Danny Pearson & Cheryl Pearson v Commissioner for Housing in the Act

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES TRIBUNAL

CITATION:DANNY PEARSON & CHERYL PEARSON –v- COMMISSIONER FOR HOUSING IN THE ACT [2007] ACTRTT 25 

RT 2359 of 2006

Catchwords: Compensation, breach of covenant for quiet enjoyment.

Issues:Breach of covenant for quiet enjoyment.

Conduct of neighbouring lessee of common lessor.

Liability of lessor for specific damage caused by action of tenant.

Liability of lessor for compensation for breach of Residential Tenancy Agreement.

Legislation:Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT)

Sections: 6A; 104 (d);

Prescribed terms: 52;70;73.

Cases cited:Project Blue Moon Pty Limited v Fairway Trading Pty Limited, ACTTT 139 of 1998 and 243 of 1998 (16 April 1999);

Aussie Traveller P/L v Marklea P/L,(1997) QCA 2 (11 February 1997).

Hawkesbury Nominees P/L v Battik P/L, (2000) FCA 185 (1 March 2000).

Mullins v Pace (1998) NSWRT 251;

Worrall v Commissioner for Housing in the ACT (2002) FCA 127;

Sampson v Floyd (1989) 33 EG 41

Ingram v Department of Housing (Tenancy) (2002) NSWCTT 84 (8 May 2002).

Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 9 Exch 341

Robinson v Harman (1848) 1 Exch 850

Northern Sanblasting Pty Ltd v Harris (1997) 188 CLR 313

Elliot v Nanda (2001) 111 FCR 240

Department of Housing v Consumer, Trader and Tenancy Tribunal & Ingram (2003) NSWSC 150

Tribunal:Ms J Lennard, Member

Date:             19th November 2007 

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY                   
RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES TRIBUNAL               )          NO: RT 2359 of 2006

RE:     DANNY PEARSON & CHERYL PEARSON

(Applicant/Tenant)

AND:COMMISSIONER    FOR HOUSING IN THE ACT

(Respondent/Lessor)

DECISION

Tribunal  :          Ms J Lennard, Member

Date  :          30 March 2007

Decision  :          19 November 2007

  1. That the respondent – Commissioner for Housing in the ACT, is to pay an amount of $16,500.00 to the Applicants – Danny Pearson & Cheryl Pearson, within 7 days of the date of this Order.

…………………………….
  Member

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY                   )
RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES TRIBUNAL               )          NO: RT 2359 of 2006

RE:DANNY PEARSON & CHERYL PEARSON

(Applicant/Tenants)

AND:  COMMISSIONER FOR `                HOUSING IN THE ACT

(Respondent/Lessor)

REASONS FOR DECISION

19 November 2007  Ms J Lennard, Member

Re: Premises at 7/5 Tennison-Woods Circuit, Bonython ACT

BACKGROUND

  1. The Respondent is the lessor and the Applicants are the tenants of premises at 7/5 Tennison-Woods Circuit, Bonython ACT. The Residential Tenancy Agreement between the parties in relation to those premises commenced in December 1995.

  2. Rick Kennedy and Elizabeth Daniels are residents of a neighbouring property, 8/5 Tennison-Woods Circuit, Bonython ACT. The Respondent is the lessor of that property. Rick Kennedy and Elizabeth Daniels and their nine children have lived in their premises from about January 2005. Ms Elizabeth Daniels is the tenant. Residential Tenancies Tribunal notes that not all of the children live in the premises all of the time, and that for a period of time the children had been removed from the premises by child protection.

  3. The Applicants made application to the Residential Tenancies Tribunal on 23 November 2006, for damages for breach of contract by the Respondent, constituted by the lessor’s failure to prevent conduct by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Danny Pearson & Cheryl Pearson v Commissioner for Housing in... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] ACTRTT 25
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Danny Pearson and Cheryl Pearson brought an action against the Commissioner for Housing in the ACT, seeking compensation for the Commissioner's failure to address a breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment and for specific damage caused by the actions of a neighbouring tenant. The Applicants, lessees of a property managed by the Commissioner, alleged that the neighbouring tenant's conduct significantly interfered with their peaceful enjoyment of the property and resulted in specific damages. The Commissioner, in turn, denied any liability for the alleged breaches, asserting that the issues were within the purview of the Residential Tenancy Agreement and not subject to their responsibility.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the Commissioner, as the lessor, was liable for the neighbouring tenant's actions that breached the covenant for quiet enjoyment and caused specific damage to the Applicants' property. Additionally, the court had to determine if the Commissioner was responsible for compensating the Applicants for the breach of the Residential Tenancy Agreement. The Applicants argued that the Commissioner's inaction in addressing the issues amounted to a failure to maintain the covenant for quiet enjoyment, while the Commissioner contended that the issues were purely between the Applicants and the neighbouring tenant, governed by the terms of the Residential Tenancy Agreement.

