Hawkesbury Nominees Pty Ltd v Battik Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Hawkesbury Nominees Pty Ltd v Battik Pty Ltd [2000] FCA 185

LEASE – breach of covenant for quiet enjoyment – obligation of lessor not to derogate from grant – whether assignee of lease entitled to sue for damages sustained by it on lessor’s breach – whether damages limited to period for which tenant paid rent.

LEASE – termination of lease – whether in the circumstances repudiation of lease by lessor or lessee.

DAMAGES – measure of damages for breach of covenant in lease for quiet enjoyment discussed, whether damages as assessed were justified by evidence.

Shevill v Builders Licensing Board (1982) 149 CLR 620 referred to
Goldsworthy Mining Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1973) 128 CLR 199 cited
O’Keefe & McKenna v Williams (1910) 11 CLR 171 cited
Dennett v Atherton (1872) 7 QB 316 referred to
Robinson v Kilvert (1889) 41 Ch D 88 referred to
Martins Camera Corner v Hotel Mayfair Ltd [1976] 2 NSWLR 15 discussed
Aussie Traveller Pty Ltd v Marklea Pty Ltd [1997] 1 Qd R 1 discussed
Aldin v Latimer Clark, Muirhead & Co [1894] 2 Ch 437 discussed
Telex (Australasia) Pty Ltd v Thomas Cook & Son (Australasia) Pty Ltd [1970] 2 NSWR 257
referred to
Dawson v Dyer (1833) 5 B & Ad 584; 110 ER 906 cited
Edge v Boileau (1885) 16 QBD 117, Halsbury, Laws of England (4th ed) cited
Taylor v Webb [1937] 2 KB 283 cited
Dowse v Wynyard Holdings Ltd [1962] NSWR 252 cited
The Progressive Mailing House Pty Ltd v Tabali Pty Ltd (1985) 157 CLR 17 cited
Gates v City Mutual Life Assurance Society Ltd (1986) 160 CLR 1 cited
Mira v Aylmer Square Investments Ltd [1990] 1 EGLR 45 cited
Robinson v Harman (1848) 1 Ex 850 referred to
Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd (1991) 174 CLR 64 applied
Calabar Properties v Stitcher [1984] 1 WLR 287 cited
Pennant Hills Restaurants Pty Ltd v Burrell Insurances Pty Ltd (1981) 145 CLR 625 cited
Tramways Advertising Pty Ltd v Luna Park (NSW) Pty Ltd (1938) 38 SR (NSW) 632
referred to
Todburn Pty Ltd v Taormina International Pty Ltd (1990) 5 BPR NSW (SC) 97333
referred to

Southwark London Borough Council v Mills [1999] 3 WLR 939 applied
Jenkins v Levinson (1929) 29 SR (NSW) 151 cited
Karaggianis v Malltown Pty Ltd (1979) 21 SASR 381 cited
Setana Pty Ltd v Permanent Trustee Nominees (Canberra) Ltd (1987) NSW Conv R 55-322 cited
Homebush Abattoir Corporation v Bermria Pty Ltd (1991) 22 NSWLR 605 cited
Wilcox v Richardson (1997) 43 NSWLR 4 cited
Bradford House Pty Ltd v Leroy Fashion Group Ltd (1983) ATPR 40-387 cited

HAWKESBURY NOMINEES PTY LIMITED AND OTHERS v
BATTIK PTY LIMITED AND OTHERS

A 47 of 1999

GALLOP, HILL AND GYLES JJ
1 MARCH 2000
CANBERRA


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY

A 47 OF 1999

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE AUSTRALIAN…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hawkesbury Nominees Pty Ltd v Battik Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 185
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hawkesbury Nominees Pty Ltd v Battik Pty Ltd is an appeal case concerning a dispute over a sublease agreement. The lessors, Hawkesbury Nominees Pty Ltd, had subleased basement premises to Messrs Williams and Brayshaw, who later assigned the lease to Battik Pty Ltd. Battik sought damages for breaches of covenant for quiet enjoyment and an implied term regarding the air system, while the lessors cross-claimed for damages for wrongful repudiation of the lease by Battik. The Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory found in favour of Battik, awarding them damages of $130,000 plus interest and dismissing the lessors' cross-claim. The lessors appealed the decision to the full Court of the Australian Capital Territory. The appeal centred on whether the lessors breached the covenant for quiet enjoyment by relocating the exhaust fan and reducing the efficiency of the restaurant's kitchen. The primary judge found that the lessors did breach the covenant, rejecting the contention that the exhaust system was a tenant's fixture or that Battik should take the premises as they were at the time of assignment. The judge also rejected the argument that the covenant for quiet enjoyment did not extend to keeping the premises fit for use as a restaurant. The lessors argued that ordinary contractual principles applied to the lease, but the judge found that Battik's actions, including holding an auction on the premises, constituted repudiatory conduct, justifying the lessors' acceptance of the repudiation and termination of Battik's obligation to pay rent.

The full Court of the Australian Capital Territory allowed the appeal in part, substituting the award of $130,000 with $93,956.12 in favour of the respondent. The appeal was otherwise dismissed, and the appellants were ordered to pay three-quarters of the respondents' costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed to the extent that in substitution for the sum of $130,000 there be judgment for the respondent in the sum of $93,956.12.

