AA Shi Pty Ltd v Avbar Pty Ltd (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AA Shi Pty Ltd v Avbar Pty Ltd (No 5) [2010] FCA 971

Citation: AA Shi Pty Ltd v Avbar Pty Ltd (No 5) [2010] FCA 971
Parties: AA SHI PTY LTD (ACN 100 459 667) v AVBAR PTY LTD (ACN 100 433 752) and NIR INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 100 276 015)
File number: QUD 121 of 2010
Judge: COLLIER J
Date of judgment: 3 September 2010
Catchwords:

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – Cross-claim to substantive proceeding concerning breaches of contractual obligations – non-appearance of cross-respondent at trial – Order 32 rule 2(1)(d) enlivened – Court required to consider merits of cross-claim and make determination on balance of probabilities – Court entitled to assume correctness of matters upon which cross-claimant bear the onus

TRADE PRACTICES – whether licence arrangements met statutory definition of Fuel Re-selling Agreement in s 5 Trade Practices (Industry Codes – Oilcode) Regulations 2006 (Cth) – whether cross-claimants entitled to terminate relevant agreements – whether cross-respondent failed to pay relevant licence fees – whether cross-respondent improperly retained money from sale of fuel – whether breaches of relevant agreements were within the meaning of s 36(1) Trade Practices (Industry Codes – Oilcode) Regulations 2006 (Cth) – calculation of interest up to judgment

Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 51A
Trade Practices (Industry Codes – Oilcode) Regulations 2006 (Cth) ss 5, 36(1)
Federal Court Rules O 4 r 14(2), O 32 r 2
Cases cited: AA Shi Pty Ltd v Avbar Pty Ltd (No 3) [2010] FCA 440 cited
AA Shi Pty Ltd v Avbar Pty Ltd (No 4) [2010] FCA 878 cited
Applicant A184 of 2003 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2004) 210 ALR 543 cited
Barker v. Furlong (1891) 2 Ch 172 cited
Kingdon v. Kirk (1888) 37 ChD 141 cited
NAET of 2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2002] FCAFC 304 cited
Pham v University of Queensland [2002] FCA 203 cited
Rediffusion (Hong Kong) Ltd v Attorney-General of Hong Kong [1970] AC 1136 cited
Scoway Pty Ltd v Faxon Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 249 cited
Stone v. Smith (1887) 35 ChD 188 cited
TVBO Production v Australia Sky Net Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 1132 cited
Carter JW, Peden E, Tolhurst GJ, Contract Law in Australia (5th ed, LexisNexis Butterworths 2007)
Date of hearing: 17 August 2010
Place: Brisbane
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 47
Counsel for the Applicant: The Applicant did not appear
Counsel for the First and Second Respondents: Mr P Dunning SC with Mr D Quayle
Solicitor for the Respondents: Clayton Utz

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

QUD 121 of 2010

BETWEEN:

AA SHI PTY LTD (ACN 100 459 667)
Applicant

AND:

AVBAR PTY LTD (ACN 100 433 752)
First Respondent

NIR INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 100 276 015)
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

COLLIER J

DATE OF ORDER:

3 SEPTEMBER 2010

WHERE MADE:

BRISBANE

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

The termination of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AA Shi Pty Ltd v Avbar Pty Ltd (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 971
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

AA Shi Pty Ltd (AA Shi) filed a proceeding against Avbar Pty Ltd (Avbar) and others in the Federal Court of Australia, seeking relief related to an alleged breach of contract. The dispute involved allegations of breach of operation agreements and misconduct in the operation of service stations. The case reached the trial stage, but AA Shi failed to appear, leading to the dismissal of their claims under Order 32 rule 2(1)(c) of the Federal Court Rules. Additionally, the court addressed a cross-claim by Avbar, which sought a declaration that the operation agreements did not constitute "fuel re-selling agreements" under the Oilcode, and sought damages for alleged breaches of the agreements.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the operation agreements between AA Shi and Avbar constituted "fuel re-selling agreements" as defined in the Oilcode. This definition includes agreements where a supplier grants a retailer the right to offer, supply, or distribute motor fuel under a system substantially determined by the supplier, among other criteria. The court also had to consider whether the agreements met the statutory requirements and whether there were breaches entitling Avbar to damages.

