Dangar & Anor v Mansour & Anor (Residential Tenancies)

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



DANGAR & ANOR v MANSOUR & ANOR (Residential Tenancies) [2016] ACAT 61

RT 234/2016

Catchwords:              RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES – compensation – leased premises not a valid address

Legislation cited:      Residential Tenancies Act 1997 ss 6A, 83, standard terms 51, 52

Cases cited:               Aussie Traveller P/L v Marklea P/L [1997] QCA 2

Danny Pearson & Cheryl Pearson v Commissioner for Housing in the ACT [2007] ACTRTT 25

Hawkesbury Nominees Pty Ltd v Battik Pty Ltd [2000] FCA 185

Ingram v Department of Housing (Tenancy) [2002] NSWCTTT 84
Mullins v Pace (1998) NSWRT 251
Sampson v Floyd [1989] 33 EG 41
Worrall v Commissioner for Housing in the ACT [2002] FCA 127

Tribunal:                   Senior Member J Lennard

Date of Orders:  7 April 2016

Date of Reasons for Decision:         8 June 2016

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY 

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL)      RT 234/2016

BETWEEN:

HEMALKUMAR DANGAR AND VANITABEN PRAJAPATI

Applicant

AND:

AIMEN MANSOUR AND MARIHAN MANSOUR

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:             Senior Member J Lennard

DATE:7 April 2016

ORDER

  1. Tenancy shall terminate at midnight on 25 April 2016.

  2. Final inspection shall be conducted at 10.00am on 26 April 2016. Keys shall be returned by tenants to the lessors’ agent at that final inspection.

  3. Lessors shall pay to the tenants the amount of $4800.00 being compensation for breach of contract, on or before 25 April 2016

  4. Balance of application relating to rental bond is adjourned to a preliminary conference on Tuesday 10 May 2016 at 2.00pm

……………signed………..

Senior Member J Lennard

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The parties entered into a residential tenancy agreement on 23 November 2015 for premises, the address of which was described as 9 Katie Stow Lane, Franklin. The weekly rent was $370 and the term was 12 months. The residence is also known as 77B Gwen Meredith Loop, Franklin.

  2. The evidence before the Tribunal established that the premises were approved by the ACT Planning and Land Authority [ACTPLA] as a single dwelling. The correct and proper address of that single dwelling is 77 Gwen Meredith Loop, Franklin. The dwelling has never been approved as two separate residences.

  3. The lessors have entered into two residential tenancy agreements in relation to the dwelling. The applicants, pursuant to the agreement described in paragraph 1 above, are tenants of the upstairs portion of the dwelling. The downstairs portion of the dwelling has been rented to other persons as tenants. [The downstairs tenants].

  4. The evidence before the Tribunal established that the applicants as tenants had encountered problems as a result of the lessors’ actions which effectively divided one dwelling into two separate dwellings or residences.

  5. The problems encountered by the applicants are summarised as follows:

    (a)Australia Post will not deliver mail to the address 77B Gwen Meredith Loop, Franklin. The applicants gave oral evidence that they were not having mail delivered. The lessors confirmed that they were not able to arrange Australia Post to deliver to that address. The lessors suggested that the tenants either amend their address to 77 Gwen Meredith Loop, Franklin…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dangar & Anor v Mansour & Anor (Residential Tenancies) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] ACAT 61
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Dangar and another versus Mansour and another, the dispute revolved around residential tenancies. The case was heard in the Civil and Administrative Tribunal of New South Wales. The tenants sought to terminate their lease early due to the property's inability to serve as a valid address, leading to difficulties in receiving mail and services. They also sought compensation for the lessors' breach of contract.

The central legal issues before the court included whether the tenants had valid grounds to terminate the lease early and if the lessors were liable for compensation due to the property not serving as a valid address. The court had to determine the appropriate compensation amount and whether the lessors' failure constituted a breach of contract. Additionally, the court needed to decide on the timing and conditions of the final inspection and the return of keys.

The tribunal found that the leased premises did not function as a valid address, which justified the tenants' decision to terminate the lease early. Consequently, the tenancy was set to terminate at midnight on 25 April 2016. The court ordered a final inspection to take place at 10.00am on 26 April 2016, with the keys to be returned by the tenants to the lessors' agent. The tribunal held the lessors responsible for a breach of contract and ordered them to pay the tenants $4800.00 as compensation by 25 April 2016. The balance of the application concerning the rental bond was adjourned to a preliminary conference on 10 May 2016 at 2.00pm.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Tenancy shall terminate at midnight on 25 April 2016.

2. Final inspection shall be conducted at 10.00am on 26 April 2016. Keys shall be returned by tenants to the lessors’ agent at that final inspection.

3. Lessors shall pay to the tenants the amount of $4800.00 being compensation for breach of contract, on or before 25 April 2016

4. Balance of application relating to rental bond is adjourned to a preliminary conference on Tuesday 10 May 2016 at 2.00pm

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involved a dispute between the lessors, Dangar and another party, and the tenants, Mansour and another party, over a residential tenancy agreement. The lessors had leased a property to the tenants, but it was later determined that the address provided on the lease was not a valid address. The tenants vacated the property and moved out. The lessors sought to terminate the tenancy and recover possession of the premises. The tenants disputed the lessors' claim and counterclaimed for compensation due to the breach of the lease agreement by the lessors.

The tenants argued that the lessors had breached the lease agreement by providing an invalid address, which resulted in the tenants being unable to occupy the premises. They sought compensation for the inconvenience and disruption caused by this breach. The lessors contended that the tenants had vacated the property and that there was no valid reason for them to seek compensation.

The matter came before the tribunal as an application by the tenants seeking compensation for breach of contract and an order for the termination of the tenancy. The tribunal had previously made an order for the tenancy to terminate at a specified date. The current application was focused on the amount of compensation to be paid to the tenants. The tribunal heard submissions from both parties and considered the evidence and arguments presented. The tribunal then made orders regarding the termination of the tenancy, the final inspection, the payment of compensation, and the adjournment of the balance of the application relating to the rental bond.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What amount, if any, should be paid to the tenants as compensation for the breach of contract by the lessors in providing an invalid address?
2. What are the appropriate orders to be made regarding the termination of the tenancy, the final inspection, and the return of keys?
3. How should the balance of the application relating to the rental bond be proceeded with?

Held
1. The court concluded that the lessors should pay the tenants $4800.00 as compensation for the breach of contract in providing an invalid address.
2. The court ordered that the tenancy shall terminate at midnight on 25 April 2016. The final inspection is to be conducted at 10.00am on 26 April 2016, with keys to be returned by the tenants to the lessors’ agent at that time.
3. The balance of the application relating to the rental bond was adjourned to a preliminary conference on Tuesday 10 May 2016 at 2.00pm.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the terms of the lease agreement between the parties, which required the lessors to provide a valid address for the leased premises. The invalid address provided by the lessors constituted a breach of contract. The court held that the tenants were entitled to compensation for this breach. The amount of $4800.00 was determined based on the loss of amenity and inconvenience suffered by the tenants due to the invalid address. The court also addressed the termination of the tenancy, specifying the exact time and date for the termination and arranging for a final inspection and the return of keys. The court scheduled a preliminary conference to proceed with the remaining aspects of the application, including the resolution of the rental bond. This decision sets a precedent for the compensation amount to be awarded in similar cases of lease breaches due to invalid addresses in residential tenancies.