Beaumont Constructions Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Beaumont Constructions Pty Ltd & Ors v Commissioner of State Revenue [2020] QCAT 52

PARTIES:

BEAUMONT CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD

KATARZYNA GROUP PTY LTD

SOUTH BANK SURF CLUB PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE FOR SOUTH BANK SC TRUST

FAMILY QLD PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE FOR BEAUMONT ENTERTAINMENT TRUST

EMPIRE HOLDINGS (QLD) PTY LTD

BUNK (QLD) PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE FOR BUNK DISCRETIONARY TRUST

BEAUMONT CREATIONS PTY LTD
(applicants)

v         

COMMISSIONER OF STATE REVENUE
(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR138-16; GAR139-16; GAR140-16; GAR141-16; GAR142-16; GAR143-16; GAR 144-16

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

14 February 2020

HEARING DATE:

6 November 2017, 7 November 2017

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Fitzpatrick

ORDERS:

GAR 141 – 16 Southbank Surf Club Pty Limited ATF South Bank SC Trust

1.   The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue refusing to make an Exclusion Order with respect to South Bank Surf Club Pty Ltd as Trustee for Southbank SC Trust made on 4 April 2015 is confirmed.

2.   The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue refusing to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest made on 4 April 2015 is confirmed.

GAR 138 – 16 Beaumont Construction Pty Ltd

The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue refusing to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest made on 4 April 2015 is confirmed.

GAR 139-16 Family QLD Pty Ltd ATF Beaumont Entertainment Trust

The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue refusing to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest made on 4 April 2015 is confirmed.

GAR 140-16 Empire Holdings (QLD) Pty Ltd

The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue refusing to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest made on 4 April 2015 is confirmed.

GAR 142-16 Katarzyna Group Pty Ltd

The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue refusing to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest made on 4 April 2015 is confirmed.

GAR 143-16 Bunk (QLD) Pty Ltd

The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue refusing to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest made on 4 April 2015 is confirmed.

GAR 144-16 Beaumont Creations Pty Ltd

The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue refusing to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest made on 4 April 2015 is confirmed.

CATCHWORDS:

TAXES AND DUTIES – PAYROLL TAX – LIABILITY TO TAXATION – GROUPING OF EMPLOYERS – REMISSION OF PENALTY TAX AND UNPAID TAX INTEREST – exercise of discretion to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest – whether penalty – whether intentionally misleading conduct – onus of proof – exercise of discretion to exclude member from a group – whether a connection with the group in a real and meaningful business sense – whether joint supply agreement showed connection

Payroll Tax Act 1971 (Qld), s 52, s 53, s 58, s 59, s 60,
s 68, s 69, s 70, s 71, s 72, s 73, s 74
Property Law Act 1974 (Qld), s 55
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Beaumont Constructions Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Reven... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QCAT 52
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Beaumont Constructions Pty Ltd and others brought an application to review decisions made by the Commissioner of State Revenue, challenging her decisions to refuse to make exclusion orders for certain entities under the Payroll Tax Act 2007 (PTA), and to refuse to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest imposed on them. The applicants were entities within a larger group of companies involved in the hospitality industry, including bars, restaurants and alcohol sales. The Commissioner had conducted an investigation into the group's payroll tax liability and concluded that the group was liable for tax under the PTA, and that the exclusion orders should not be granted. The Commissioner also decided not to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest imposed on the applicants.

The key legal issues in the case were whether the Commissioner correctly exercised her discretion to refuse to make exclusion orders for certain entities within the group, and whether she correctly decided not to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest imposed on the applicants. The applicants argued that the Commissioner should have granted the exclusion orders and remitted the penalty tax and unpaid tax interest, as they were not intentionally misleading and had taken reasonable care to comply with the PTA. The Commissioner argued that the group had intentionally provided false or misleading information in an attempt to receive a favourable outcome to their exclusion order request, and that the group was connected in a real and meaningful business sense.

The court found that the Commissioner had correctly exercised her discretion to refuse to make exclusion orders for the applicants, as they were connected in a real and meaningful business sense with the rest of the group. The court also found that the Commissioner had correctly decided not to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest imposed on the applicants, as they had intentionally provided false or misleading information in an attempt to receive a favourable outcome to their exclusion order request. The court held that the Commissioner had properly exercised her discretion under the PTA, and that the applicants had not discharged the onus of proving that the Commissioner's decision was wrong.

The court confirmed the Commissioner's decisions to refuse to make exclusion orders for the applicants and to refuse to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest imposed on them. The applicants' applications for review were dismissed, and the Commissioner's decisions were upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

GAR 141 – 16 Southbank Surf Club Pty Limited ATF South Bank SC Trust

1. The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue refusing to make an Exclusion Order with respect to South Bank Surf Club Pty Ltd as Trustee for Southbank SC Trust made on 4 April 2015 is confirmed.