The court examined the nature of the agreements and the roles of the parties involved. It found that the agreements did not meet the statutory definition of "fuel re-selling agreements" as they lacked the supplier's substantial ongoing role in the retailer's operations beyond merely branding and supplying fuel. Consequently, the court held that the operation agreements did not constitute fuel re-selling agreements under the Oilcode. The court further found that AA Shi had breached the agreements by failing to pay licence fees and retaining money from fuel sales, entitling Avbar to damages.

The court ordered that the claims brought by AA Shi be dismissed, and all interlocutory restraints on Avbar be discharged. Additionally, AA Shi was ordered to pay Avbar's costs, including reserved costs related to the application. The court also declared that the operation agreements did not constitute fuel re-selling agreements under the Oilcode and ordered AA Shi to pay damages to Avbar for breaches of the agreements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

I now turn to my reasons.Background The notice of motion filed by AA Shi seeking the leave of the Court to allow it to carry on the proceeding otherwise than by a solicitor was listed to return on the first day of the trial of the substantive proceeding, namely 16 August 2010. Following my order of 17 August 2010 dismissing the notice of motion, there was no appearance by AA Shi in respect of the substantive proceeding. Order 32 r 2 of the Federal Court Rules provides:(1) If, when a proceeding is called on for trial, any party is absent, the Court may:(a) order that the trial be not had unless the proceeding is again set down for trial, or unless such other steps are taken as the Court may direct;(b) adjourn the trial;(c) if the party absent is an applicant or cross claimant dismiss the action or the cross claim; or(d) proceed with the trial generally or so far as concerns any claim for relief in the proceeding.(2) Where the Court proceeds with a trial in the absence of a party, and at or at the conclusion of the trial an order is made, the Court may set aside or vary the order, and may give directions for the further conduct of the proceeding.(3) Subrule (2) does not enable the Court to vary the verdict, finding or assessment of a jury at a trial except with the consent of each interested party present at the trial. The respondents/cross-claimants submitted that, in light of the absence of AA Shi from the trial, O 32 r 2(1)(c) was engaged in respect of the substantive proceeding, and the claims against them should be dismissed. I agreed that O 32 r 2 (1)(c) was engaged in respect of the claims of AA Shi pursuant to the application filed 13 April 2010. Following delivery of judgment in AA Shi [2010] FCA 878 I ordered, in summary, that pursuant to O 32 r 2(1)(c) the application be dismissed, all interlocutory restraints on the respondents/cross-claimants be discharged, and AA Shi pay the costs of the respondents/cross-claimants including all reserved costs in respect of the application. I made these orders in circumstances where:·AA Shi and its sole director and shareholder, Mr David Yahalom, clearly knew that the trial in the substantive proceeding would commence on 16 August 2010.·AA Shi was not represented by solicitors as required by the Federal Court Rules and I dismissed its notice of motion seeking an order that the Court grant leave for it to carry on the proceeding otherwise than by a solicitor.·No further orders were sought by Mr Yahalom, in any capacity, for an adjournment of the proceedings or to arrange for AA Shi to retain solicitors.·The respondents/cross-claimants were subject to interlocutory injunctive orders in circumstances where AA Shi had not appeared at the substantive proceedings, and no submissions had been made in support of continuing those restraints.·Material in the affidavit of Mr Nir Avrahami sworn 10 August 2010 and filed in Court on 17 August 2010 supported an inference drawn by the Court that the businesses, carried on through the stores at the service stations of which the respondents/cross-claimants were lessees, were being run down by AA Shi, and that continuing injunctive restraints would harm the respondents/cross-claimants.·Order 32 r 2(1)(c) does not require the trial judge, confronted with the non-appearance of an applicant, to embark upon any investigation of the merits of the absent applicant’s claim (Pham v University of Queensland [2002] FCA 203 per Drummond J at [26], followed in NAET of 2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2002] FCAFC 304 at [4]); and·In order to avoid doubt as to whether, pursuant to the terms of Orders 1 and 2 of 6 May 2010 (AA Shi Pty Ltd v Avbar Pty Ltd (No 3) [2010] FCA 440) the interlocutory injunctions against the respondents/cross-claimants were discharged by the commencement of the trial on 16 August 2010 or a specific order to that effect was necessary, I ordered that the interlocutory injunctions in place against the respondents/cross-claimants be discharged.Cross-claim

