Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v D M Faulkner Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v D M Faulkner Pty Limited [2004] FCA 1666

TRADE PRACTICES – exclusionary provisions – scrap metal industry – auctions – agreement among merchants – nominated bidder – controlled or restricted bidding at auction – subsequent allocation of a payment for goods – loss or damage unquantified – submitting respondents – defending respondents – market – whether the ‘purpose’ of provision in an arrangement should be approached subjectively or objectively – application of totality principle – where company is alter ego of individual – penalty – factors to be considered in determining penalties for contravention of Trade Practices Act – application of the “French factors” and the “Heerey factors” – permissible range – proposed penalties – whether variation from proposed penalty can be made where it is within the permissible range

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – substituted service appropriate where respondent determined not to accept service – nature of the Court’s discretion and power to grant injunctive relief – no case submission

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 4D, 4F, 45, 45A, 76, 80

Federal Court Rules O 7 r 10

ACCC v ABB (2002) ATPR 41-871
ACCC v FFE Building Services Limited [2003] FCA 154
ACCC v Ithaca Ice Works Pty Limited (2002) ATPR 41-851
ACCC v Roche Vitamins Australia Pty Ltd (2001) ATPR 41-809
ACCC v Tyco Australia Pty Ltd (2000) ATPR 41-789
ASX Operations Pty Ltd v Pont Data Australia Pty Ltd (No 1)(1990) 27 FCR 460
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Medical Association Western Australia Branch Inc (2003) 199 ALR 423
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd (1997) 75 FCR 238
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v CC (NSW) Pty Ltd (No 8) (1999) 165 ALR 468
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v ABB Power Transmission Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 819
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ABB Transmission and Distribution Limited (2001) ATPR 41-815
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Chaste Corporation Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 398
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Fila Sport Oceania Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) [2004] FCA 376
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Midland Brick Co Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 693
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v NW Frozen Foods (1996) ATPR 41-515
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Pauls Ltd [2002] FCA 1586
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Universal Music Australia Pty Limited (No 2) [2002] FCA 192
Commerce Commission v New Zealand Milk Corporation Ltd [1994] 2 NZLR 730
Hughes v Western Australian Cricket Association (inc) (1986) 19 FCR 10
ICI Australia Operations Pty Limited v Trade Practices Commission (1992) 38 FCR 248
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298
Minister for Industry, Tourism & Resources v Mobil Oil Australia Pty Ltd [2004] FCAFC 72
News Ltd v Australian Rugby Football League Ltd (1996) 64 FCR 410
News Ltd & Ors v South Sydney District Rugby League Football Club Ltd & Ors (2000) 200…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v D M Faulkne... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 1666
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought an action against D M Faulkner Pty Ltd and other respondents, alleging price fixing and anticompetitive conduct in the scrap metal market. The dispute was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The legal issues involved determining whether the respondents had contravened the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 by engaging in collusive bidding at auctions, and if so, what penalties should be imposed. The ACCC alleged that the respondents, including D M Faulkner, had entered into agreements to fix prices and restrict bidding at scrap metal auctions. The respondents admitted to the allegations, leading to the court's consideration of the appropriate penalties. The court found that the conduct of the respondents amounted to serious breaches of the Act and imposed penalties and injunctive relief against the respondents. D M Faulkner was ordered to pay a penalty of $80,000 and was restrained from engaging in future anticompetitive conduct.

The court considered several factors in determining the penalties, including the severity of the breaches, the culpability of the respondents, and the need for deterrence and punishment. The penalties imposed on D M Faulkner and the other respondents varied based on their level of involvement and culpability. The court also ordered that D M Faulkner and other respondents jointly pay costs towards the ACCC's legal expenses. The final orders included specific injunctive relief to prevent the respondents from engaging in similar conduct in the future, along with pecuniary penalties and costs orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

13. The First Respondent, by its servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, is restrained from

a) making an arrangement or arriving at an understanding with other scrap metal dealers (“the ring”) which contain a provision that the parties to the ring will engage in controlled or restricted bidding at the auction by:

i) nominating one or more of the parties to the ring to bid at the auction; and

ii) not bidding against the nominated bidder/s; and

iii) after the auction, bidding amongst themselves for the goods purchased by the nominated bidder/s (“the knock”), on the basis the unsuccessful bidders at the knock would be paid for their participation in the ring and knock.