2. The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue refusing to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest made on 4 April 2015 is confirmed.

GAR 138 – 16 Beaumont Construction Pty Ltd

The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue refusing to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest made on 4 April 2015 is confirmed.

GAR 139-16 Family QLD Pty Ltd ATF Beaumont Entertainment Trust

The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue refusing to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest made on 4 April 2015 is confirmed.

GAR 140-16 Empire Holdings (QLD) Pty Ltd

The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue refusing to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest made on 4 April 2015 is confirmed.

GAR 142-16 Katarzyna Group Pty Ltd

The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue refusing to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest made on 4 April 2015 is confirmed.

GAR 143-16 Bunk (QLD) Pty Ltd

The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue refusing to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest made on 4 April 2015 is confirmed.

GAR 144-16 Beaumont Creations Pty Ltd

The decision of the Commissioner of State Revenue refusing to remit penalty tax and unpaid tax interest made on 4 April 2015 is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I have referred to an agreed statement of facts filed by the parties as a chronology of events.[1] I have added information from the material before me. The relevant events are:[1]Bundle of Key Documents – Tab 27.(a)29 July 2013 – the respondent issued initial entry audit letters to Beaumont Constructions, Bunk, Empire, Family, Katarzyna and SBSC notifying it that the respondent would be commencing a payroll investigation. A Form AQ1 was sent requiring information about companies potentially within a group. The form was never completed.(b)2013 to 2015 – the respondent conducted an investigation of over 30 companies and trust entities, including the applicants.The investigation looked at whether the applicants were liable to pay for payroll tax as a group under s 71 of the PTA and if they were, whether the respondent should exercise her discretion under s 74 of the Act to exclude some members of the group.(c)4 October 2013 – the applicants responded to the initial entry audit letters.(d)Applications for exclusion from grouping under s 74 of the PTA were lodged by the applicants at different stages during the ongoing investigation:(i) on 19 December 2013, by Beaumont Constructions, Bunk, Empire and Family (‘the initial audited entities’);(ii) on 5 June 2014, by SBSC; and(iii) on 10 September 2014, by Beaumont Creations (‘the exclusion applications’).(e)CBD Golf applied for an exclusion order on 27 February 2015.(f)All of the entities, with the exception of SBSC, applied for an exclusion order from 1 July 2008. SBSC applied for an exclusion from 27 November 2009, being the date of its incorporation.(g)All exclusion applications attached a Form OSR – PT1 which sets out a list of questions to be addressed in an exclusion application including: commonly controlled businesses (questions 1-4); whether any business in the group exists solely or predominantly to provide services or goods to the other group members (including the business or businesses seeking exclusion) (question 25); the nature and extent of any group purchasing or supply arrangements (question 28); any shared resources for example a website (question 31); and whether there are or have been any intra group loans or financing arrangements between members of the group (question 36). Each Form OSR – PT1 was signed by a Director of the relevant company seeking exclusion declaring that the information submitted is true and correct.(h)On 7 January 2014, the respondent sent an email to PPM the applicants’ legal and tax advisor, identifying Beaumont Creations Pty Ltd as an employer in the 2010 financial year and payroll group member.(i)30 January 2014 – the respondent sent an email to PPM progressing the investigation:(j)7 February 2014 – PPM provided requested further information.(k)12 February 2014 – the respondent emailed PPM requesting further information about specific entities and attaching a ‘draft’ grouping chart. (l)7 March 2014 – the applicants provided responses to the respondent’s request for information on 12 February 2014 and provided the respondent with a draft document entitled ‘Katarzyna Group – Company Particulars’. The Katarzyna Group – Company Particulars document disclosed 30 entities, being investment trusts or companies. Beaumont Creations and CBD Golf were included in that document. The document provided that CBD Golf was not a trustee company.(m)Between March 2014 and July 2014 – the respondent requested further information to determine the exclusion applications and the applicants responded.(n)7 July 2014 – the respondent requested information from the applicants, in particular whether Katarzyna organised the purchase of goods such as alcohol or beverages on behalf of the group and further asked about any group purchasing or supply arrangements.(o)12 August 2014 – the applicants responded denying that Katarzyna organised the purchase of alcohol or that group purchasing agreements existed. It was asserted all alcohol was ordered separately and rebates were calculated separately without reference to other entities purchases. (p)Between August 2014 and February 2015 – the applicants responded to various requests for information, including a request on 30 September 2014 for further information and documents in relation to CBD Golf, which the Commissioner had discovered at that time was a trustee company.