The court found that the Commissioner, as the lessor, was indeed liable for the breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment due to their failure to address the neighbouring tenant's actions. The court determined that the Commissioner had a duty to ensure that the residential environment was suitable for habitation, which included addressing disturbances caused by other tenants. Furthermore, the court held that the Commissioner was also responsible for compensating the Applicants for the specific damage caused by the neighbouring tenant's actions. The court emphasised that the Commissioner's failure to act constituted a breach of their obligations under the Residential Tenancy Agreement and warranted compensation to the Applicants.

The court ordered the Commissioner to pay $16,500 to the Applicants, Danny Pearson and Cheryl Pearson, within seven days of the date of the order. This amount was determined to be adequate compensation for the breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment and for the specific damage caused by the neighbouring tenant's actions.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. That the respondent Commissioner for Housing in the ACT, is to pay an amount of $16,500.00 to the Applicants Danny Pearson & Cheryl Pearson, within 7 days of the date of this Order.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Pearsons, Danny and Cheryl, were tenants of a residential property managed by the Commissioner for Housing in the ACT. Their tenancy was governed by a Residential Tenancy Agreement. The property was part of a larger housing estate, and the neighbouring property was occupied by other tenants. The neighbouring tenants engaged in conduct that caused significant disturbance to the Pearsons, including loud noise, disruptive activities, and other disturbances that affected the quiet enjoyment of the property. The Pearsons reported these issues to the Commissioner for Housing in the ACT, who did not take adequate action to resolve the disturbances. As a result, the Pearsons experienced distress and incurred specific damages due to the breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment. They sought compensation for the damages caused by the neighbouring tenants' conduct and the Commissioner's failure to address the issue adequately.

The case was heard in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The Pearsons filed a claim against the Commissioner for Housing in the ACT, seeking compensation for the breach of covenant for quiet enjoyment and specific damages caused by the neighbouring tenants' conduct. The Commissioner denied liability and argued that the disturbances were not within their control. The matter proceeded to a hearing where evidence was presented, and submissions were made by both parties. The court considered the evidence and arguments to determine the liability of the Commissioner for Housing in the ACT for the breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment and the compensation owed to the Pearsons.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Commissioner for Housing in the ACT is liable for the breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment due to the conduct of the neighbouring tenants.
2. Whether the Commissioner for Housing in the ACT is liable for compensation for the specific damages caused by the breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment.
3. The amount of compensation, if any, that the Commissioner for Housing in the ACT should pay to the Pearsons for the breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment and the specific damages incurred.

Held
1. The Commissioner for Housing in the ACT is not liable for the breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment due to the conduct of the neighbouring tenants.
2. The Commissioner for Housing in the ACT is liable for compensation for the specific damages caused by the breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment.
3. The Commissioner for Housing in the ACT should pay an amount of $16,500.00 to the Pearsons for the breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment and the specific damages incurred.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the relationship between the Commissioner for Housing in the ACT and the Pearsons as landlord and tenants respectively, and the obligations owed under the Residential Tenancy Agreement. The court concluded that while the Commissioner for Housing in the ACT had a duty to ensure that the residential premises were fit for habitation and did not cause a nuisance to neighbouring properties, the Commissioner was not liable for the breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment caused by the actions of the neighbouring tenants. The court held that the Commissioner's responsibility for maintaining the premises and ensuring that they were fit for habitation did not extend to controlling the conduct of neighbouring tenants. However, the court found the Commissioner liable for compensation for the specific damages caused by the breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment. The Commissioner's liability arose from the fact that the Commissioner had failed to take reasonable steps to address the noise from the neighbouring property, which had resulted in the specific damages incurred by the Pearsons. The court held that the Commissioner was liable for compensation for the specific damages caused by the breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment, and awarded the Pearsons $16,500.00 in damages. The court noted that the amount of compensation awarded was based on the evidence presented by the Pearsons and was intended to cover the cost of repairing the damage to the Pearsons' property caused by the noise from the neighbouring property. The court did not consider it necessary to order the Commissioner to take any further action to address the noise from the neighbouring property, as the compensation awarded was sufficient to address the specific damages caused by the breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment.