FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
United Group Resources Pty Ltd v Calabro (No 5) [2011] FCA 1408
Citation: United Group Resources Pty Ltd v Calabro (No 5) [2011] FCA 1408 Parties: UNITED GROUP RESOURCES PTY LTD ABN 17 114 888 201, AGC INDUSTRIES PTY LTD ABN 57 079 939 898, MODERN ACCESS SERVICES PTY LTD ABN 87 129 312 590, DOWNER EDI ENGINEERING POWER PTY LTD ABN 53 000 983 700, MONADELPHOUS ENGINEERING ASSOCIATES PTY LTD ABN 52 008 861 836, CBI CONSTRUCTORS PTY LTD ABN 90 000 612 411, DECMIL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ABN 58 116 776 991, FREO GROUP LIMITED ABN 64 009 325 124, MAMMOET AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ABN 77 075 483 644, PCH GROUP LTD ABN 41 009 120 021, RCR CONSTRUCTION & MAINTENANCE PTY LTD ABN 97 063 053 814, RCR POSITRON PTY LTD ABN 38 106 084 879 and JOHN HOLLAND PTY LTD ABN 11 004 282 268 v BRAEDEN CALABRO AND OTHERS LISTED IN THE RESPONDENTS' SCHEDULE A AS AMENDED and THE AUSTRALIAN BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSIONER File number: WAD 14 of 2010 Judge: MCKERRACHER J Date of judgment: 8 December 2011 Corrigendum: 16 December 2011 Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – unlawful industrial action by more than 1300 respondents - some represented - some not – breach of Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) and Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) (BCII Act) – purpose of industrial action – motivation of respondents – industrial motivation – liability – liability admitted by represented respondents – agreement on remedy and penalty – appropriate penalty to be determined by the Court – whether it is appropriate to make declarations – analysis of transitional provisions of the FW Act – differences between an agreement-based transitional instructions, Workplace Relations Act instruments and transitional instruments – meaning of industrially-motivated in the BCII Act – definition of ‘industrially-motivated’ in the BCII Act – operation and construction of para (a) of the definition of ‘industrially-motivated’ in the BCII Act – operation and construction of para (d) of the definition of ‘industrially-motivated’ in the BCII Act – meaning of motivation – disruption to the performance of work for the purpose of industrial action
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – respondents who have not entered an appearance – former Federal Court Rules O 32 r 2(1)(d) – Court required to consider merits of case and make determination on balance of probabilities – Court entitled to assume correctness of matters upon which the applicant bears the onus – Federal Court Rules 2011 r 1.04 – whether proof of service on absent respondents required before affidavits can be read – where service was not effected personally – leave required to read affidavits without service – where respondents had notice of proceedings and consequences
EVIDENCE - reliance on inference – proof of any fact on the balance of probabilities from which the Court infers a further fact – inferences from primary or intermediate fact – circumstances to be taken into account when drawing…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read United Group Resources Pty Ltd v Calabro (No 5) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] FCA 1408
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the industrial action was indeed unlawful and motivated by purposes defined in the BCII Act, such as supporting claims against employers and disrupting work performance. The reasoning relied on both inferential and testimonial evidence, including admissions by agents of the unrepresented respondents. The court concluded that the failure of the unrepresented respondents to deny or explain the allegations against them strengthened the case for liability. The court's decision acknowledged the agreement between the applicants and the represented respondents on the remedy and penalty, leaving the exact terms to be determined by the court. The final orders included declarations of liability and scheduled a further hearing to decide on the remedy and penalties.
The court declared that all respondents engaged in industrial action, violating the FW Act and the BCII Act, and ordered a hearing to determine the remedy and penalties. Represented respondents and applicants were directed to notify the court of any affidavits they intended to rely on and outline their contentions on remedy. Unrepresented respondents were also given the opportunity to file affidavits and contentions. The court further ordered that the applicants notify the unrepresented respondents of the findings and the upcoming hearing on remedy. The decision highlighted the importance of evidence, both inferential and testimonial, in establishing liability and underscored the court's role in determining appropriate penalties.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. There be judgment on liability in favour of the applicants as against all respondents.
2. The intervener’s case against the appearing respondents is adjourned to 10:15 am on 9 December 2011 for the intervener to apply, should it elect to do so, to adduce evidence on one additional aspect only (concerning paragraph 51A of a draft agreed statement); to adduce that evidence if permitted to do so and for the appearing respondents to adduce evidence in response on that issue only, should they elect to do so.
THE COURT DECLARES THAT:
3. The respondents engaged in:
(a) industrial action within the meaning of s 19 of' the Fair Work Act (Cth) 2009 (FW Act); and
(b) building industrial action within the meaning of s 36(1) of the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) (BCII Act),
on 22, 23, 25, 27, 28, 29 and 30 January 2010 by failing to attend for work on one or more days on which they were rostered to work, for either the whole or part of their rostered shift, as specified in the table annexed to the original orders made herewith, having been attached to the Applicants’ and Intervener’s Minute of Proposed Orders in relation to Liability and Directions in Relation to the Hearing on Remedy dated 20 September 2011 entitled ‘Final summary of respondent numbers and representation’.