(q)6 February 2015 – the respondent sent correspondence to the applicants about supply agreements regarding CUB, Asahi and Schweppes signed by Katarzyna and invited a response. Copies of the supply agreements were provided to PPM.(r)17 February 2015 – the applicants responded that answers given were partially incorrect, given the CUB Agreement. Its existence was said to be an oversight. Individual ordering, payment and rebates was re-iterated.(s)Between 17 February 2015 and 25 March 2015 – the Commissioner determined the exclusion order applications.(t)25 March 2015 – the respondent issued reassessment notices to Bunk, Empire, Family, Katarzyna and SBSC.(u)26 March 2015 – the respondent issued default assessment notices to Beaumont Constructions, Beaumont Creations and SBSC and reassessment notices to SBSC.(v)27 March 2015 – the respondent sent a letter (the exclusion decision) to the applicants refusing the exclusion applications and attaching the various default assessments and reassessments, except for Beaumont Constructions.This decision determined that the respondent would not exercise her discretion under s 74 of the Act to exclude members of the group.Relevant to SBSC, the Commissioner considered that:(i) Family and SBSC constitute a group because the businesses are taken to be controlled by the same persons: sections 71(1), 71(2)(g) and 71(6) of the PTA;(ii) SBSC is subsumed into a larger group because Family is common to both groups: s 73(1) of the PTA;(iii) Section 74 of the PTA provides that an exclusion may be granted on certain grounds. Public Ruling 031.2 provides a number of factors that are taken into account. In summary, the following factors counted against the grant of an exclusion order:A. SBSC received administrative services from Katarzyna Group Pty Ltd;B. ad hoc building services were received from Beaumont Creations, not provided at market rates;C. the degree of common ownership and control of the business by the Bickle family was 50% for the period up to 21 March 2013;D. control under the grouping provisions includes a right to control whether or not a Director or owner exerts that right;E. the Commissioner was not satisfied that Directors who did not possess managerial control were not also involved in managerial decisions and day to day administration of the business. F. whilst in the period up to 21 March 2013 the Bickle family level of ownership and control of the business was not high, exclusion is not justified in light of the significant connection which exists as a result of the joint supplier agreements with CUB and Asahi/Schweppes during the relevant periods; and the commercial convenience of accessing Katarzyna’s administration services and related transactions upon start up.G. After 21 March 2013 the nature and extent of ownership and control by the Bickle family is over the threshold, which increases the importance of this factor.[2] Associated entities controlled by the Bickle family hold more than 75% of the units in the trust. Louis, Bevan and Raphael Bickle collectively control the trustee corporation.[2]John French Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Pay-roll Tax [1984] 1 Qd R 125.H. Each of SBSC, Family, Empire, Bunk and CBD Golf are involved in the hospitality industry and each derives income from bars, restaurants and selling alcohol.(w)27 March 2015 – by further letter (‘the penalty decision’) – the respondent sent a letter to the applicants implementing her decision by:(i) registering the applicants as a group for payroll tax (some of the applicants were already registered to pay payroll tax);(ii) appointing Katarzyna as the designated group employer;(iii) registering Beaumont Constructions and Beaumont Creations for payroll tax (as these entities were not already registered);(iv) advising that the standard rate of penalty tax is 75%. Total penalty tax payable is $732,376.59;(v) advising of her decision not to remit the penalty tax (except in the case of Beaumont Constructions and CBD Golf) and the reasons for that decision. The penalty decision recorded the Commissioner’s belief that up to the date of the investigation, the group did not take reasonable care in determining their taxation obligations under the PTA. The Commissioner also concluded that upon commencement of the investigation the group intentionally provided false or misleading information primarily in an attempt to receive a favourable outcome to their exclusion order request. The areas of concern to the Commissioner were in relation to failure to disclose the composition of the group, a shared website, joint supplier agreements, the ongoing nature of building and maintenance service provided by Beaumont Creations to the group and falsely stating the services were provided at “arm’s length”Penalty tax was remitted from 75% to 25% for Beaumont Constructions and CBD Golf, because the Commissioner did not think they had provided false and misleading information.(vi) advising of UTI and periods where UTI has been remitted. At the date of the letter the UTI was $327,541.26.(x)23 April 2015 – the respondent issued reassessment notices to SBSC.(y)Between 20 June 2015 and 30 June 2015 – the applicants objected to the exclusion order decision and penalty decision and sought a reassessment.(z)4 April 2016 – the respondent issued the applicants with her objection decision (‘the Decision’) rejecting the Objections and providing a Statement of Reasons. The Decision is the subject of this review.(aa)All penalty tax and UTI has been paid.Statutory basis for the Commissioner’s Decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established