Bufalo v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bufalo v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2011] FCAFC 111

Citation: Bufalo v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2011] FCAFC 111
Appeal from: Official Trustee in Bankruptcy v Lendlease Primelife Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 145
Parties: ANTONIO BUFALO AND ORS v THE OFFICIAL TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY AND ORS
File number: VID 177 of 2011
Judges: MANSFIELD, BESANKO AND FLICK  JJ
Date of judgment: 26 August 2011
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – appellants fail to appear – application amended at hearing – judgment delivered  

BANKRUPTCY – application by Official Trustee for directions – need for care when drafting the direction sought

Legislation: Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 39
Bankruptcy Act1966 (Cth) ss 30, 134, 178
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 4, 17, 24(1A)
Federal Court Rules O1 rr 4, 8, O14 r 7, O32, O52 r 38A
Federal Court Rules 2011 rr 30.21, 36.75
Cases cited: AA Shi Pty Ltd v Avbar Pty Ltd (No 5) [2010] FCA 971, cited
Adam P Brown Male Fashions Pty Ltd v Philip Morris Inc (1981) 148 CLR 170, 35 ALR 625, considered
Ali v Collection Point Pty Ltd [2011] FCAFC 87, cited
Apache Northwest Pty Ltd v Newcrest Mining Ltd [2009] FCAFC 39, 182 FCR 124, referred to
Applicant A184 of 2003 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCA 1076, referred to
Association of Architects of Australia, Re; Ex parte Municipal Officers of Australia (1989) 63 ALJR 298, cited
Australian Broadcasting Commission v Parish (1980) 43 FLR 129, cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v D M Faulkner Pty Limited [2004] FCA 1666, cited
Bufalo v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2007] FMCA 1411, cited
Cabcharge Australia Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2010] FCAFC 111, referred to
Condon v Watson [2009] FCA 11, 174 FCR 314, referred to
Croft v Evertop Investments Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] FCA 749, cited
CSR Limited, Re [2010] FCAFC 34, referred to
Decor Corp Pty Ltd v Dart Industries Inc (1991) 33 FCR 397, referred to
Different Solutions Pty Ltd v Commissioner, Australian Federal Police [2008] FCA 1571, referred to
Donnelly (Trustee), in the matter of Hancock v Porteous [2002] FCA 607, considered
Duckworth, Re; Ex parte The Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (Unreported, FCA, Nicholson J, 20 October 1995), cited
Evans, Re; Ex parte Sweeney v Evans (1995) 61 FCR 556, cited
Goodricke v Comcare [2011] FCA 694, cited
Hoffman, Re; Ex parte Worrell v Schilling (1989) 85 ALR 145, cited
House v Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority [2011] FCAFC 72, referred to
House v R (1936) 55 CLR 499, considered
In the matter of Kenneth Stanley Kitt; Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2005] FCA 1564, cited
Johnson Tiles Pty Ltd v Esso Australia Pty Ltd [2000] FCA 1572, 104 FCR 564, considered
Kenso Marketing (M)…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bufalo v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCAFC 111
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Bufalo v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy involves the Appellants, Giovanni, Joe and Tony Bufalo, challenging the proceedings and decisions of the primary Judge in a bankruptcy matter. The Official Trustee in Bankruptcy had initiated an application for directions, and the Appellants contest the manner in which the proceeding was conducted and certain discretionary decisions made by the primary Judge regarding practice and procedure. The dispute revolves around the assignment of assets by the Official Trustee to Lend Lease, following a Deed executed on 29 September 2010. The Appellants argue that the primary Judge erred in several respects, including allowing an application to further amend the Respondent's application without notice to them, proceeding to hear and determine the amended application without giving them an opportunity to be heard, and making certain discretionary decisions without adequate reasons.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether the primary Judge erred in allowing an oral application to further amend the Respondent's application without notice, and whether the primary Judge should have adjourned the trial, given directions for further amendments, and reserved the Appellants' costs. Additionally, the Court had to consider whether the primary Judge erred in directing that the Official Trustee was justified in accepting an offer to assign certain assets, and whether the primary Judge failed to provide adequate reasons for his decisions and orders. The Court also examined whether the primary Judge should have recalled the parties to hear submissions on new material discovered after the hearing and made new directions for the proceeding.

