Cook's Construction Pty Ltd v SFS 007.298.633 Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Cook's Construction P/L v SFS 007.298.633 P/L (formerly trading as Stork Food Systems Australasia P/L) [2009] QCA 75

PARTIES:

COOK'S CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD
ACN 004 782 558
(plaintiff/appellant)
v
SFS 007.298.633 PTY LTD (FORMERLY TRADING AS STORK FOOD SYSTEMS AUSTRALASIA PTY LTD)
ACN 007 298 633
(defendant/respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 9301 of 2008
SC No 10993 of 2001

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

3 April 2009

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

26 February 2009; 27 February 2009

JUDGES:

Keane and Fraser JJA and Daubney J
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the orders made

ORDER:

1.    Appeal dismissed

2.    Appellant to pay the respondent's costs of the appeal on the standard basis

CATCHWORDS:

RESTITUTION – MISTAKE: RESTITUTION ARISING FROM A PLAINTIFF'S MISTAKEN ACTIONS – RECOVERY OF MONEY PAID UNDER MISTAKE – RELEVANT PRINCIPLES – where appellant and respondent related as sub-contractor and contractor – where appellant warranted to respondent that appellant licensed builder – where respondent paid to appellant moneys for services rendered on that basis – where appellant not licensed builder – where respondent claimed against appellant for moneys had and received insofar as respondent paid appellant on mistaken belief as to appellant's entitlement under contract – where appellant claimed respondent's action should fail insofar as the respondent did not disprove the appellant's entitlement to reasonable remuneration under s 42(4) of the Queensland Building Services Authority Act 1991 (Qld) – whether respondent's action for moneys had and received maintainable

RESTITUTION – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – restitutio in integrum – where appellant claimed respondent not entitled to claim for moneys had and received insofar as respondent cannot restore appellant to pre-transaction position – whether restitutio in integrum element of respondent's claim for moneys had and received

EVIDENCE – BURDEN OF PROOF, PRESUMPTIONS, AND WEIGHT AND SUFFICIENCY OF EVIDENCE – GENERALLY – SUFFICIENCY – where appellant claimed respondent's claim for moneys had and received reduced by appellant's claim for reasonable remuneration under s 42(4) of the Queensland Building Services Authority Act 1991 (Qld) – where appellant claimed respondent's claim failed insofar as it did not particularise appellant's reasonable remuneration to be deducted from claimed amount – whether burden of proof held by appellant or respondent with respect to demonstrating reasonable remuneration on the evidence

INTEREST – RECOVERABILITY OF INTEREST – AWARD OF INTEREST ON DEBTS AND SUMS CERTAIN – OTHER MATTERS – where trial judge awarded interest against appellant from date of last payment by respondent – where appellant claimed interest should not be awarded because respondent received value for money – whether interest should be awarded

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – POINTS AND OBJECTIONS NOT TAKEN BELOW – WHEN NOT ALLOWED TO BE RAISED ON APPEAL – COURSE OF CONDUCT AT TRIAL – where three of the appellant's contentions on appeal were not litigated at trial – where respondent argued that it would…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cook's Construction Pty Ltd v SFS 007.298.633 Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] QCA 75
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal before the Court of Appeal was between Cook's Construction Pty Ltd (appellant) and SFS 007.298.633 Pty Ltd (respondent). The case arose from a sub-contract agreement where the appellant warranted to the respondent that it was a licensed builder. The respondent paid the appellant for services rendered on the basis of this warranty. However, it was later found that the appellant was not a licensed builder. The respondent sought to recover the moneys paid under the mistaken belief that the appellant was entitled to them under the contract. The appellant argued that the respondent's claim should fail as it did not disprove the appellant's entitlement to reasonable remuneration under the Queensland Building Services Authority Act 1991 (Qld). The appellant also claimed that the respondent's claim was reduced by the appellant's claim for reasonable remuneration and that the respondent's claim failed because it did not particularise the appellant's reasonable remuneration to be deducted from the claimed amount.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the respondent's claim for moneys had and received was maintainable. The court also needed to determine if the respondent's claim was reduced by the appellant's claim for reasonable remuneration, and who bore the burden of proof in demonstrating this remuneration. Additionally, the court examined whether interest should be awarded against the appellant from the date of the last payment by the respondent. The court further considered whether the appellant should be allowed to raise points and objections on appeal that were not litigated at trial.

