a report mentioned in section 29 about the state of repair or general condition of the premises, and of any goods leased with the premises, is evidence of that state of repair or general condition on the day the tenant was given the report.(3) If section 29 (1) has not been complied with, evidence by the tenant about the state of repair or general condition of the premises, and of any goods leased with the premises, is evidence of that state of repair or general condition on the day the tenant took possession of the premises.[11] The requirement for which are set out in section 29 of the RT Act In summary, a failure to comply with the statutory requirements in section 30 in relation to an ingoing condition report does not render a lessor’s subsequent claim for compensation invalid. The section provides only that “evidence by the tenant about the state of repair or general condition of the premises … is evidence of that state of repair or general condition on the day the tenant took possession of the premises.”[12] Exactly what this means is unclear, but the Tribunal must at least consider the evidence of the tenant to be evidence of the “general condition” of the house at the commencement of the tenancy, even if ultimately it is not satisfied that it amounts to proof of a particular matter. This means, in practical terms, a lessor who fails to properly complete an ingoing condition report may struggle to satisfy the evidentiary burden should they later make a claim on the bond. However, there is nothing in the RT Act preventing the lessor from bringing a claim. [12] RT Act section 30(3) It is unclear to me whether the failure to include an outgoing report in section 30 the RT Act was a policy decision or an oversight, but either way, there is no equivalent provision that applies where there is a failure to comply with the statutory requirements for an outgoing condition report. So, what, then, is the purpose of an outgoing report? Given the legislative framework, it would appear to be that a properly completed outgoing condition report is evidence of the condition of the property at the time the tenancy came to an end, but it is not conclusive proof, and its completion is not a prerequisite to either party making a claim for compensation. That said, this is all rather theoretical in this case. The appellants, quite rightly, admit to having caused damage to at least five walls and a ceiling. The photographs speak for themselves. Their evidence is evidence as to the state of the property at the conclusion of the tenancy. It is disingenuous to argue they are not liable for the cost of repairing at least the conceded damage.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.