4. Each respondent employed by:
(a) United Group Resources Pty Ltd (first applicant);
(b) AGC Industries Pty Ltd (second applicant);
(c) MAS Australasia Pty Ltd (third applicant);
(d) Downer EDI Engineering Power Pty Ltd (fourth applicant);
(e) Monadelphous Engineering Associates Pty Ltd (fifth applicant);
(f) Decmil Australia Pty Ltd (seventh applicant);
(g) PCH Group Ltd (tenth applicant); and
(h) RCR Power Pty Ltd (twelfth applicant)
contravened s 417(1) of the FW Act in respect of each day on which they took industrial action on 22, 23, 25, 27, 28, 29 and 30 January 2010, as specified in the table annexed to the original orders made herewith, having been attached to the Applicants’ and Intervener’s Minute of Proposed Orders in relation to Liability and Directions in Relation to the Hearing on Remedy dated 20 September 2011 entitled ‘Final summary of respondent numbers and representation’.
5. Respondents 865 and 871 (who were employed by the sixth applicant) contravened s 417 of the FW Act in respect of each day on which they took industrial action on 22, 23, 25, 27, 28, 29 and 30 January 2010, as specified in the table annexed to the original orders made herewith, having been attached to the Applicants’ and Intervener’s Minute of Proposed Orders in relation to Liability and Directions in Relation to the Hearing on Remedy dated 20 September 2011 entitled ‘Final summary of respondent numbers and representation’.
6. The respondents who were members of the Construction Forestry Mining & Energy Union (CFMEU), Communications Electrical & Plumbing Union (CEPU) or the Australian Manufacturing Workers Union (AMWU) (other than respondents employed by the thirteenth applicant) as at 23 January 2010 and during the term of the order made by Commissioner Cloghan of Fair Work Australia on 23 January 2010 contravened s 421(1) of the FW Act in respect of each day on which they took industrial action on 25, 27, 28, 29 and 30 January 2010, as specified in the table annexed to the original orders made herewith, having been attached to the Applicants’ and Intervener’s Minute of Proposed Orders in relation to Liability and Directions in Relation to the Hearing on Remedy dated 20 September 2011 entitled ‘Final summary of respondent numbers and representation’.
7. All of the respondents contravened s 38 of the BCII Act (except for Respondents 817 and 825) in respect of each day on which they took industrial action on 22, 23, 25, 27, 28, 29 and 30 January 2010, as specified in the table annexed to the original orders made herewith, having been attached to the Applicants’ and Intervener’s Minute of Proposed Orders in relation to Liability and Directions in Relation to the Hearing on Remedy dated 20 September 2011 entitled ‘Final summary of respondent numbers and representation’.
THE COURT FURTHER ORDERS THAT:
Directions as to hearing on remedy
8. The matter be listed for further hearing in relation to remedy on 13-16 December 2011, commencing at 10:15am on 13 December 2011.
9. The intervener to:
(a) give notice of its intention to rely upon any parts of any affidavits which have already been filed; and
(b) file and serve any additional affidavits on which it intends to rely
at the hearing on remedy together with an outline of contentions on remedy, by 4:00 pm on 25 October 2011.
10. The non-appearing respondents to file and serve any affidavits on which they intend to rely at the hearing on remedy, together with any outline of contentions on remedy, by 4:00 pm on 8 November 2011.
11. The represented respondents and the applicants to:
(a) give notice of their intention to rely upon any parts of any affidavits which have already been filed; and
(b) file and serve any additional affidavits on which they intend to rely
at the hearing on remedy, together with an outline of contentions on remedy, by 4:00 pm on 22 November 2011.
12. Each party to give notice of its intention to cross examine the deponent of any affidavit to be relied upon by another party at the hearing on remedy by 4:00 pm on 28 November 2011.
13. The parties to file any agreed statement of facts in relation to remedy by 4:00 pm on 28 November 2011.
14. The matter be listed for directions at 10:00 am on 29 November 2011.
15. Liberty to apply on 3 days’ notice.
The Court notes that the applicants will notify the non-appearing respondents of (a) the Court's decision as to liability, (b) the fact that the matter is set down for a hearing in relation to remedy on 13-16 December 2011, and (c) the directions made in relation to the hearing on remedy, by (i) sending a notice in the form annexed and marked ‘A’ to these orders to the last known address of each of the non-appearing respondents, and (ii) affixing a copy of the notice to the noticeboard(s) usually used for the purpose of communication with the respondents at the workplace on the Pluto LNG Project.
Annexure A
FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WAD 14 of 2010
Important Notice to Respondents
Name and Address of Respondent
Findings made as to liability
1. The Federal Court of Australia has determined that you have contravened s 417 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and/or s 38 of the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005 (Cth) in relation to industrial action taken in the period from 22 to 30 January 2010 on the Pluto LNG Project.
2. The Court has listed the matter for hearing on 13 - 16 December 2011 (commencing at 10:15 am on 13 December 2011) in relation to any remedy it may impose in respect of your contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 and/or the Building and Construction Industry Improvement Act 2005.
