Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v EDirect Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v EDirect Pty Ltd

[2012] FCA 1045

Citation: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v EDirect Pty Ltd [2012] FCA 1045
Parties: AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v EDIRECT PTY LTD ACN 108 532 083
File number: NTD 28 of 2010
Judge: REEVES J
Date of judgment: 21 September 2012
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – trial in accordance with O 32 r 2(1)(d) Federal Court Rules (now Rule 1.04 Federal Court Rules 2011)

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – considerations in exercising discretion to make declaratory orders under s 21 Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – public interest in declarations in consumer protection litigation

TRADE PRACTICES – s 52 Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) – misleading and deceptive conduct in connection with and supply of mobile telecommunication services – representations as to pre-approved credit of potential customers – representations as to referrals made by individuals known to potential customers

TRADE PRACTICES – s 51AB Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) – unconscionable conduct proscribed by s 51AB not limited to specific equitable doctrines – consideration of Parliamentary intention behind s 51AB as expressed in Sch 2, s 21(4)(b) Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)

Legislation: Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth)
Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)
Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No. 2) 2010 (Cth)
Federal Court Rules
Federal Court Rules 2011
Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v C G Berbatis Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) (2000) 96 FCR 491; [2000] FCA 2
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v EDirect Pty. Ltd. (in liq) [2012] FCA 976
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Francis (2004) 142 FCR 1; [2004] FCA 487
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Grove & Edgar Pty Ltd (2008) ATPR 42-269; [2008] FCR 1956
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Keshow [2005] FCA 558
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Lux Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 926
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v MSY Technology Pty Ltd [2012] FCAFC 56
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Radio Rentals Ltd (2005) 146 FCR 292; [2005] FCA 1133
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Seal-A-Fridge Pty Ltd (2010) 268 ALR 321; [2010] FCA 525
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Simply No-Knead (Franchising) Pty Ltd (2000) 104 FCR 253; [2000] FCA 1365
Australian Consolidated Press Limited v Australian Newsprint Mills Holdings Limited (1960) 105 CLR 473
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v National Exchange Pty Ltd (2005) 148 FCR 132; [2005] FCAFC 226
Bennett v Elysium Noosa Pty Ltd (in liq) (2012) 202 FCR 202; [2012] FCA 211
Campbell vBackoffice Investments Pty Ltd (2009) 238 CLR 304; [2009] HCA 25
Campomar Sociedad, Limitada v Nike International Limited (2000) 202 CLR 45; [2000] HCA 12
Corporate Affairs Commission of NSW v Transphere Pty Ltd

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v EDirect Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 1045
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) filed an application against EDirect Pty Ltd for misleading and deceptive conduct, and unconscionable conduct under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (TPA). EDirect, which traded as VIPtel, supplied mobile telecommunication services and related equipment to Australian customers. The ACCC alleged that EDirect misled customers regarding their credit approval status and the referral sources of their contact details. The court was required to determine whether these claims amounted to misleading or deceptive conduct under section 52 of the TPA and whether EDirect's conduct was unconscionable under section 51AB. Additionally, the court had to consider the public interest in making declaratory orders and whether it was appropriate to do so in the absence of an active contradictor.

The court found that the ACCC had not proven the allegations regarding the referral and credit representations. Furthermore, the court determined that EDirect did not operate a high-pressure sales system as claimed. The court also noted that there were significant discretionary factors to consider in making declaratory orders, including the absence of an active contradictor and the potential public interest in such orders. Given these factors, the court decided that it would not be appropriate to exercise its discretion to make the declaratory orders sought by the ACCC. Consequently, the court concluded that the ACCC's application should be dismissed in its entirety.