14. The Second Respondent is restrained from

a) making an arrangement or arriving at an understanding with other scrap metal dealers (“the ring”) which contain a provision that the parties to the ring will engage in controlled or restricted bidding at the auction by:

i) nominating one or more of the parties to the ring to bid at the auction; and

ii) not bidding against the nominated bidder/s; and

iii) after the auction, bidding amongst themselves for the goods purchased by the nominated bidder/s (“the knock”), on the basis the unsuccessful bidders at the knock would be paid for their participation in the ring and knock.

15. The First Respondent pay to the Commonwealth a pecuniary penalty in the sum of $80,000 in respect of the conduct referred to in paragraphs 1 - 2 above.

16. The Second Respondent pay to the Commonwealth a pecuniary penalty in the sum of $10,000 in respect of the conduct referred to in paragraphs 1 - 4 above.

17. The First and Second Respondents jointly pay the Applicant the sum of $10,000 towards its costs in these proceedings.

Date: 30 September 2004

33. The Third Respondent, by its servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, is restrained from

a) making an arrangement or arriving at an understanding with other scrap metal dealers (“the ring”) which contain a provision that the parties to the ring will engage in controlled or restricted bidding at the auction by:

i) nominating one or more of the parties to the ring to bid at the auction; and

ii) not bidding against the nominated bidder/s; and

iii) after the auction, bidding amongst themselves for the goods purchased by the nominated bidder/s (“the knock”), on the basis the unsuccessful bidders at the knock would be paid for their participation in the ring and knock.

34. The Fourth Respondent is restrained from

a) making an arrangement or arriving at an understanding with other scrap metal dealers (“the ring”) which contain a provision that the parties to the ring will engage in controlled or restricted bidding at the auction by:

i) nominating one or more of the parties to the ring to bid at the auction; and

ii) not bidding against the nominated bidder/s; and

iii) after the auction, bidding amongst themselves for the goods purchased by the nominated bidder/s (“the knock”), on the basis the unsuccessful bidders at the knock would be paid for their participation in the ring and knock.

35. The Third Respondent pay to the Commonwealth a pecuniary penalty in the sum of $120,000 in respect of the conduct referred to in paragraphs 1 - 3 above.

36. The Fourth Respondent pay to the Commonwealth a pecuniary penalty in the sum of $15,000 in respect of the conduct referred to in paragraphs 1 - 6 above.

37. The Third and Fourth Respondents jointly pay the Applicant the sum of $10,000 towards its costs in these proceedings.

Date: 30 September 2004

42. The Fifth Respondent is restrained from

a) arriving at an understanding with other scrap metal dealers (“the ring”) which contain a provision that the parties to the ring will engage in controlled or restricted bidding at the auction by:

i) nominating one or more of the parties to the ring to bid at the auction; and

ii) not bidding against the nominated bidder/s; and

iii) after the auction, bidding amongst themselves for the goods purchased by the nominated bidder/s (“the knock”), on the basis the unsuccessful bidders at the knock would be paid for their participation in the ring and knock.

43. The Fifth Respondent pay to the Commonwealth a pecuniary penalty in the sum of $10,000 in respect of the conduct referred to in paragraphs 1 and 2 above.

44. The Fifth Respondent pay the Applicant the sum of $2,500 towards its costs in these proceedings.

Date: March 2004

57. The Tenth Respondent, by its servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, is restrained from

a) making an arrangement or arriving at an understanding with other scrap metal dealers (“the ring”) which contain a provision that the parties to the ring will engage in controlled or restricted bidding at the auction by:

i) nominating one or more of the parties to the ring to bid at the auction; and

ii) not bidding against the nominated bidder/s; and

iii) after the auction, bidding amongst themselves for the goods purchased by the nominated bidder/s (“the knock”), on the basis the unsuccessful bidders at the knock would be paid for their participation in the ring and knock.

58. The Eleventh Respondent is restrained from

a) making an arrangement or arriving at an understanding with other scrap metal dealers (“the ring”) which contain a provision that the parties to the ring will engage in controlled or restricted bidding at the auction by:

i) nominating one or more of the parties to the ring to bid at the auction; and

ii) not bidding against the nominated bidder/s; and

iii) after the auction, bidding amongst themselves for the goods purchased by the nominated bidder/s (“the knock”), on the basis the unsuccessful bidders at the knock would be paid for their participation in the ring and knock.

59. The Tenth Respondent pay to the Commonwealth a pecuniary penalty in the sum of $2,500. in respect of the conduct referred to in paragraphs 1 - 2 above.

60. The Eleventh Respondent pay to the Commonwealth a pecuniary penalty in the sum of $5,000 in respect of the conduct referred to in paragraphs 1 - 4 above.