The Court of Appeal held that the respondent's claim for moneys had and received was maintainable. The court found that the appellant's contention that the respondent's claim was reduced by the appellant's claim for reasonable remuneration was not valid, as the burden of proof rested with the appellant to demonstrate this. The court also ruled that interest should be awarded to the respondent from the date of the last payment by the respondent, as the appellant had not shown that the respondent received value for the money paid. Finally, the court determined that the appellant should not be permitted to raise points and objections on appeal that were not litigated at trial.

The appeal was dismissed, and the appellant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs of the appeal on the standard basis. This decision highlights the importance of warranties in sub-contract agreements and the consequences of breaching them, as well as the principles of restitution and the recovery of money paid under mistake.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal dismissed

2. Appellant to pay the respondent's costs of the appeal on the standard basis

Background

Background to the litigation

Cook's Construction Pty Ltd (the appellant) was engaged by SFS 007.298.633 Pty Ltd (the respondent) to perform services as a sub-contractor on a construction project. The respondent paid the appellant for these services on the basis that the appellant was a licensed builder. Following completion of the services, the respondent discovered that the appellant was not, in fact, a licensed builder. The respondent sought to recover the moneys paid to the appellant on the mistaken belief that the appellant was a licensed builder. The respondent filed an action claiming moneys had and received against the appellant. The appellant, in turn, argued that the respondent's action should fail because the respondent had not disproved that the appellant was entitled to reasonable remuneration under the Queensland Building Services Authority Act 1991 (Qld). The appellant also claimed that the respondent's claim was reduced by the appellant's entitlement to reasonable remuneration and that the respondent failed to particularise this amount. The appellant further argued that the respondent could not claim for moneys had and received because restitutio in integrum was not possible. Lastly, the appellant contended that interest should not be awarded as the respondent received value for money. The trial judge awarded the respondent the full amount of the payments made to the appellant, along with interest from the date of the last payment.

The case initially proceeded in the District Court of Queensland where the respondent successfully claimed the return of moneys paid to the appellant on the basis of a mistaken belief that the appellant was a licensed builder. The appellant then appealed to the Queensland Court of Appeal against the trial judge's decision. The appeal focused on several issues, including the recoverability of the moneys paid under mistake, the restitutio in integrum requirement, the burden of proof in relation to reasonable remuneration, the recoverability of interest, and the admissibility of new contentions raised for the first time on appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the respondent's action for moneys had and received is maintainable despite the appellant's argument that the respondent did not disprove the appellant's entitlement to reasonable remuneration under s 42(4) of the Queensland Building Services Authority Act 1991 (Qld).
2. Whether restitutio in integrum is an element of the respondent's claim for moneys had and received.
3. Who bears the burden of proof in relation to demonstrating the appellant's reasonable remuneration on the evidence.
4. Whether interest should be awarded from the date of the last payment by the respondent to the appellant.
5. Whether the appellant should be permitted to raise points and objections not taken below that were not litigated at trial.

Held
1. The Court held that the respondent's action for moneys had and received is maintainable despite the appellant's argument that the respondent did not disprove the appellant's entitlement to reasonable remuneration under s 42(4) of the Queensland Building Services Authority Act 1991 (Qld).
2. The Court held that restitutio in integrum is not an element of the respondent's claim for moneys had and received.
3. The Court held that the burden of proof in relation to demonstrating the appellant's reasonable remuneration on the evidence lies with the appellant.
4. The Court held that interest should be awarded from the date of the last payment by the respondent to the appellant.
5. The Court held that the appellant should not be permitted to raise points and objections not taken below that were not litigated at trial.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court found that the respondent's action for moneys had and received was maintainable. The Court concluded that the respondent did not need to disprove the appellant's entitlement to reasonable remuneration under s 42(4) of the Queensland Building Services Authority Act 1991 (Qld). The Court emphasised that the respondent's claim for moneys had and received was based on the mistaken belief that the appellant was a licensed builder, which was not the case. The Court further determined that restitutio in integrum is not a necessary element of the respondent's claim, as the focus was on recovering money paid under a mistake. In terms of the burden of proof, the Court ruled that it was the appellant's responsibility to demonstrate the amount of reasonable remuneration it was entitled to under the contract. Regarding interest, the Court upheld the trial judge's decision to award interest from the date of the last payment by the respondent, finding that the respondent had a right to interest on the sum due. Finally, the Court held that the appellant should not be allowed to raise new points and objections on appeal that were not litigated at trial, as doing so would unfairly prejudice the respondent. The Court also noted that the respondent would have been able to meet these contentions with evidence if they had been raised at trial.