The court's decision led to the dismissal of the ACCC's originating application filed on 18 August 2010. The court did not find it necessary to address whether EDirect's conduct was unconscionable since the discretionary factors precluded the making of declaratory orders. The orders of the court were that the originating application filed by the ACCC on 18 August 2010 be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The originating application filed 18 August 2010 be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Initially, the ACCC also sought injunctions, reparative orders and costs against EDirect (paras 12 to 24 inclusive of the ACCC’s originating application). However, those claims for relief were abandoned after EDirect was placed in liquidation in August 2011. Before proceeding to identify the issues that arise from the pleadings in these proceedings, I will briefly essay some of the factual background to the proceedings and some aspects of the procedural history that are particularly relevant to some of the matters that have to be determined.FACTUAL BACKGROUND From at least 29 May 2009, EDirect, trading as VIPtel, carried on business in Australia supplying mobile telephone services and related equipment to its customers. It is not in dispute that EDirect’s services and goods were of a kind ordinarily acquired for personal, domestic, or household use within the terms of s 51AB(5) of the TPA. During the period mentioned above, EDirect used a particular form of sales method to conduct and promote its business. The basic details of that sales method are as follows: EDirect used a call centre located in Delhi, India to make telemarketing calls to potential customers in Australia. It offered those potential customers bonuses to enter into mobile telephone contracts with it. The bonuses were either a 26 inch LCD television, a 32 inch LCD television, a mobile telephone or a 7 inch laptop computer. If a customer agreed to enter into a mobile telephone contract, EDirect supplied him or her with a mobile telephone and/or SIM card, together with a quantity of written materials. As well, EDirect proceeded to deduct the monthly access fee and any additional charges from that customer’s bank account acting under a direct debit service agreement it also entered into with that customer. When making a telemarketing call to a potential customer, EDirect provided each telemarketer with a particular script and instructed the telemarketer to follow it. Among other things, that script included an introductory statement to the following effect:... I got your number from your (Relation) (Referrer’s Name), because I offered him/her [a mobile phone or contract bonus goods] and she loved the [mobile phone or contract bonus goods] and she loved the calling plan ... but she couldn’t take advantage of it because she’s stuck in a contract (or state reason). But she thought it would be a great fit for you, so she gave me your name and number and she asked me to give you a call and tell you about it. As well, each telemarketer told the potential customer that he or she had pre-approved credit for a mobile telephone service plan. Most of EDirect’s telemarketing calls were divided into three components: a sales component; a verification component; and a referral component. A different telemarketer usually conducted each component. The sales component was directed to identifying a suitable mobile telephone plan for the particular customer and obtaining various details from that customer, including his or her full name, address, bank account number and Bank State Branch (BSB) number. The verification component was directed to obtaining the customer’s consent to enter into a mobile telephone service contract and to enter into a direct debit service agreement to authorise the deduction from the customer’s bank account of the minimum monthly access fee and any additional charges under the mobile telephone service contract. The referral component was directed to obtaining the name and telephone numbers of friends or family of the customer who EDirect could contact to ply their mobile telephone services.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In EDirect (No 1), I proceeded under O 35A r 3(2)(c) of the Rules based upon the deemed admission of the facts pleaded in the statement of claim. Here, the situation is somewhat different. EDirect has admitted certain of the facts pleaded in the ACCC’s statement of claim in its defence and denied others. Then, apparently because it was placed in receivership, and later liquidation, it decided to take no further part in these proceedings. However, this withdrawal does not affect the admissions EDirect had already made in its defence. Further, since it had an interest to oppose the relief the ACCC was seeking and, in fact, it initially did so, this withdrawal does not negate EDirect’s role as a proper contradictor: see EDirect (No 1) at [49]–[51]. However, that does not remove from consideration the discretionary considerations attaching to this proper contradictor factor. Those considerations were mentioned in passing in EDirect (No 1) (at [49]–[51]). They were also identified in Corporate Affairs Commission of NSW v Transphere Pty Ltd (1988) 15 NSWLR 596 (Transphere) at 605, per Young J as follows:There are two main reasons for this principle [that there should be a proper contradictor]. The first is that unless there is some res judicata against a person who is interested in asserting the contrary to the declaration, there is no practical reason for making it. The second reason is that unless the court has the assistance in presentation of both legal submissions and evidence of matters of fact, it will not be in a position to make a solemn pronouncement.Both reasons go to the court’s discretion rather than being matters which affect jurisdiction. In an appropriate case the court may make a declaration notwithstanding that there is no proper contradictor: Territory Insurance Office v Kerin (1986) 84 FLR 1; … Secondly it is quite clear that where the interests of justice so dictate, the court can make a declaration notwithstanding the fact that the defendants who are vitally interested, have not given the court any assistance at all.(Emphasis added) In light of my decision in EDirect (No 1), it is appropriate to add this about the decision in Transphere. Elsewhere in his reasons, Young J followed the established rule which I considered in some detail in EDirect (No 1) and decided not to follow: see EDirect (No 1) at [21]–[39], the effect of which is summarised at [18] above. However, I do not consider this, or anything said in EDirect (No 1), or said by the Full Court in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v MSY Technology Pty Ltd [2012] FCAFC 56 (see EDirect (No 1) at [49]–[51]), affects his Honour’s observations in Transphere about the discretionary considerations associated with this proper contradictor factor. I will return to some specific aspects of these discretionary factors below.FOUR ISSUES ARISE As I have already noted above, the ACCC has alleged that EDirect contravened ss 52 and 51AB of the TPA. In its statement of claim, it alleged those contraventions occurred when EDirect engaged in the following conduct:Section 52(a)by making the referral representation (see at [6] above), it engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct;(b)by making the approved credit representation (see at [7] above), it engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct;Section 51AB(c)by employing the sales method it did in the telemarketing calls it made to the potential customers whose calls were recorded in the approximately 3,000 recordings described above, it engaged in a system of conduct that was unconscionable in relation to those customers as a group of persons;(d)by entering into the mobile telephone contracts and the direct debit service agreements it did with each of the eight individual customers described in the statement of claim:(i)in circumstances where it employed the same telemarketing sales method as described in (c) above; and/or(ii)in circumstances where it employed a telemarketing sales approach in relation to each individual customer as pleaded in the statement of claim;it engaged in conduct that was unconscionable

Decision

Reasons for decision

So, because of the presence of all these discretionary reasons in this case, even if the unconscionable conduct alleged against EDirect were established in relation to some, or all, of the eight individual customers, I am not persuaded that, in all the circumstances, it would be appropriate for me to exercise my discretion to make the declaratory orders the ACCC has sought (set out at [118] above). Having come to this conclusion, in the unusual circumstances of this matter outlined above, I do not consider it is necessary for me to decide whether EDirect’s conduct was indeed unconscionable and therefore in contravention of s 51AB of the TPA.CONCLUSION In summary, for the reasons set out above, I have concluded that:(a)the ACCC has not established the referral representation: see at [38]–[41] above;(b)the ACCC has not established the approved credit representation: see at [56]–[58] above;(c)the ACCC has failed to establish, on the balance of probabilities, that EDirect designed and operated a high pressure sales system in its telemarketing calls to its potential customers: see at [107] above; and(d)because of the various discretionary factors present in this case, even if the ACCC had established that EDirect’s conduct was unconscionable, and therefore in contravention of the TPA, in relation to some, or all, of the eight individual customers described in the ACCC’s statement of claim, I would not have exercised my discretion to make the declaratory orders sought by the ACCC in relation to those eight individual customers because I am not persuaded, in all the relevant circumstances, that such declaratory orders would have been appropriate: see at [130]. It follows that the whole of the ACCC’s originating application filed 18 August 2010 must be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.