2. Otherwise, the appeal is dismissed.

3. The appellants are to pay three-quarters of the respondents’ costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

By a sublease dated 22 September 1994 but stipulated to commence on 1 February 1994 (“the lease”) the lessors had subleased the basement premises to a Mr Williams and a Mr Brayshaw. On 22 November 1995, Messrs Williams and Brayshaw assigned the lease to Battik Pty Ltd, the First Respondent (“Battik”). Battik claimed that the appellants breached a covenant in the lease for quiet enjoyment or breached an implied term not to interfere with an air system so as to render the premises unfit for the purposes of a restaurant, and that in consequence it was entitled to damages. The lessors cross claimed for damages for wrongful repudiation of the lease by Battik. Battik succeeded in the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory in its claim and in the result was awarded damages in the sum of $130,000 plus interest. The cross-claim was dismissed. The lessors now appeal to the full Court of this Court against the judgment entered against them.The factual background to the appeal The lease provided that the lessee was obliged within four months of the commencement date to upgrade the kitchen in the basement in accordance with a schedule which was attached to the lease. Notwithstanding this requirement the permitted use of the premises was stated to be :“Any use permitted by the Crown Lease” Clause 25 of the lease provided as follows:“(a)That the said Lessor will at its own expense light and keep neat and clean the entrance hall adjacent to the premises, stairs, passages, lavatories, conveniences and water closets in the said building and will pay all rates and taxes which may be payable in respect of the premises during the continuance of the term hereby granted provided that nothing herein contained shall create in the Lessor any obligation to pay for outgoings that may be occasioned by reason of the business and the nature thereof carried on by the said Lessee.(b)That the said Lessee paying the rent and charges aforesaid and performing and observing the covenants provisions conditions and restrictions herein contained on the Lessee’s part to be paid observed and performed shall peaceably hold and enjoy the said premises without hindrance or interruption by the said Lessor or any other corporation person or persons claiming under it until the expiration or sooner determination of the said term.(c)Subject to clause 23 that the Lessor will provide and maintain the air conditioning plant in good order and condition.” Messrs Williams and Brayshaw used the premises for a restaurant, serving Italian style food. When they took over the premises it was ventilated by an exhaust fan located in the basement. There was ducting from the kitchen to the fan and thence from the fan to the roof of the building. This appears to have created complaints from tenants of the building as odours from the restaurant were dissipated up the exhaust ducting slowly and were detectable to the other tenants. Between 14 and 16 August 1995 the appellants moved the exhaust fan from the basement area to the roof, apparently to obviate the annoyance to other tenants. According to Mr Williams this caused an increase in smoke in the kitchen and an increase in heat. Mr Williams requested that something be done. He believed that the problem may have been the existence of holes in the vertical ducting. Mr Williams recalled receiving a complaint from customers siting close to the staff entrance to the kitchen. He did not recall any complaints from customers sitting further away. He used a free standing fan in the kitchen to help cope with the heat

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GALLOP, HILL AND GYLES JJ
It was the case for Battik, as pleaded, that the lessors were in breach of the covenant in the lease for quiet enjoyment by virtue of the defective exhaust ventilation system, and that this had led to financial loss to Battik. Battik further claimed to have been entitled to terminate the lease as and from 26 June 1996. By way of defence the lessors claimed that the exhaust system, inclusive of the fan and the ducts were tenants fixtures and thus the lessors had no responsibility. Alternatively any right to claim damages was denied. By way of cross claim the lessors claimed rent unpaid to 25 June when they had resumed possession of the premises. They claimed that there had been repudiation by Battik which had been accepted by the lessors resuming possession and claimed damages. The decision appealed from The learned primary judge took as the first issue in the case the question whether the lessors had breached the covenant for quiet enjoyment by the relocation of the exhaust fan and the consequential reduction in efficiency of the kitchen of the restaurant. His Honour was of the view that they did. He said:“I have found it likely that it was compounded by a gradual deterioration in the capacity of the joints in the ducting to prevent fumes leaking out. There was, therefore, a combination of a failure to repair the exhaust ducting system, a failure to operate the air-conditioning and fresh air ventilation systems satisfactorily, and the effects of the decision to relocate the exhaust fan in an attempt to minimise the leaks of odours from the ducting thereby exacerbating the inefficiency of the system at the range hood level.” In so finding, his Honour rejected the contention that the exhaust system or part of it was a tenant’s fixture. That matter is no longer in contention between the parties. His Honour also rejected a submission that Battik should be required to take the premises as it found them at the time of assignment, a submission closely connected to an argument that there was no cause of action in Battik because the breach, if there was one, arose before Battik became lessee by assignment. On this latter matter his Honour said:“It is no answer that the breach was initiated when Battik’s predecessor in title was the lessee. It continued up until the time Battik repudiated the lease. It was a continuing breach of an express covenant. Battik is therefore entitled to damages for any loss caused by that breach.” His Honour also rejected a submission that the covenant for quiet enjoyment did not extend to an obligation to keep the premises fit for use as a restaurant. His Honour then turned to look at the position of the lessors. He noted that the right of the lessor continued until the lease was terminated and stated the question to be determined to be whether the circumstances surrounding the termination of the lease gave rise to an action for damages by the lessors or afforded Battik a defence to the cross-claim. In his Honour’s view ordinary contractual principles were applicable to a lease, notwithstanding that a lease operated to confer an interest in land, save that for conduct to be “repudiatory conduct” it had to evince an intention no longer to be bound. His Honour then said (paragraph 166 of the judgment):“It is also clear that, by holding the auction on the premises, Battik was then indicating an intention to abandon possession. That repudiation was accepted by the lessor physically taking possession of the premises and excluding Battik from them. The holding of the auction was itself a breach of cl 5 (c)(6) of the lease. It did afford evidence of Battik’s intention to terminate the lease and abandon possession. Clearly the lessor was entitled to accept that repudiation. Thus, as from 26 June 1996, Battik’s obligation to pay rent was terminated.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GALLOP, HILL AND GYLES JJ