The Court found that the primary Judge did not err in allowing the oral application to further amend the Respondent's application, as the Appellants had not been prejudiced by the lack of notice. The Court held that the primary Judge was entitled to proceed with the hearing and make orders on the amended application. Regarding the direction on the assignment of assets, the Court found no error in the primary Judge's decision, as the evidence supported the conclusion that the Official Trustee was justified in accepting the offer. The Court also held that the primary Judge did not err in ordering the Appellants to pay the costs of the Second and Third Respondents, as the Appellants' appeal was dismissed. The Court concluded that the primary Judge's decisions were within his discretion and adequately reasoned.

The final orders of the Court were to dismiss the appeal, dismiss the Notice of Motion dated 15 April 2011, dismiss the Notice of Motion filed on behalf of Bufalo Corporation Pty Ltd (in Liquidation), and order the Appellants to pay the costs of the Second and Third Respondents. The costs order reflects the Court's determination that the Appellants' appeal was without merit and that they should bear the costs of the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed.

2. The Notice of Motion dated 15 April 2011 is dismissed.

3. The Notice of Motion filed on behalf of Bufalo Corporation Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) is dismissed.

4. The Appellants are to pay the costs of the Second and Third Respondents.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before this Court the Appellants challenge the manner in which the proceeding before the primary Judge was conducted and a number of his discretionary decisions going to matters of practice and procedure.THE BACKGROUND TO THE DISPUTE The background facts which led to the decision of the primary Judge are within a narrow compass and should be briefly mentioned. As summarised by the primary Judge, each of the now Appellants had been declared bankrupt and had been or were to be discharged upon the following dates: In February 2007, Mr Giovanni Bufalo had also commenced a proceeding in the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia seeking an order that the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy assign to him “the chose-in-action constituted by reference to rights arising in respect of or in connection with [the Supreme Court action] and the subject matter of that proceeding as set out in the third amended statement of claim …”. Messrs Antonio and Giuseppe Bufalo were joined as parties to that proceeding. That application was one brought pursuant to s 178 of the Bankruptcy Act. The application was dismissed: Bufalo v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2007] FMCA 1411. Thereafter, on 29 September 2010 the Official Trustee – and apparently after prolonged negotiation – entered into a Deed with Lend Lease in which the Official Trustee agreed to assign “the Assets to Lend Lease Primelife …”. The Deed was conditional upon an application being made pursuant to s 134 of the Bankruptcy Act. The Definitions provision to the Deed contained (inter alia) the following provisions:In this Deed, the following expressions have the meanings indicated hereunder:1.1“the Act” means the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth);1.2“the Assets” mean the BC Shares, the CN Shares the Bankrupts’ Claims and the Further Claims;1.3“the Bankrupts” mean John Bufalo, Joe Bufalo and Tony Bufalo; (and each of them);1.4“the Bankrupts’ Claims” mean:1.4.1the rights and title of each of the Bankrupts which vested in the Trustee under the Act either upon the Bankrupts’ respective bankruptcies or during the period of their respective bankruptcies to bring and maintain an action for damages or other relief against Lend Lease Primelife, its servants, agents, directors or consultants in respect of, arising from, or in connection with, or comprising the subject matter of the Proceeding and the Related Proceedings, including, without limiting the generality of the foregoing, their right to bring any application to set aside the orders made in favour of Primelife by Master Kings of 15 August 2001 and/or the Honourable Justice Mandie on 29 October 2004 in the Proceeding;1.4.2any right or chose-in-action identified in John Bufalo’s submissions to the Federal Magistrates’ Court on or about 15 August 2007 in an undated document entitled “Submissions of Applicant” in the Federal Magistrates’ Court Proceeding”;1.5“BC” means Bufalo Corporation Pty Ltd (receiver and manager appointed) (in liquidation) ACN 007 122 296;1.6“BC Shares” means John Bufalo’s and Joe Bufalo’s ordinary shares in BC;1.7“CN Shares” means John Bufalo’s legal and equitable rights, including any right of redemption, in relation to 1 out of 2 shares in Confalo and 1 out of 3 shares in Newpark which were held by John Bufalo in Confalo and Newpark from in or about October 1998;1.8“Confalo” means Confalo Enterprises Pty Ltd ACN 007 326 169;…1.19“Proceeding” means Supreme Court proceeding no 6668 of 1999;…1.21“Related Proceedings” means Supreme Court proceedings no. 6477 of 2000 and 6478 of 2000;