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Seventh, the failure of AA Shi to pay licence fees in the sum of $221,409, and the retention by AA Shi of money from the sale of fuel in the amount of $7,375, were supported by the evidence of Ms Avrahami and the material contained in the respondents’ Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions.Relevant evidence While the interlocutory injunctive relief was granted on the basis of extensive submissions and evidence before the Court tendered during previous hearings, the cross-claim was not the subject of specific submissions or evidence before the Court until the hearing of 17 August 2010. An important reason for this was that on 18 June 2010 I directed that all evidence in the substantive proceeding was to be oral. Accordingly, at the hearing on 17 August 2010 Mr Dunning SC called Mrs Fay Avrahami as a witness and through Mrs Avrahami tendered a document entitled “Tender Bundle”. This document contains a large number of business records relating to the operation of the four service stations. I have already observed that evidence of the party prosecuting the claim can be admitted notwithstanding the absence of the respondent to the claim at the relevant proceedings: Scoway [2004] FCA 249. I note also that evidence in affidavit form had previously been tendered in the proceedings, and is also available as the basis for decision in this case. In particular I note:·the affidavit of Lily Avrahami sworn 23 April 2010;·the affidavit of Michael Israel sworn 23 April 2010;·the affidavit of Nir Avrahami sworn 23 April 2010. I now turn to the issues requiring determination in respect of the cross-claim of the respondents/cross-claimants.1. Did the licence arrangements created by the operation agreements meet the statutory definition of Fuel Re-selling Agreement in section 5 of the Oilcode? Section 5 in the Schedule to the Oilcode provides a detailed definition of “Fuel Re-selling Agreement” as follows:5 Meaning of fuel re-selling agreement(1) A fuel re-selling agreement is an agreement:(a) that takes the form, in whole or part, of any of the following:(i) a written agreement;(ii) an oral agreement;(iii) an implied agreement; and(b)in which a person (the supplier) grants to another person (the retailer):(i)the right to carry on the business of offering, supplying or distributing motor fuel in Australia under a system or marketing plan substantially determined, controlled or suggested by the supplier or an associate of the supplier; or(ii)consent to be a transferee in relation to a fuel re-selling agreement; and(c)under which the operation of the business will be substantially or materially associated with a trade mark, advertising or a commercial symbol:(i)owned, used or licensed by the supplier or an associate of the supplier; or(ii)specified by the supplier or an associate of the supplier; and(d)under which, before starting business or continuing the business, the retailer must pay or agree to pay to the supplier or an associate of the supplier an amount including, for example:(i)an initial capital investment fee; or(ii)a payment for goods or services; or(iii)a fee based on a percentage of gross or net income whether or not called a royalty or agreement service fee; or(iv)a training fee or training school fee;but excluding:(v)payment for motor fuel at or below the usual wholesale price; or(vi)payment for the usual wholesale price of motor fuel taken on consignment; or(vii)payment of market value for purchase or lease of real property, fixtures, equipment or supplies needed to start business or to continue business under the fuel re-selling agreement.Note To meet the requirements of subparagraph (1)(b)(i), a supplier must have a substantial on going role in the retailer’s operations, in addition to being responsible for branding and supplying fuel. For example:(a)a traditional franchise or commission agency arrangement would meet the requirements of the subparagraph because of the supplier’s substantial on going role in the operations; but(b)a ‘supply only’ or ‘supply and branding only’ agreement with an owner dealer would not meet the requirements of the subparagraph.