61. The Tenth and Eleventh Respondents jointly pay the Applicant the sum of $2,500 towards its costs in these proceedings.

Date: 30 September 2004

77. The Thirteenth Respondent, by its servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, is restrained from

a) making an arrangement or arriving at an understanding with other scrap metal dealers (“the ring”) which contain a provision that the parties to the ring will engage in controlled or restricted bidding at the auction by:

i) nominating one or more of the parties to the ring to bid at the auction; and

ii) not bidding against the nominated bidder/s; and

iii) after the auction, bidding amongst themselves for the goods purchased by the nominated bidder/s (“the knock”), on the basis the unsuccessful bidders at the knock would be paid for their participation in the ring and knock.

78. The Fourteenth Respondent is restrained from

a) making an arrangement or arriving at an understanding with other scrap metal dealers (“the ring”) which contain a provision that the parties to the ring will engage in controlled or restricted bidding at the auction by:

i) nominating one or more of the parties to the ring to bid at the auction; and

ii) not bidding against the nominated bidder/s; and

iii) after the auction, bidding amongst themselves for the goods purchased by the nominated bidder/s (“the knock”), on the basis the unsuccessful bidders at the knock would be paid for their participation in the ring and knock.

79. The Thirteenth Respondent pay to the Commonwealth a pecuniary penalty in the sum of $10,000 in respect of the conduct referred to in paragraphs 1 - 3 above.

80. The Fourteenth Respondent pay to the Commonwealth a pecuniary penalty in the sum of $15,000 in respect of the conduct referred to in paragraphs 1 - 6 above.

81. The Thirteenth and Fourteenth Respondents jointly pay the Applicant the sum of $10,000 towards its costs in these proceedings.

Date: 30 September 2004

Background

Background to the litigation

Most of the respondents (the first to fifth, tenth to fourteenth and seventeenth respondents) (‘the submitting respondents’), for the purposes of these proceedings, admitted in substance the allegations in the amended statement of claim insofar as they related to contraventions of both as to factual matters and that those facts amounted to contravention of the Act and so enabled the court to proceed to impose penalties. I have referred to these agreed facts in some detail below as they contextualise the ACCC’s allegations. The ACCC and the submitting respondents negotiated penalties which they considered appropriate and submitted them to the Court.BACKGROUND FACTS AGREED AS BETWEEN THE ACCC AND THE SUBMITTING RESPONDENTS These allegations are of price fixing and collusive and anticompetitive conduct in the scrap metal market at the small-trader end of that market. In the market of the New South Wales scrap metal industry, the first and second respondents are small to mid-size traders when compared with the major traders Metalcorp Recyclers Pty Ltd (‘Metalcorp’) (a division of Smorgon Steel Group Limited (‘Smorgon’)) and Simsmetal Limited (‘Simsmetal’). Scrap metal merchants and metal recyclers purchase items manufactured from metals such as steel, iron, copper, brass, stainless steel and aluminium for processing and reselling. Scrap metal items purchased are broadly those metal items that are no longer wanted by any entity for their original functional purpose. Metal items may be those that are derelict, off-cuts, in disrepair, new and unused metal goods or second hand reusable items such as plate, beams and railway lines. Most scrap items must be processed by at least being cut into smaller pieces so that they are less bulky for loading into trucks and containers and removing contaminates and can be sorted into bundles of like metal. The process of sorting and cutting bulkier items is the area in which the respondents operate. The processed metals are then on sold to a limited number of larger operations: Metalcorp, Simsmetal, BHP Billiton Limited (‘BHP’) or Smorgon in the case of ferrous scrap and Simsmetal or Riverside Metal Industries Pty Ltd (‘Riverside Metal’) in the case of non-ferrous scrap. The end users of ferrous scrap are BHP and Smorgon. A small amount of non-ferrous scrap is exported. Metals can be categorised into ferrous and non-ferrous metals. Ferrous metals, which include steel products (but not stainless steel) and cast iron goods, are almost always magnetic. For resale, ferrous metals need to be cut to small specifications, usually not larger than 800 mm x 800 mm. Railway line, steel beams and steel plates are processed by oxy-cutting and/or mobile shear excavators. Whitegoods and car bodies are processed through shredding machines, which remove the plastic, and other non-metal contents. Non-ferrous materials are non-magnetic and are processed differently, depending on the metal. They include copper, aluminium, brass and stainless steel.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BENNETT J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BENNETT J