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The surviving Grounds of Appeal provide as follows:1.The Learned Primary Judge erred in law:-(a) in hearing and allowing an oral application made by the First Respondent on the 23rd of February 2011, on the day of the hearing of the proceeding, to further amend the first respondent’s Amended Application dated the 20th December 2010 (“the Amended Application”) in the terms sought by the First Respondent in the course of the hearing of the proceeding without Notice to the Appellants, and without giving, or affording, the Appellants any opportunity to be heard on that (oral) application; and(b) then proceeding that morning (23rd February 2011) to hear and determine, and make final orders on, the First Respondent’s Amended Application, treated by the learned Primary Judge as further amended in the terms sought by the First Respondent in his oral application made to the court that day, without notice to the Appellants and without giving, or affording, the Appellants any opportunity to be heard on the First Respondent’s Amended Application, as treated by the learned Primary Judge as further amended on the First Respondent’s oral Application made to the Court that same day (23rd February 2011).2.The Learned Primary Judge should have:-(a) adjourned the trial of the First Respondent’s Amended Application;(b) given directions to the First Respondent to file and serve a Notice of Motion on the Appellants, identifying the further amendments proposed to be made to the Amended Application, and to also serve an affidavit, or affidavits, deposing as to the basis for the application (to further amend the Amended Application);(c) reserved the Appellant’s costs of, and incidental to, and thrown away on account of, the application of the First Respondent to further amend the Amended Application.3.The Learned Primary Judge erred in law in directing that the First Respondent is justified in accepting the offer to assign the Assets as defined in the Deed dated the 29th of September 2010 (other than the BC Shares) contained in Exhibit GMA 5 to the Affidavit of Gina May Anderson sworn on 7 December 2010 and filed in the proceeding (“the Direction”).…8.The Learned Primary Judge erred in not giving reasons for:-(a) the Direction;(b) his order that the Appellants pay the costs of the Second and Third Respondents of the proceeding.9.The Learned Trial Judge erred in the exercise of his discretion in ordering that the Appellants pay the costs of the Second and Third Respondents of the proceeding.10.The Learned Primary Judge erred in law in the exercise of his discretion in proceeding to authenticate the orders made by him in court on the 23rd of February 2011 in the context of, and having regard to:-(a) the oral application made by the First Respondent that day to further amend the Amended application; and(b) the affidavit, or affidavits, sworn by Leonard Warren in the afternoon on the day prior to the hearing, and relied upon by the Respondents in the course of the proceeding on the 23rd February 2011; and(c) the documents discovered by the learned primary judge upon returning to his chambers, at the conclusion of the hearing on the 23rd of February 2011, namely:-(i)a faxed letter from a Mr Jerome Borazio advising:-“…that Antonio Bufalo, Third Respondent, was ill and unable to attend Court, and required a 3 to 4 week adjournment.”(ii)a medical certificate from Elsternwick Medical Centre, certifying that Mr Bufalo presented at 8 am that morning with:-“a hacking, suffocating cough malaise and weakness, and he has been diagnosed with a chest infection and a possible left basal pneumonia (and) the certificate also says, in the opinion of the treating doctor, Antonio Bufalo is unfit to attend Court.”11.The Learned Primary Judge should not have proceeded to the authentication of the orders made by him on the 23rd of February 2011 but recalled the parties to hear submissions on the material discovered by him (the Learned Primary Judge) on returning to his chambers, and made directions for the further carriage and conduct of the proceeding.12.The Learned Primary Judge erred in drawing the inference that:-“it appears… the Third Respondent, acting with the knowledge of the Fourth and Fifth Respondents, assumed that sending the material contained in the fax would automatically lead to an adjournment of the proceeding (and) That assumption, if made, was unjustified…”.THE DECISIONS MADE ON 23 FEBRUARY 2011

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.