3. Directions have been made in relation to the hearing on 13 - 16 December 2011 in accordance with paragraphs 8 - 15 of the attached document.
4. If you would like to participate in the hearing on 13 - 16 December 2011 in relation to remedy, you must file a notice of appearance in the Federal Court of Australia and comply with the directions set out in paragraphs 8 - 15 of the attached document.
5. If you enter an appearance in these proceedings, you are entitled to be sent by post a copy of the Court's decision on liability without charge upon written request being made for the same to the applicants' solicitors, Freehills, by any one of the following means:
Postal Address: Freehills DX 361 Sydney (Attention: Emma Krasenstein)
Facsimile: Freehills 02 9322 4000 (Attention: Emma Krasenstein)
E-mail: emma.krasenstein@freehills.com
6. If you do not enter an appearance in these proceedings and take steps to participate in the hearing on remedy on 13 - 16 December 2011, the Federal Court of Australia may order that you pay a penalty and that a permanent injunction be imposed upon you to prevent you taking any unlawful industrial action.
Freehills
Solicitors for the Applicants
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
It follows that each unrepresented respondent in the URR Summary who has a 'Y' marked in the column entitled ‘s.417’ contravened s 417 of the FW Act on the days specified in that table by engaging in industrial action during the nominal term of an enterprise agreement. Consideration of liability of the unrepresented respondents In s 36(1) of the BCII Act ‘industrially-motivated’ is defined as follows (the IM definition):Industrially-motivated means motivated by one or more of the following purposes, or by purposes that include one or more of the following purposes:(a)supporting or advancing claims against an employer in respect of the employment of employees of that employer;(b)supporting or advancing claims by an employer in respect of the employment of employees of that employer;(c)advancing industrial objectives of an industrial association;(d)disrupting the performance of work.The employer referred to in paragraphs (a) and (b) need not be the employer whose employees do the work to which the action relates. Proof of industrial motivation (as defined above) against the 616 unrepresented respondents raised particular considerations which may not always be encountered. In relation to the unrepresented respondents, the applicants argued a case in relation to para (a) of the IM definition and did not, unlike the ABCC, argue in relation to para (d). The applicants and the ABCC submit that the building industrial action undertaken by each of the unrepresented respondents in January 2010 was unlawful pursuant to s 37(a) of the BCII Act. It was unlawful as it was industrially-motivated, in that it was motivated by a purpose, or by purposes which included the purpose, of:(a)supporting or advancing claims against an employer in respect of employees of that employer (para (a) of the IM definition), or (b)disrupting the performance of work (para (d) of the IM definition). In order to prove the unrepresented respondents’ industrial motivation, the applicants and the ABCC rely on inference, and additionally, in the case of some of the unrepresented respondents, admissions made by their agents. I am satisfied that the applicants and the ABCC have, in respect of the unrepresented respondents, presented evidence and argument fairly, albeit favourably to their case. No other evidence or argument at all was adduced. As such, I have adopted substantial portions of the submissions of the applicants and the ABCC on this topic without repeated attribution. Reliance on inference – the principles It is necessary, first to consider the inferential case. Proof of any fact on the balance of probabilities can be established by circumstantial evidence (Seltsam Pty Ltd v McGuiness (2000) 49 NSWLR 262 (at [90])); that is, by proof of primary, or intermediate, facts from which the court infers a further fact (Shepherd v The Queen (1990) 170 CLR 573 (at 579). The primary facts can themselves be the product of inference from other facts. The applicants and the ABCC submit that in this case, in which the civil standard applies, ‘you need only circumstances raising a more probable inference in favour of what is alleged’ (Bradshaw v McEwans Pty Ltd (1951) 217 ALR 1 (at 5)). A fact may be proved by inference if according to common experience the fact is the more probable inference from the unexplained primary facts (Bradshaw (at 6)). Certainty is never possible, and is not required (Transport Industries Insurance Co Ltd v Longmuir [1997] 1 VR 125 (at 141)); all that is necessary is that ‘circumstances are proved in which it is reasonable to find a balance of probabilities in favour of the conclusion sought’ (Bradshaw (at 5)). For the purpose of considering whether this test is met the Court must ‘consider the accumulation of the evidence’ (Chamberlain v The Queen (No 2) (1984) 153 CLR 521 (at 535)). It is appropriate ‘not only to evaluate each of the factual contentions separately but also to form an appreciation of the overall effect of the whole of the evidence’ (Clay v Clay (1999) 20 WAR 427 (at [55])), by considering ‘the weight which is to be given to the united force of all the circumstances put together’ (Belhaven and Stenton Peerage [1875] 1 App Cas 278 (at 279). The Court may draw an inference from a combination of intermediate facts, even if none of them in isolation would support the inference (Chamberlain (at 536)). It also means that:[a] true picture is to be derived from an accumulation of detail. The overall effect of the detailed picture can sometimes be best appreciated by standing back and viewing it from a distance, making an informed, considered, qualitative appreciation of the whole. The overall effect of the detail is not necessarily the same as the sum total of the individual details.(Longmuir (at 141)). The overall effect can be a product of primary facts that are combined like ‘strands in a cable’ (Seltsam (at [90])).