(2)For subsection (1), the following are taken to be fuel re-selling agreements:(a)the transfer, renewal or extension of a fuel re-selling agreement;(b)an agency arrangement to which the requirements of paragraphs (1)(a), (b) and (c) apply;(c)an interest in a fuel re-selling agreement.(3)However, any of the following does not in itself constitute a fuel re-selling agreement:(a)an employer and employee relationship;(b)a partnership relationship;(c)a landlord and tenant relationship;(d)a mortgagor and mortgagee relationship;(e)a lender and borrower relationship;(f)a fuel agreement related to a retail site that is not owned or leased by the supplier;(g)the relationship between the members of a cooperative that is registered, incorporated or formed under any of the following laws……(4)A fuel reselling agreement may apply to 1 or more retail sites.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I now turn to the issues requiring determination in respect of the cross-claim of the respondents/cross-claimants.1. Did the licence arrangements created by the operation agreements meet the statutory definition of Fuel Re-selling Agreement in section 5 of the Oilcode? Section 5 in the Schedule to the Oilcode provides a detailed definition of “Fuel Re-selling Agreement” as follows:5 Meaning of fuel re-selling agreement(1) A fuel re-selling agreement is an agreement:(a) that takes the form, in whole or part, of any of the following:(i) a written agreement;(ii) an oral agreement;(iii) an implied agreement; and(b)in which a person (the supplier) grants to another person (the retailer):(i)the right to carry on the business of offering, supplying or distributing motor fuel in Australia under a system or marketing plan substantially determined, controlled or suggested by the supplier or an associate of the supplier; or(ii)consent to be a transferee in relation to a fuel re-selling agreement; and(c)under which the operation of the business will be substantially or materially associated with a trade mark, advertising or a commercial symbol:(i)owned, used or licensed by the supplier or an associate of the supplier; or(ii)specified by the supplier or an associate of the supplier; and(d)under which, before starting business or continuing the business, the retailer must pay or agree to pay to the supplier or an associate of the supplier an amount including, for example:(i)an initial capital investment fee; or(ii)a payment for goods or services; or(iii)a fee based on a percentage of gross or net income whether or not called a royalty or agreement service fee; or(iv)a training fee or training school fee;but excluding:(v)payment for motor fuel at or below the usual wholesale price; or(vi)payment for the usual wholesale price of motor fuel taken on consignment; or(vii)payment of market value for purchase or lease of real property, fixtures, equipment or supplies needed to start business or to continue business under the fuel re-selling agreement.Note To meet the requirements of subparagraph (1)(b)(i), a supplier must have a substantial on going role in the retailer’s operations, in addition to being responsible for branding and supplying fuel. For example:(a)a traditional franchise or commission agency arrangement would meet the requirements of the subparagraph because of the supplier’s substantial on going role in the operations; but(b)a ‘supply only’ or ‘supply and branding only’ agreement with an owner dealer would not meet the requirements of the subparagraph.(2)For subsection (1), the following are taken to be fuel re-selling agreements:(a)the transfer, renewal or extension of a fuel re-selling agreement;(b)an agency arrangement to which the requirements of paragraphs (1)(a), (b) and (c) apply;(c)an interest in a fuel re-selling agreement.(3)However, any of the following does not in itself constitute a fuel re-selling agreement:(a)an employer and employee relationship;(b)a partnership relationship;(c)a landlord and tenant relationship;(d)a mortgagor and mortgagee relationship;(e)a lender and borrower relationship;(f)a fuel agreement related to a retail site that is not owned or leased by the supplier;(g)the relationship between the members of a cooperative that is registered, incorporated or formed under any of the following laws……(4)A fuel reselling agreement may apply to 1 or more retail sites.